High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1757/2014dismissed

Mohinder Singh And ANR v. State Of Haryana

2019-03-14Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Kuldip Singh18 pages

!"# $#

% &' ()* * !" # $#

# $

! " # # # $ # " ""$ $ !

# $ " % & '( ()%&)* ( +(($+$ ( ($ (( ,-

((!) +!'!) %

&'( !

&) *+ $ , , - ./ &00012 . / * , , ,

&0' !

&) *+ $ , , 0 00012 . / * , , , 3 ,

'0 !

&) *+ $ , , '00012 . ! / * , , , ,

! ' $ '404'0&

, 5 6 " ! , ,,"

, " " *

8 !

$ " !

" , $

3 9 " " , $ ! " " !

8 , , !

" !9 "

, 5 6 , " ,

$ , 9! ! " !

" "

9 , 5 " * , '404'0&

, , 9! 5 6 " !

9 , " , ,," 5 6 " , 1 9 " , ,," ! " ,

! $ ! :* !

;

, !

9 "

9 ! 9 " " !

2, , 3 , $ !

& $ 3 , ," ! ,

& ! && + + $

$ 3 , ! $

) < " ,

= < "

> ? 5 ,

- ?2 , 7, 0'0'0& ! *

8 @3

( ?2' !

)0'0& @3;

4 ?2& + , 7, '404'0& !

, !

! " !

" , $ " !

9 , " $

9 "

9 ,, @3@ $

9 ,, @3: $ ,, ! " , * 7, $

) 2, , !

#* 9 !

&004'0& * ,

! 9

$ ,

" , "! , ! !

9 ,, @3 * 23 , ! ! , '=1&0 ! ? !

" , 9 A , " " , !

3 , $ " !

9 $ " !

" =02'00 , ,

$ " !

, "! , 0 ?2) + " 9 7, @3B -0'0& + 7, ,

" 9 ! 7 , "

9 ! ! ! @2&141-4 &004'0& "

! :

< "

+ B&>) -0'0&

?2= +* 9 '404'0& + 7, , + " *

8 00'0& 5

, , @38 '&04'0& , 5 6 ! < !

! $ ,

! , , < 9

= "

9 $ !

" "

9 $ < ; '(1'404'0& ! "

, , " . / $ "

5 6

9 $

5 6

9 $ " !

9 , $ , !

" , < + " 5 7 $ 9 , , 9 "! ,

" @382)

' ?2- 5 7, 9

@382= @3824 & ?2( , "

+ ! 2

" ,

5 7 6

; C ,

, , 8 '404'0& !

9 , " , ,," ! 2

! , * , , , " , " 9 5 7 !

9 " !

2 3 , " " * 23 ,

, , @3D ,

, " , " !9

5 6

" 4 !

" " "

9 , 5 " ,

, 9! 5 6 9 5 6 , !

! , @3D ! " " 5 6 "

! 9 $ , "

5 6 !

! , @3D !

) ?24

! ! + 9 !

23 , " " * 23 ,

, @3 5 6

! 5 " !

! E !

" "

9 " E !

5 6 !

, !

! E , 9! 5 6 3 E , ,," 9 " , !

! , @3 ! !

, @3

, ?20 5 , @3 !

, @3 > ?2 , 7, '404'0& !

, 9!

" 5 6 !

" " " +

! " 5 6 !

" $ !

, 9

" ! , " " !

9 " !

23 , " " , @3?1 !

! , @3?1

- ?2' + 9 '404'0& A 8 ! , " , + ,

" " , , :

! , *8 A

( ?2&

! 9! 5 6 ! !

23 , " " * 23 , , @3?&1 ,

; C ,

! ! 5 6 !

, .$ / +

5 5 6 !

, ! $ +

5 <

" , !

! , @3?&1 ! !

, ! 5 6 , , '&04'0&

( , 5 7 ,

, , 9 ! , !

! , @3?&1 ! , 9! '(1'404'0& 5 6

, , , 9 ! , " !

! + + , @3?&1 ! !

" 9

; 5 6 !

! ; ; , @3?&1 ! !

4 ?2) 5 7 !

23 , " " , @3?)1 " 5 6 !

, " 22 ! . <

, , !

! , @3?)1 ! !

! , ! 5 6 , , , 9 "

9 ! , ,

! , @3?)1 ! !

