← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1625/2014dismissed

Bhagwat Sarup & Other v. State Of Haryana

2018-12-13Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu14 pages



      

 !""

   

$%& '()  $  ))**  ( '  +,

) 



 !

'& " - " "  ( '  +,  $ )   "#$% &'()*"+,-./* #0.123#"$#  &'()*"+,-./*#".&4*"2.&532.43+ -

 ."

/$"0' "! &" $  '"1 )' '

$(0! 0 $))**    (%2"

0! 0 $) " "        )/%0)( ,! / *0+,

#0.123#"$#6 3$"4(%1 &"**") &!5"

%

 "1"

*""     3$))*$5 "

 " ( %"

  $4(%1     6 6     7 6 0  )! "*,0     5,  " " * '"   2(%0  +"0  "

 '"     

'    

 8

#0  &$5,  $  !!(  $%&  '()0  $ 0  -&  '$* *"5*(&!$%&" $  " $  !( '! " # 0  0 79- '! "

 $1! 0

7  ))**  $%& '()"("

% $)  !, $ ) ))* 3$))*:($"1$5    ** $))** &! "!    ! ( %*" "1)" 1  ),"



08!$ "

(* ),1

"

0 ( $( %"%("1)" 1  , $  !)( "$5*( '! " # &" $'! " 79- 3$,& *! "!    ! ( %"%("1)" 1  & , $ !)( "$5*( '! "  9- ))** $

&*! "!    ! ( %"%("1)" 1  & ,  ),"

  08 "

(* ),1 "

0  ( $( %"%("1)" 1  $1 $ $ ! )( "$5*( '! "

 $1! ))** -& &*   ! ( %"%("1)" 1  &,  ),"

  08 "

(* ),1 "

0 ( $( %"%( "1)" 1  $1 $ $ !)( "$5*( '! "

 $1! ** $  !& ( ! !( *,  "1"

*""    ;   

       $  5  "*  5,  &"&    $1  -*    $ !1   !  3=$ 1  1 0>? -0  $!  $ 

 5( 

8

#  0$& "

%  $$" $( +  "! $ -& 0$ 0 05*( $%& '( 0$%& $"1*0$"&"02%"$'"

" 5 $$" 0 1*,0 -& ' ( @(*")'"

"*" &%""

%5 "

% $"

)$&$ A* 9  $1 &$"*-)*"$* 2%"



# *"-"

%"  5 $5 $$ A*!1  $) 3$, "  !($ A* -& 0$ 0 5*(  ""

% "!"1"

 *,() $" $ )$& 3$1"

%"* 0 1*,0 $%& 0$"&"02%"$'"

"0-& 0' ( @(*")%= "5*& $ A**" (0-) 2%"

 $1-* ** $ $!**)  $%(  $ A*0' -* @ (%$  $1-*!$ $) 3$"* !)1 $) * % &" $ $"&)  3$1 " "5(   $))** &1 ,  ! "  $!$%15"*)$ 5 & $ A**"  (    -&  '(   B90  >? -8 0  &  %"   - 1 1 ?1"

 " &! (!   $5"$ 0-) 2%"

 9  "% " &!"(   $ !$** &)( ()  !1)* " ** $!*1*" " 3$)!( " ?1"

 (15&"

"

())  " ! 3$  1  $!!(&!( '! " #  -  3$, " $! $)!( " !!( $ * =  $)**"5" 3$))** &! "!    !

