Hakam Singh And ANR v. State Of Punjab
! "
# $
% ! "
& '(& ) )
)* +
'(& ) + (* ! "#$ %&!'&&( ) * + ,&!'& '( ) *-!& * . + '
&/ ( (,"
)
)* +
,
' && & !(' !' ) &* 2 34 3516( * 7 8 + 54
* (& * +*'! 2!&(" ''** (+ ++* &'" *& :53;351;:97('*% ) &* +* )&*& ( ('* )&* )(' !' *&! 2 34 3516( ' & ! * * ( * %/''&+<* *-. '* )&*
-. /01 )$02
) 0 $ 2 /-#30 $
2$0 /%&!'
:537
&! % & % + &+
15(555;= 2 % '
&! % & %
/%&!'
3517
&! % & % + )#
8(555;= % '
&! % & %
2&!'
:537
&! % & % + &+
15(555;= 2 % '
&! % & %
2&!'
3517
&! % & % + )#
8(555;= % '
&! % & %
' * )&* "* % !!&) + % ' ) &* + * )&*& - .( ( "* %!!&) + %'* >& ' *-. - .( "*% &% '% "# ' 7 )&*&!7 ( (')*' &'%(' !' '&?* &&!'&
"+ '&7 ( +
:
'!& +' *& *"* %* &'
2'&*'<'&"&@=18;
&&! '&(&& ' 11 5A 3519( ; )& &!' !2&' /',& &!'( ,& &!'(7 !&!'(7/% &!'(7/'& &!' 7 ,&!'2 & * *& 2&' &! # *'*/&! + * ) )'&* =:1== :A16 2'&*' 2 "&! &) "# 7 % &!' 2! &! 2 & ( %/( 7' &* @'' &* #*' " )&!& ('*&) *&+ %& '/%&!'(/ &!'&/- * .( 2&!'(&!' !'; + %&!'(2' & +)&! %/( 2'&( &%& )&! ' (&!'(2' & & & & &! & ' )&!( / &!' ' 2 )!"&'&+& && &!&' %* * '
" 2 '" '& &!2&''&% '&')&! ' " '%& &!+&) '+/ *'
" 35 #! (/&!'&/% !! '&+&) '+/ 2&''&*B&!' /%&!'
2&!'2 '+'/&!'2 '& +&) '+/ '& (# # 15 5A " 3$:5;:$55?* */('#" '')% /&!'"# &+&*&!&,& '&%&' %* * &'+& '& " # "B "# &/&! ' "& + + & &+ %& (* *& :53;351;:972!& 4)
)
>2+ &!'<*&)!& % +C' ; )&&!' !2&' '
&* ++&*&*' ' *2 &* 'C % % :8-.2 ' " #2+
% %<%&& ' !'7 ,&!' 7/% &!'
!'& +' * + ***2 ' %*& +#2& ' &!'
* & 2!
+ %'>2&2' 2 ' !2&'
'& '
%&&!'
'+&! &
&! '% # " #&!' 2! ) '" 2% &
* ' * 2 2&' ? ?
% 2 # %2/& & )& %% '+&! &
&! '& !2! ) ( "'#* "&+ ( >+ &! ' ! '' 2% &! & ('& &' "
5 & '2&+ ' % & * ' * 2 2&' "&! &% & ? ?
% 2 # +2' ) /',& &!'
'! % +'* 2'&*'2'+"2 /& & )& %% % +'2& 2* ' ' ! ' +'& !2/ ' % % !2&' ' % * 2 / &
& ' * & '* + '&'&* '& && & '% '! ' */ &,# )& !-"&.2'&*'% %& ++&*& * '&' &#* + % + *', &!' +)&! %/2* *& 1A17 '
' ! ' 2 / & & )& %% ' ** 2 14 5A ' 2 & ' * %%&& +'*&%2* ) '% +' ** * *& 36 +)& ** !'& + ' * +* )#2 % +'2&2 * %% 2 /*' +2 + ++* 2 +'" &2 "&
+ * % & + &)&!& "# ' &)&!&! ++&** * (& ' - .('&& ++&%&) *& 16:7 ("+ ' 7 %%& ! * * (!&" ''**
&&(
)
& &! ' ++* *& :53 7 " <*&)#&""#'7 +& (' * %%&&!
% 7 )& 54 3519(* %%& '* '7 + ' & !( (
)
+& &! &%+*&*(*'! *& :53;3517"*%+% (!&" ''** ( 2'&*''#
!&#( (*&% &
+ ' *& *( ' *& <%& &< 2& + * % & + * &! + ' && + ' *& 2&( ' && & !* * ( 2 * &!( *& :1: +' 7 ( " '&( ' ** *&% + &% &*& ( (
& **
'& +*('** <%& /%&!'
