Sombir v. State Of Haryana
!
""## $%
" !
""## $%
" &
""## $%
"
'
(
)**
+*,-.
, % % ""##
!
(
+
/*.
)
(
)% '#.
""## !
(
2%"# +% %#.
(
+%# (# .
, % % ""## &
(
,# (# -.
2.
31
) ## , # ""# ,,
!
!.
%" ) /
5
! 6.
# # ) 7%8.
9:#% %.
7*;;.
*% ## , # ""# ,0# ,,
0 8 *
6*%8* ,"%8
%".
# # ) 7%8
" "% *0# % ) !
5!
' 8 #.
),0 # (-
( .
# # ) 7%8
.
%" ),0 # (- " "% *0# % ) & ,
( .
*%8* " 8
&
!.
# # 7%8 ," %" #.
),0 # (- * :
<
!
"#$
%
&
'
( (
) = !
0 % %#1
3 .
" " %1 % 8 8 .
# .
, )
0 ," %0 ," ,
3 .
*%8*
%".
# # 7%8
>% # 8 % 7 '-*.
)% # (8 , " *8 " #1 8 *, "% *0# % )
'.
*.
% (1 , >% " *8 "% *0# % ) ?
'
3 .
* , # %88 *.
88 * " 1 ""# 8
>% #.
" 0 >%
## %" 0, 88 0
.
0 0, 88 >% * * %".
0, ," %" * *,.
*% *1 # % *8 ""# %" 0 * %
&
8 "% ,0 @ * * 9:
8.
* .
!
,* +%,.
) #8 * )%*.
0# " ) # 2.
7*;; 2 ,
* # 0 8 8 / 3 9
& * 7 + *.
0# *#.
* , "## 8 %1
A" 8 , *%8* $6 # ,.
7*;; 0% *" # B 1%8 , 2# 3" #.
7*;; * 0 * , A -.
7*;;.
,* +%,.
) #8 * * 2# 3" #.
7*;;
@, ,81.
, - ;% )% , ) 8*.
7.
+*%8 * %%,0 * ;%1 1
$ .
0* )%.
, * , 01 * , * ##8 <* " 7# .
#*
6*1 * 0*
9# (* 1%8 )%
)% - 8 %
C 1.
!
#8 * 0* )% (* * 8 7*;; , "# -
6*1
! * A -.
2%8 .
7*;; 0%
"
, )%
6*1 8
* - )%
6* 1%8 01 , * ,1#
C *, # (8 ,.
*, *
##8
C 01.
* * #.
- % " # "- * )% * * * * * , 0- *
)% ##
*
6* * 01 # 1 " ,1# *1 %# 1 *,
*1 , * *,
)% * 2# 3" #.
7*;; 0% 1
(* # " *,
"1 - #8# 8 %#" =
?
C 0 0 , , 9:* ,"# $ .
,# @ 9:* 8 % ) !
5!
' ) & , A, ) 8*.
) 8 %> 9:* 5 ,* +%,.
) *%8* )%*.
0# A, ) 8*.
) , 9:* * 8
8 ,* 1 , ,* +%,.
)
>% " 8 01 )% #%
>% " 9:*
C "# >% 9:* '.
",, 01 )% 8 % 2# 3" #.
7*;;
",, " 9:* '!
% * % < ;% " # ; %% 0# 1 * * ,, % % %8* % * 1 % %=
C , 1.
%8* "# 9:* 'E 5 "" "# % , (*.
0*
)% ) 8*.
9) * - "*8"* 9:*
'!
9:*
'!
' * 8 # ,
# # # "# %.
"#.
# * # F+F - "
1 ,,%, 9:* &
C 1.
!
# +%, ,##1
# "# 0%## # "# #* )% #8 * ,"# #.
* 8 , # ",,.
- "
1 ,,%, 9:*
C &
% 8 8 .
#% , 9:*
% # * -" # 3 3 (1# 0 8 8 /
3!5& ?
,, (* )%"
##8 6
'%% #% ,.
,1# - "
1 ,,%, 9:* !
"# 9:* 'E 5 "# 1 ,1# ""
C !
),0 ,##1
C &
% 8 8 .
),0 % #% , 9:* '! <* * -" # " # 2%8 8 )%, 1 # 1 "# * * * :#% -#8 %# 8 , " # =
'%% #% ,.
%1 " #
!& 0 , 1
-* 9:* '! " # ""
" # "#.
# * # F+F - "
1 ,,%, 9:* '!D
"# 9:* 'E 5 "# 1 %1 " # ""
(,%, , 9:*
"" , ),0 "# %
C
7 '-*
C
% 8 8 .
