High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1259/2013dismissed

Harpal Singh @ Raju v. Narcotic Control Bureau, Chandigarh

2016-05-03Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan15 pages

! "# #&'('$ )

** + $*

.'( 12 ********* --#.."

3#,(2( ,&$"'&( $",$.

2,#24 0'/,0 ******** #(-$#"

5-.

********* --#.."

3#,(2( ,&$"'&( $",$.

2,#24 0'/,0 ******** #(-$#"

) 6 7 *

,#(#") ,* ** * '/04 9$&"#4 --#.."

:$"0 --#.(* ,* * * 0,54 #'$, "'/ $2(#.4 ,#(-$#" 0'/,0* 7

4 *

;

"0'( ('/.# 12/5#"4 (0..

'(-$(# "<$ &$#&"# --#.( '*#* $*

%'.# &&2(#--#.."

.'( 12 $*

%'.# &&2(#--#.."

5-.4 ,'('/ $2"

(5# 12/5#"

&$9'&"'$ "#

** 9'# <0'&0 &&2(#--#.."( <#,# &$9'&"# #&"'$( & ,&$"'& ,2/(

(;&0$",$-'& 2:("&#( &"4 = ' (0$,"

6 &"6 $,#, (#"#&# "# >** 9'# <0'&0 "0#;

<#,# (#"#&# 2#,/$ ,'/$,$2( '5-,'($5#"

;#,( #&0 %'# (* 4

#&04 #%2."

"0#,#$%4 %2,"0#, 2#,/$ ,'/$,$2( '5-,'($5#"

;#,( #&0 #&"'$ & &"4 -((# .#,# 2/#4 -#&'.

$2,"4 0'/,0* 0#;

<#,# .($ (#"#&# 2#,/$ ,'/$,$2( '5-,'($5#"

;#,( #&0 %'# (* 4

#&04 #%2."

"0#,#$%4 %2,"0#, 2#,/$ ,'/$,$2( '5-,'($5#"

;#,( #&0 #&"'$ &"

$"0 (#"#&#( <#,# $,#,# ,2 &$&2,,#".;* -,#(#"

--#.."( <#,# ",'# $ &$5-.'"

%'.# ,&$"'&( $",$.

2,#24 0'/,04 ?$.

' (0$,"

6 6*

%&"( ,# ) %&"( ,# $ *@*

=4 "

:$2"

)

4 #(0 .$$'4 "#..'/#&# %%'&#,4 -$("# "

?$.

'"4 ,#&#'9# (#&,#"

(-#&'%'& '%$,5"'$

$# 5

,-.4 ,#('#"( 0'/,04 ,#

'9$.9# ,&$"'& ",%%'&A'/ &(#(* % ,' &$2&"#4 "0#;

& --,#0## &$",:*

(' '%$,5"'$ ,#2&# '"$ <,'"'/4 9'#

B* *

-,$2&# :#%$,# 2-#,'"##"4 0,'

.<'#, 825,4 <0$ -2"

$"# B*

$ (5# ',#&"# #(0 .$$'4 "#..'/#&# %%'&#,4 &$("'"2"# "#5 &$2&"

,'* &&$,'/.;4 "#5 &$("'"2"#*

<$ -#,($(4 5#.;4 '.

825, 2"5 8,", <#,# 1$'# B'

"4 #&"$,4 0'/,04 '#-##"

<'"#((#(*

0#,#%"#,4 #"',#

"#5 .$/<'"0

'#-##"

<'"#((#(

,#&0# #, &2.9#,"

#&"$, 4 0'/,04 (","# -'&A#"'/ (2,9#'..&# "0#,#*

:$2"

4 5-.

(## &$5'/ 4 #&"$, > 0'/,0 &,,;'/ :/ 0'( 0*

# <'"# #, &2.9#,"

($5#:$;*

0#4 %"#, @ 5'2"#(4 &5# $"0#, ('#*

&&2(# 5-.

0# $9#, (' :/ 0'5*

0#,#%"#,4 :$"0 <#,# (2,,$2#

"#5*

%"#, D2#("'$'/ :$2"

"0#', 5# '#"'";4 "0#;

(#,9# $"'&#( B* B* + 2-$ 5-.

,#(-#&"'9#.;4 '%$,5'/ "0#5 :$2"

"0#', ,'/0"

/#"

"0#5(#.9#( (#,&0# :#%$,# /E#""# $%%'&#,*

#&.'# $%%#, 9$.2"##,# (#,&0#

"#5*

&&2(# $-## :/ 5-.