@=1(,,&!' @=3 * ' +*)& *
+* *& +'&(( '
- .("#' && & !(('
* %/'+ ) &* +* )&*& ( ( % ' * >' *- .( ('
) &)) ) (
)(
(()
' * + '!!&) * )&*=
'&(')&! #! "+ '&7 (''&% ! ) &* +* )&*& ( * >' *-.- .( &% ( '* )&*=
('& 2&'! &+&%&# + ! %&
*&& ( =
*&& + ' )& *(<&&! * '+ (''! ''
" ** ( ( ' ) &*( *'! "+ '& 7 ( "
6 >' ( &
) &)) ) ( )
)(
' '' (' * '! "+ '&7 ('', !%(*'! "+ '&7 (& 2%& ( 2#&+*
) )& *))* () 1:
)&!'*'!- . 2!&'* )&*( ' *& % &* ' && + *2& ' ***(2'
& '2&" <(@=1= ' &!'
'&<%&& =&=*'&+( '' % *' &!( ' 5A 3519(2''2 &'&+& 2% )&!' <!&'* +& ('" 3 :5;:
55
% (2'' 2 &!(&'/ '* * &'+& ('' & + %'/ ' +//&/&!'( 2''*' '(' /' /%&!' 2 &!'2"&!
// &/&!'("& *' '/%&!'2 % 2&' ( ( 2&!'2% 2&'& &
@=1 ' * & &+#" ''** (2' 2
&'7
+'&+&&'&<%&& =&=*'&+('// &/&!'+ 2 '& /(" ' + '&&!'&%(2' (' /''** *% 2 '&% '&% )(' /''# ' '&%'&*' &* ' *** # (' '#2 &%&'&% @=1 &+&&'&<%&& =&=*'&+(''
! ** '&%''#2 "B//&/ &!'
@=1(+'% ' /' '< #(&' % &!(" D;15 55 (!%" + !' & '+& +//&/&!'( ' &* *' ' &+&'''#+ ''" " # + //&/&!'('2#&!' * +'
&* ++&*&+ )& &! *& ('% %"+ ' * * ('/%&!' 2&!'% // E/&!' '+' '& " # +&
1A
'&<%&& =&=*'&+('' )'& )& # * %&2&&!
@=1 ++ ' + <*&!* <%&& ("# &!* ' +(' +* * '+& &*&+ %'&%('#*' &!>' && - .( ( * % & & '& <%&& =&=*'&+( ' "&!!& (+( (* &) '+ (* *& " &! ' && +@=1 & (4 ' !' &%*# & " &! * &" * ** "#* &"#2&)&==)&% &*)& *( "#" +! * " & ' & >& "% "#% &*)& *
' * 2' * * # '" # +' * /&!'
& '2&" <@=A &!
'* +'<%&& =&=*'&+(' ) ' % % ("*%' "#' "# !
'
) '<&*' +')& &! +
7 !
' % % &&! <'&"& <'&"&
1D
)( ' ' ) ' ' * + ' + * /&!'-<'&"&.(2 2&! '% '! ' */* "#'&,& )& !-"&.(2'&*' "% %&( 2'&*' "++&*& * ' & ' &# * + ' ) % % &,& &* "#@=A( '" # + * <* '&+
1. A lacerated wound of 8X2 cm present on left Frontotemporal region with brain matter coming out from the wound. On dissection s/c infiltration of blood was present. On further dissection blood clots are present over frontotemporal area of brain in skull cavity.
2. 4X1 cm lacerated wound present adjacent to injury No.1 and is 2 cm below. On dissection s/c infiltration of blood was present. On further dissection, blood clots were present on left frontotemporal area of brain in skull cavity.
'+ ('" )<* &,&("*% ) ** '" # +' * ( +&*'&!# # ) ' *)& (" * & # )'' +' &*&%& #2 + ++*('"#'* )&*
) ( )
)&8)9
)
):
4 ) )2;
-0#2$3 #0-0. 0 /-$$#-<-.)2 ;1
&!'* +&)&!& ("&!% & '
( * )&* /% &!' % &! &* %( 2'&*' < & &! ' &! &* %(% "#'** & )"&%<* '&+
=
!"
#
$
%
"
"
& '()(*)('+
$
,
#
%
!"
!"
% "
-
.
$
$
%
$
# "
) &% ,
"
#
)/
012,
!"
#
3 !
.
!, ! -
!"
4!
!
"
) 3 0 !
.
!, -
!"
4!
!
"
' " ) &! &* %( * )&*/%&!'(! * ) '2 + ++*& " & ( 2'&*' 2 / & &* & ( ' !'
* )#%% <
)2;
-0#2$3 #0-0. 0 /-$$#->-)2 ;1 3:
&!'* +&)&!& ("&!% & '
( * )&* 2 &!' % &! &* %( 2'&*'< & &! '&! &* %(% "#'** & )"&%<* '&+
!"
#
$
%
"
"
& '()(*)('+
$$
,
%
!"
% "
-
$
%
$
# "
"
%
6 ) &% ,
"
#
)/
012,
!"
#
3 !
.
!, ! -
!"
4!
!
"
) 3 0 !
.
!, -
!"
4!
!