7 '-* % #% ,
* 9:* 'E 59 8 8 * * 8 " # ),0
C
%* 8 - (*,,.
)
C !
)% #
C , 1.
% 8 8 .
% #% , 9:* '!!
8 8 # , ,,
C !
(8 ,
C 1.
% 8 8 .
% #% , 9:* '!
8 8 # , * % ,,
C ?
(-
C
% 8 8 .
% #% , 9:* '!&
(,%, , 9:* '!?
"" , "# %
C D
* # #% ,.
%* 8
3 % #% , 9:* ?
* <* * -" # %1 " # #8 * 8 , 0:
* * * :#% -#8 %# 8 =
'%% #% ,.
%1 " #
!& 0 # 8
!& 0 0:
#1 8 ,
-* " # 8 9:* ?5 9:* ?5 " #1 ""
%1 " # 8 "#.
# * # F(F - "
1 ,,%, 9:*
"# 9:* 'E
5 "# 1 ""
C !
"# >% 9:*
,% ,* ##1 %1 " # #8 * # 8
!& 0.
.
" 9:*
5 ' .
0#5,%
C
""1 @)H.
(*%0 *, # #1
/
?!
+
C
7 * , "" # "# 9:*
'!
) #%* 8 "% 8 ),0 %) & ,
9:*
'
9:*
'& )* * '-*.
).
* (8 .
7*;;
C !
"# >% 9:* 'E
*8.
8 %* 1.
*%8*.
# * "
3 3 (1# 0 8 8 / 3!5& ?
##
" 9:*
8 * * ".
# ,1# # )*, (8 ,.
2# / !.
)*- /8.
*%8*
), % ) ?
C* %%# ".
1 8 .
-
,"# 8 .
*## " % ) !
# 8 ## ;, ) 8*.
)3C5" ?
) :#% #1 0# % ) .
*%
,, #
!
# * 7% # (8 .
7*;;.
,, # 0 % )
"% :, ,1
%0>%#1.
"%0# "% # "%
#% "% .
# # 7%8 " 8 % ) !!
* .
"# .
# , # ,"#
.
# %# :,
,
# %# ""##.
*
8% %0, 0 * % *.
@ , * , % ),0 #0#.
, .
*% %0, * 1 .
%" 8 8 % 8 % 8 * %
# " % 8 * ),0 0, ,
3 %0,
# " % % 8 % 8 0 8 @.
* .
8% .
,.
% ),0 'ED.
'E
#8##1 # .
* * 8
!
#1.
# ) %# * 8% *.
*##8 0 * % ## , .
0, 8 *.
* %
!"#
!$%
'ED :, * * %#.
!
0* * , % 7*;;.
, * 8 " 8 0 0* )% (8
3 .
;%
6* 'ED "- #8 * 0* * ) # 2.
* 0* 'ED )% "- * , "" 'ED.
8 6( A -
)% %* "- * , 0 6(.
* # 0* $ 8 % 6( 0
- 0* 'ED "- 'ED , % 6( 0 * # " , , %.
* # :, 8 ,.
* * # #8 * ),0 * * ,1# "" * ,1#
# " * , 8 ,1#.
*.
),0 * , %"1 8 " ## *
,1# "- * , 3 3 ,- 0 8 8 / 3!& ?
3 " 1 # " % 8 * , , 1 # " 8 0* )%.
,"#
),0 *, %.
"- * , - % " # "- " * * 0* )%.
* * - "
0*
3 " *%8* - 0* )%.
*%8* $ * %.
0% $ "- * , % ""* 8
% * , " " # $
6* .
## *, "- * , # %.
* ,1#.
2%8
$ * , 0 8 )% 2# 3" #.
7*;;.
'ED "- - $ * *" # ,- 8 8, *.
, 8 # 0%
'ED * 1 8, *.
1 %
"# .
% " % 8
&
'ED.
:, * %0; : 8 :,
3 .
'ED % %##1 * 8 8 ## 8 :,
6* .
%, 1 8 "- 8 'ED :, *
'ED.
1 1 8 ," , ,0## *, " %#1 , 8 % 1 %* * 0 8 1 * "- 8 * , :, * .
:,
6* .
%, 8 .
0,
8 'ED
?
* %# % 'E
$ ) 8*.
* * , 0 0, 'ED
3 1 1 8 ," , ,0## *, " %#1 , 8
( .
*
'ED 'E
6* .
% 0 .
.
'ED 'E
>% 1 *.
*.
**%8* "% * % 0# * 8 *8 8
!
" *#, 8 'ED 'E
% # *.
0* * " :, * * ),0 " * * , 1 " # )%
* 'ED 'E
"% # 8% :, .
0% % 8 % * .
