Darshan Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS.
!"#$%&&$'
() !* +, ,!"#$&&$'
(
-(".,"/- &&&&&&&&&00 11(")
.)() !* 3"4(5(" !)-
&&&&&&&&&
0!"
")
# 67 & . 2. 67 & .8 7 .
")# &( ,"
.,"/-9 !+() *!
(00 11(")& &.& &.&,""(9 ,),!"(1&& 3"4(5& &!-,)( /9 !+() *!
0!"
") !&)!:& & & 7 .9& (
-(" .,"/- +!;01(,"(") -( *,1 )-, (00 (1 (/(,"
43 /;
") () %&$$&90(
5<1 ,),!"(1.
,!"
3 /
-!+9 ) (+=!3 )9.("/ 9 , >-,+--, +!;01(,")+(
;,
(" (++3
(+?3,)) !*+-(
* (;
(/(,"
))- ;& ,* *(+) !* +(
(
)-() (
-(" .,"/- +!;01(,"(") -( *,1 ( + ,;,"(1 +!;01(,") (/(,"
) (++3
3"
.
+),!"
9%9@99$@:
( >,)-.
+),!"$@' 9,">-,+- (11 )-()(+-(".,"/-,"43
, -, 5 !)-
(" 2,+
")!* 3 3 >( (.(-,5!;;,))
9( ,03 (( ),9.("/ & - 3 >( !>"
:$ -!0 >-,+->
") !3))! ,**
")0
!"
& (4>,"
.,"/- (++3
/!) ( -!0 * !; !"
!/,9 ) "(") !* 3 3 >( !;;,))
& - 3 3 >( ( !;;,))
/!) (+() (, -!0 * !;
(4>,"
.,"/- (++3
& " $'&$&9 () (5!3) &:& 9 (
-(".,"/-+!;01(,"(")(1!"/>,)-(+-(".,"/-9 (4>,"
.,"/- (" (43>( /!,"/)!,)<.("/ &A- ")- <
(+- ,"* !")!*
("3;(" ;01 9(11(++3
(++!
)- ;& .3=- (4.,"/-(1,( .!", (++3
(,
B-!
)(),!")-()(+-(".,"/- -!31 "!)5 (11!> )!/!
(" 5 =,11 & .3=- (4.,"/-(1,( .!",/ (001 >,)-(+-(".,"/-& ++3
3 +-( (".,"/-/( (/(" ( (51!>* !;,)
>-,+- -,))- ,/-) !*- ( !*(+-(".,"/-&++3
.3 4,).,"/-/( /(" ( (51!>* !;,)
>-,+--,)1 *) !*- ( !*(+-("
.,"/-& (4>,"
.,"/-(++3
/( (/(" ( (51!>* !;,)
!"5(+= !*- ( !*(+-(".,"/-(" )( .,"/-(++3
/(
()(=3(51!>!")- ,/-)1 /!*(+-(".,"/-&++3
(4.,"/-("
.(> (4.,"/-/( , !" ! 51!> (+-!" ,/-)( ;!*(+-(".,"/-& !;01(,"(")(
-(".,"/-(" (4>,"
.,"/- (,
(1( ;9!">-,+- (11(++3
("(>(<& )>( *3 )-
(11 )-()!"
,0)!*,"43
(+-(".,"/--( *(11 "!"/ !3" (" -, /3"> ")!**(++, ")(11<& (+-(".,"/- ,"43
>(
;!
)!-!
0,)(19>-
;
,+!
/(11< B(;,"
&), *3 )-
(11 )-()0!1,+ +!"", >,)-(++3
(" , "!)
/,
)- +(
& 9)-, +!;01(,")& *)
+!
,"/0
1,;,"( < 9(++3
>
3;;!"
(" +!;;,)) )! *(+ ) ,(1& ++3
>
+-(
3"
.
+),!"
9%9
( >,)-.
+),!"$@' (" .
+),!"$@: 9 )!>-,+-)- <01 "!)/3,1)<&-
(*)
9+!;01(,"(")1 -, & A- " 1 5<0 !
+3),!">( 03))!(++3
9(++3
+-( ("
.,"/-(" .3=- (4.,"/-+1(,;
)-())- <>
"!)0
")())- ),;
!* !++3
9>-
(++3
.3 4,).,"/-9 )( .,"/-9 (4>,"
.,"/-9 3
(4.,"/-(" .(> (4.,"/-+1(,;
)-()!"$'&$&9()(5!3)& 9)- <>
")!"*1!!
