Narinder Kaur Alias Nikku Ram v. Usha Rani And ORS









 

 











 

 
!
""

#$ %&
'(


( 
#)


 
 
 
 
 
$  
*((+,
-(.
/0.
111
 
 


 -(
) 
0
)

 
2
(
 

 

/3 
$4 
)
+5
(
 

6 
06
72
* 0 .
8(.
0
9((
(
))6
6
+5
(
)
 *


(


06
$  .
:;

( 
(
<$=
9
 

-(
.

 2


(
).
 
(

06


$4
9

6 

(



(
(
&)6

9
(
360
9

)

>
 ;;;.
 2

?
5
 665
 +

(
)6


>+96

6.
9
%@5
2 .
* 
 .
8(
(  




(
<
) 5=

(
+
  65


2 

  ::A
 

+9
(
(

(
)6

 65
B( 
0
9(
(
)6


(
 


C
6 
(

 A:
9(
2 

(

) 5
9
6626.

6

2
(
 65


2 

  ::A

(
(
 

(



(
+


4










 A:
9 
6
6626.
66

0

-(

 

+
) 65
 
0
@2 

 

  
/3 
$4 
)
+5
(
 

6 
06
72
7
0 .
8(
/
 
) 
@
9
)
 2
(
)4 




2

(
) 6
)
 &)6

0
(

) 5



)2
(


(

) 5
+65
3)
+5

6692
(

 

69


>90 .
(


6 
9
6

/
))6
/3 
$4
9
6
2
(

@2 

 

(
 



+
)2

-(   .
(
)4  
 

6



)

(
 
) 5
2
(
) 
)

 
 @


/
))6

$4 

*

$
9
0
+5
(
) 52

(
 6

(
+?

 
06
*
 DA;
 A
9((
(
+
 
+5
95

(
 )2
  
E
(0
( 
6 
6
A
8 
6

(
0( 65
+ 
(
(
 )2
 


+6

>
+ 
(

(
 6

(


6
+5
)
 




5.
( 

6"6(


  5
2
+2
 
+5
(
 6
 .
9((
966



(


(
))6

2
(
@2 

 

  

E
(0
 
(
+ 

+5
6 
6
(
)
+

(
 

+
0

 

*

$
6
9(
5



65
9



4
"10. Stay of suit.-No Court shall proceed with the trial of any suit in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim litigating under the same title

44









where such suit is pending in the same or any other Court in (India) have jurisdiction to grant the relief claimed, or in any Court beyond the limits of (India) established or continued by and having like jurisdiction, or before [the Supreme Court].

Explanation.-The pendency of a suit in a foreign Court does not preclude the Courts in [India] from trying a suit founded on the same cause of action".
D
-(
+@
 652
*

$


) 0
 
 


@ 

 665
 52
9
) 666


)

(
 




C 

66.
(

6 

) 
@.
9((
9
) 65
 
202

2(

@2
(
 




2

(
)

(

0
(

) 5
3)


 

69

E.
( .

(
(
 

06
 

 
9(
69

E
(
 
)

(
 .
(

 5
96
6
(
62




)


;
 2

.
*

6
9(
9
6
.
9( 

(
) 
.


6 5




))6

)2

-(2(
))6




(
.
*


 (


(
0


))6

)2.

+?


+

6

'

  .


+
22
(




+

6
+5
(
)
66
(
@2 

 

  

$4 

65

-(
 6
 
6
2(65

(
(

2 2
6 
(
+
@
+5
(
 6
 
.
( .
(
 
6

5
(
) 2

(

6
+5
(
).
9((
9

)

-(
 6
 
2(65
+ 0
(
0
(2(
(
) 

(
) 

+(

9 
(
 .
(

6 
9





E





   



4A4









!!"

""#.

669
+5

 
B(

(
 

(


  

   

 
$% !

&

'(')
&*+
,-
'./01
23
/
4
""+ "% .

9
(6
(
(
)   5
+@

*

$


) 0
(
 




@ 


 665
@2
)
(
 
)

-(
826 
 
(
) 0



 
(
(
 

 


 65
9

E
9
(6
(


+
+6(
(
(


+9
(
 
) 

(
 

(




(
6


 65

+665



(
 6


9.
 2
+"
2

(
) 
.

+.
) 

) .

(
+

+0
6.
 
(
 
>90 .

(

)6

.
(

2(
9

6 

) 
@.
9( 
(

2(

(
6

9

)

E

+

9(
 5
(
(
06


(
) 0

9((

5


 


9
96






(
6




-
(


(
 .

96

) 





(
2(

+(
(







*66

.



(
) 2
) 2 )(
6.

) 5

+
3)

9
665







)   65.
*

96
))65


 
)2
+ 

 




@ 


*66

.

6 5
.
0
(
@


0
 4)6

9
(
(
96

+
)


(
)
) 5
3)

 
9(
69

'
(
  .
(
 6
 .

(
 
)

(
 .


 
5
66265
+5
@2
(
))6
0
+5
(
4)6


*

$

52

(
+?


4









:
E
09

(
 


  .
E



5


(
) 
0
)

(
 

 265
 

$2
))6.

5.
(66
6

)


 
 










 

0516,17
%&
$%$+
02 2
F((
)"2& 

G&
F(( ) +6

G&