%88 0, "% 0* * # %#.
* %88 * 8.
% 8 * " :, * .
,"##1 #
C, %" ## "
.
% ),0 0* 'ED 'E
%* %# .
0 %#1 ; 8 8 " * %
# 0# 8 * 1 ),0
&
% 8 % % # 8 ),0 8% #% , ," 9:
'!.
* 0, : *
!
"
"
## !
" !
$%&'(&$')' !
! *
## )+&'(&$')'& "
, -" .
" / -1 2 *1
.!
## !
"
"
" ! 3 1
## !
"
/ -! 1 !
" " .!
5" 6 !
"
*!
!
1 " / !
1"
"/ !
*1 "
##& 6 / / " &
1 " !
1"
& 5 , 89
5 ,
.& 5
:;
* *
##& <" * * .!
## $=&'(&$')'> 8 0 : 8% #% , ),0 .
# * * #1 8% #.
0% * # % % 8 1 " # 9:
'!D.
8 8 "# * 8.
# 8 .
, 0 8 :#% #1 - * ,
) "%% * *%8* 1 ,, 9:
'!D.
% 1 " #
6*% 1
8 8 0 ,,.
* 0 0# * 0#1 1 8% % 9:
'!.
* 0 0# " "" #
( .
* 0 0# 0 8 * 8 0# %88 *
6*%.
1 1 8 0 ,,
%##1.
0 **%8* >% 0# %# %
, 'ED 'E
D
% 8 % % # 8 #.
8% #% , ," 9:
* 0, : *
, , " 0# , .
# )5 (8 ,.
5 +*%8 % 8 , 8 % 1 '# ) .
1 * ,# *% 1 8 % #%.
C
#%
, % , # .
!
.
#8 * ),0 )5 + *.
5 ,# (- )5 C, '-*.
5 7*;; * ,% )% 8 (1# % 1 0-.
,1# * 0 -" # , 6 ,1 ,.
-1 * -" # * , * 0 #-.
*, 01 - # ,.
8 , # 8 1% ,
E * "" * 8% ,
<" , ,
89
<" . " 3!
" <
-7,
4
##& <5.
" %(= * * .!
## 5 * * .!
## )=&'(&$')'> 8 0 : 8% #% , #.
# * * #1 8% #.
0% * # % % 8 1 ,1# 9:
!.
8 8 "# * 8.
# 8 .
0 8 :#% #1 - * ,
) "%% * *%8* 1 ,, 9:
!.
% 1 ,1#
6*%.
1
8 8 0 ,,.
* 0 0# * 0#1 1 8% % 9:
* 0 0# " "" #
( .
* 0 0# 0 8 * 8 0# %88 *
6*%.
1 1 8 0 ,,
%##1.
0 **%8* >%
! 0# %# %
, 'ED 'E
% 8 % % # 8 # (- 8% #% , ," 9:
?.
* 0, : *
, / -1 "
" !
, / -1 2 *1 . 5# .
!
## !
!
!
" ? / ""
"
, -"
" "
"& 2 )$&'(&$')'
@" , -" "
, -"
1 /"& 1 " * 1 !
!
!
!
!
, 1 1 " -!& 1
*1 " .
.!
!
, !
=''''
1 & 2 )+&'(&$')'
"
##& , , -"
## !
"
/ -! / /
& ,
"
!
"
/ -! , -! /"
!
, "
"
"
3 1
##
' " "
! 1& , -! !
"
/ " -! , 1 "
1 1 / !
!"
1 / !
1"
1 1 / 1 1 " !
1 & ,
/ !
" !
"
/ -! , / " -! !
"
-! !
& 6 * 1 !
!
!
1 " / !"
! & 6 * "/ !
*1& *" " & , / -1
89 <" - " "
"& 5 61
1! * <" , -& , .,
##& )A&'A&$')'> 8 0 : 8% #% , # (-.
# * * #1 8% #.
0% * # % % 8 1 " # 9:
.
8 8 "# * 8.
# 8 .
# 0 8 :#% #1 - * ,
) "%% * *%8* 1 ,, 9:
.
% 1 " #
6*%.
1
8 8 0 ,,.
* * 0 0# * 0#1 1 8% % 9:
?.
* 0 0# " "" #
( .
* 0 0# 0 8 * 8 0# %88 *
6*%.
1 1 8 0 ,,
%##1.
0 **%8* >% 0# %# %
, 'ED 'E
" ,, %" 01 )% % !
'E
'E * "
* .
%* 8 9:
'!.
# %"1 %" 01 )%
( .
* " % * )%.
8 ;% " # ; 0# 1.
* * ,, %.
