High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18687/1991allowed

M/S Maya Engineering Works v. State Of Haryana

2023-08-29Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari17 pages

! "

# $

% ! "

&!'!(%%

&!")%%* +,

" # $# #

+ -.+ / /

/& 0

-.+ / 0 .& % &'( )*+'"*+, -.++ &' /+"++0, -.+ 1*23456574889 *+/+, -.+ 1*2345:;488!9 )+0, 0 , +'++<* ++&*+%,# , +'++ ==== /

/& 0

1 .&**<0+.//>1 0+<,+ +0<**1+.*&% .+0,*1,*+/ +&% 1*%*+.// /+0'<** /% 1.+291+.>&**<+ 1* -0/+ 0?+1 +0.4@5, + +&+ ! *%**+,*29.*+00%

*.-+.2911.+29A4!7+ 4!5 23456574889+ A4!5+ 4!82345:;4 88!9A<*1.-0'/& '*1.+29 +&.+/.-0' .;+ .61* $+ .>.,58;2*+11*.+00 +*B.1 58;B9 : .+.*+&-1.+292+9,+ +<+ &.+/. 8!882A4!634 5:;488!9,*&'+0+% &1*3*+*+ +<+ > &+0>+* + + ;

<-,.1<0+ 23456574889, +<+ &.+/. ,++'&'*3,*%*+ /+ &'*35!88,+%+*./1+<+ *&.+//+ 2$3 435$2 ; *%* +00' *%* 1.+29 2+9, <*.* *.&.+/.-0' .;+ 61*B.1 58;B,*.-0'*'+85+ 85:,**0+ /& *+ +.>1.+29< & 0+ ,+ *+ 1.+29<+00< 0+<% ./%1.1.++/ /*B.158;B @

<-, ++ 2+9,&>0'*/% 1.+29+ +0*/% +<+ &.+/. +.* /#6788

43592 $ # 94 35:3838

*, 6 * 0+ .0 1 * 29 &/, *+ *%**1.+29,+&.+/ .;1*B.

" 158;B,1+.>1*<0+ &.+/ .-0' !6!8552A4!7345657488+ A4!5 345:;488!9,+ +0&.+/100< &'+ .0++&./% . 6 1 * B. 1 58;B, * !!!858 2A4!5345657488+ A4!8345:;4 88!9 <-, * &/ *+ . !@C:85: + CC@88,*.+ +*/+)%1*+<+ 8!882345:;488!9,+%/292A4634 5:;488! + A 45 3456574889 +* &.+/ A. 4*29+ *3*1 /+, +'++ D&+ #-0/ *', 3*+ %+* + * - 1

+'++, +.% *%* * #., D&+ + #+/,

+'++,3*+ %+**1,*'&/*+*+ +%/ .+'% * * *+1 A+. . , . <*1 +0&././0 <*,*+-+0 &'2A 4: 345657488 + A 4!, 4@ + 46 345:;488!9

# $

!" "#"" !" $" % % $"

& !'

( !'

&)* +

' ',! - "'&

! !" &#" !' &.

) &'!"! / !+

(

. / +

(! '

" ( !" *"

"! !"

" - +

($ & "

" !"

' " &! &

!' " &-

!" -!$" '

!"'

!" - +

!" !' "'- +

" & &' -

+ 0' ,!

"'+ ' !

12 "& "

' !" " "

' ! ! ! " 3"

3 "

"',! "' (4566/

; +

!!!' / +

'" ( '( " !'

#"'#" / 7+

!" ('(!'#" / .+ " ' '"" (

!!' ' ,! "' ( 4566 3"

3 "

"- +

" " '&'" ' "

! '

!'! - "!

! ! !

- !'

'! (& &' " " ( '. !"

&-8 7 3>0', *' &/ *+ . * +%/ 2+9,&.+/ +<&*+011* -1 +'++&'* #.,D&+ +#+/, +'++,3*+ %+*+ *3*1 /+, +'++D&+#-0/*',3*+ %+* >0,*'1*&/*+<*/1 0;+ 51*

01"1* -/1 +'++,877,-

' <*1+A+. *+1,*3.01+&* .-0'&0,+ +& &'*+%/2+9 ++/0',*.*'&/*+<*+00*. . 1&./%./01.+0',*+0&./ ./0 <*,+*+-+0 &'2A4:3456574 88+ A4!,4@+ 46345:;488!9,*&' *.01/'0&./++. * 92- :"

' !

