National Insurance Company Limited v. Karam Singh And ANR
" #$%$ & '('
) *+ )'
,
-
,'
.....
!
"# $%" &'
"("
' ''"# $%" &
) ***** -
,'
/ '
01 ' '"
+&, & -./!"
'.& '0 !. "1" 2334535)
+6'0"- 8# ."'"
,%" 52)&53)4'.! '"' "0'"
+
"." '
% , &,"1" $,"&'0 &' ,%6 5 9&,6 !00": '&"% &' "'"
) 1&"""!%-+". . "9 ;< 4<5)1'%'1"
&0' "6 !
"6."%-".,%6=53)35>2)>)?>;233332@;) &" !0&
4#=3#333> $", &0 )@)353)?)?)353)@
1$#' !%-1"
,)<)553)? ! !"%& 1'%'"A )22 23)553)?1"
. % 2?4 ",%"9"!# %"","!+0
&%,"0 1"
'"&0"
+6'
) 1'' "6!"% /!"'% 1"
!+0
+6'$ ."..%6))3253)4,,' %!0 1
!,6
, ' "6#'1$#'%,"0 1"
%
!,",6# '
&, "
,%"! %557 8&'.",$% !' %# )4@?+&'0"- 8#
."' 2
%$. ' %# '
"6 !+0 ,61''6" $"!
+(%
%,!
.'"'A /! 1"
. "&" ,"6&)<
&0 ' %%!% & ' % "$ '" ' 1"
.,.% "&'"
,%" "&.!" .' &' "6" "-"
"" 0
0."',
'"0"6+ " +6'
"6"
'% + 0 ,6#' ,%%!,
'"$"-&&%$
"%'$'%," $' "0 " "$ ' ,
'" '"
%0 ! "
" !, & ' !B ," .,.%> ,"6' "&'
,%" = %
&"0%"+, ,!&'
!1"
"
+6 ' ' 0" - "," 7!+,% ,6 $% 8#
."'#'1$#!
&",.&' "0"
(!
%"6 1
1$- %55 7@8&'.",$% !'
%#)4@? <
% "&'$ %"
!% +&' 0"- 8# ."'"
'$",
$"% +6'
%$ " #'"
,%" &'
,%"1"
",,1 ' $",!
4#=3#333> 1 +,"
&"$!&
,%"",.1' C4D "!0&0' "&'&,, ",:"
",,6#'% "%%!& &%%6& $% " ,."B ",.1' . 1"
", "1" ..$ '&#' '"
+&, ; " %! , "
". +'",& & ' ".! '"'
"
"%' ' ,%"&" &)<
&0'%00
&'% " "
'"$+
. & !%'" ,"6 " !,'&#' '"
"- "
/!"
% ' & '
"6" 0."',
+6"-."
"
$ '$'%,%
'"' ,%6 %!0&"
"0" "6 +,." !
' 0 ,6 ' % &
"0".>'&%"!
'"''"$.%0 , 1''0
" &' ,%6 %!0#'%,"0 !+0 +6'0 !.'+(% /!61"
" '%! ,&'
"
1'' ' ,%6 %!0 %" "6 % /!%& ,"6 .&'% ' ,%" >
,"6
&'%,"01'' "6#'1$#
= '&", &"6 $ &' ,%6 %!0" >"6 '0 &' ,%6'+"
1'& '% /!% "&%,"0& !%' ,"6
&%,"0'"$+ %+ '! ? %"#%! ,"
".+'",&&'
,%" ,"% ,"% !
' ' (!
.0 &
+".
"
# ##
%
# # ##"
1,,"
'(!
.0'0"&$
%& % $
5 # '
(%)
*!+ % '" ,"60".' %0 "6"+!%%!%&'& ".! 6> "' %,"0&! ' %
'"'E+, !
0 ! '"
","
6', '"& (!
.0 '"1''.!
& '%,"0
! "'"
+ ,6' .! & ,"6
&'%,"0# !%' ,"6%"+ %- +&"",'
&'%,"0 %" + '+&&" ,%6& !%''6 %'%",
&"!, &!' & ' %%!,"
! +6 '
.!," $, 0!'67 8 +". &% >> %> >5);>34>53)) 533453)) &!' +!