* * % % * 1 % %
# ,, ;% 'E 01 : *
)& , $ / " " 1 " B & ""
1"
& $& 6 + & C " 1 1 /& +& 6 C"
& %& D 1 # !
&>
!
6*%8* 0# , 1 , 0 0# , 1 " 0, , *%8* ,, /
?
+
@)H
3 .
# " @)H * * 9:
& 8.
* " :, .
%# ,8 * : "
)& 6 . ! 1 ) B. &+)=> "E , , =% )A=A& "
1"
& $& &+)=> 1 ) . ! 1 ) !
/ 1 /!
" / 1& +& 6 "
BD E 1"
D&& %& " "!
/ &> 6*%8*.
- "% 8#1 0# * 8.
*8 8 .
*%8* "" 8 0:
0# 1 %
( .
*%8* "% * 0 0# " *8.
*%8*
# #1 ,, %".
0 , # %"
3 .
%# :, .
0# , @)H ,1 * # %* 1 8 0 %".
0, % "%
/*#.
8 #1.
0 : %#.
%" 0# , )#8 * " ,#1 #% 8.
0# # , * 0#8 8 0# 8%"
6*%.
* .
* #% 1 " )#8 0% *%, 0# # , * 0#8 8 0# 8%"
0 #% 1 " ,1 * 0 , #1
8 8 * 0 , ".
, *%8* % 8 ## .
" @6 .
* , #1 ,,0 5 , #1 *1.
%# #8 * # 0# ,.
)#8 ,- 8 0 "" ," *
#1 - 0 " % 8 .
0 %.
.
" 0 8 # , 1 0, 8 # * 8*# 8* * %
&
,1.
8 " ,, " * * 9:
'!.
8 * * * 0 "
)% # +%,.
( # C .
2 , 3" # 7*;;.
# % 8 % ,- 8 %"1.
01 .
* : 8 * , ,## 0%##
?
0 ,## 0%## - " *%8* ,, 9:
5
( .
8 9:
& #.
% # "# (- $.
0, H01
## "# , *%8* 9)H ,* +%, / &!.
@)H
( .
"%# 9:
& ,- #.
, " 0 # "# #01.
#F * % .
%* "
8 :* 0 %" # 98# * #"*0 : 8 " #1 # ," F.
* ,"##1 ##1 8 * .
.
" , #F
0 * 8 % 9:
&.
0# .
0 , 1 , #01 *.
%," %" #
%##1.
,- 8 * .
*%8* # ,,.
0 %#1
- #8##1 ,.
" ##1 * * 0 % %88 .
# ,, **%8* 0 , 0, .
* %#1 8
6* .
.
* 8 .
%# :, " #1.
%".
0# * # "# %.
%" #* )%.
%"
!&= 0%## ,- 5.
* 0 - % 01 )%.
%" %1, " # *,0
!&= 8 * 0 ),0 .
"" .
* , 1 ,.
0,
# #1 .
, * * , 1 ,.
0, *%8* # ,,.
* 0, #01
.
%# :, 9:" # , 1 ,.
% #1 " * , 1 ,.
0,
# #1 .
*%8*
# #1 ,,.
0 .
0, * #01
6*%.
" ## 9:" * * ,, "0
8.
# *8 8
,1.
0 : %# :, .
## 9:" " , 1 " #.
,-
"- 8.
!& 0%## (- 5 0, * ,
( .
* 0 8 ##1 "# * 8%* % / # 0#- 8 " ## * "# /
.
* 0%## : 01 * %"1 01 .
,#1
* * " #.
%* * "% @)H ".
>% * 08 8 0#- 8 #
6* .
0% %# ##1 #1 , 1 , 0, # , 0% % , %.
% # ;% .
0, ,#1 0# *
)% #1.
0 .
#.
#1 0# %# % >% , 'ED 'E
0% 0 **%8* # #% , %".
0 >% * *
'
#- % 8
# " 8 8 % 8 % 8 .
,1 # .
% %.
,.
0% #1
*##8 :, .
%" 'E * %# % >% %
0 >% 8 0
# #1 #% ,
# #1 1 ,,
@ " "- 8 0% % , 8 1
8.
0 % "%
!
>%.
,"%8
.
>% * * .
0, " #1 .
,".
%" * # # 7%8 % 1 8 " 1.
0% 1 8 , "" .
""
>%.
* , ""#.
, ,
0 #.
*%" .
," %" * *, % :% # # 7%8 *%8* * * 8 ,, # >% *,
""1
1 # * * #.
0% #1 :" 1 " # , # 8 ""#
!
* *
(%""$%$$ )*+,-*
*,)*,.-/,012345.,0-63,7! ,-56
*,)*,..,/6.)08+, ,-56