High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1242/2003allowed

Charanjit Singh v. State Of Punjab

2017-11-11Mr. Justice Arun Monga19 pages

!"!#$% & '

#(!

!#)&*"&

++,, #

.#( / "+#0#

( #0 # &'

++,, # "

.#( / "+#0#

# !"

% & '

( ))))

*+, "%% -. #+/0/. 1$/223

-. #+45/. 1$/223 (" (

! $"%%'

%$"!"

$" +326/223 ( "

! " 7

"!" " +8 $ # "" 9 " " ( ""+5:8 $($

; ";

" % % $ $ +2 $ $ -+222227. "<$

$ %$$ $ % %$=%

1 >$ " %$ (!$$

% */, > "

2820/22+<! ?$$" < '

"$$"

!% "

! ( @ ! A " % - % $ !

A " "

( +22 $% 9 $% $!

( 832 % " !

$ " "

%$%!

B( !$ ? " < ' "

% $ $ "$$"

>!$!

% & %

&?""

$ $ $! "

% ' C& ?( "

$ "

%( &'71 < ' ""!

$ $$&' ( <

"$!

$ ( ? " < ' ""

( % " "$ "$%" !

$ ( D ( "@$%""

( $ " $( "$ & E?$$"

( " "$ E$$" %% " $

< ' $% ""

%$% E$$"

" $$"

( 682 % 1

- 9

" %

" !% !"

< ' 9 ( $ "$ "

9 & % & ' &' ( % " ( "$$! ( (" % " $ ( D ( ""@

$ " $ ( " $ E $$"

( ( "

*3, < ' "

% % " $ 9

- <! ?$$" ' % $ $! ( ( $ " > $+22 % " $% "( % " $ %"

%(38 ">(

$! $!(

$; ;>

$ ! - % >"

" "

% ( > $ " $ $"

( <! ?$$" %$ "> ?

" "

" $ -0227. "! $%

' -/227.% $-+27.

"! $% % &' = " " % $-+27."!$%& % &? "

"! $% <! ?$$" !"

<7 @? """

$$=

;

; "

" ($ $ "

2620/22+> %$> " '

( " " ( @? ! > " " > !"$"

#68 2520/22+ F" "" ( '

( " - ' ?+220/22+ F" "" ( ?" $ $F " $ ( > !"

$ ( $1 $1 "/8$ " *0, $ $"

" $ %

"+8 /8$ "> "

*8, > "

= %

A.+ 1

-% 9 A./@ - ' A.3 < ' <! ?$$" A.0 <

% A.8

' 9>? A.6

A.4< " A.:- '

A.5 1

A.+2 @ 1% A.++ > $ "

!" *6, > %$ " "3+3 >

% "

*4, < $" !" = %@ & % 9A.+ & '

9A./'

( 9A.3 9 % 9A.0 $"

!" *:, >

$ ("!"

" 7

% "

" >

$($ *5, " (

! (% "82 $" ( "% &'"

( "(%

" $$"

! ( " ( $%

" $$"

">% $

A.+!

" " " "$&'

*+2, " $ (% ! $

"!( " 2820/22+ % "- #+5 $ " ( %( < "7 @? A.:>"

% < "7 @?

% F" "" ( > ".

= % $< " A.: !

- #+5 2820/22+

% % >

- % $ !

$<! ?$$" < ' > !" %

!"-#+5% ( " % @ $ (( (=- #+5 "< "

$ "$% $

% F >"

$ ( %

( ( % (

" ( (">( "$

370 $ "

" ( "

"=$F<-"

< "($

; $ *++, " $ (%

."% "$ "8/.$" ! ( > "$9 ($

"%%

%%$ >

$$" "F%#/5 $

% @ %

*+/, " $ (%

F <

F "

( "

$ " > 7"

% @? "-#+5$%2820/2++ +220/2++ """"

#+7:: (# "" 1

D (F 4/ *+3, " $ " " "$" $"

"$ "

.'$ " $ (% - % $ ( " " F<-$ % " "$" (

' " $ $

% "

!%9 % $ "%

( "$!

>$ " A./ ".

