High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/105/2017dismissed

Jagir Singh Alias Johny v. State Of Punjab

2023-07-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari15 pages

! !!" #

! # "

! " #$## %&% '( $

# !

! " % %

# "

# (

(* & +,-./0 # &

1 #

(234

& $ % * 5# 1%# # & ** (

6.-$% #

( (

* * ! & %## 1 *

* /.%...27% % 5# ##

( (

* * 0* #

$ )# 1

* 5# # 5 1 #5 8 * %5#5 4* 9/% $### %* )# 5# #

# &

: #5 8 * * #% 8

# % 9 %

$#5"% & (# %$### %* %( ;< 1 % #*

% (

# * "

5 $## $#"" #&5

!1 1

( # *1

# 1 ( 5 " *1

* %5#5

* /- 1 ( 1 ## $ 1% # % * 5

5 # (#

# %

( & 1 (% 5( * ( * *5 # ( (# 1 !# (#% /0% $# # 1 %

" # ( % # #%* %

( (#

5 ## 5 # 1

# 5# *# * * #

* # (% # 5 ( (#

# #

* 1 (# 8*( //1 %#

(5 #

5 ( #

# 5 ( (#&

(% ( (#**

##* = (5 # 1 #* *"

(#*

+6.* *15 " 5 # # #

% #*1

* # 5 ( (#5 ,..*

1* *1#

5# 5 # "

* ( # * *1

* 5 #

5# ( (### 5 *1

* # #5 (# 5 ###

5# ( # *1

5 1 (5 #

# # # & #

## 5*51 *1

(# 1%

( (#51 *# )# *&*1

1# *% ## #* *%*1 1

( # # 1 *# ##

# *( * 5 ( ( #* 1 %

1 ** " > #

# & % ?-@,5

( -;//-./<

6.-$(

# 7

( (# # 1%5# ##

7 * (# %

# *A9//B5 # # # ##

%5# #

1 * 5 1 ( # 7 A34+B# 5A##

# "# %5# #5

*& ( & 1 5 ## CC "

& & 1**34902)# = (5 # 1#

2 # # 1A9-B * # D 18 * )# ##( # 5 # ##( # # 5 ")# # 5

% 5#5 # 5

# &

/@;$ $ # 41 -<//-./<%# 7* * # 5

$ & %* 1#E 7* *%$

(# ## # # & ( ( 5# # 5 "

& & 1**34902E (# *5 #

# CC)# # 15 # & # &

# )# 5

5 )# -@//-./<%# 7

1 * (#A9/.B)# #2

* # # =!( )# =!(

(# 4

&1 1#$

& /;6-./0** #

*#$

( *

6.-$%# 7

5 # (7 #& -+6-./0 (1 5# ## ( 1

* )#

# (

(

# 7

4* * 1 5&5

)# (& 9A BD 18 * % #

'% 8 % $# # 1%$ * (# $ & 8 * (

1 1#

& /@+-./0 )# # 7

5 4*

6/6 $ $ 5# # # # (

& (

# * 1#

* )# 7

1& 5& % # 1

(* -//-./< 34-

)# $ #& ( #

9/ #5 8 * 9- # 1 # # * & & 1# % & # 7

* * % & ! !!!

! !

# 7

&#* 1 ( # # 5

# * 21 5

# # %# %#5

# # * # #&

% 5# % # $ #

5 (1 # #

* # ## 5

9- # 1 175

% %# * * &* * 1# 5

# )# % # 5 # ( #9/-8*

# * * &* # & 77& # &

1* 5 ( # A34/B

/0/ $ $ 1 # & ( %5# # ## #

/- # #

5# #5 *## 7# A 7

B # ** #* # *# %5# %5# # #5

4% # *# 5

# #* *# # ,2,/<* #

* # # 9/ #5 8 * 9- # 1 * # # 8* 5 # *

)# % *# % &#8*5

1# & ( (( 1 *# # * 1 * #

& ( ?

5# #5 * 1#

# # #?%# " ,..* -;//-./<%5# % * 5 ( & # /-6.* -;//-./<)# %# * # 6 #

1 #( (#?5# ## 4 # # % #

%# 7

& #

5# (

# 9/% 5# 175

% # #

# 5# *1 **

74* %#( 1* ## 5#

5# (#

# 1 #& #

)# %

# * 197/ # 4* 7# &%9-

# 1%5# 5#

** 1 #**

# # * 1& %(

= 5# ### 4 ?

# #

* ##

7 (# # 7

9/-% % # 175

%# %#

(#*#( # 7

# #

* ##* & % % 1# 1

# & 1#175

)# % # ( # #

(* &

% %

1# $

* ( 1 & 1%# %# *

9 #& # 4* # # & * # #

# 9/ #5 8 * 5# #* #17 5

# % # ( #5

4% * 5# # *5 # # &

1* # (# *%#15 5 #

* 5 &

1 * 5# #5

* ( (# 5

#5")# * (5

&<701 # % * (* 5 ## 7

( (#

( &

= 5 ## )# #5 # 5 # * * #*

& (5 ## * # # #

1%# 7

( & (# #

( (##

/6//-./< #(

" # 1% # ( * +.. * = (5 ##

,..*%#

5 # #

5& %#* " *# 5 "

,2,6.*

# % %#

( (##

###

5 ## #

A5B

# #

*##

)#5

= 1 # # $ 5#

# *

74* 5& %

(

74* %# * #5# #

#*%## # #

* *# ##

# ** 15 # * # % % 5# ( (##

(#5 #

# % 5 (# 5 # #

% % ## (## #

## * # ( (# *# * )# & 4 #

: ## *1 34/# ,!

