High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1921/2011allowed

Sanjay @ Sandeep v. State Of Haryana

2015-09-187 pages

! !

"#$%#$&%#$'()*$+$,%-#.(/)0$&$1.&%$)2,%#$)2*$-%3 $-

554

#$$

#%$&'( & ( )

* +)

*,,,-.

+) $ !

#$$ )

, +)

,,,,-.

#%$&'(& ( ) '

" !

./'.

.$$/.

0.', # 1

( '%#',, ,, ! !

2 !

! !

5 " " !

! " 0

1 1 !

1 2 !

'6#',, *,, !

1 '

6)78-7%7 /.,$/81/79$2,%#$#2//87&$77%7&2):7&7,)&71$)#$&%#$&$7-:$//

22;

, 6 0.%# %#$ 799(-$) %..< #$& %. =2//7*$ #$2<#(1(&7 2-%&29% !7&,7/ 7,) <$1% #$& 2, >2$/)- 99(-$) 7,'78 7,*:7, 97//$) #2- 0&.%#$& 7&)$$1 7,*:7, .=$& %$/$1#.,$ , 6 7//%#$799(-$)%..<#$&%.0(--%7,)7,217%7,)/$>%#$&,$7&

6 %#$%.2/$%:#$&$#$&>7%#$&7,)%#$1./29$.>>2927/-:$&$1&$-$,% $&>7%#$& 2)$,%2>2$)#$&7,)799(-$) 29<8 2<7- #$1./29$711&$#$,)$)7//%#$ %#&$$799(-$)7,)&$9.&)$)#$&-%7%$+$,% ?

"? & 7=$$, 2=2/ .-12%7/ 7,217% +$)29./$*7//8 $@7+2,$)%#$1&.-$9(%&2@7,).12,$)%#7%%#$1.--202/2%8.>&71$97,,.%0$ &(/$).(% $&9/.%#$-:$&$&$9.=$&$)7,)%7<$,2,%.1.--$--2.,

" 7+ 2:7- %#$ >7%#$& .> %#$ 1&.-$9(%&2@ /.)*$) 7 9.+1/72,% %#7% #$& )7(*#%$& :7- %7<$, 7:78 08 %#$ 799(-$) #$ 1&.-$9(%&2@-(>>$&$)-%7%$+$,%(,)$&$9%2.,5? &

A@ B;0$>.&$%#$ /$7&,$)()2927/7*2-%&7%$ "4,-1$9%.&(&$-#!(+7&-1.<$70.(% %#$ 2,=$-%2*7%2., 9.,)(9%$) 08 #2+ 2,9/()2,* %#$ 7&&$-% .> %#$ 799(-$)

99(-$) 29<8#7--(0+2%%$)2,#2--%7%$+$,%(,)$&$9%2., 66 &

%#7%%#$1&.-$9(%&2@:#./2=$)2,#2-,$2*#0.(&#..)1&2.&%.%#$ .99(&&$,9$#7)7/.=$7>>72&:2%#799(-$)7,'78 7,)$$1:#.:7- :.&<2,*7-7970/$.1$&7%.&7%7+7/<#7 99(-$)7,'78(-$)%.=2-2%%#$ #.(-$.>%#$1&.-$9(%&2@2,9.,,$9%2.,:2%#%#$970/$-$&=29$ 99(-$) 7,'78 2,>.&+$) #2+ %#7% %#$ 1&.-$9(%&2@ :7,%$) %. +7&&8 #2+ #$ 1&.-$9(%&2@:7-7+7'.&7%%#$%2+$.>.99(&&$,9$ >7/-$97-$#7)0$$, >.2-%$)(1.,#2+

99(-$)7,'78 7,)$$12,#2--%7%$+$,%(,)$&$9%2.,66

9.,%$,)$)%#7%#$7,)%#$1&.-$9(%&2@#7)7/.=$7>>72&:2%#$79# .%#$& #$1&.-$9(%&2@#7)*.,$:2%##2+.,#$&.:,-:$$%:2// #$ #$&-$/>97+$%.#2-=2//7*$#$<#(1(&7 $#7),.%<2),711$)#$& $#7)

? 0$$,>7/-$/82+1/297%$)08%#$1./29$

, %#$ -2)$ .> %#$ )$>$,9$ " '78 .#7, 7/2:7/ 7,):&2%2,*@1$&%:7-$@7+2,$) $#7-)$1.-$)%#7%%#$/.=$/$%%$&- 7&<%. #7)0$$,:&2%%$,08%#$1&.-$9(%&2@

#$%&27/ .(&%#7=2,*7)=$&%$)%.%#$$=2)$,9$.,&$9.&)97+$ %.%#$9.,9/(-2.,%#7%%#$711$//7,%-#7)9.++2%%$)%#$70.=$.>>$,9$- 9#7&*$)7-7*72,-%%#$+

%2-%#$97-$.>%#$1&.-$9(%2.,%#7%799(-$) 29<8 2<770)(9%$)#$&7,)%#$&$7>%$&799(-$)7,'78 7,)$$17,) 29<8 2<79.++2%%$)&71$(1.,#$&