;,11>-
(+-(".,"/-+(;
(" ( =
)- ;(5!3)(++!3") !*=-(" ()-930!">-,+-3
(4.,"/-)!1 -
>!31 *3 ", -)- (++!3") ,")-
!* ;
;5
!*3 3 >( !;;,))
9>-
30!"(+-(".,"/- (")!>(
-, -!3
(" +(;
!3) >,)-( ,"/1 5(
1/3"(" *,
&- 01,")
-,).3 4,).,"/-(" )(
.,"/-& (+-(".,"/-(1 !/( (51!>!*53))!*/3")!3
(4.,"/-& ++3
(1 !1 * & *)
,"/0 !
+3),!"9(
5<+!3"
1*!
+!;01(,"(")9 +!3"
1 *!
(++3
(" /!,"/ )- !3/- 9 1 ,),!"(1 .
,!"
3 / -!+9 ) (+=!3 )9.("/ 9(+?3,)) (11(++3
& -( 1 +!3"
1*!
(00 11(")91 .)()
+!3"
191 +!3"
1*!
0!"
") !&)!:(" -( (1 !+
*311< /!"
)- !3/-*,1 & -
,!"!*+!;01(,"(")-( 5
"
! 3+ (5!
&")-,
+(
95!)-0( ),
,"43,
& ), "
<)!
! 3+ ,"43
5<(+-(".,"/-,"43
& (+-(".,"/- >( ;
,! 1 /(11<
B(;,"
5< &( 0(1.,"/- A@>-! 0!
)-()!"$'&$&9>- B(;,"
(+-(".,"/-9- *!3" *!11!>,"/,"43
!"-,
!"# 6$& 7(+
>!3" C +; B $&% +; 5!"
0 1<,"/ !51,?3 1<!")- 1 *)* !")(1(
(!* =311$%+;* !;-(, 1,"
&
-51
,"/>(
")&D (<>( ( ,
& 7(+
>!3" &%+;B$+;1<,"/!51,?3 1<,"1,"
!* <!&$>,)- ,**
!*+;&D (<>( ( ,
& & 7(+
>!3" @ +;B $&% +; B 5!"
0 1<,"/ !51,?3 1<!" ,/-) !*!++,0,)(1(
(!* =3119@+;* !;
<!&$&D (<>( ( ,
@& 7(+
>!3" :+;B$&%+;1<,"/-!
!E!")1<!")-
(")
,!
( +)!* ,/-)1 /+;5 1!>="
& D (<>(
( ,
& %& 7(+
>!3" $+;B$&%+;9+;5 1!>,"43 <!&@& C&
@ C& 7(+
>!3" $&%+;B$+;9!")- (")
,!
+)!* !")- ;, 1 !*1 *)1 /&6 11,"43
+(3
>,)-513")> (0!"(" >
+(3
>,)-,"C-!3
& 5-()83;( A )() )-()- ;
,+(11< B(;,"
.3 4,) .,"/- (++3
!" $'&$&9() :&@ (" *!3" *!11!>,"/
!"-,
!"# 6$& 31),01 1(+
>!3" &+;B&+;," ,(;
!"
* !");
,(1(" 1()
(1( +)!* ,/-))-,/-,"?3,("(1(" ,/-) 1!>
0( )!*(5 !;
"(" !0)3;>,)-+1!)) (" *
51!! >(
")&D (<>( ( ,
(" ,"43 <>(
*
)!.3 !"& & 7(+
>!3" &+;," ,(;
!")- 1()
(10( )!*
,/-)0(1;>,)-+1!)) (" *
-51!! &D (<>( ( ,
&
(10(), ")!*,"43
*!11!> #
'0
;,"3) & $@'@;,"9-
+!"
+,!3 &.3 !">( +(11 ,;;
,() 1<&"43
-!>")!)- .3 !"&6 & 5-() 83;( A (1 ! B(;,"
)( .,"/- (++3
(" *!3" *!11!>,"/,"43
!"-,
!"# 6$& 31),01 1(+
>!3" &+;," ,(;
!"* !") 1()
(1(" ,")
,!
;
,(1( +)!*1 *)1 /(" 1 *)("=1 9$C ,"+-
,"1 "/)->,)-+1!)) (" *
-51!! 9B (<>( ( ,
(" ,"43
*
)!.3 !"&6 "43
>
*!3" >,)-," C -!3
(" >
+(3
>,)- 513")*,
;& 5-() 83;( A(1 !;
,+(11< B(;,"
(4 .,"/-(++3
(" *!3" *!11!>,"/,"43
!"-,
!"# 6$&
- > 11,"/(" +!")3 ,!"$$+;B%+;!")-
0!
,!1()
(1( +)!*;, 1 !* ,/-)( ;& D (<>(
( ,
&6
% A- ")-
,!"!*+!;01(,"("), +!
!5!