" #* **15 " #&# # *1

* * #

** 1 5 * 5# ( (# # 5 *1

# 5

(# 5 ##

5 5 (( # # "5 ##

#* ( (# 51 *# # ( *1 34/#*1

# # !1 # # 1 *# # > & (#4* 7#

4* # 5

& #% 5 #

5##

# 5 # #

= 1 # %# # # 1A9-B# ###

)# 5

*## 1# 5

# 5

(( #5

## #**

5 1 5 # # * )# 5

4* * 1# 5

5 # # # * # 4* 7# ###175

# )# %

1 **

# 97/ )# # 5

5# #5

9-% # # # * #

#& 9/ #5 8 * ( # *% +2+6.*%#

*# #

)# # 5 # A9/-B #% "

#55# ##5

1 ( 5# #

,6.* "

* %# 5# * # #

# #5 8 * A9/B5 5 ( #

* # # 5#

( 1 # 5 *# * ** (# % & 1 9- # 1 (# #

* # %5# # & 1 ## # # # #5 8 * 5 ($

= 1% # &

% * 1 97- # 1

# 97/ #5 8 * #

& # * # (5# # 5

** 1#

E# *1%# & " *

97- * ( 4

74* )# % # * & * " #

*#%# 1( && 15 #

# )# 45

5#5 4* 1#

175

9/-8*%# (# * 9# # 5 4* % #5 //1 C ( ( # #

5( #

1#%# #

( * # *" # # 4* 7# # # # 1% #5 # +..* # !*A*

B 9- # 1 # # # 5& %#& ( *# #% #* " ,2,/<* 5# #*#*% #

7 ( (#5 = (5 ## *# # 5

## 5 * 5 # #

7# 5 (%# *# 5 ##

# # 1 # # * *%( # *# 5 #"

(

# # ( #"##

# " ## 7# # 51 9#&4* #

## 8*A9/-B

/0/$ $5 * # #

/+--./0)# (# #

#* * # /-* 5# # ##* # 5 * # # 7# # ** #* # *# 1 (# )# % 1 #

# * * * &* * # & #

(# 34/% #5 17 5

% # ## /-*?

# % # #5

9/ #5 8 * 9- # 1 & # 8*5 # * 9#&

# # % 5

*# # * # %#

9#& ( # (##

& # $ 5# %# $ # ## # 5

9/-8*

/0/$ $%#

)# %#

(

# 7

( 5 #

A BA

B1 #

5 A

B = # B 97/ 97- #

1 ( **

& 1 * 1

' )

# & # #

** # * 1 ( # % # 4* !

(#%! %$ & %* 96% 5#5 #** #E #

4# &# * * 34962E% % &# # % &#

# *$#5# 1 8 %5# 5 1# *

1 # 1#

# 4* 7# # &##* 5# *"

1 # 1# % # %## 4

:A/B )# 5 ( * " -+ * F ; * (# "5 5# #5 # G 1 # & #1 (%

" 5 *

/*4-*H # % # % *

5 ( A-B

.-*F/* 4 *1%#

* " 5# ( * "

# (# 5 # #

( "

(# 7* *% # # E %#

#5 * #14 5 ( ( 5# #5

)# #(1 /6--./0 5 # # %## # ( #

# *# 5# ## 1

# * * )#

(

74* #

(( # ## #& 5

1 5# #5 #5& 1#5

)# & 4 #

: 5 (

(( # #&

1 5 (

(( # 5 #& ( 1#

4# ( * "> )# & ( ( 5# #5

4 9/.# ( 1 # 5# # # # # *&##

A5# #5

# "# B "# *

9/ #5 8 *

# *& ##

** #* # 1 (# (##

90$

(# 5#5

1# & ( (

( & (

###

5 & *# "# * 1# & ( ( & (#

#* & % 1 ### #

#* # #1 ( (#? %5

# ( * )# #

5 ,2,/<* # #* 5

/-6.* #& 1 *1)#16#

(# %#% 5# * &#*

* %# %

# 1 % #

* *% % *1

= %#

5 #

#1 1)#

74* # & ( ( 9/* 7

#5 8 * #5 (1%#1#& # 1

%#?# 5 & & * ( (?# &

& 1

1 1 #

# 5& % &%

#1 * *%# %

= # 1% ( * # $ ##(

# # ( ?%

* 1 5#

&%#

## ( 5

(

# & ## )# * $ #()*(+*( (, ()- ./0123 '3

!/(/1 .4 (5(3/0()6 2+7+)(, 881(, .

&6 -19+-1- .)

# #

: 5#* 1 ( (# ?

( 1

# # 5& %

( 1 # # " # 1 4* % # " # %5## 1 4 # % 1 #

# 4 # 5## # * & (

1> & 5# &( 5 # * %# $ 1 ( 1 & 1 # *

(* & +,-./0 )# % (1% *

(& * $

= 1% # *

(* &

+,-./0 *

(1 :!!" # ;

:# ";

17/ 9## "

(2 2 9## 2