← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/714/2016dismissed

Amartej Singh And ANR v. State Of Punjab

2019-05-24Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu22 pages



      



        

      

 

 





  

      

   





  

        !"#$%&





'

()$*#+, ,$%&  



'

 

  

     

  



 !"

 #  !"    

$%&%'(%&)%*+, - 

    #    $    

$%&%'./%&)%*+,  $%&%'.'%&)%*+,

*   0

 1       



  

                         



    



 

     

!

"#    $   %   &   



%  ' ""(  "( ""

")   



         

        "( 

 '  * 

 +    

 ,  "-.( /  0'*+ , 01   

#( !" .

     ) 

 2 + % /  02+%01      34 (- $* +$%",+) %#!

.+),$% .%)%+ ,%/0.,%12 /   2& " 0    

           

3    3  

   /+ +++4% 

  3   

      

     * 3 -(!)3 .,%12 /   2& " 0    

           

3    3  

   /+ +++4% 

  3   

      

     * 3 0!3$) .,%12 /   2& " 0    

           

3    3  

   /+ +++4% 

  3   

      

     * 3 4(%5(! (6 $).,%12 /   2& " 0    

           

3    3  

   /+ +++4% 

  3   

      

     * 3

 



  

 

 

    .

 #( !"  ) 2+%

)

   

      



 

  "!

(

") 2

  5

 +64 7      2        

      8 $ 9  

:  9  

 9  :      

         

 6      

 

    

 9  :         ""-  ' ;74 9,4"--  <        

2

  5



   ;        

  

   ,

           

  

       =          2

  5

        ;    



  



        >?

+6 @,  >?

+6 @* 2

  5

  

 *+/*1     *+/*1   7

   

%  

>?

+6 @>  >?

+6 @;   %  

   -"

   =     '  -"

 

"     

  

".

         ' ", "=  -", -"= 7    )-  .           

2

  5

            

  

 070

*+    

  

 0

< '

- 



 

 

2

  5

      ;% :  ;        2

  5

                ,2 ' 

  ;5

     

   

 ;  

  

 0'0 5 ".

(

") 2          8;% :

       *$8 

  >?

+6 @#        %    

(      

 *  



      5 =   

     

 ,    

      

  

     



  ?  %

     % 

  

     

 0 " 6

   



 

 "    ""  "   " 55 $$ 03 

  "  "  0 ""  6

 



   " 0    " !

"     " 

 " 

! - "   / #  "  

     ! ! 3     "     !  "  

    , #  "  

       " " ' 7 !    "        !    " !3 "3 . 7% -$ 

     !

 " 3  

 !

 8674 ""

  !  

8674 

'+/*+5  9 2 

    .* "  3 

++4++  " 

   :0:2 ;  " "

5;.++45;.++   " 

   :0:2 

   < 2*;   .         "





   -

  " 3  .* "  3 

++4++  " 

   :0:2 ;  " "  3 

5;.++ 45;.++   " 



/   :0:2 

   < 2*;   .         !    

 

  "

 " 3

" "   "  &= =     

 

   .+/*+5 -   !  " 3  ; "  3 

++4++  " 

   :0:2    "  " 2//4*  $  

  

"    " 

 #      *+/*+5 -    

  $ " 86

   1!   > *+/*+5



  "

 " 3

" "   $  &= =     "

   " /*%   2& "  " 3  ; "  3 

++4++  " 

  = ; "  "  3 

5;'++45;'++   

  =

  

 

" "  > **+/*+5   

    ; "  3 

++4++  

   :0 ;  " "  3 

5;'++ 45;'++   

  =  &  " 2? 0     3 

  **+/*+5

  &  " 2?    "  " 2/,4* 9  "%6

    "   

  

    '+/*+5 9  "!     



 "" ; 7%* 

      '+/*+5      " 

 =   -     " 3 - 

   "   

 

 =  1

  1   !

  1   !

 

     ! "

, "

"

 

 7 3        !

  1    "  +; 

2-%(1%+;; "  

   <   ""3

  9 !



> " "

   3 0

     3  "  9

 "" 03 

3  3

  "  !



> "  "   3      ""     

   ! "

  "   ?  "   

 2 "    867*4  867*4&  " 0 

 & @&A #   - "   &           

 03   

&  $   867*48  867*4-  

 $   " ) 3

 "     0  ;

 ) " 

 3  0    3 .*  "     2 )  ; ;) 

 

 5;.++   " 9 !



> "     B B   &      B0B > .+/*+5  !   "

867*4/  

&= -    867*4, -

  "" 

 -  "    " "  ! " ) 2)%+& @0A ((*/   &    =   - "    "! 0     -%5.%+(+(   "! 0  

   9 "%6

     .+/*+5  $   6"       3  "  " 3

 $ 03   "    " 3    "    $  .+/*+5 9 C 3   " " 3 -

 

@&A #    -    " 3

'

 9 C 3 > " "" 1





   

   '+/*+5 )  

   -$



    

"

 + 7%5 $  

     !