"$$A $2"

-$.;"0## :/4 <0'&0

> &$"'# "0,## -&A#"(4 <,--# ,$< "-#*

'D2',;4 '(&.$(# "0#,# 0#,$' (' -&A#"( (5# :## :,$2/0"

0'/ $9#, '/0*

(5..

-$,"'$ &$",: #D2'9.#"

0# 5"&0 ("'&A "A# $2"

0# $9#, ,#(0 825, &$2&"

"#("

0#.- %'#. ,2/ #"#&"'$ A'"

&,,'# "#5*

"#("'/4 '"

%$2 #,$'* <#'/05#"4 '"

%$2 #&0 -&A#"

&$"'# A/ 0#,$'*

-&A#"( <#,# "A# '"$ -$((#(('$*

( -#$-.# (","# /"0#,'/ "

(-$"4 "0#,#%$,#4 (#&2,'";

,#($(4 #"',#

"#5 .$/<'"0 '#-##"

<'"#((#(4 (#'E# &$",: <#"

:&A $%%'&# ('"2"# $2(# $* = #&"$,4 0'/,0*

<$ (5-.#( /,5(

#&0 (#-,"# #&0 -&A#"

<#,# (#.#*

-,$-#,";

0# $9#, 0,'

.<'#, 825, 2-#,'"##"4 #-$('"'/ (5# .A0*

(""#5#"( <#..

5-.

B* B* + #&"'$ +@ &"

<#,# ,#&$,#*

%"#, &$5-.#"'$ %$,5.'"'#( '9#("'/"'$4 &0.. -,#(#"#* <#,# &0,/#(0##"# #&"'$( = &"*

-.## $"

/2'.";

&0,/# &.'5# ",'.* (2--$,"

'"( &(#4 -,$(#&2"'$ #B5'#

.<'#, #-$;

C4 ,#(0 825,4 "0# "#..'/#&# %%'&#, C4 #(0

.$$'4 &$5-.'"

4 '.

825, C>

02< 54 (('(""

0#5'&.

B5'#,4 74 #< #.0'*

C0# #B5'# #&"'$

,* **4 .'( 12 -.## &$",: ..#/# 09# :## :,$2/0"

0#,

* * /'9# 5-.

"0#,# $ ## '9#("'/"'/ $%%'&#, <'"

5-.

",(%#, &$",: '/0*

(""# -,$(#&2"'$ ("$,;

%.(#*

$"0 '#-##"

<'"#((#( ,# ("$&A <'"#((#(*

-,$-#,";

"5-#,# <'"0*

(5-.#( <#,# /$"

.;(# "<'&#4 <0'&0 "0#', <#'/0"

'%%#,#"* -#,&#"/# '&#";.5$,-0'# :$"0

,#-$,"( '%%#,#"* %',("

,#-$,"4 '"

* F4 <0'.# (#&$ ,#-$,"

*>F* (#.

0# $9#, '#-##"

<'"#((*

%2,"0#, ..#/# '9#("'/"'/ $%%'&#, 0'( "#5 &$55'""# "0#%"

0$2(# '/0*

4 /$. 1#<#..#,;4 $# #&A.&#4 /$. ,'/4 $# <"&04 $# -2,(# &$"''/ &,4 '#"'";

&,4 ,#/'(","'$ &#,"'%'&"# (&$$"#,4 $# '/'".

&5#,4

+ $# #, ,'/4 %$2,

:$"".#( .'D2$, &# &$"''/ 52(", $'.

A/ <#,# ("$.#*

"'5#4 1'#, '/04 02 54 $/'#,

.4 "$(0 '

5#(0 825, #'/0:$2,( <#,# -,#(#"*

%2,"0#, (""# 1'

$04 ',#&"$,

,,#("# -$.'&# <0'.# 0# -$((#(('$

A/ (5&A*

..#/# (' ',#&"$, 2(# &$..#&"

<##A.;

5$#;

,2/ -#.#,( 0# .($ ',#&"'/ :,'/ 5$#;

'%%#,#"

&&2(#4 <0'&0 0# ,#%2(#* &.'5# 0# (#&,#"

'%$,5#, 0'/,0 -$.'&# 0# 0 /$"

,'# -,#5'(#( "-.4 <0$ &$9'&"#

,#9#"'$ $,,2-"'$ &"

$2,"*

&$(-',&;