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

$7&,$)9.(,-$/711$7&2,*>.&%#$711$//7,%-:.(/)=$#$+$,%/8

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

#$=$&8>79%%#7%-#$#7)9#.-$,%.*..=$&%.7&22<$%7, 2,-%$7).>1&.9$$)2,*%.#$&17&$,%7/#.(-$9.+1/$%$/89.&&.0.&7%$-%#$/.=$ 7>>72&1&.'$9%$)08%#$799(-$)%#&.(*#7&<%. -1.<$,%.08"

$,+78/2$0(%92&9(+-%7,9$-).,.% #$1&.-$9(%&2@#7) -%7%$)2,#$&-%7%$+$,%(,)$&$9%2.,5 &

%#7%799(-$) 29<8

2<7-#7=2,*%7<$,#$&>&.+#$&9.//$*$/$>%#$&2,%#$9.+17,8.>799(-$) 7,'78 7,)$$17,)%#$&$7>%$&#$:$,%7:78 (%C(2%$(,>.&%(,7%$/8 :2%#%#$%(%.&2,*.>#$&17&$,%-7%7&22<$%7,-#$#7-9.+$.(%:2%#7, 2+1&.=$)=$&-2.,2,#$&-%7%$+$,%(,)$&$9%2.,5? &

&$9.&)$)08 /$7&,$)()2927/7*2-%&7%$%#7%-#$:7-&71$)080.%#%#$799(-$) #2- +7&<$)2+1&.=$+$,%2,%#$=$&-2.,.>%#$1&.-$9(%&2@>&.+%#7%.>#$& -%7%$+$,%(,)$&$9%2.,5 &

9(%-%#$=$&8&..%.>%#$97-$

% 2- %#$ =$&-2., .> %#$ 1&.-$9(%&2@ %#7% -#$ :7- %7<$, %. 7&2):7&., 080(-7,):7-&71$):#$,-#$-%78$)%#$&$:2%#%#$

5 799(-$)>.&.&6)78- ,6 -#$:7-%7<$,%.#$<#(1(&7 )2-%&29%!7&,7/7,)%#$&$7>%$&-#$:7-%7<$,%.7,217% %2-=$&8-%&7,*$ %#7%%#$1&.-$9(%&2@:#.#7)7/&$7)89&.--$)8$7&-.>7*$,$=$&&72-$)7, 7/7&+%.7%%&79%%#$7%%$,%2.,.>%#$1(0/292,.&)$&%.-7=$#$&-$/> (9#7 -%&7,*$9.,)(9%.>%#$1&.-$9(%&2@*.$-%.0(%%&$--%#$)$>$,9$=$&-2.,%#7% -#$:7-2,>79%79.,-$,%2,*17&%8%.%#$$,%2&$-$C($,9$.>.99(&&$,9$ 5

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

,=2$:.>%#$70.=$>79%-7,)92&9(+-%7,9$-7+.>%#$ 9.,-2)$&$)=2$:%#7%%#$1&.-$9(%&2@#7)2,>79%/$>%>&.+%#$9.//$*$.>#$& .:,799.&)7/.,*:2%#799(-$) 29<87,)%#$&$7>%$&:2//2,*/8799.+17,2$) 799(-$)7,'78#7=2,*-72)*..)08$%.799(-$) 29<8:#.#$/1$)#$&%. '.2,799(-$)7,'78 $&9.,-$,-(7/79%:7-%#$9(/+2,7%2.,.>#$&/.=$ 7>>72&:2%#799(-$)7,'787-$=2)$,9$)08%#$).9(+$,%-7&<%.

$-%70/2-#$)%#&.(*#"'78.#7,7/2:7/ #$7&%2>2927/=$&-2.,%#7% -#$#7),..997-2.,%.7%%&79%%#$1(0/29:#$,-#$:7-2,%#$9(-%.)8.>%#$ 799(-$) >.& -. /.,* 7 %2+$ %#&.:- 7+1/$ ).(0% ., %#$ 97-$ .> %#$

B 1&.-$9(%2., 7%#$&%#$(,,7%(&7/=$&-2.,1(%>.&%#08%#$1&.-$9(%&2@%#7% -#$#7),.%7%%&79%$)%#$1(0/29)(&2,*#$&%&7=$/7/.,*:2%#%#$799(-$)7,) %#$ /.,* -%78 :2%# %#$ 799(-$) 9.+1/$%$/8 >7/-2>8 %#$ %#$.&8 .> %#$ 1&.-$9(%2.,%#7%-#$:7--(0'$9%$)%.&71$7*72,-%#$&:2-#$-

#$&$>.&$ #./) %#7% %#$ 1&.-$9(%2., >72/$) %. 7))(9$ -7%2->79%.&8$=2)$,9$%.1&.=$%#$9#7&*$-7-7*72,-%%#$799(-$)711$//7,%-

.%#.>%#$+7&$$,%2%/$)%.79C(2%%7/ #$'()*$+$,%.>9.,=29%2.,7,) -$,%$,9$17--$)08%#$%&27/ .(&%C(7%#$711$//7,%--%7,)-$%7-2)$7,)%#$8 7&$79C(2%%$).>%#$9#7&*$->&7+$)7-7*72,-%%#$+ #$80$-$%7%/20$&%8 >.&%#:2%#2>%#$2&9(-%.)82-,.%&$C(2&$)2,9.,,$9%2.,:2%#7,8.%#$&97-$ 4

.,-$C($,%/80.%#%#$711$7/-7&$7//.:$)

$1%$+0$&

(/7%2