 "!5 + !0 $) ))*  A   !( *  ))"

%    5$*    $  ))**  $1 *,%( $  $)!( " $"* ) $!%"

 $))**  A !( *))"

% $'  $1 *,%( $  $)!( " $)" !5,  5*(5  A  !( *))"

% $) " " (51"  $   !&  $ ))** 5 $ !  <$$* !( * $) " %  $(%$ $4(%1 !,!(**,



 3=  $   "  $  ,&"

  +   ""  $  

 5( 

8

#  0$& "

%  $$" $(  +  $  "  +  &  !!(  -& 0  $ 0   '$* *"5*( $%& 0$%& $"1* $"&" 3& "5 "

%$" )$&$ A*  $"

% $ "0$" )$& -) 2%"

*!1  $)  !($ A* +!1 &     $  &  1  &" $  )" *  3$,     "!"1"

 ""

% $" )$&$ A*02%"

 -) ))** -& %= "5*&  $5!=$ A* ))**

5*(%= "5*&  $!$ -) <$ 2%"

**& !!($ " &1$ "

$"!$ -)*!**) !!($ *" $  $"5!=   $"!$ !!($%&  $"&"3& "%5*& ** $&" $ * $"   +"5 $' )*0 "!@ $ A** !$ $) @ :(  $"*    ="**$5 $  *""

 $" 3$!!( &,1 $) * % &" $ $"&)  9 4(& =  +)" *0+" 3$,& !*5(%$  3$!(:(*&" $$" )$&$ A* & !!(  $15"*!$%5,$"11-& 3$,$

* ! "  $),1 9 $"!?1"

 " 0$) $ $$

  12%"$'"

"0-&  2%"$0' ( 2%"$ @(*)!!("

B9 3$?)*  " %" 5,$"1& $  $ )*"!$ :(" *,5(  $ 1 $) &$$(& " ( ))" $"$( +&!  &" $$"  1 0>? - +$ " $(%% "  $  $" $)15"*!$% 15"*"

 $$($%& '() +) $ -& &(

%

$15"*!$%$)"

 $5("*"

% +) $ :(* !$%15"*$   = "

$") ! $ A*$%   $$)-& % "

%15"*!$%  $1, <$ $ $ $ "0!!(&5 "

%$" )$&$ A*"

  $"$) +& "

% " !5(   &,&$  $ !!(  ""

% +$:(  $))**  ) $*" $" )$& <$"*%"

%  $$)" *0 $,$  1 ,)$ !**  $)*"! $,&))*? 3$,$ =  $"

4("

(  +&!!1) "5,@ 1  1 "  =)*!  !"

%$"  1 '  1 -< 3=$ "(*,!5 5,-< @  " !!"

% $0$&) "

 $$($ $ $ A*$%   $$)!!(-& % "

% $15"* !$% 3$,$:(* 1( #8 '$$1

" '$!1( $$( '$( !!(-& 0$  05*(C'$*  $%& '()03"&" $%& '() $%& '()$"1*:(*"

%&" $$"5 $ 5 "

%$"1 +5 $-) 2%"

&!!1) ,"

%$ 3$, " !($5 $$ A*05( "

 $1 "10!!( $   =(  $")" * $ "$  2%"

  "$   ( 3$ 0$ "$  -) !!(5*( -& !("

4("  ( -)&" $ = " !!($%&  $"&"3!("

4(" $" $ 5 $&" $* $" +( !*3=$ 0$ ' )**"   $) +( !*:(  $!!( )*"$" )$& 3$ 0!!($ "$  $5 $ ( -)

!!( &,1 $) * %&" $ $"&)  3$, = $ 4( +)" *0+" '$&!  &" $$  1 >?  9 $!?1"

 " 0$) $ $&1""

 $ , #&" $-& " "**%A $" '$"   $ $ 5 $2%"

 -)$%  !($5 $$ A* 3$" !5 &  $"$(  $$) $!!("5(    3$& *, &$("

5 & 3$"

!" $ = )*! 5(  6)!&,1 $$) $!!( B" *,02%" & $   $  "  (  (!**)  $) -)&*$  5( #)!&,1 $)*!&$ ( !**) +( !*3=$ & "

% 6)!&,1 $ )*!&$$5 $&*,"

% 3$,$%   $$)" * (  '9$ '"

%$$%" B90>? -8

-<#  5*"A*$ =  $)"! ( $)*! !!( ! +$* = )$ %)$ $5,0">? -   >? - 

  1" @(1* %&" $ $115 $ $! (! ) 1 1?1"