0'/,0 -$.'&#4 -."# %.(# 2-$ 0'5*

# $"0#, %.(# -."# 2-$ 0'54 <0'&0 0# :## &D2'""#* 5-.

0'( (""#5#"

.($ &.'5# '% &$",: :,$2/0"

0#,

"0# 0# (0$2. 09# :## 1$'# '9#("'/"'$4 :2"

0# .#"

$%%*

(5-.# (#.( <#,# "5-#,# <'"0* #%#&#4 #B5'# 1'#, 82, C4 <'%# &&2(#4 0'( #'/0:$2, 1'#, C4 /

($ '/04 C 4 ,'

@ $:'4 "#..'/#&# %%'&#,4 0'/,0 C>4

.<'#, 825,4 2-#,'"##"4 0'/,0 C4 C+ &.$(# #%#&# #9'#&#*

%"#, 0#,'/ .#,# -#&'.

2:.'&

,$(#&2"$, &$5-.'"4 .#,# &$2(#.

/$'/ "0,$2/0 #9'#&#4 .#,# 2/#4 -#&'.

$2,"4 0'/,04 &$9'&"# (#"#&# &&2(#--#.."(4 %$,#('* 09# 0#, .#,# &$2(#.

&&2(#--#.."(4 .#,# &$2(#.

,#(-$#"

09# .($ &,#%2..;

/$# "0,$2/0 %'.#* $,#, -,$9# ,#&$9#,;4 #(0

.$$'4 "#..'/#&# %%'&#,4 <0$ &$5-.'"

"0'( &(#4 0'5(#.% --#,#

,,"# #"',# $&&2,,#&#*

# %2,"0#, -,$9# $ ,#&#'9'/ '%$,5"'$4 "0#;

%$2 5-.

&$5'/ ('# 4 #&"$,> 0'/,04 &,,;'/ :/*

C0# "0#;

A#-"

<"&0 $ 0'54 '"

%$2 &5# "0#,# :/ 0# $9#, 0'5*

C0# <#,# ,,#("#4

-&A#"( <,--# :,$< "-# <#,# ,#&$9#,#*

,$5 (' -&A#"(4

A/* #,$' ,#&$9#,#*

# .($ -,$9# (#-,"'$ (5-.# "A'/ (5# '"$ -$((#(('$*

# %2,"0#, ("# :$"0 5-.

.'( 12

= 5# (""#5#"( #&"'$ +@ &"4 <0'&0 ,# B* B* + ,#(-#&"'9#.;*

'( (""#5#"

&$,,$:$,"# "#..'/#&# %%'&#, ,#(0 825, C '.

825,4 '#-##"

<'"#(( C>* 7#,# &$2(#.

.'( 12 ,/2# 0# :## %.(#.;

'9$.9# -,#(#"

&(#* ("$,;

($2/0"

-2"%$,<, 1'

$04 ',#&"$, <0$ ."#, $ ,,#("# ",'# -$.'&# A##-'/ 0'( -$((#(('$

A/ (5&A4 '%&"

'9$.9# ,&A#"*

(' 1'

$0 &$..#&"'/ <##A.;

5$#;

,2/ -#.#,( ',#&"# :,'/ 5$#;

$"0#, ,2/ -#.#,(*

# %2,"0#, (""# 0# ",/#"

('&# 0# '%$,5#, 0'/,0 -$.'&# $ 0'( '%$,5"'$4 "

.4 <0$ ,,#("# ."#, $ &$9'&"# $2,"

,#9#"'$ $,,2-"'$ &"4 ==*

0#,#%$,#4 '"

&$(-',&;

0'/,0 -$.'&# ,,#("

0'5*

# .($ ,#.'# 2-$ (""#5#"( 0'( <'%# 1'#, 82, C4 0'( ,-.6( ($ /

C #'/0:$2, 1'#, C* 5 9'#< "0#,# $ -,$$% 1'

$04 ',#&"$,

;<;

'9$.9# -,#(#"

&(#*

-,#(#"

&(#4 (#&,#"

'%$,5"'$ ,#&#'9# &$5-.'"

#(0 .$$'

0# .' ",- ,,#("# :$"0 (-$"*

5#,# %&"

.'( 12

<'"#(( ($5# $"0#, /'("

$# -$.'&# $%%'&'.

