High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/683/2016dismissed

Veer Kumar v. State Of Haryana

2022-03-11Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma13 pages

$$%%#& '&#&()#*##

& #+!

"#,#& (&-#$$%%#& .

/&&#%,% ,)#*##1/&- '# #2-#3, ,)#*## (&-$&'&#&

4&-3%1('/3"

5 ,64#&&-/.( #*/-/%-#&3#&-(#(#&-7$&&/8 9-1('/3"

5 %#%*"&#&&-#&(#&-/( &- $/%%# / &- %$"& ( # -/%: "&/#% 1%%2/3 -/% %.&&-/ (#&- & %#* 1 &-/"#% % # ( &-"

9-* #% %. & &-/ (#&- & $/ # (%/3 ( /&*,2&-$-*/#%#"&/#%

&/&-$&##%%&- $##"& ( # (#&-- -# 2 "#%/3 2* # (#&- 1- - ""/&&-#"( %##2"/#2%#&(#$ $-/1# 3-& #(/%-2*(#"#%%(%/3(% &

;<81-1# =*#(#3#&&-&/"(//&(/%# "$%#/& 2( &- $%/ &#&/3 /& #%/# &-/ &-#& - 1# & */3 / &- %# ) (#&-, &- #$$%%#& -/ -# > #%%* ## %&-/&-/3-&,1--"&--#3"1-%& #&&#"#/#3 '--##%/("-"&-## &#2 &&-/

2- //& 2 &&1"&-#3,-(#&- !

"#-#""/&& #$- 9-///&-#$$/&-#*&/"1--"&- -#3&&-2#.1--/1./3#'1$ '-/&&%% &-/ //& & - "&- /3 &- &1 "&-, - (#&- -# ""/&&2##&1/&-- '--#&%&-&/(#&&--% &#-'

"/&# !- ## ?1, @

= / &- #* &/", - (#&- !

"# -# ""/&& 13 #& 1/&- - /&-/ - 3#/3 &-/ //& - -# &% - -% &#- ' "/&# !- ###&#'-#"# &-2#/(&-#/"$%#/&B<

, ("#%541#3/&

9-"#&&1#/&/3#&2*CD'4!#/%#-!# ,/& $%# 1# $$#, &#&"& ( 1/& '&/ ( &- /"/#% , @A (-&E&-

:1, &#&"&($ &/> '&/ (&-

1#, &- $ &/> # &- # 1 "/%3#%%* >#"/, &- # 1##&##(&"$%&/(/&/3#&/,# 1# -#%%#&(#&/#% (//3##,$ /-#2% '&/( (&- &&/(-/%("'> #%((&,

(-& E&- '&:,&-&/#% &-#3-&&-# &1-/- &-# $%#&3 /%&*#%#/"(#&/#% 4 & $ /& #, &- $ &/ >#"/ # "#*#

$ &/1/&#$ "#&/#% "&# 2+&1-/-1>-/2/& = (& #$$/#&/3 &- / , %# /&/#% '/ F 3, B>% / & ( )/ /"

3- #3#/& C", !

.-&# / /& + 3"& ( /&/ #&

# ( & #&

-% #$$%%#&D# !

"#3 /%&* '&/(&- ' &#&-/"& 3/3 /"$/"&(#$/ ( *##&$#*#(/(

D 4(# %&($#*"&( (/,--#%%( &- 3/"$%/"$/"&(#$/(

"&- 33/ #3#/&&- #2#/ + 3"&(/&/ #(&,&-#$$%%#&-#(/%&-$&#$$#% G# % ( &- #$$%%#& -# -"&%* 2"/&&&-#&&-#$$%%#&-#2(#%%*/"$%/#&/&-$& # 9- # ( &- $ &/ / "%* 2# $ &- / "&#&/#%/ 9-/%2*&-$ &//-/3-%* &#/&* ?/$&1/&-#2>#"//&-/# #&-&/#/2#&-&&/"*(&-((//#%1/& 91 &#- / '

/&# !- ## # &# '-#"#, & 1-" &- $ &/>/&#&&-###&&-&///&,-#&2 >#"/#"&-(&-$ &/>-#&2>#"/ 9-$ &/>& -&/% 4->#"/#&/,&-$ &/> /&-&&("$%#/&# 2"/&&&-#&--#"#&- "$%#/&&-#./3($%/# & G# %( &- 2"/& &-#& &- B>