, , 9! 5 6 9

" 9

! + + , @3?)1 ! !

, 9! '(1'404'0& 5 6

, , , ! , " !

! ; ; , @3?)1 ! !

'0 ?2=

" , , 5 6 !

, 9 !

, ! , , " B 9 !

! " ,

! !

9 " !

23 , " " , @3?=1

' ?2>

, $ ! , 3

" !

9 , " "

9 " ! 9 8 9 !

9 !

2, , 3 , + ,

, $ , ,

! , !

,, , !

'' ?2( *

! " " !

9 :* !

! @3?(1+ !

0 '& ?2- ; $ ;

2, , 3 , $ 2, , @3?-1 ! !

, * !

') $ :

< @3F 9 ! 3"2 ) , " 9 ! , " " , 9

" 3" ' & #

* , .

" / !

3"2=

= =

- , E ,

E , 9E " 3, ,E , " ! A 3, '00 , " "

! " #$ :

< @3C , , !

3"2> ./

3"2>".

'= $ ! "

, ?2( , $ , @3D $ @3D " , @3D ?2&

! 5 6 < $ , ?2&

! , 5 6 !

" "

9 $ " !

, " " !

* !

2 , , 3 ,

'> $ ? ( 0 & ) = ! " ! ! , ,

'- ?2- ; $ ;

, @, " !

* !

< 3 , @3F # * , .

" / !

3" -

'( < " ,

, " !

! ? , $ , " !

, " $ !

, && + + !

, " " $ 9 * !

$ , $ " " $ !

$ , !

, 3 , ! $ 3 " !

0> * @

'4 $ < G" , +

!" # $% " "& !' %" ())* +,)- *., " ! 0> @ ! 5 ! , !

,, $ <

2 %$ &" ! ""! ' ! ( " ) ! ! ) ) ! * ! ( )! ! ! ""! ! ! ) ! " *

+ "") " )! (! ,) " ) " ! " ) ! (! ! ( ! )! -)$ . /), ! ( ! ! !!! ! )!$ . /), ,) ! ! $ 0 ) )$ 1 ! ($ 2 " 3) 3)!

.- 5 7) * ( . 3 /$ ! " 3)! ($ ! !, 1%885

-- %9 $ : * ! !! ) ! )! (! " ) * ! + "") $ : ) ! )! ) (! * " !, (!, , " ! ) ! " $ ! ' ! ! !

8; " (! . * *! ! " *! '!*, " ! ! )! " (!, " )! $ &)! 1 ! ! * , ! !! ! " (! ! < 1 . , * (!, ! * *) '$ : )! " (!, ='==!= $> ? ! ""! ' ) ! ! ) ! )! *) )!) )! )! ) !) ! )! " (! , !! " , 7) ! " ) ! (!$ : )! *) " ( , $ &! (* " !

8; " (! . * !!, )! ! ! " ) ,( ,! +!! * *

& $ : ! " ) !! , * '!, 7) ! ""!, ! +!! ! ) )! ! )! )! ! ! ) =!=!=)==""=!=+!!$=

5$ . * 7)! * + ! -) ! !!! * !

;9 ! 9@ . " -) . ! - " -) A B $ ($ 2$ 0 ) 1 % -- 6

! * ) 58 5% " * =)!=< 58$ & !! ) ! !, " !, ! )! -) 1@ " !

;9 * !

9@ . ! )! " (!, , ),, ,==!==2 !$=:===")! ! ) !, " ! ! 7)

! !, * ! ) (! !$ 0) ! !, ! !) " !) * ) ) , '! ! ! ")! ! " )!( !$ ! " )! 2 ! ! 7) ( * ! ! ,C " ! ) ! "" ) ! ! 3"$ 0 ") ) DD +! "'>$

2 "

) "

!, )!! * " *'!, )) ! *'

*$ : * ! 7) )! ( $ . 7) ! " ) , " )! ! ! ( ! +! " " ! )$ :) , " ! !

) " "C "! !!, ! )! !D " =$= $ : ! ! (!, !

! !, ! !! " )! " " )""! ! *, " (! ! ) * "

A!" ! 0 ($ . 1 -*$ ;5 $;6 >!, " * * ! * " ! ( ! ! * " ( !>$ ! +!, "") " ! ) " )! ( " * *! '!*, " !! ) ! , ( " = =)!$= 5%$ ),,!, !! !(!, " , ( , )$ ! !, (!, ,) " 3(!( 2 ! )!( ( !' " $ A! " !, )! ! ! ) '!*, " !

