Ram Singh @ Ramu v. State Of Punjab
!" #$%$!&'())
*+
, -%.% *
' /0
*) *0*00 /0
*) *
! "##$ %&
( )#*$ $
+,- .....
0*001) )"# '#
&"!#!
,+ !/
0$
## (# 2+ !$ 34#5$ *" -1 &%#&
''& +#"-
6
%
$ *" -1 &
! #/ #/ #
/##!
#
#'
₹ 1 '# $8
'+ /5#!
1/ '#$ '+
!
#! + #/ #/
#
1
#'
'& &
,+ #&# /
37 90:
;0 :
!#
-# / % (#!"
<$ -
% (#!"$ !
-+
1 $
"1 * "
#-#!$ &/# -#!
+
% =+
> + /# =+
1+!
"#/
"
# /1 =#"
=+
1+!
"/
?
'+
/" !
#! 1+!
#
+
% =+
/#4
/ (#!"
'
#!$ / (#!"
+
-
#
@ - #!#!
* 1 ? '+
0 :
-+ :
$ +
% =+
> + /# =+ # &
"#/ /-# - 0;6
" 6
06 ("
#&
"+-
/ (#!"
-#!
- #!#!
+''#&#
*
/1 5# A " "#$ &/# !*#"
+& =+ (#!"
B-"
(#!"$ '
-+ :
/#+ &
/ &1& # C "/ <"
"1
&"
+# /# !$ "1 "
/ #
* / (#!"
!+#!
&/#C #
+
% =+
+#!
+
&5 )"1 #// #1 &
"#/ + *"
#!
/ (#!"
#!
&/#
+& !
"% '
/# '+
#
)" #/
-+
8
/# &
#% "#&1
# #&#
? %#
1 # C &
#%
&/# &/ / #/# "/
/ #!
'
%#!
"/ $ &/# !*#"
+& =+ (#!"
&
#' / #&
#% -"#
&&+
/
* / (#!"
#
-#!
"1#&1 -+
- #!#!
/ &1&
* 1
"1
&#'#
/ (#!"
#
-+ / (#!"
+#/1 5#
"#
#
!+#!
0 :
B! &# +!"
3 / 37 D@
!#
6
-# / % (#!" 7%#!# ### 7E+
D@ 68 +!"
# D@ 68D
(/ *#
&
/ /
& +&
/ /
&
D@ :
:
'
&/# #%#!# '#
8&"
&//#
+ (# %#
; : " !
6
/
!# $ *"
#&&
&#/
# 6
&+#
% # @/#
/1 % *#
(/ &&+
&
*" #
#
#& #/##!
%# !# "#/
' #/#&# *# /1 /"
? - (#!"
@/#
<
'& &&+ 8
: B
# + &# %#
&
'&
&# &+/& &&+
&+#
+&&'+1 %
# !# -1
-
+- *$ &&
#!1$ &%#&
''& +#"-
6
&
#
!#!
$ %# #/+!
,+ !/
0 !!
#%
'
'#
0 B
&+
%"/1 !+
# + !
1
*
'& &%#&#!
''& +#"-
6
&#!
"#/ #/ #/
#' !+
#@#&-
1
6 '##!
37$ ' $ #-##1 /-#"/ % /+&"
7&# E+#
"% &&+
-+
8
0 :
*" 37
!#
;0 :
-+ 3+ / $ & !
1*#$ +-/# "#!"1
+-'+ #/+&"
#'
"1
'& $ *+
"% #-
"% '
% & "1
#
1#!
!+
--### "1 *+
"% # %
% )
B
&+
!+
&+
%# #&# / #& %#
&
/ /
$ +&"
#,+ # *"#&"
*+
&
- &+# % # &/#C #
"1#&1 -+
3+ / $ &/#
#
-+
8
0 :$ / / & +&
;0 :
-+
/ /
D@ :$ #/ -*
/ /
0 "+ $ ' $ #/
*+
&/#
&
%# * "
/
&
#& -'
"$
+-,&
+1
#
/
* 1$ ' $ -#!
/ /#%
/+
&/#C # %#&#
6
$ "+$ + !