5'G $& #% & $$& &- # ( &- $ &/ # " % 2 && #* ( &- >-/2/& G# % -# 2"/&& &-#& &- /"$ 3

4- + 3"&(&-9/#% &/$ %*2# "/#+& #&2&#/ %# '&#& % -# 2"/&& &-#& &- #$$%%#& -# /3-&%* 2 /& # &2* &- &/#% & 9- / 3& / & -1 &-#& &- #$$%%#& -# ""/&&&-(( 9-$ &/-#>#"/#"#*#

1/& & $ /& # (& #$$/#&/ ( &- / , &- 9/#% & -# /3-&%* /& # & &- #$$%%#& @ C -# 3/ &- 3-&( % /#&/ & &- 2"//"#2*%# %(&-#$$%%#&#%#'&#& %#-#3&- 3-&-%1 &

( $/3 ( &-, /& 1 % 2 #$$/& & $ &-&#&"&(&-/&/""# '&/

4#"#1-/-## ;'&#&"& ( ?#" ( /&/" >>>> # 3-& ( !

"#, #3 #2 & = *#, & &, /& ( 4"#/%#2#, -1#, '&/

4 #"#H

I )1 "#* 2&-/& -# * # / 1-/- %##/1-/--%* #J C#&-2&-/&#4& */&-%# # 4 & * / 0"& '/ '#* '-%,4"#/%#2# I * .1 # & 1-" * # "#./3 &#&"&J K'/ 4.1&-#&4#"3//3"*&#&"&&# 3 I * .1&-#&(//3* &#&"&&2 13, $/3 % #%2 //&/#& #3#/& * J

5- K'/ 4.1&-#&(//3#*&#&"&&2 13, $/3 % #%2 //&/#& #3#/& " I $/& &-#&, &/%% * 1#& & 3/ * &#&"&J K '/ '&/%%, 4 #" "#./3 "* &#&"& 4 #" "#./3 &- &#&"& & ( "* ( 1/%% # 1/&- &#*(#$ (" &/ 'D/)// /&/" 'D/B3%/- F4,4%%#L##3/&#&,4"#/%#2#

-1#

= 4 #" #&/(/ &-#& $ &/> / "#./3 - &#&"& % &#/%* #& - 1 ( 1/%%, 1/&- & #* ./ ( /"$ %/("#* G&-&#&"& 2 'D/B3%/- F4,4%%#L##3/&#&,4"#/%#2#

-1#

= I C-#&&#&"&* 1#&&3/J '&#&&-#&#2 &&1"&-#3,"*(#&- !

"#-#""/&&13#&1/&-" &&-#& &/", 4 # "* (#&- 1/&- - # #(& (//3$$& /&*,--#""/&&13#& I * 1#&&#*#*&-/3%J 9-#(& @

=,1-41##%#& &-- #"*"&--#3&&-2#.,&- / &- &/" "* (#&- -# #3#/ ""/&& 13 #&D#$ 1/&- " 3#/

=, 4 -# &% & "* &#- / &-/ 3# 9-, 1 3&%3&-54 I )#* 1#&&#*#*&-/3%/#/&/& &-/J ? '/, 4 & 1#& & #* #*&-/3 % / #/&/&&-/ 'D/)// /&/" 'D/B3%/- 4&/(/2*4GF4,4%%#L##3/&#&,4"#/%#2# !#/%#-!# -1#

= ? = D!!

64& / &/(/ &-#& &- &#&"& ( $ &/> '&/

1# / #"# 4& / #% &/(/&-#&$ &/>"#-&#&"&% &#/%*( - 1 ( 1/%%, 1/&- & #* "$ %/ / ("#* 4&/#%&/(/&-#&&-&#&"&(&- $ &/> # #2 2# & # & # & ( 1-#& -# 2 &#& 2* - # &-/3 -# 2#%&&-/#&-#"1## #>$%#/&&-$ &/>1-/3&-#"#(& #"/&&/3&-&&(&-#"&2& 'D/B3%/- F4,4%%#L##3/&#&,4"#/%#2# -1#

=8 9-$/&/"#2*&-$ &/>1-#$$##

C 2(&-&/#% &/$ //&&/&*#

!" # ! $ % &'( ) * $ '+ ( ! ' , -.!/ 0 1 " 2 /$ 32

! 4 0 /1'56 0 ! '. ! & ( 3% # 0! 7/% '% '% ' !

# ! $ %8 $ 6% %3222% # 39%6%32

% 8

! . !!