"
' " ) &! &* %( * )&* 2&!'(! * ) '2 + ++*& & & ( 2'&*'2/& &* & (' !'* )#%% <
F
) *
& ) ( )
)&8)9
4 && 8)9 &! +' *&)#% &* %( )(' #" ''** * + '& &*& & ( &'*&%)(" )>'&?)&*&!'& & * * )& + ' ) &*&%& # &%( ' &)&!&! ++&** * ('+ %'& *&) *-. + '&'& &! / &!"#'%( 2'&*' *-.2"/ 2 <*&)# '%( 2'+( '# ' !' * )# %% -. *&)#* % & &<'&"&( (&<'&"&F( *&)# & * ' ) * )&( ' &)&!&! ++&* * * ' " ) 2 &* % 2' "* %&! "#*' +'* =* )&*( ( 2''# '%/&! +'
&* )&'& *&)&*( '&)&!&! ++&** * * >*(*&#& " % '" ) 2%% -.
' !''&!&! +*&# ' 2 "* %2 #(2''#' "# & (' <&* + '& *&) &! ' ( ( ' ++&**& # )'')* )&(2!& ( (
* &) ' ' !' *) !% "&! # "# ' &)&!&! ++&** * ("# &! +' && + @* * ( )(''" ) &"<* #
('*+ !&!')&  ' +'" ) 2 %% -.( ' "* %&! &' & "* %&! ++&**& #
)
3A >(" ''" ) 2%% -.*>&*& )& #2 '
#'# * " '" )* &" * ** ( ( > ' *& *( ( * " '% &*** & *' +
)?&
'"+ &*)& *(&* % & &' + '+&! &< ( 2'&*'<'&"&@19;7"* %&!
' ' ! ' +'+&!&% & (2+ '& &' %(2&+& "#@=18 * )&&!'( ')"*&*/ ( 2'&*'< 1 A')"&!
)(&"* %*' "#@=18&'&<%&& =&=*'&+( ' 3A 5A 3519('+&!&% & +** 2&!' /%&!'('2 "& &' * + %&&!'
'& -<*&)!&. !'( ( '" )% +&!&% & +'* )&*('* *&)#<'&"& <'&"&C"* %&! ">#() "#' +'+&! &< 2'&*'< @19;7&&! ('*+ '
& &= %*'&! "&! % ( ' &= ' 2
' ! ' "&! ' ) ' ! ' +&! &% & ( 2&''2 *'& "&! &!&&% & *&)# +
* )&* 2&!' * )&*/%&!'(''+&! & < * * ( & ''&++&*&&%&&#&=" '
') +'+&! &< &<* '&+
, #
$
$
"
#
) 7)(*)('+
!
) ! $ ) 4
#
9) **:;.<
) 7)(*)('+
=,5 9)*'
'')(*)('+ <(('<+ ,4;
4)!
!
"
" ;) 9
!" 9) '((8
$
$"
$
$
>>
$"
$ 9 , $
%
"
$
? @A $
% ) )
"
"
%
$
$
$ "
$
2 $
!"
!
$ #
"#
$"
$
"
? ,A
$ # %) @ $
%
$ #
"
$ %
) 2
$
# ) !
% $
%
$
"
) 2
$
)
2
$"
$
$
$"
$ 9),, $
%
"
$
? @A $
% ) )
"
"
%
$
$
$ "
$
8
"
$
!"
$ #
"#
$"
$
"
? ,,A
$ # %) @ $
%
$ #
"
$ %
) 2
$
# ) !
% $
%
$
"
"
) 2
$
) !
.
!"
="
$ $
!
.;
$
="
$
!
.
="
4
))))/ ' " ) - .( % "# ' +&! & < + %/&! +
& &= * % & &= 2
' ! '"&! ' ! ' &% & ('2&'2 *'
& "&! &!&&% & *&)# +* )&* 2&!'
* )&*/%&!'(" ")& #* % &'"+ &* )& *('(+ )&!'!& +'** &'*'! ++* %&#()& &#)&! & "&! ' ( )& *"* % * '"#'* )&*=
(" !!&)''* *& - .2& (!& ( ( * &) ( ' !' *) !% "&! # "# ' &)&!&! ++&* * * 7 &#( 2' ' " ) %
&* *& %& =*'! =" ('"# '&++&%&)&=* % & (2% "#'+&!
& < ( ' &! & &* # && "&! 2 !&'* )&*('"#*>&-.* *&)&# 3D 7 >#(' *& '"#' ) ' '&'*'!!&" ''
=* )&*
(
:5 * >*('& %&&'
( (&& &%& '&% ! ) &*( (* >' *-.
5 - .++&% %&& :1
+'
=* )&*- . "&(' ( '*-.&% '* )&*=
(" "+ '2&'<* "#' & !* * (' !''& 2&!* %%&2 :3
'* #(&+#(" 2&'&** *2&' 2+'< &# + & +&%&& + '+&&! +
'* "+ '2&' 2 8)
)* +
8+ (* 9 % ! "
/)&!' *101@-<2 ;A-
A
*101@ 0-B3 A