 "  $5,2%"



$))*"! " 0>? - +$)- +$  "! $**&"

% 4("  $5,2%"



A! &( "

 $1"*!$ *"%$ *,

* ""E ? !1 &" $"

 1%"

&" $  "

% 5*!= %  A!   &(     $  1"*    !$  *"%$ *, 5 $*  "))*"E ? !1 &" $"

  1%"

0  "

% 5*!= %  A! &(  $1"*5!= * "&" $"

 1%"

"E?#!1

6  A! &(  * )" *%" =(**"E

 ?   !1  &" $  "

   1%"

0  5*!= %   "

%  A! &(  "%$  1)*%" "E6?

!1&" $"

 1%"

!!"

% ) 1 1?1"

 " ) 0!( $&"

4(" " *% 5,5"

0*( %$  3$"

4("& 1 1  ( ("!"  !( $"

"

,  (*"  '($@(1* %&" $ $115 $ $! (! ) 1 1?1"

 "  $5,-)C $* 9 &! (!   - 

+$  "! $ **&"

%"

4("  $5,-) D"

 !"!(*&( "

 $1"* $!$  ?

"

"E0"

 1%"

0  "

%&) 5*!= %&) 0 1"*  $*

"))*G ""

 "

!"&(   $*  "))*0!*!( &** "

1%"

)"

*$) ? "

"EG """

 )"

*$)&(  1"*  $"

4(,    ?

"E0!*!( &**"

1%"

 "  !"!(*&( "

 $1"* $5!=  $ * "0 ? 0"

 1%"

05*!= %  "

%&)

  *! &(   $!*)  $* "0 ? 0 1)*5 &! ( F 3$"&"

$*)"

:( )!"

% 9 $")"

" 0 $!(  $&$1$%"!$!=(  $"

4("  $* *( %  $ $ &$"!$& 1 1"

 ( ("!"  !( $"

"

,!(  ( 

 -(  A * %&" $ '($@(1  1" @(1$"**$! (! ) 1 1?1"

 "  $ 5,     (  *"  $  A*  - 1 1  )  "  ?$"5"    >? -

8 +  "! $**&"

%"

4("  $5,$

A*

 *! &( &) "E ?  )    *  "    $0  1%"

  &   ""

 *! &( "E ?!1  $!!")" * %" !*)01%"

&"

   """

 "

!"&(  5!="

1"(?"*",*"

 "E  #  ?   !1 )"

*  $)  &" $  &**  "

 1%"

  "  "

!"&( "E#? !1  $"%$ " 5!=01%"

&!* &**"

    "

!"&( "E#? !1&" $&**"

 1%"

&)  $* "5!="

 $ !)(*%" F !!"

% $")"

" 0 $!( $&( "

4(, " * % "  5"

 * *( %*"

%  $1$% $!= ** 4("& 1 1"

 ( ("!"  !( $"

 $ "

,!(  ( 

'94"

-$) $ "!* "!*"!&!  " (   $:( '+! (! "

% ) 1 1?1"

 "  $5,2%"

0 ( -)  ! (! "

%) 1 1?1"

 " 0"!*"!$  $*)!*$"

%&"

%!* $ $!  &"* ! %5(** &$"!$&11 $5,5, $"!* "! 3$ "!*& = "

)" "!,110

7 >? -2 3$ 0$"" )*!!!( ! 9  "% "

%"!*"  "1) ,! "% #

50 &*5(**  5* "

 $ 1 $)*!0 )"!5"!= "

&" $5*0 $!$))* 1 $  +**" 5*1 &)*!1 $* $ !( ,  5* "

)"!5$  5* "

)"!  5* =  

0!!($ 1"!*(  1 >? - +"!* $ $$=) ! !* $5* "

!* $

!$))*&   $ "1!!( ! -" *&% !5, 1"

% $ $1  $&  ='"& "5( 5,$

+" "" $!)" *"  >? -## + " $(%% "  $

 $"

%&!  $"

 !!!($

#9 )! =$@(1) $ $! $   1  >? -  +  ! (!   "

:(  )!"