= % *+0, ? " (% "$

1 $1 = >$ " %$ !$@ (% !" ( "

>" "$ % D

$ 7 "! "0/

82$#9 "

( $ " $% " "! $%

"$ <"

$" ""! ! % $ " 82 $ #9 "

" *+8, " $ (%

$ ( "

@ (% %$A.:< " $ "$ "

% -#+5 " " >"

% " $

(% " "! $$" $%

" !$"

"% (

(% *+6, < ! " $ ! " *+4, >%$A.+

" $$"

' ! #

< " " "$ &'"

% "!$ >$ (% " " "" "!$ " '

" " "" $ "!>$

% ! " " ! $"

#9 " %

" '

! " #"

% ( <

9 "> % ""

%($ " > ( (

( ( ! $ "

9 " $ < ' "!$"

(% $%!

<! ?$$" ""

' 9 "$!

% $ "- % 9 > " ( " ( ($ "

9 > "9

" $ ' %%( %

- % (<! ?$$" $ A- % $

( " < ' *+:, ""%$ 1

( < '

; ;

- % " $ " $ % (

!"!%%

G=9 % ( 9 >9

"%%

%%$ <$%%

"$" ! ! =

< ' ! " %% (@ & & ' > %% " 9 $ " % "+6+ 9 $$ " ' "$!

% - % !

" "% > " % "

$">( !

!( " $!

%$ !

<H >% (

" %>

" "

"$ (

" $ "

$% (!

*+5, > %$ < ' <! ?$$"

( " ( ( %

"( ("9!

@ "

$%!

( "

%$8.4 % " " % $ "% B(

"$+22 $%

%>$

"$"! " $

% $% % > $ % " $

;

; " " $

; ; $ >

; $$= " > $ "

( (@ !$ "

$% B( >%%( %$ >"

% ( $!

/320/22+

% " > &'$"

% $ 1 $ "

A $

($/320/22+

$ 1 !

" $%

$ " "

" ! %$

( */2, >".= % $$ !

' "$!

% ! ( $ ( ' - % > " (

%! ( '

9 "$!

> @? "!%%

" "

-#+5>$

" " $% %$"

( */+, %$

A.4

1 " $ %

"%( %( % $1 @ ! $$ ! " $

1 @ - $ !

% *//, > % $ < "7 @?

(%"

2520/22+@$

$%/5 $ !

$! " - '

$F > % "

#%% (% ( $"

( <! ?$$"($%@% $ " 2820/22+-#+5>(

%$ % $ #9 "

" !@ ( % % >" (% $ $$= $

% > $ "

% $ ( " " -#+5( - #+5 ! " >"

- #+5( % ( " 99- $ $ @? " $% >@ $ !

% " >

% @? > $ % % - #+5 F % > $ % %%( $ ! "((%(

*/3, F%%$ $ "

(" "

! %% @?$" % - #+5 # " " > %$ @? A.: " "$% -#+5 $"

$ "! %% > "

" " >="$"

%$- #+5 " !@ $ !

% = % */0, <

$% % $ "!% @? ( $$"

! " #

$ ;

; $ >"

% @?

% %>

$<! ?$$"

% %

- % $ !

<! ?$$" < ' > !" % " -#+5 " " @ $ " (!

;

" */8, A.0 ".= % %$ "

( ( % (

"( (" >( $ ($

370"

"( "

% %$F<- "

G! "($

; $ */6, F% % $ A.+ A.: "

( " !

$ "82 $"#

"$&' (

A.+(

" '

#!$

( @? ""

-#+5$ %$A.: "= $ % " "

(

" # ! ( !

$ "8/.$" G! "0/ 82$" " $ "$"

(

( !(

( */4, > %$A./

"%% %%$

(%@ "

> $$" " % %$! $ !

" % $ @ " $% #/5

""$ $$%#/5

"!" @ $ "

( ! "

$%/5> %$A.:!

" "% "$$

$%#/5 %$"! $ %

$% 8 F

% !

% @? ( " $ $$"

" % $ - #+5

$ @? $ "

"" "7$"

#+7:: ( # "" 1

D ( F 4/ <!$

"##$%"&

%!' &()* + ,**$+ "##- ;./

..0 !1;

"262:/2+/."% " $ "=

( ($

< %

"3+3 '

% "

"" $%9 % $ "%

( "$!

>$ "

A./ ".= % */:, >$$ " ""

% "$"

( "

!" $% $

F > "

" %

" % "

*/5, < !$ $ " ""

% " $ "

<% % '

% $"!" $" +326/223 ( "

"" (

"D #%

"D "$

#!%(++/2+4 3 2 4 A 7 I7# A I7#