 " 3  

 !

86754 -     " 3

  $ " 86

   7%( 

 1  !  

! " 86  5 * 7%/ "

   



" "     "   "!  "      "  

"

"    ?  "    - "    " 3   9 2 

  

-> - !    " -      B2 B 0 " 3 



  

  +   *+   /   ++   */+  7  ""    3 

  - 

  

  ""  3  "    " !3 5 7%, = 

   

   "  ""

     867/4  " 3       '+/*+5 ( 7%' 0 

       "3  "    ? 9   " "   " $   "! "    ?  3  "    -      9  "%6

     " 3 

  *'5   0  

 

  *+   +  /  *      /++  

 " 3

  

 0  .*



.

/ &7% 

     #  !



   1

  



 

"           !

  03  !

 

 3 "

 " !

 > ,+/*+5   5+  = 

 !

   

 " 1"

 = 

     ,++   

 

 =!

       %

% 

   1

  



     3   "  0

  1   ! " 

2)%+$&%((*/ 0 3     9     

 7

3 "  1   " "

 

   "       " 0 ! "   9 " "

     "     3 1





   

   " 

 =  03 C 9 " "

    9  "% 6

        ! " 3   " ""

   "" 1

  



 !

3

 9 " "

 

"      ->   & , &7%* 1"

   "" 1

 





   "

?  -      ! " 

2)%+$&%((*/  "

" 

" " "

  1





  

 03 C      - ! 3    ' &7%5  

  "     &7% 

   &7%* 1"

  



" 

;

""   . &7%(   

     

 



  " 

 =  ,+/*+5 -   ""





 

   1

 "    " 

 =    .++4;++   ,+/*+5 ""    3   "  

  "  = 



 )  ,+/*+5   .++4;++  -  

     D     "   ; 0 $ " 86

B   86D 0  B "

  9 " "



"    - !    !    3 !

 "      

 3  

   "

  "  "    !  " 3    "

       

 3

  ""

   &7%(   

  

  "   " -  



  "  ,+/*+5  .++4;++  0 !

 &7% 

 &7%* 1"

   &7%5  

3 

"  3  

   3 = 

  -!



 2  = 

 -!



 ! 

6

   "

 *+ 0  #     $

  

 !

"#$% &% "#$' () # *$  #% +,-./0 . )'#  )# %% +#!0 1,- !       "   3 

 3  

 " 3   ""  6

 

 



      " "   "3    C 3  "   "! @../  A   3  !    4 

! "  ""   0  #  !     %

+   

    

          

     

    



  

      

 

 

      

     

   

    

 

    



      



 



   



    

 

  

    

 !    

  

"      #$% 

&'

%(

&%%)    

 *  +    



   





   

       

 

    

          

   

       

    

 ,(-- "

.         "  

     /  

     

 

  



 

    

   



                 0 

( ) &%%)  



 ! 





  

            



   "    

 







    "      



      

   

 

2   &$'&%(% 3





   

,4 (&   ($.   "        

    

  4 (#       

    

  

 ! 



  

 

   , .

     



 



         

 

   5  0         





  





 

 

6    " !   

 

 

 6

  !    "  

  "   " * 0     

   ""  3    "  

"

"    ?  "    "3

"" "

   0 " 3  " 

&= 9     " " 6

     ! 

" !

$< #

" "  2 

     0    !

 "        "   

" 

"  !   "    ! 3 



 " /+   2& "   C    " 



"  "   "!   "       0 "     

     5 /+ +++4%      7%, = 

 0     $  

3

! " 5/   2& " 9    ""    3  

" "

   "  "3

3  ** 0  #     $

!$&  *2 &%   #3* +,-.40 .5 )'#  )# %% 441 !   "    "   3 ""       ""   "          

" "

   0  #  !     % (& !  

  7 

4 (    



       

 

      !   

               

*   



  



           8

   

 

    

  

   

$   394 :

    



  

      

 

 

   

$ 394:

   ;

$ 4 

    <,(.

  



  



    :

           

  0       



         

    

         

             



 



 = 

< 



   

6 

  

   "

      

     ,&. 1   

 



   

 

  

  

      

  

   

  

  

      



  6 ! = 





,(.

  

$  

 

 >    ?

   >    ? 

  

        

 

     



,&.

  

$       

  

$    

    

   0        

  

  

     

      



    8

  

 

    

         

     

 

   

 

 @

 

 

5  

    

$   394 :

            8       

  

    

 



 

    



  ! 

  

   

   

 



 

     



 





  

 



   0    





     "

      

 



    

$   394 :

            

 

       

 

   

  

 

6 *5 0  #     $

()!6 *$#  *2 *$ * # &%   ")*78 +,-.40 9 )'#  )# %% 951 ! 6

  

 B" "

B   B B 0  #  !     % (# !   

 

  

 ! 

   

       

 

  "   

    

  :

  



    

  

 

 

             

 

 

      " ((% 

    "  

A(-%     " :  



     

  " 

    



    



  

  

        !   

          !  