$"" & "

& " " !' " ;

" :" &&- <-

"$"!' ! '

! $ !$" -8 5 * 1* . 1 * 0+ .0 1 * 29,+&.+/. *,*+,+ 0'*&' *.01/'0,+*&./++. *+ .0&./ +E %//+ &'* B&0 A3.+ &

'( )(

*+% (!,#

- ..

+ / %0 /

,<*++%+* !7 + !5,++<*1&./A+. *+1,*>+&0 .01/'0*+& ,<*&'+.% &'*/<**. 0 *+%/ 2+9, + *B * &./% - 0' ./0 <*, *, * + 0 %+ , +%+ *

( .. ,+*1/%%*1/+ . *+1 /+)++<+ +.*1.+2+9 16 '= '

( '" "

- & = " . #"!

( &

-:!! " :4>(?456@A4 :4650:"

( . :"

( '

#"'(!) 9! '

B '

B #"'-

#"'("( " &- ' . 9

8-' .9 #"'8 ' $ ( : ) 9

:" #"' 8( &

B & " (!'

"B&&"

!#"!

!& -8 1<- #" '

:': 09:'8+42"

C (:':0>1-( & ;$&

1D46+-92-D<@- #"!

"!& /

!' '&

" /

' &

' / " !' '- #"(

! '!$ "( (9#"!

8 ' !. - '

" (!" $ -2-D<<E--

'& " *" ) - -

! ' !'" ' !

$ & 'F ' / 7 &(&&!! ( '-8 :'0"

+ '

'!!

-&( "&"

& !& (& " '

$ ) 92-D<5- ( ( ! "

' &( ! .

(

"!& ( & ' "!&)- - & "! &""! '&!& ( & & !&

-C""! "

."(& !' " '

$ -" '" $ !&

! . -

'&&" &"

0!"

-2*D55 ! &+ & -8 8 *'1*&/*+*+&--<*+&+0 +E %//+ &'*+ %*30 + &( '

( ) + *+% &

4 ++

+( $0 /

*,*'&/*+*+&-.0*%* 1 >'+ &/+'&./.+? ,,* +<%1*+ +A,**+ +%/29&./% - 0' . & +* +% >' * .. *0, *' &/ *+ * +%&0/++00+. . &'* %%,*+ * +<% 1 +%/ 2+9, .+00' * . 1**,2A4:345657488+ A 4!, 4@ + 46 345:;488!9, +* +0 &./%- 0'./0 <*,*+'*+1+' >'* .. *1,*'&/*+* .0 1 /' 0 * - .29 2+9, &./ 100' ++. * +%/29 2+9, *&' * .*+00% /+ * 1.+29 2+9 + > & &'*3 /#6788

43592 /323

# 9 *0+ +0 -.+ +0, +'++*+ -'1.100'+% &1*3,*+*+&-/+ +%/ .0 ,&'*1+./1* .'1*+.> 0+ *&%0?+*.11*%*>&0. 3>0', * +% *+ + .*, .+ * +&-

+%/ + &1 * 3 &' * .0 1 * 29,+.. ,*&'* +<%1*+.> . %>'<0 &./+ * .. ,**&'*.01/'0 &./++. >+*+%/2+9 !

1*&/*+.- ./+ &'* 3+<00+* B&0A3.-0'-5+ .1

( &( &

( - ..+ *+% &

$ 6%%6% .$ 9 :(

+( !

4( + *+% &

4( + $ /6 ;9 :

(

4( + *+% &

4( + ;$ 6%%6% .$ 9 &

*+% + 7 8 .

, + 8% / %

4( + "<6 &$ ;9 &

*+% -5+ *

- ..+

( ;$ & 9 / !

& 70 -

4( + *+% &

4( + $ 66 .$

= >

8 .

"#( 7 *+% % ? +( @#!

$ & .