+,+#'# D%#
&
&
#
/
# + /
%# #
*#$
: +-/#
+''#&# %# % &+# % # % !# "% %
1 !# "+-
E+
'/#1 //- *"#&"
% !# #&
& 3+ / $ %# &$ & &
#
&
&/# * &
&
*"#&"
*+
'& *""
&
&/#
#/ *"
#%
&
&/# '
# "+ 1
* 2+ !/
&
0
## (# 2+ !$ 34#5
#
&E+#
&" ! /
!# "#/ ; B
&+
($ &
!+
#/+!
,+ !/
0 *
-
+
&## %#
&
# 6
"% %
-# %#
&
#$ "+$ 1
-#!
%#
/
#/# < "
&+
#
+
&
"#
- #& +$ !#'+
'
%## 6
$ *"#&"
F 6 *
"G <"
*/ &+
-+
- #1 #,+
&&+ *# "
/ &# &+/& *#"# % 1
#!
"* -'
" +-,&
+1
/
"+-
#%
"+-
0
&&# *#"$
/
* 1$ +&"
" &
*
"H$
+&"
"+-
#% "
/
"% &+
" D@#G3
+ +-&#$ * 1H " "% / /#!
&#
*
"#-## &$ ;0 ;0 <"%
&//#
*
" +#"
#/ #/
/ *"#&"
" " % 1 -+ *"#&"
/1 @
#/ #/
#'H '+
#
'
7 # D%# &$
*"#&"
F
+/#
*
"G<" E+# *""
&//#
*
*/
"* -'
+&"
*/ +-,&
+&"
+1
/
&&# *#"$
/
* 1$ + " +/ +&"
&+
*
" D@#G3
+ &#$ *
"H " "% / /#!
&# 6 7 #
$ 6:
0H
?C- (+ / +
!!"
+/-
& "
+/# !# &&+
"
#
1 '
'*#!
# # -#!
# " */ / ++
"$ ## *#"# % 1
#!$ ### " +-,&
+1
/
"+-
#%
"+- #% &&#
/
* -'
% +1
/ /
+
&#+
"% &+ &&#
#% #5
/
* 1
6 7 &$ %# / /
&/#C #
#
++
"
<
(+ "#
"5$ #& ''#& #%# ?#$ -" *" !*#"
/ 9!
I+ "#"
"+ & +&
/ /$
'*#!
#,+ # * F9&5$ B#!+
' # &5$ &/ !"
J &/ - "
- -&5
#!" # 9 5 B 1@
&" &+ +-/+& "/
"!
#&" $ - *
&+
&5
#
&%#&+
!#
#&# &5 1#!
#+ &+ -
&5 9&5 /+& &+ ?1#
- &+ &+ &"
H : #
&/#C #
#
++
+ "1@# &+
!+# +''#&# &
+ #
# &# &+/& '+
-- #/ -* #,+
#+
-- #/ -*
/ / @/## 0 "+ )" ' $ -#"
&/#C #
#
++
" 0 &#'#&1
< % (#!"
#! 1+!
#
/#4
/ (#!"
-+ '+
/" #
#&# )"
# /
'& /# "
&/#C #
/# 1 5 & / #/# "/
< % (#!"
&! #&1
+-,&
"1#& -+
/ " &&#
/
* 1 )"
"%
"%#!
- +!"
*
/ / &1& )"#
&/# *
<
=+ (#!"$ +& &/#
? &! #&1
'
#!
/
/ &1& +
% =+
&&+
* 1 )" !+/
<
<
#
*#$ ' $ "#
#/1 &
#
+$ !+/
%#
/ # B
&+
+- # + %#
&
#/&"
#-##1 #
*#$ *" / + *# !#% &# &+/& '
&+
/ % (#!"
"# @/## "1
1 !#%
*
-+ * +
!#% 1$ & %#
< +"'+1
#/
#!$
* !#% "1 *+
!#% /# "$ %##$ *#!
/&"#$ # -@
"+"
#&
)"# '& &/ &+# % # '
#! &+1
#!
* 1$ *"#
##!
/
/ &1&
(#/# 1 -'# &
#%
/
< @ "1
&%
&"1 -#!
'/#1 ''#
#/
1 '+
/" #&
#!
)" ' $ #//1 --
#- & ! '/#1 1#!
% /
# * *#"+ #%%#!
"#
)"+$ +&&#&1 %
%#
&
+-,&
/
* #// #18 -'
"
; ; & '+ # '& "% %
&+#$ -+
"#' + &&+
&$ 5#!
%#* &#'#& %## *
&
*
" ?C- (+ / + # $
%&!!'!!()"
#
+/#
D%# & / #1 #
& # 6
-#" "
F; /1 /#
# !#+ # *# +
*
K"K "+$ /5#!