'
@
$.',"%&'
,%" '"& (!
.0'%%!,"#'%! ,"
".+'",& & ' %
'" ' "+$ (!
.0 "
<
.! '"+, ' +" &"% &" "
' 0" &
( ) %% #'% /! '"
"- ,"%3=))533?" ' "0'"
+ '
,%" '% /!A '"
+. 3<))533? ,& '!
%
'"'1"
" 0 .&'% ' ,%"!' $'!.''0"6+" ,"6
& %,"01'' "60,",6#$'0"& $
%& (% ), '% /! - ,"% 5@)353)3" 'A /! 1"
. ' "0 "6' %,"0/! 1"
#'1$# !+0 1'' "6 )<)553)3 '!
'"" ,"6
&%,"0 1'' "6%"+/!" " ,"6 .
&'% '$ .".".%6"
1,,'"+$
%"
#' '"
"-B !
0
%' &' %0 "6+6"
"%'.',"1 &%0".% 1'!"6 ,"6".! '"'"&
% 0
.' %"
" " &"%6"
'"$ +.$+6'
,%"& !%' " ,"6
"%'.' ,%"&)< &'%%!%&$ 4
! , & '
'"
&", & "6
%!0"6$ %.$ " &"%6" !&&%"
&
,"6"
"%'.' ,%"!' 0"."+!' % /! )3 '"$'" ," %! ,"
".+'",&&'
%$ " '"$.'!.' ' %!0
;
",.1'' " )) ' 0"6
! 1'%'" &% "&'
! 1''" ,"60"&'% ',"1 &%0".%6%"+"-"
".! !&&% "' %,"0! ' ,%6' ,%6 +,"", ".0" '0 0!
+
, ! !"0+.!
,6 0"> "&'%,"0 '%0 , ",&' +&&1'%'' ,%61"
+" $6$ &"!, %"+', !&&%..' "#1'%'
+',"
'& )5 ' ,%6 %!0/! ,." .' % /!% & ,"6" 0"&'% .$. "
%,"0',"1&%0".% F'' ,"6 ,6 "%%!&
&'%,"01'' "6#',"1 1,, , '" !%' ,"6%"+"-"
&"",'%"
&' '" ",&'+& ' ,%6%" + +6" "60,6"
" !,& !%' ,"6' %"
, +6'%! , '1 '"''"
+ ,"6 .'% ' ,%" ''"
'!
0" ',"1 &%0".% 1,,0%"+ '"" ,"6&)<
.'0"' ,%1!, '"$%"
%"
.
&&% %",".',
' "6'(!
.0
%"'!
+ .! ' '&"% '
+,6&'
"6"-.B !
$
%"+.
$'!.'#'0 &' ,%6 %!0
?
%+'% /!%& %0 ,"%&'"& % # '1$#' "0",%"+'+"
%%,!
'" !%'"
% '"
% /!%" +".'.' "",,'
"00# '%"
&' "6'"'% /! $- ,"%'"',
1"
$ !&& +6' &!, ,"6+6 !.. '" &", 1"
&, +6' ,%/!" '% " $
!.. '"'$&'& %%! )2 %% .,6#'%%!0 "% &'%"
'" %,",6
'1'"'
"-"
/!"
B %
!&" !
"&.!" ' &' !"% %0 "6 '!
%"
. ' %'"% & ' %0 "6&"-."
"
0."
1.
""%$' $'%, )= "-.% "'&"% %%!0 "% 0" &+","%.' " /! &'
%$ " # ' % ","0!"1" +6'0"- ","7!+,% ,6$% 8# ."' !% +6)3D'.$.
% , %55 &'.",$% !' %# )4@?"/! +"
, /!"",,' " '
!' 0"- 8# ."'&",
B ' /! )< ' "%% .,6 ",6",,1 '
% , "0! &
4#=3#333> "
"1" $ "1"
2334535) +6 ' 0" - "," 7!+,% ,6
@ $% 8# ."' !% +6 )3D & &",! & '
,%""-"
/!"
"&.!" ' & ' %0 "6 ,, ' +& 0"6 + %",%!,"
"%% .,6
0-
,'
3
+ /
F''
"-.>"
> F'' "+, >