,<*,&./ *+ +0 4.+00% 1 1.+29 1 +.>, ' * +.>%+*'&./% - 41.+291 +.>1*<0+ *1,*&/*+*4 +<% 1*+.>1.+29+ +0*/+)%291++<+ +.*1, +0**+1.+29 &./% <* +<, +* &./ 1 <* + - 1 - .+ : *0+ +0 -.+ +0, +'++*+ +0+% *+.-1+.+-+0,1+',* &./%%+ *,'*+.11.+29

2+9& *+<+ /+ +.*1,&100'. &'*E %/2+9,<*,*+& *+* +.29%+13$D 3+++%+0*0+.*% 1+.>. %, <) + 0,+%+*

-//+)0+<10+.>1*<0+

4 2$$:38 <35#6788

43592 $ # 94 35:3838

*8 &!'!(%%,1=$38 <35#6788

3592 /323$ # 92 28< <48 2983>2 $

$9#883>3

352<7 3*

?#!, ; 9 * +.* 1 * 2 &!'!(%%, *+%/2A459& - ./0+.<**. . ,+,/& * &- 1/+ +012A4:9*+*. . , + * * +%/ 2+9 *. &./% ./0 <*&'* !9 * .0++ .61*B.1 58;B &.+/ !!!858 <*+, * +%/ 2A 459 &.+/ A. CC@88, *1, * +<% 1 * +%/ 2+9<+/+ *./1++<+ , ./<*1<++' &'*3,*%* + /+ 5!88 :9 A452+9*+& +<* +/1* -+.%*%**#.,D&+ + #+/, +'++, 3*+ %+* + * 3*1 /+, +'++ D&+ #-0/ *', 3*+ %+* *1, * +<% 1 * +&-

+A*+/1* -1 +'++,*'+ &. &/+ *%*+)%1A.- +.*/1.0661*31

+ ;9 *1, <* * 1/0+ 1 +&- A+. 01"1* -/1 +'++, 877,+0+/1*+&-.0661* 31 +& <** 01" 2+9,&*/+)*3.01.00.-0' &01* +<%1+%/2+9+ +0 ./&*/*&0%+./0'<** +.+)%/1 02+9*1,& ../+0'* .. ,&.+/&0%+ - * +%/ 2+9, .+00' <* * . . , + * * +%/ 2+9, &.+/ - 0' ./0 <*, * + /+1+- 1/ A 4:, +* *+ *B +)%%*1/ @9 *+&-.

/0 <*+%/2+9+ *+.1*+0++.* *-1.@291*B.158;B* +&%*+-1.& &E./1 .@29&.+//+ &'*&1 * +*' .. , ' <* * +%/ 2A 459 <+ +< &> * 1.+29 2+9 1 +.

" +..+&E.&%+ +%+* 0+ &% +.> -, * +<%12A4:9 / &/+ &+ /+1+..+.&'*+*'.. 1* + + &E.+*+.1*,+ 0+ * 0+ &% +.> /+0',+0<*'+<+ .1* <0+ 23456574889*+&/+ @ * 1* >0 1*+&-, *+,*300. .. ,<+> &.//.+ +&* +<%1 +%/2A459,*++0'/1.@291 *B.158;B,.+00'<*&.2!91.@29 +),+&* .,*+ &E.<*.*0 * A.

1+%/2+9,+*+.1*.. ,* &+% 1+0'+ ..0-' 6 *+%%11+0'+ ..0-'*+ &E.+*&'*300... ,*.++&+.* *+%/2A459,<*.*1+2+9, +< &*+01 1 * - 1 +'++ &'* #.