$ /,$2 0$. 0# $"

'9$.9# -,#(#"

#.'/ #,$'*

9#,;

#(;

-,$&2,# (""#5#"

<'%#4 ($ #'/0:$2, &&2(#*

&$55$ A$<.#/# %"#, (2&0 ,#&$9#,;4 5;

"'5#(4 -$.'&# .($ (#,&0 0$2(# &2.-,'"

4 "0#,#%$,#4 "0$2/0

-,";

5'/0"

09# 9'('"# 0$2(# .'( 124 :2"

0'( ("$,;

"0#%"4 &.'5# (""#5#"

#&"'$

,* ** &$,,$:$,"# 0'( <'%#4 ($ #'/0:$2,4 &$"

:#.'#9# ,'/0".;

'(&,# .$<#, $2,"*

.#,# &$2(#.

,#.'# 2-$ 2"0$,'";

$6:.# 2-,#5# $2,"

= ,'5'. + -,#(( &$(&'$2( -$((#(('$ &$",: $"

-,$9#*

"0'( &(#4 :$"0 <#,# --,#0## "0,## -&A#"( <,--# :,$< "-#4 <0#,#'

A/* 0#,$' %$2* 0#,#%$,#4 &$(&'$2( -$((#(('$ &$",: :$"0 -,$9# :#;$ ..

,#($:.# $2:"(*

.#,# &$2(#.

--#.."( %2,"0#, ,/2# "0'( &(#4 7 %$,5 $"

%'..#*

.#,# &$2(#.

,#.'# 2-$ 2"0$,'";

"0'( $2,"

,'5'.

(' 2"0$,'";

"",&"# -,#(#"

"0'( &(#4 -.&# 7 %$,54

0 -,#-,# #"'.( ,#&$9#,;* .$<#, $2,"

#."

"0'( (-#&"

0#.

0 %'..# #"'.( (5-.# (#"

(5# 0#5'&.

7:$,"$,;4 #< #.0'*

0'( <0"

#B&".;

$# 7 %$,5* 0#,#%$,#4 -#, -,&"'&# /#&;4 #"'.( <#,# (#-,"#.;

,#&$,# "0#,# $"0'/ <,$/ (5#*

.($ %' $ %$,&# &$"#"'$ .#,# &$2(#.

--#.."(

(0$2. 09# %',("

--,#0# 5-.

<0# 0# %$2 -&A#"( (0$2. $"

09# <'"# 0'5 5A# #.'9#,;

&$",: '/0* 5 9'#<

<"# (## <0$ #.(# '9$.9# ,2/ (52//.'/*

0#,#%$,#4 -,$&#2,# $-"#

<'"'/ 5-.

5A# #.'9#,;

.'( 124 &$,,#&"*

5#,# %&"

&$2. $"

-,$&## /'("

0#,

* *4 <0#,# &$('/5#"

:,$2/0"4 $ /,$2 &D2'"

&&2(#* .#,# &$2(#.

--#.."( %2,"0#, ,/2# -,$-#,";

"A# (-$"

$%%'&# * "

(2(-'&'$2( &"'9'";

-,"'&2.,.;

9'#< %&"

-#, ,#-$,"

74 #< #.0'

B* C=4 <#'/0"

%',("

(5-.# %$2

+*> /,5(4 <0#,#( /,5( (5-.# (#-,"#* 5 9'#< 5#,# %&"

"0#,# '%%#,#&# *> /,5( $ /,$2 0$. (5-.# "5-#,# <'"0*

&$2. 025 #,,$,*

.#(( '"

%$2 -,$-#,";

"5-#,# <'"04 $ :##%'"

& #B"## &&2(#*

(-#&'%'&

-#$-.# (","# /"0#,'/ "

(-$,"

(#&2,'";

,#($(4 <$,A (#-,"'/ (5-.# $# $%%'&# *

.($ $ $"

%' ;

%$,&# &$"#"'$ .#,# &$2(#.

--#.."( -#, (""#5#"

02< 5 C4 0# .;(# (5-.# (2-#,9'('$ * * '/04 0#5'&.

B5'#, 0#5'&.

B5'#, 0'5(#.% (0$2. 09# -#,($..;

#B5'# (5-.#* 5 9'#< ,*

02< 5 C

(('(""

0#5'&.

B5'#,*

<$,A &0#5'&.

.;('( $"

(2--$(# $# ($.#.;

0#5'&.

B5'#, 0'5(#.% 0# & &2(# (5-.# "#("# 0'( $9#,..

(2-#,9'('$ "0#,# $"0'/ <,$/ (5#*

'5'.,.;4 '% %',("

,#-$,"

(5-.# B* C=4 -#,&#"/# '&#";.5$,-0'# *F4 :2"

,#-$,"

(#&$ (5-.# B*

84 '"( -#,&#"/# *>F4 "0'( '%%#,#&# -#,&#"/# 0,.;

0#.-( &&2(#*

.$<#, $2,"

#."