 "      "

      "    

   



  



  

    



 

(   "    

   

     

     

    ((% 

    " 

    " ! 

        

    

 !   

            " 

  

  

  

     

   

 

     (' 

 

   

*

2    54&%%$ ' 00 A#         ;,'15,  && &.

&& ! 

>

?

     

 

  

      

      

  

    B 7

  2  :   :

 + @ C()') A 00 &'A   "

 

 

      

 >

?

      



   &$ !   >

? 



                     &A :

  D     8 * 4 ()'&&00()A

  

 

    

  

    

 

          

 

  

    

    C   

  & !   >

? 

     

,  & #6*./5:  1/;.

  

   

     

/ 

"      E  

  

     

  

   ,)!!

&* &

#!   *%%./59< /99.6 (- 9

 84 C&%(% ) 00 #%-       



    

 

  

      



     7   *   2   8 7C  &%( # 00 &&&  

           ; ,*  2   00  &$- $)  &( &&.

&( 1      



   

      >

?    

 

(-    

 

 

  





     

   

      



      

  !                

    

      

 1 

 "

     

  > ?      

     



           

  



  

    

    

  



   

 

  C      

       

              

  &&                    

        



 

 

    

       !

  

,   



   



 

          !  

  

      

    

  

  

        

  !





       

       



 

   

  









 

  

     

      

 

   

6 ()       



 

   

      

     7

  0  @ 8 3



&%(( (( 00 $A'   

 "      

 

        

  9 

 :

   



    

 



  "F  

    "  

  F            

 

         

   ((% 

    "    "    

  

     

  " !    

       

            

        



 

  6    "      !

 "    "

" " "3 !  3   

" 

    *( 0  #     $

*  *$ *$  #% &%   #3* +,-.:0 .1 )'#  )# %% 1,- !

'

   "   "    "       ""             0  #  !     % (( ! 5  0     

    

  

     ; ! 

 

  C       :

   (% 





A( "

 4   "  

 C  

         " G 

   

   

          " GG! 

   

  

 "

     

 



  " 

 C      

      



   



 3

  

   

  

    

  ! 



 

 C  

 

        

     

    H  +  

        

       C       C





  

    

          C

 "  

    

   

    C    

 

   "

       

  

  C        !    

 

  I     



      

 

  



 C

  

  

   

.

   

     

   

  

A   $   :

  

     

  !            

 



 

 5      

    

 



 

 

  





  



 

6 ,= .    (# !      

 C 

       

      !    

   

    

 



 

 (' !    

  * 2 B :

  5 4     

; &%  

&%,.

"



   



  

&%  0 H   :

   



      

   6 I  

  

     

   

 ! 

>

?

 



      

 

   !    



  C "  &$ !   >

? 



                   &A 4

  

 

     

  

;

     

 

      

  

 

  

    

    C   

  (- !0   ; &# 8

 

   



   

 

             





 

   

$   :

     



 



    

      





  

A  

 

      

   &' 

 

   



   



 

    

$   A  :

6 ,= . () 1  

 

  

  

$   A   :

  



    

      

 

         

  

     

  :

   

    :



 

$   :



      

     



 



        

 

   6 */ 0  #     $

 # '!  *2 &%   ")*78 +,-.-0 / )'#  )# %% 9-; ! 6  E F   " /(  "  "

   "3 

" 

 

!  "

" 6    E  3    "

  

3   9

*+     "

  " 6 0  #  !    % ($ 

    

    

 

  

      

      4

      



       

 

  

 

   

(-   :

 

   

 

   

 



         

  "

  (A  

A   :

   

 

        ; JA 4 

 

    

   :

       

    

      

 

 



    :

     ,.   

 

    

 



   

F ,.      

 

 



     F , .   

  

    

 



         

   

 

    

 

   

F  ,.         

   

       





    

 

 

 

             







  

 

 

 

 

      

     

   J

* ( 1    

                

     

      

 



 

    

    

   4

       

$   :

 

  



  







   !

     

  

       

         

   

    

 6 *,     .+/*+5   *+/*+5 867*4, 867*4/ 867*4, 867*4'

 3    " 3  "   &= 0   ! "    *+/*+5     =

        0   3  7%* 

 !  ""

      7%* 

  "  "3    "   

   .++      +(/  C     ,/  -     <9

  

    867*4  86742   3  9 !



> " 7%/ "

     3    "   +++   '+/*+5 ""     +5+  2 "      &  0

 "     */  "!3     /5+  7%' &  0      "    */  0 

 "  "          

 "  "    0  !

   3 -$



 -     3   0   !

 "    

 3  

 " ""    '+/*+5

**     "

   3 -!



   



  5++.*+5 -  ""     "

  ""

 "   &=  .+/*+5   *+/*+5 7  ""  6

   " 55 $$ "

 " C

        "  &  9> " " "  "  ;   "! 0    ++4++  "          )  ; ;) *' ""

3   

         7 8.9:

 7 .

.

:

 9(; <

' 9  + 7 

4   G42 7  G42