$ $ % ( 1 %# ! " ! !1" %# !! 8 ' !%

#/ ! -.% ! 1 $ % ($ 1 / ! ! !. !!

$ $ % # 1 !!

. $ 0:0 1 %! ; % # ! $ ! 8 1 %

7- ( ! /! " ! % ' -.%3 $ % # / ! -.% -.%3% # ! $ $ % ( ! $! ' ; 1 $ ! ! $ !!1 < . %*; !!1% '=< =< '+ ( !', " ..$ '

'%%8 !

$!' $ '

' (/ ! % #"1 %!

. ! 1 % # 3%6%32

1!! 1 5%%32

# !!

/ %01 ( ( -.% 1 %

!1 (( -.%31 % $ '

%0% !

(/ % (! -.% 1 $$ %

$ !

%#"1 -.% % '! !

# "1 -.%3 1/ $ %# -.%3 "! %#/! !%# "$ ! 1" #1 !% *&>(0 '=< =< '+ ( !', -.!/0 ? " 2%

%32

C (/ 2&# / &- #3 "& ( &- %# %(&-#$$%%#&

9-&##3 "&(&-%# %(&-#$$%%#& &-#&&-/&/"-#& -&/%#"&-#&-&#-1& >#"/# C2*&-$ &/,/"// 9-#(#/ $/&/(&-/&/" #&2#/$/"#%,2 &/&#2 # / /& &/&* 9- $ &/> / - >#"/#&//-/( -#%#%*$&-#& 1 39%26%32

%: ! . !!

$ $ % ( 1 % '

! 1 1" 1 $ "

1 $ "1"%'

! ! ! ' %

/ ! -.% ! ($ 1 / ! !

! . !!

$ $ %'

1 !!

. $ 0:0 1 A%9-/$/&/( &- /&/" 2&#&/#& &- (( ""/&& 2* &- # :1/ <. . 1 !

! "1 ! -.% -.%3%'

/ -.%3 " ! %'

/! %: !

" 1"$ ! 1 !%

&-", &- $/&/ ( C &- $ &/> / 2#&1/&-&-$/&/( C

CD'4!#/%#-!# / 1-/- - -# $ /$& ( #$$%/#&/ B>

( "$%#/#&, 3/&#&/ 54 B>

, $$##&/ ( 3- /& $%# B>

, 3& &#&"& ( '

/&# !- ## # &# '-#"#, -% &#-(&-/&/","/%3#%>#"/#&/(/&/",3& &- &#&"& ( /&/" '&/ ( &-

, "/#% >#"/#&/(# ,&#./3/&$/2/&-&/(/#&(/&/" B>

# $$##&/ ( -#%%# & 4 - >#"/#&/ - &#&&-#&&-/&/"2#%%*&%-#2 &&-#&(" @

= & @

=,-(#&--#""/&&#$ $-#2 &=&/"

C##%&/1/&-&-#3 "&(&-%# %(&-#$$%%#&&-#&#$5'G$&B>

, % &2&&## -(( '&/(&- ' &/"# &#3#/&&-#$$%%#& %*2# " %& 2( ,&"#&-#&(( '&/(&- '& -#&2""/&& '&/ (&- '&&/$ %#&&-#& 1- ""/& #33##& $&#&/ > #% ## %& -#%% 2 $ /-1/&-/3 /"$/"&(#&"1-/--#%%&2% &-# &1&* *#, 2 & 1-/- "#* >& & /"$/"& ( %/(, 1-/--#%%"#/"$/"&(&-"#/(#& #%%/((&-#& $#-#%%#%2%/#2%&(/,1/&-#&- 4&-$&#, #$$/&/( C, G/$*'/3%#,/#%((/1-#% &##((/#/&B>

//&&-((&,/&&#$/&-#&

=, - "/%3#%%* >#"/ &- $ &/> '-

10- $ G ( &- $ &/> B>

= '- /&/(/ B>

@ & B>

/ #%1#,/#%1#2,#3/#%1#2,$ 2/-#/&2(&- $ &/>, &#. 2* - #& &- &/" ( "/#% >#"/#&/ '- $&-#&$/2/%/&*(> #%/& #&2 % & 5" #$ #%(&-G(&-/&/"1-/-/#B>

=,/& &#$/&-#&&--*"(&-/&/" 1#&##3/##"/&& &1 (/3 #/%* 5 &-", C= + '-#"#, /#% ((/ 1- -# & # #((/#/& B>

A & &- ((& &-#&

=, - "/%3#%%* >#"/ !