%  +  1  $ ))*"! " ! (! "

%) 1 1?1"

 " +% )) $ " )* >? -H +*" "1) " #

51" )*! 3&"5(** &**"  +*" 5* "  $"

!*("

% $"1 $" )*! +**"  $*)1 $) +* ="

)" (5*5$    5* =   "

&" $5* -& $%& '()1"!*  1  5$"1">? - >? -')! "*, +" """1) "

5 

  '9  1  -=$   ""  $  !!(  -& $%& '()1"!*(  1    $"

 !!!( -& @(10= "&!&$"!$$$=) ! !*  $ &  =0") $&=0+"



'9-=$$ $ !!( + 1"!*(  1 0>? -0  $5"&$"!$ $1 !,!* &! 6  9 )!   '44  '"

%$     !!(  $  + 1"!*(  1 0>? ->>  $""

 !)" *&% ! * %&" $!* $ -*!&*% 1!  !!( )(! '(=$&"

0'< &$) $ $&) '0 "1*+(5 ,05&*""

!

# +$)(!  !%"  $1 $!$0

+) $  ( @(1 *&) . "

, '(% "

/ 1 . "

,+)" *05&*" /.0'$%$" ( /.+05&*" +*1"  $ "%  ( ( @(1  *&  (   $  !%" 1150   !$0

+*1"  $ ?!)  )"

 $& "%  ( %"

  , "

-%" /.0'$%$1#

 

3$"

4("!"5, $!& 1 1"

 ( 3$&("!"  !( $ 3$) 1 1) $ 5 (*,) 3$)" *&% !  $"  !!!( $   $"

 !!!(-& 0= "&% ! 3$ 1 " "5(   $))** " $ :(* =)*!5 &

 ( -&  1( #8 3$))** &" $!11

54! $(*,&) "

!*("

%)" *0= " * $"  != $5 $$ 0-) 2%"

 3$,&!*5(%$ "

 $$)" * 3$!"&1  $5""!*(   1 15, $))**  B'A) 0>? -220( 

DA5 ,>?1"

 "

-(! !15( " 1=*)&&  ! 1 $5*( ,1)" *1= <8 $15 #

F! "% 3 ""

%&  "

 $*5 ,1&) 1=<8 9 ""

% 1!$ "1&( "

&="

%  3$!*&**"

""(*!$! " "!1= )  #

F"! "%!1=8  8 

F"5(** 1=8  8  $   "! "%! 5(** "1( ,1 )" *1=<8 &?1"

 !1)(    !1)" 1"!!)      $  ?1"

 "  !"  (  "

 $ *5 ,0 $(*  *,""( 

( ,1)" *1=<8 $15

F! "%""1"

"

1!

    7  9   ""

%  1!$ "1  &  (   "

&="

%  9 $5 " $(%$ +&0 $ "1"  * ""

%!

 5%" !" ""!**, 

F"5(** 1=8  8$5

"1( ,1)" *1=<8   1 , $"1  $11= 55!(,"1$% " & "

""(* !$! " "!1= 

F"! "%!1=8 08 08#08

8 $5 "1( ,1)" * 1=<8   1 , $"1  $11= 55!(,"1$ % " & "

""(*!$! " "!1=  ) "

"%"

*1'*%,""" " !* $&" $ F !!"

% B'A) 0>? -228 05*!(*  5 !  $(" 

 3$)**"5" = 5, $  5 ) <  '(=$&"

0') $ $$4"

$"( ""

 $ 1 $150 # 3$  !%" )(!& $ 1 $!$0

< *1"  $  ( @(1 *&

 ) 1 $1 $150  !$0

 /.0 '$%$ 3$)**"5""(5*%&) 9 ! $!!( "* ) $)**"5"0$") !  $) !