(5# %$2 &$",: /,2.# %$,5*

0#,#%$,#4 $# (#"

/,2.#4 -#,&#"/#

'&#";.5$,-0'# &$2. '%%#,#"*

:## &,2(0# %$,54 "0#,# &$2. ,#($ <0;

"0#,# '%%#,#&# -#,&#"/# '&#";.5$,-0'# <0# #"',# -,$-#,";

"0$,$2/0.;

5'B# 5# 0$5$/##$2(*

/,2.# & #9#, 5# 0$5$/##$2( -$((':'.'";

9,'"'$ "0#,#* .#,# &$2(#.

--#.."( %2,"0#, ,/2# '#-##"

<'"#((#( -,$(#&2"'$ ,# ("$&A <'"#((#(* 5 9'#< $# '#-##"

<'"#(( '.

825, #B5'#*

9# '%4 (""#5#"

'#-##"

<'"#(( '/$,#4 "0#,# $ /,$2 '(:#.'#9# (""#5#"

&$5-.'"

"#..'/#&# %%'&#,4 <0$ -,$9# ,#&$9#,;*

2,"0#,4 0 5# (""#5#"

#&"'$ +@ &"4 <0'&0 5'((':.# #9'#&#*

"0#', (""#5#"(4 09# 5'""# ,#&$9#,;

&$",: "0#5*

.$<#, $2,"

#."

-,#(25-"'$ #&"'$ > &"

0$. 09# %'.# ,#:2"

(' -,#(25-"'$*

.$<#, $2,"

.($ #."

%&"

&D2'"".

.'( 12 $"0#, $ /,$2 0$. -,#(#"

%.(#*

.#,# &$2(#.

,#%#,,# 2"0$,'";

$6:.# 2-,#5# $2,"

,'5'. + ,/2# (""#5#"

5# #&"'$ +@ &"

&$"

,#.'# 2-$* $"0#, 04 .#,# (#'$, ("'/ &$2(#.

,#.'# 2-$ 2"0$,'";

$6:.# 2-,#5# $2,"

> ,'5'. + <0#,#' (&$-# 5'((':'.'";

(""#5#"

#&"'$ +@ &"

'(&2((#* 5 9'#< "0$2/0 ($.# ,#.'&# &$2. -.&# $ (""#5#"

#&"'$ +@ &"4 :2"

> <0# (5# &$,,$:$,"# (""#5#"

9#("'/"'/ %%'&#,4 ,#&$,4 <'"#((#( $"0#, $&25#"( -.&# $ %'.#4 '"

&$2. (%#.;

,#.'# 2-$*

&&2(# 09# $"

,#",&"# (""#5#"

5# #&"'$ +@ &"*

0#,#%$,#4 0#. $6:.# 2-,#5# $2,"

!" #

= ,'5'. + (5# &$2. ,#.'# 2-$* -#B $2,"

#9# /$# #B"#"

#B"#"

&$9'&"'$ & 5'"'# ($.#.;

$ :('( &$%#(('$ 5# (""#5#"

#&"'$ +@ &"*

.#,# &$2(#.

--#.."( ,/2# "0'( &(#4 E#""# %%'&#, .<'#, 825,4 2-#,'"##"

#B5'# -,$(#&2"'$*

# ,#.'# 2-$ 2"0$,'";

"0'( $2,"

> ,'5'. @* 5 9'#< "0'( &(#4 9#("'/"'/ %%'&#, ,#&$9#,;

<'"#((#( 09# :## #B5'#*

0#', #9'#&# &$2-.# &$%#(('$ 5# #&"'$ +@ &"

(2%%'&'#"

-,$9# /2'."

&&2(#* %"#, /$'/ "0,$2/0 (""#5#"( <'"#((#( $&25#"( -.&# $ %'.#4 5 9'#< ..

"0#(# (-#&"( 09# :## #."

.$<#, $2,"*

/2'."

:$"0

&&2(#--#.."( :## -,$9# :#;$ ..

,#($:.# $2:"(* 0#,#%$,#4 "0#,# $ /,$2 '"#,%#,# 12/5#"

&$9'&"'$ $,#, (#"#&#*

$(#D2#".;4 $ $"

%' ;

%$,&# :$"0 --#.(*

&&$,'/.;4 (5# ,# '(5'((#*

8 7

** + (1A(