High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1206/2013dismissed

Charan Singh v. State Of Haryana

2017-11-18Mr. Justice Mahavir Singh Chauhan12 pages

! " #

% & ' & ()' &&

* +

),)#

---- .

/" * 01 2$

3" ) % )'4 " ) * $)

'" 5 6 % "

"* * $

)4 "

4 '2"2 7" .

2 "

8 /" * 2$ "

)

" 9 ) 4

'

" 4

(

) 4 6 2

) 8

:"*

"

*

2 3 :"4

; 2"$

<8

:"*

=

*

4 43 :"4

* $

.4 "

* $ "

2 " 4 (3 :"4

)4 " 4 (4

)

"

4

2 #

"

" 2"5>$

4

/

' 4 $2$

$#4' ) 2" $

*

)

*

) "

"

" 2 " 4 $ " * *'

&

& (2

)4

*

$

* ( " 4 * (

?

* *"

3 :"4

')

" *2 1)0)4 4

' " #4' )

) $

" * 5)0

* ?

" ;

2 $)

"

" * 4 $ * "

@) $

/" * *2

"

) 4 ) * ) * $

2"

(

2"

* 4

" $

* ".

4 *

(

*

* '

*"

" 2 "4 $A 2 * 8

:"*

) B 6 " 5 4

5 6% 4 4

" * '

) " % 4 "

"

4

'40

/

) 2 4 ) $ 4

" 5 6% '"

6%)4 ) $ " $ * 6 ' ) ";

*%?) 6

C %? D# 3

2

C %?

,"

*

E ,"

*"(

C%?5

#

C%?1* 8

) %? 8

0 /"

C%?:

C%?6 2

C%?@6 "2

C%?D#!:"*

%?#!

%?F $ 2 :

%? # :

' .

* "4 "

%)4 *

"'4 " ")4 "

* 6) $;

*

* $ "

4) * $) ?

8 ? * $G '

"*

%"2 % " 4

" ")

"

'*"

/" *0 01)' "

2')4

4 7"

'

*2$ ' 2"2 B

'

*"

/" *

2$ "

) "

F

"

4 / $ 0'

(

" * * "

$ * " * *%?6 2

)6'

A )4

*

&

(HH

2 " 2 *)4

4

4 / $A " )

**"

4

" & ' ) * ) $4 "

$

4 * .

2

* * ?

)4

$

* ) 4 * '"6"

) 4 2* 4 $ " $

) "*" 6 D' 2 A

)

" "2*

"

4 '$

*

"

4 ' 2$

") 4 "2/ " $2$ "I

* * 4 $ .

"

$ ' 6

'

"

'

"

5

4 7" * 9<=.

4* "

'2 "2"

) 2 $/"

$) 4

"

4 '$

*

C <=6 " 2 4

2 ) "2/ " $

* 2$

"2 ' "2 4 $* 4 $C <=.

*4 $

' ** 4 $% 2)

@ J * $) *

4 "

*G5>$

2 "

%?1)

*) 2 4 B64

)

$

'"4 *

" < = " *

2

" "* 4 $ 4

*2 10)4 ' .

) "

* *"5)0 * * " 4 2 $

" 4 2"

) 4 2 $"

"

*"A ) "

* ".

) $* &

& "

* * 4 $2$

" " " $ ) * * * " 4 4 "4 "

'2$ "

$4" ( $.

) @) * ' * 2$

' 8

" 4 $

* * %? 8

<" = * $

"

"7"

4

" D;%)*2 4 ' *

"

%?)6 2

)6'

A ) * %?5

#

)4 " * * 2$" )

"

*

(

" () "

)"

5*2 4 * ) ; 2 7" $"4

"4

<

$2 ( * $; *

*

4 4 ' !

.

"*"

D' (

" $ ' 7" *<= 4 4 $)

0 7" *

2 6

!""#$% & '())*+, ,-)) 4 $% 2)@ 4

4 $% 2)@ 4

'' ( '

4 $ 4 $% 2 " K K4 $K6 )K4 $K*

$ $ '

"

2 "

$ '

2 ' $ $< =2$

$ *

$ *

C <2= 2$

$ *

2$ )

$ *

$ C 2 *

*

)2" "4 *

4 * &" *% F 4<

=

D;

6B *'

"2) 2$

$ * *

$ *

* ) *)

)

2 * 2 4 $ 4 * )" $

*

K 6""#$%

./!0/12 34 '())(+(5,6 2 ' K.

'

"

2 * 4 $ ))4 *

?*"( * '6*"2 **2

*

$ **

'

$ * $) ' $ .

4 $ "

2$ "

D' "

2$ * "* 2

"

2 " " '

( 4 '$

*

.

'$

2 "

2" "

"*

" 4"

' 4 6

4*"2/ " $

* 2$ "2 * $ **2 5@)6 % 4" 2

6"

" $

*4 2$ "2

' ) 4 ) $*

4 $ ** $ 2$ 2"

2 $/"

$ 2 4

@ '$

*

)" "2 ' *

' " 2 2 " L 5 )6 % ?

7" "4

" $4 $ 4* '

** $2 4 "2/2$" " $ 0

* ) 4 ) $ *

4 $)

)D' '

"

"*

"

" 4 $ A"

' $ "

4"

)6 % .

4

'

"

4 "2 '2$ 4 " " "

4 (4 4 ' 4* ** "

"

$) 4" 7"

$ 4 *2 )6 % 6"

" 4" *" '( ' "

$" 4*

"

"

4 4" * " * 2$ ** "K 6 7 .!""#$%

./ 8 "4# 7 '6---+56-9)

2

4 $ ) 4 ; " $

*

"

2" $

"

"" "* $2 ' * 6 " $

* * 4 $ 4

' )

2*2K2 K

*

$ 2174!""#$%84& 8#74'6--:+ (6::9

2 K8 "*"

D' 4" 2

4

" 4

* ) " $

* " ' 4 ' " $

* & **2$ 4" ' " ) "

" " $

*4 4 $* 4

';

* 2 '* .

2 " ;

" '

' K 2 K .

;

' *4 7" 2 "

/ ( *"

2 42$; $* * .

;

4 ;*$ 6 2

*K2 K $$*"4 *K** $2 K.

2 "4

56 "

< = D' .

* 4 *4 *K2 K 2 *2$ "

) " ")

4' )

;

K2 K 4" $* $

'

" 2 *" 24 " $

*

7".

*"2;

;* ' (K

6 ) " "

" "

" "4 "

$

*

.

2

4 " *

4 4 * ' 2 / "

;

* %?1)8

)%? 8

%?:

) "

4 " 42$ "D' * " %) "

( 6 "

2 ) "$ " '2" 4 0

$

4 *

'"

*2

.

' $2 (2 4

"

' 2

"

2$ ".

4 "

$

*

C

"

" "

* " "C * 4

2 '2$%?1)4

$

'"4 $ *

" < = "

*

2

" " * 4 $ 4

* 2

10)4 ' 64 $ ) '* $2 '

2 " * $2 '2$ ' 5 6%

4 D' "

"*4 $ 6 " "

*

4*

"

4 '$

*

"" ) ( "2"

$ 2 $/"

$ " $

* 2$ "2 ' 4 $*

4 $2

24 $ 6'4 2'") 2$*.

*"

/" *0 2$

"

"

"$ )" 2$ "$" ) % ):

)

2 1) ; $ $

' +

'

;4#"4# 7<#=2 3> #7$ #8?

#7 > $ ;4#"4# #<$ "/1#?

#7 > $