"## # $G B>

/ &-/ 3# )$/&-#& &-/ &-/3& 33&&-#&&-$>#"/2*-/"/&#$#2%($("/3 > #%/& )$&-#& 1#,$ 2/-#/#1#2( 3%#$/B>

&B>

#&-#",1-/-1&#.2*-/"#& &- &/" ( "/#% >#"/#&/ ( # 9- "#&/#% # /&&1-/-# ((//&&$&-#(#/((#3#/&&- #$$%%#&2*##2% 2&

= 9- #3 "& #/ 2* &- %# % ( &- #$$%%#&&-#&&-$ &/>-#& -&/%/#%(-%$ 4&- $&#,#&/#2,&-$ &/> %* $$&&-# ( &- $ &/ / - >#"/#&//-/(, # %#& / >#"/#&/, - -# & -&/% 9- (#& &-#& &- 1/& 1# %# -&/% #& &- /&# ( &- $ 2%/ $ & # - 1# #%%1 & >#"/ &- 1/& ( /- + &/(/#&/ ( +&/32%&-/(&-1/& )1,&- &-#& 2 * #( %, # $/"# (#/, # 1/& 1- "#. /((&

11- &#&"&#&/((&&/",-#3#(&-& &- )// -# & 2 # # / # # 1-% 1/&- # /1 & (/ & 1-&- #* 1/3-& - % 2 #&&#- & /& C-/% >$%#//3 &- /&/#*#% (-&/%1/&,)72%'

$" &/ &'(& )(&* +*,( -. /&/0 )1

# !!

% 23!

-# 2 #

B%%%%%# 1!! ! / 1 $ + ! $ ! < . %

/ 1 $ 1 ! $ $ . / $ $! ! %%%B 9-//11#/&#&2*&-)72%'

$" &/

&40*'5&-./&/0)1

# !!6%"2 !1-//&1#2 &-#&"%*2# #1/&/#&("-/&#&"&"#/&- 54,-//#&2-%&2&&#%%* %/#2% /"/%#/1 1# &#. 2* &- '

$" & / )-+*'&77& -. /&/0 )1 &5*&/&8& # !"!% 3&-#&&-$/&/(#-&/%1/& #2%/ $#&%#& $&&->&&- $$&&-#(&- $ &/ 4/&/0)194&5&/-*+59'(.+*, #"66:% 3"2 &-'

$" &-#2# B5%-/ ! ! / ; $! + ! $! % -/ C 1 "1! C $! !

$ ! 1 / 1 +!! / 1 / /%: + !! ! !

< $ "C

12- %

< = %

! !%-/ C1 / <$ $ 0' ! ! / ! !C! / %( $ ! $ ! $! ! %B

4&-$&#,&-$ &/>&&/(/&-#$ > #% ## %& #& &- -# ( - (#&-#$$%%#& &1/ M (/& &/" 2(&-#3/&#&/-&#&"& '&/ (&-

# &/"2(&-9/#% &/&-1/&2># C

?##2%>$%##&/-#23/2*&-#$$%%#&D# &-#& 1-*-/1# 3-&-#%%% -/ #%%3#&/#3#/&-/"

'(##&-#3 "&(%# %(&-#$$%%#& 3#/3/$&1/&1#>#"//&-$&#/ , ):2% '

$" & /& /& + 3"& /

!",1-/% / /3 / &#/% &- $%/3-& ( &- /&/" ( > #% ## %&, -# 2&-#&&-&&/"*(/&/",/ -#,//&#%# % &- # "$%%/3 # 1-/- /&#& %./3 ( 2#&/(-&#&"&,&- &- %(//((/ %&*& #&&-&&/"*(#/&/"(> #%## %&#%&/&# # , 1- - &&/"* /$/ (/ # / ( & 2 %/#2%

4/1(&-#2/ /,1#(&-/ /1&-#&&-//%%3#%/&*/&-+ 3"&(/&/# (&$#2*&-9/#% & /3%*,&-$&#$$#%

13- &#/"/#&-+ 3"&(/&/#(& $#2*&-&/#% &# $-% /3#$$%/#&//&-/#,/( #*, -#%% &# /$ ( #/3%* 3/&* & & 2#. &- G1 & ')!!N B 49N )4 FN0B FN0B

#$%&% '( ?

"= D ?

* $! D