>,)-;
,+(1
9,)+!;
!3))-()"!,"43 <>( ()) ,53) )!.3=- (4.,"/-& "43
()) ,53) )!3
(4.,"/-(" .(> (4.,"/-!")- ,/-)( ;>,)- !" ! (
"!)*!3" ,"7 & )( .,"/-, (11 )!-( /, ")(=3( 51!>!")- ,/-)1 /!*,"43
(+-(".,"/-9>-
!" ,/-)1 /9)>!
1(+
>!3"
*!3" &(=3(51!>, 1,= 1<)!+(3
,"+,
>!3" & 3)!**,
))-
,"43
9)>!(
!")- 1 *) !*- ( (" )-, ,"43 <,
!")- ,/-) !*- ( &!>
9,"43 <()) ,53) )!(++3
(4>,"
.,"/-!")- 5(+= !*- ( !*,"43
(+-(".,"/->,)-/(" ( (51!> "!))-
&- ,"43 <!")- ( !*,"43
*!3" )!5 / !3
,"/* (+)3
& - ) ,(1!3 ))!!=,")!+!"
(),!")-())-
, 1(<!*% (< ,"*,1,"/)- +!;01(,")& -
"!)-,"/)! )!0+!;01(,"(") (
-(".,"/-* !;(00 !(+-,"/-,/-
(3)-!
,),
>- "0!1,+ (11 1< , "!))(= (+),!"&-
*!
90 !5(51<9+!;01(,"(")*,1 +!;01(,")(*)
(+-(".,"/-,"43
>( 5!!= *!
+(3 ,"//3" -!),"43
)!(++3
.3 4,).,"/-(" )( .,"/-(" 513"),"43 <)!(++3
(4.,"/-&-
!")-
!"!*(++3
.3 4,).,"/- -!> )-())-
;31),01
1(+
>!3"
+(3
>,)-/3" -!)!")- ,/-))-,/-(" ,/-)1!>
0( )!*(5 !;
"(" !" ,/-)0(1;&- /3" -!),"43
!")-
!"!* (++3
)( .,"/-(
!" ,/-)1 /(" 1 *)("=1 !>9)- ?3
),!">!31 (
>- )-
.3 4,).,"/-(" )(
.,"/-(++3
+!31 /, ,"43 <!")- ( !*(+-(".,"/-(*)
-( ,"/
/3" -!) ,"43
F A *," )-() ,) , !35)*31& *)
-( ,"/
/3" -!),"43
,")- )-,/-(" ,/-)1!>
0( )!*(5 !;
"9 (++3
.3 4,).,"/-, 1,= 1<)!5 ," -!+=(" >,11"!)5 ,"(0!
,),!")!
C /, ( ,"43 <!")-
!"!* (+-(".,"/-& ")- !)-
-(" 9 (+-(".,"/-9(*)
, ,"/- ( ,"43 <9( )() 5<-,;9>,11"!)5 ,"( 0!
,),!")!*,
)- /3"& "
)-,"/, +1 )-()(+-(".,"/->( +(
<,"/ (/3"())- ),;
!*!++3
& 2,+
")!*)- 3 >( !;;,))
(" ()&,")- ;!")-!*("3( <9- "!) 300!
)!
+(
</3"&-
*!
90!
,5,1,)<, )-(),)>( (+-(".,"/->-!*,
/3"
-!) (" )-
(*)
/, ","43
5<!)-
!"
9!)-
)-("
& ")-
+, +3;
)("+
9,"*1,+),"/!*,"43
5<+!(++3
1,= 1<)!5 ,"
1* * &!>
9)- ) ,(1!3 )-( ,/-)1<+!"+13
)-(),"( ,),!")! 1(<!*% (< 9)- ,"43
"!)+!
!5!
5< ;
,+(1 &3 ,"/ )() ;
"),"!3 )9(
-(".,"/--( )()
)-(),"43
/, ">,)-/(" ( (51!> >-,+-;
("
)-())-
/, ">,)- -( 0 >-,+-+!31
31),","+,
>!3" & )-
9)- ) ,(1 !3 )-( ,/-)1<!5
)-()0 !
+3),!"-(
)- /
!* !++3
&- !
+3),!"-( "!) B01(,"
)- /3" -!),"43
!"
)-
!"!*.3 4,).,"/-(" )( .,"/-(" ,"43 <!")-
!" !* 3
(4.,"/-& -
*!
9>
!*)- , >)-()) ,(1!3 )-( )(= "!"
!* )>!0!
,51 , > (" -( ,/-)1</ (") 5 *,)!* !35))!(++3
("
(+?3,)) )- ;!*+-(
* (;
(/(,"
))- ;&!"
?3 ")1<9> *," "!
*!
,")- (00 (1(" (;
, (++!
,"/1< , ;,
2. 8 7 . $&&$'
4= A- )-
(=,"/!
#
!
A- )-
0!
)(51
#
!