 5(*(   ))**"5"0 $"A$")+ I5* $ '()1( "

  

 776 '

#0 $$* $  ! $)!( " (!!"

"!$%"

% $5( 0" " !(15  $!!(0&$)  $)**"5"0 )" &" $ 5*( ! "

, ?!*( $)"5"*" ,$") !  $ )*!!!( ! 3$"A$")$$*(  

<1( 5"

1"

 $  *"5""   ?!) "

)!"*% * "%"

 $9 "

- *

, $*& 9 " *,(*" !!% ""

'! "

   $  >" !  !  $  !   &$"!$   ! "  &" $ $! "

"(* 9**(  "

%" (  $)"" "& $)(!"

%"

 $" ! ?

J3$:( " "&$ $!11" !"1 *!(  ! "

 G $!  $   $  0& A$ "* J

# 3$A "

&*"5"1 J*&$J  $ &" (!  " !&$ !!( =!(   !*"

 $ &$  $!!( ! =)*!$& &,1 $)*!!!( ! $ " "? 1*, "1)55* $ $&(*$) "!") "

 $!"1 9 " 5"!*& $ "

!"1"

*!0"

&$"!$ $!!(" **% $"

*"! )$,"!*"

4(,   $)

# $5( "  $)!( "  ) $  $!!( &)   $!  $) "!") "

 $!"1 3$5( &(*  5* 5, $1!  $  $ !!($)  $ !*"5" 3$)* $ !!("

(!$! 5! " *,&$  $ 5( $5 "!$%5, $)!( "  "! "*, (  ! $)!( " (!!"

"!$%"

% $5(

" ""

!(15  $!!(0&$)  $)**"5"0 )" &" $5*( ! "

, ?!*( $ )"5"*" ,$") !  $)*!!!( ! <$

$) ! $!!(  $! !!( !$ 5  5*"$ "! "*,5, $)!( "  $(%$ *"5*  " !0  1**, $  !(  &(*  5  *&   5*"  ,  !( " !    $  !  $  $  & *&$  &$  $  !!( !  $))   (  "  $ " !(!5, $!!("(!$:(*" ,  (!$  $  $!( 1,  "

1 5* (5  %"

%  $"  ) !    $  !   &$  $ !!( ! =)*!0 $!!(&(*0 (5 05  " *  $5 "  $  5*(5 B $ )()0" &(*5( ))" "  5*"&

$ 0"

(!$!"!(1 !0 $5(  $!!("  $  $,  9  **&0  $0  $   "!  )  " :(" 5*"$"

% $)**"5" 3$"( $ 5 *"!!" "($ $- , '      K -  G  '      $$     "

% / %1-"1)* F 3$  1 15,,&"

-< 3=$  @  "(*,!5 5, $1"!*" !   5,-<  1" @(10-<  '($@(1 -<

 -(  A   !!"

%    B'A  ) 0  >? -220  $  )" *0  &$"!$  $  5

!  $"

 !!!($ &(&) !"1 9 &( "

 $&="

%! " " 3$= "&*% !

 $5""!*(  1 15,-& @(1 3$"

4("&

1 1"

 ( 3$"

4("&!(5,"1 = " 3$ ))** $1( *&(*15*,&$"*$*"

%*,&) 

"

( $ !!11 54! "

*"! "

4("  $" *%  $ A*0-) 2%"

(* "

%"

 $" $ 3$)!( "

$) $!%"

  $))** 5,  5*(5   !"!**"

 $&** 4(%1 ! 5, $*  "*( !!"

%*,0 $))*""1" 

"& $" !"!($"

50 $  ! "1)  $))** ":(  3$"!  **"

 $15"

 ! !!"

%*,0 $"" ) " " "*"1"   4"'$1 2(%

 +"

'"

%$'"$(   2(% <$ $)="

%8  L8  <$ $) 5* L8