+'++D&+#-0/*',3*+ %+*<** ,+ ,**&' / &/+ *A.1* A.-1.&'*+1.+,*./1.0 661*31 + 7

0+0'<** 02+9+0/+ +*+* + +<%&./&*3.01,*+ +E.00.-&0'& >-.*

) &% / *1, * <+ ..+ 1 * 300. .. ,'. /+)++<+ ,./<*1 <++' ,*%*+ /+ &'*3,5!88 .>.,*.01/'0+* * E %/ 2+9, + 0 &' * 0+ .0 1 * ,+0.+&0* +<%1+%/2A459

.+0' <* 1 + 2+9 * +.>.. * &E.+ .@291*B.158;B&<*+ 1* >01+..+.1 >'* +<%1 +%/2+9+*&./%<+) * 5 *%*, * 0+ +0 -.+ +0,

+'++*+-*/0'+% *+* +<%1+%/ 2+9,>''<0 &./+ * .. ,*&'*.01/'0& *0+)>+>',** +<%1+%/2+9, +*%* .. ,*&./&+.* *1,*+%*+*+&-/+ +%/&'*.01 */+'&+.. <-,1+00*+2+9, <**+ /2A459<+ +<* .%1*+<+ ,*%*./<*1&%+' &'*3,+ & / &/+ /1.@291 * B. 1 58;B *1, * + / 2A 459 +.>1+0'+ ..0-' 0+0'* .. &.+/ &'*.01/'0% *1/-,*&'*<0 &<+)%1+' >'>+* *<0 &+'..+1*

; * +&- * .0 1 /' 0 &./% E 8 *%* * E %/ 2+9, + 0 &' * 0+ +.0,/<*+ -/-+1 <* +<+01+01.+1+.>1*<0+ ,* 4*<0+ 4+.> <-,*+) .- 1+.*1/++..+&0*+.+,+.* ,* +&-/2A459,+ <*.*1+2+9 1+0'+ ..0-'&+% ,+ <*+01+ 2+9, *. * .0 1 /' 0 &./ 100' ++. *1,%-*+&-1+.+0 .-'4* 1+.*.+2+9<**1+.- .292+9 0+0'

*+&-/+ +%/&'*0+ +0 -.+ +0,

+'+++*+0%1.+. !C *%**0+ +0 -.+ +0 +'++, *++0+% E %/2+9<*.* -+0 ++'3$D +' 3,+&.+/%+ *'.. ,& <*.*+* *+.-1+.13$D 3 &'* +/.. ,'*0+ .. &%+/+&0 1&%0+<10+.>*%*,*&>0'+%, *++'+*?+29&./%&< *,&'* +/.. ,<0 ' 4/<* -/, +.> *<0+ <-,* 1+.1*+&-.++ *3$D.. , <*+,*+) .- 1+.*1/+**+.+,0+) *-+0 '1 */2A459<*.*1+2+9*+& +% -%+ ..0-' 0+0'*+&-41+.+0

' .-'4*1+.- .2+9,<**1+.+*+ , +0+*3,+%++0'%*(+ * *,+ +0+* -/.. *. &% 4/< *0+ +.>, * %+13$D 3,*29+*&'*#+/ ..

4 =$38 <35#6788

43592 $ # 94 35 :3838

*8 &!")%%,12 2$$:38 <35#6788

435 92 /323$ # 9 ! "*++/+',.*345:;488!,- *+*+0 2A4!4@9,&.+/A. * +.11.+29 .;+ 61*B.158;B *1,*+ 1.-'+.+-+ ,+0+.*%1 *+.>. %,*- &.+/ - 1+'%*, 0-*+.> 0+ ,<*+,./0-/ 1%*,0+ -*+.> 0+ &.+/.1 * +.>% +*' .*, * &E. 10 .@1*B.158;B+*+.1*0+ 0 .. ,<+&0,++*++%,**+0%*,0+ -* 0+ -+0,*1+.1*+&- /2A469.

0 & +<4*0+ 0 .. + *+*'.. *+&%*+,<* 0*<0+ &.+/- 1+2+9*+.>% +*',**/2+9+ <*+-.100%+0' *1, 1+ + &!")%% .. , * 3 .

( 8 29 4358

#3 !!

+1/+*,*31 /*<

&!'!(%%, + , <* * +&- &-+, * +/ +00< */% 1.+291+.>>+* + + !:

<-,.1 &!")%%,*31 /*+/,+ ,*+/+.. %0' / !;

+. !@ .*/+.+2901*+-& . ,*,+00 * %+0.+29,1+',+0+ 29 1 */

/& 0

, *0 .& , % ! "

)+-%* &535:2@8 <A2

&535:

3269 A