/ #&# &+ +/
&//#
*"
+-,&
+1
/ &&#
/
* 1 +#5 %## D%# & *"
#& # &'
+ &+ *" #
%#
&+ /1 +/ -/ +#&#
#
*/ )" ' $ %#* -%$ + # &&+
-+ +/#
- 6
$ + % "#' @&+#%1
"%#1 &&+ )" 1
E+# /
*/ &+
/
" + &# &+/&L
&+
&&+
*#"#
1
#!L
+&"
*/
+-,&
+1
/
"+-
#%
"+-
&&#
/
* 1
)" ' $ # # +&"
"% -#"
&+#$
+1 &+
# +/# &&+
&+
*
" /1 # /# # @ # -'
'#
#"
+ )" ' $ &"
&$ + 14 '&
&# &+/&
%#&#/
&# #'
@#/ &&# -*
/
*
& +1
/
"H
)"# ## !#
#
?C- (+ / + (-#
(#!"
"
M ( ? 1 #/# 9 : 0
$
&#
: )"+$ #&+/- +
-+ +/# &+#1 A+
&/#C #
/# 1 5 & / #/# "/ *#"# '+
/"
#! )" %# * "
/
-+ +/# !# ! * 5
'& + 7 /
$
0 :
%##
"+ *" + #
/+
*#'
&#%& & #& '1 #/#&
&
? '+
#+ -*
-
)"
+
5
" '/#1 1
% +
&#/
'"
-
#
!#%
" 1$ " *+
5 + /
&"1 %#!
#& # 3"
-
* &#/
'
#
-#!
#+
' $
#
#
)"#
'& * "1
#/
< @/##
* 5
/
- *
'"
-+
"1
#
* 8 1 *"%
< =+ (#!"$ +& &/#
-+ 9 %#
'& #& -
* * 1$ *"#&"
&+
"
-* "/
)" ' $ '#
#&" ! -+
&
+ "#/
)" &
1 !#!
37 ' !#% &# &+/&
7&#
"% &&+
-+
8
0 :
+&&#&1 @#
&/# #' /
#% #// #1 -+
+
% =+
#%
&"
/ #/# "/ -+ #!"
' 37 !
;0 :
< @/## &! #&1
&
,##!
%#!
0 :
-&+
#
5* #
%#!
1$ #'
+&&#&1 @#
&/#
' &+# / !+/
#
-"'
!
"%
&%
# &&+
*"
'+
- #/ & +&#!
/ /
# + $
#
#"
&+#
-#!
!+
% $ *"#&"
" * #! (#/# 1$ '& !#
#
1 E+
!#
//-
'/#1 # +"'+ &+# % #
*#
!+/
#
&+
&+
% # &
-
/ #& %# &$
%#
/ # +&"
#
+ ##
!
#/
+
% =+
#/+&"
5 &
0 :$ &&#
& # #/ -*
/ / 0 "+
'+ / !#
-#!
-$ - +
/ /
$ *"#&"
"*
#,+ # @& +
&5 7 +
&#
## C -- #/C
!#% / /
-&
#,+ # #'
+''#&#
-+ &+# !# &
&1 - %
# + "1#& -+ & *1 #!
+&"
#5 &$ *"#&"
/1 % 5 #,+ - 1 3+ / !+/ % !+#$ / 5 +!! "+
$
%#
/ # 7 #C )@-5 #& 2+ # +
)@#&!1$ "#!
+!!
+ & C !+#
C"
#!C$ #! +!! "+
7
#5"C )@-5 #& 2+ # + &$ 3 #& #&#
)@#&!1 D#!""
## #
! ;6 C7 +$ #! +!! ++1 $ -+ #'
"
#4
'# /1 &/ %#&#/ & +!!C
6
)"+$ %#* & &!
&%#&#!
#/# *#
%#
&
-% #
&+# % #
: =#!
%#* &
&! %#
&
&+-##1 " &//## ''&
6
$ & 1 - + %#
&
/#C #
!+#!
/ 1 *#"# -+ '+
/"
#! &&+
* 1
0 B
&+
+- # + %#
&
*"#&"
#& #/+!
,+ !/
0$
## (# 2+ !$ 34#5$ %
+'' #'# /#1
#!#1$ *"#&"
&
# ' + &%#&#
6
!$ * 5 1
&+
& E++/ +#"/ @ & "+
+&
#/ #/
#
/##!