!! !

$ !

! )!!, !

8; (! . )!

" ! ! !!C ! " " +! " ! ( !"! " " ,! * ) * ) ( (! ) )! 2 ! *) ) ! ) ! " !!! ! "() " ! ! ! ) ( ,)$ . ! ) 0 ! * "

(!D 1 % !$ . 5%8 , %4 >) ! " !!! ! ) ) )C ) ( D *

= )") !)! ) ! " ,) !, " ! 1)!+! !

> ), ! ) ! " "$ :) )! ! )! 2 ! ! ,! (! =)=) !="="=!,=!=="()$ *( ! ! ) '!*, " ! ,! * ( )!

2 ! , " )! " )!, (! ! " " ! )$ & *=!=(==)!==,=* (=,=(!= =)""$# =) : " ! ! ( ! "* ! 0 3 .,* ($ " 0 1 449 4 -- 55@ * * ! ) ! )! " ! ) )! ! !* ! )! " ! " * ! !,=)$

$=:=7)!="=)!="="=*= ="= *! ! '!*, " ) * + ! ! " ? 0!, ($ A A 1%888 @ -- 5@%$ &! ! " ,, A " ) * * '!, ! )! " " " ) ! ' * ) %$58 ! !,$

+ ! !!, !, * ")! !, ! $ : -) !( ) )! ! 5;

* ! 5 &3- ! !! 8 E&$ : ) " !

,! !(! " , -) ! " ! !,!, 7) " ) " ) ,$ : )

> ! ,(! ! +!! * ! A " * ) $ : ! ! /), " "!, * !

) ! (! ( * !, !' ! ! " (! " * ! , * ) ! ! ( " ! ! !) )! " , " ) ,! ) ! ! ! ! )$ : -) ' ! " (! " !

8; " (! . ! *! "*!, ! ! 5 5 "

==< H5 $ : ! ) )! " " ! )! ( ,) " ) ) ! '! " ! ), ! "

!,! !!,$ : ! " ) ! ! ! ( ) ! *) " )$ ! ! " ! ) !, )! " " " )! * * ! ! (, ""! ! ) ""! *) !" ! *) ==)$ 5%$ &! *! )! ) ! !, " ! ) ! ) ) +! " ! "$ 3) ! ) ,! * " ) ! ! !! ) $ 55$ 3) ! " " ! !"! +! " ! " " +! " " )! ) " ) !"! ($ 3) ! " " ) ! * "

- (! " * )") !" " ! ( "$ ?! !"!, +! " " " " ( " ) + " !!, ! , !)! !$ : ( ! ,! ,( ,!!

&! *!

! ! (! .$ & * ) ) +! " ! " * !' ' ( !$ &! ) ( , ! ) " !) (! ) ! !) $=!=!==="="==$ $ ?! ( "! " ) A * ) ) ! ' ) " ) ! '!* * ! )! * * $ &" * ")! ) *! " )! !!, *) ! ) * ) ! ) ( ) $ ) !"! ! ) " ) *) ) * ! =A===)!==*=!==)$> .!, " ! -) * !!!, !(! )! ! 5;

* ! 5 &3- ( " 7) )! ! 58% * ! 5 &3- ! !( ) )! (! ! !! ! !="="$

6$ &! E ) -) B $ ($ " 0 1%88 @ -- 5

) " ) )!, * ! " * ! ! ( ! * ")!$ : ) *( "" ! +!! *

( " ' * $ & * " ! " ! +!! " " ) ) * ( )"! " *!, ! !"! ( ) $ & * ") ( (! ), !

8; "

(! . ! !! ( )! " )! ( ,) " ) ! ! ) ) ! *) ' ! * )! ) ! (!, " " * ! !"! ! *! ,!, $ : ) () "

'!*, ) "" !

+!! * , -) * ""!=!"!$# &0 *

9 C

" 4 !

9 "

! < $

&0'

&'( !

&) *+

& , $ , ! 5 , " +

, -+./ ,01 + / .& )2 3

%# 2(!= ) ? 9

C1B ? " C1B