#
C #' +-/#
1 *1 % 1 ! #/ #&#
#%%
& )" +&"
@
# /
*" # ''& &//#
#-#& /
#%# +&"
&
%
'
,+ !/ ?C- (+ / + 23 &4, -%.%* !" -5 6( 7*($ *" # ?C- (+ / + *"# #!
/##/+/ & % 1 %#
''& +#"-
6
*"#&"
/1 @
#/ #/
#'$
"+
*
&
% & #'+
'
!
& ,+ !/ ?C- (+ / + *.&$8. *3 -2 9 -%.% * !9 -&2 & !"!" 83$ (( *-8) 1 *" # *"#
#&+#!
#&# &#!
&%#&#
$ "
+&"
#&# %%
%
1 #&-
&$ %#
&#!
,+ ! %
#& # *
"#!"
& #&-##1 " '+
!+#1
6
$
/# "
" FTo revert to the main stream of the case, we see no reason as to why the principles of sentencing evolved by this Court over
6 the years through largely in the context of the death penalty will not be applicable to all lesser sentences so long as the sentencing judge is vested with the discretion to award a lesser or a higher sentence resembling the swing of the pendulum from the minimum to the maximum. In fact, we are reminded of the age old infallible logic that what is good to one situation would hold to be equally good to another like situation. Beside paragraph 163 (underlined portion) of Bachan Singh (supra), reproduced earlier, bears testimony to the above fact. Would the above principles apply to sentencing of an accused found guilty of the offence under Section 304B inasmuch as the said offence is held to be proved against the accused on basis of a legal presumption? This is the next question that has to be dealt with.
So long there is credible evidence of cruelty occasioned by demand(s) for dowry, any unnatural death of a woman within seven years of her marriage makes the husband or a relative of the husband of such woman liable for the offence of "dowry death" under Section 304B though there may not be any direct involvement of the husband or such relative with the death in question.
In a situation where commission of an offence is held to be proved by means of a legal presumption the circumstances surrounding the crime to determine the presence of aggravating circumstances (crime test) may not be readily forthcoming unlike a case where there is evidence of overt criinal acts establishing the direct involvement of the accused with the crime to enable the Court to come to specific conclusions with regard to the barbarous or depraved nature of the crime committed.
: under Section 304-B of the Penal Code. The above, therefore, cannot be elevated to the status of acceptable jurisprudential principles to act as a rational basis for awarding varying degrees of punishment on a case to case basis. The search for principles to satisfy the crime test in an offence under Section 304-B of the Penal Code must, therefore, lie elsewhere. Perhaps, the time spent between marriage and the death of the woman; the attitude and conduct of the accused towards the victim before her death; the extent to which the demand for dowry was persisted with and the manner and circumstances of commission of the cruelty would be a surer basis for determination of the crime test.
Coupled with the above, the fact whether the accused was also charged with the offence under Section 302 of the Penal Code and the basis of his acquittal of the said charge would be another very relevant circumstance. As against this the extenuating/mitigating circumstances which would determine the "criminal test" must be allowed to have a full play. The aforesaid two sets of circumstances being mutually irreconcilable cannot be arranged in the form of a balance sheet as observed in Sangeet (supra) but it is the cumulative effect of the two sets of different circumstances that has to be kept in mind while rendering the sentencing decision. This, according to us, would be the correct approach while dealing with the question of sentence so far as the offence under Section 304-B of the Penal Code is concerned."
; 7 * +
+ $ & #' #/ #/
''& +#"-
6
&%
1 C
#! + #/ #/ 5#!
%#* ! &%#& 1 "%#!
#/# & @
# % &
0 7 &$
&/#C #
5 & *#"# -+ '+
/"
#! *" -+ *1 % 1 ! #/ $
&+ & #'#& '+ #"
-' + #%%
#/# & 9 @
# %
#-#& &
&
=#!
%#* '&
&# &+/& / *"# '# !
+
+& & 1 $ +
&#
##$ ,+#& " / & #/
+
+&
#/ #/
#
/##!
#
#'
#! + #/ #/
*1 1 )" & '# /## $ *" &+ 1$ !
#/ #/ /
&##
9
!+/
#
-%#
/ #'#&# & &&
#!1$
#/# 0*00
()) (+# <""
5#!8
I89 <""
- I89