Anita Chaudhary v. State Of Haryana And Others

CWP-2792-2023 (O&M) - 1IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH CWP-2792-2023 (O&M) Date of decision: 05.08.2024 Anita Chaudhary ....Petitioner

Versus

State of Haryana and Others

...Respondents

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMAN CHAUDHARY ***** 


 
 
 

   

 
 



***** AMAN CHAUDHARY. J. (ORAL) 1.

The prayer in the present petition is for directing the respondents to reimburse the full medical claim raised by the petitioner on account of her husband Liver Transplant Surgery in an emergency situation. 2.

Learned counsel submits that the claim of the petitioner for full medical reimbursement on account of her husband having undergone Liver Transplant Surgery in an emergency situation has been wrongly declined and only an amount of Rs.10,07,652/- has been granted, while the total bill amounted to Rs.25,22,686/-. The petitioner is serving as Principal at Government Elementary Teacher Training Institute, Morni Hills, District Panchkula and her husband suffered from Chronic Liver Disease for 12 years and in the year, 2021 was diagnosed with HPS and was advised to undertake liver transplant. Samples of son and her daughter did not match and there was no deceased donor available in

CWP-2792-2023 (O&M) - 2North India and therefore, he was registered with Vellammal Medical College and Hospital, Madurai, Tamil Nadu, which is a super specialty hospital registered under NABH (National Accreditation Board for Super Specialty Hospitals and Healh Care) and also on the panel of Tamil Nadu State Government. Finally, the transplant took place on 27.10.2021, which is planned on emergency basis. Certificate regarding, it being conducted in emergency treatment given by Civil Surgeon, Panchkula on 15.03.2022, Annexure P-4. He submits that his case is squarely covered by the judgment passed by this Court in Roshan Lal Garg vs. 

  


 

   !" #!#


!$ !% #!#& '
'
( 




)


 )

* 
 )

  *+)
 

+
)+*


 

 , -.
 ( 

 )

'


*()


 *





   


 

  !!" #!"


#/ !

#!#&
.  


 
0* 1
 
* 2%
3

 



 

'

 


 
( 
*
) )+*)


+ 


 

*) 


'

+

 
  
)+*)


 ,
 ( 
 

  
'

 

)



04*
. 1
'
 
 '


 


* 
 


 


'
+

 )+*)
 (

 ,
  $
3
 

*) 



 
) 5
   
 
 
 

 

 




4*
 



 
 *
 
  



)
 (

3

 *
 

'


*(
 )

+ ) 
 
!6 # #!


)
'

'





 
'


* 
 

 

) 

'

 
* 
'


 (

 4
 
  !% # #!

3
 *
  
 '

*
5
* 

 


!66

#!%

 
 



  


 
' 
 *
'
(


*()

 7+
8*)

CWP-2792-2023 (O&M) - 3-  *

2
 




!

9
0#!$1
6 8
$%

 

 
'



 
* )+*)


(


#


 * ,

3
 
  



*()
 7+
8*)
 *


 
"
 
08* 1
  *

* 2/
:*

'
 
'


)

 
'
 ) 

+ 

#!/

:


- 
 
,*
' '

  ) 
 

 
)
 *'
( (  
#

#!/
'
  *
 


 
(



"! 6!;


 
+
) 

.3 < 
0 )+ 1

 

  
  = 
0.31

#

#!/
3
 
 (
₹

) *

"6# />
 

 
 )
*
'
) *

!%!!!!>
'


 

 
₹ *


  
) 
0.3 <1
) *
₹ /  "!>

'


 
+

,* 
 )



 %
,



( 
  
 


) )


*(


)



)
 

(

+


) 
 

 
 
+
 


(
,

 +
 )) 

 
*) 
 '
  *
+
 


'

<  
'

' 

4
+ 
)
?*   4
( 
@

 




 



 




) 

'


)
 *
+
 
8 
 
  +
 
 )


)
 

<  
 =




  + 


*
 
?*

   )
 

+
 
 
 5(
 )
 8 
 
+

'

*


  )
)+*)
  

( *
 

   

 
*



)
A
3 (

) 
 )
  
+

)
+ * 
 )


 

 
*



)
A
3
 

)*
+

 *)
 )
B 

) 
 )

 *


* 

+ *

*


'
  ) 
 *
 5
 )


 *)
 )

* 
+
 
*

+

<  > 
 
A


 +
  )
  
+


 
( *
 
 
+
 5(


*)




 


 8
 


( 
) )+*)

*


 
 (
)


CWP-2792-2023 (O&M) - 4-



 *

$
3

 
  
 

 
3  * 

?*

+
) 
 


  


)  
) 


)





() 
)+*)
3


)
 
8)
0 81
'


 * '

* 

 (
 
 
)

  
( )
)



 
 
 
 ' *
) 
 

)
,
'


 * 


+


' 
8 
'
)*  
 
*
) 
 
 

)
'

 + *(

 
,

 



 
  
+

 

'
 
'

)
 
+ 
 
 

)(
 

 

 '
 
 
?*
 
 
)
+
 5

*
* 
'

* 
 


)
 
3
  
 
 
 
) 
.3 <


   
 
 
)

3 *(


  )


  8 
 

 
' 4 + 
' 

 
 (
 
*
 

 
+


 8
 

 


 '(

 
 *
(


*  *

)

)
+

 
 

  
+

 

 
'

5
 *
)(
 
 
* 


 '
?*)
'


+ 

  
  )

) 
 

3
 



 
*((
 

 
 +
*
+

   )
 
  
'

5



 


)(


'


* 
+
 
*
+



 
+


8*( 
**( )




*(
 )

)(
 


 *

'


 (




 



 


 )
 


 *



 
 
,
'

*
+
*)


 
'
*
5
* 


)


 *
5
 (




 

 *

(



 

( )
 
+
( (
  (
 


5


,
'

*
+
 


+*

'

+
 

.(

C
(*  *

#


 * 
,

!

,
'



 

*) 


 

'
3
 





*
) 
)+*)

. %"!/%>

 

*(

) *
  

  
'

 

) 
 )
 

CWP-2792-2023 (O&M) - 53.

Learned State counsel has been unable to controvert the factual position and draw out any distinctive aspects in the aforementioned judgments or cite any contrary law.

4.

In wake of the aforesaid, the present petition is disposed of in terms of the judgment passed in 

  (supra). (AMAN CHAUDHARY) JUDGE 05.08.2024 M.Kamra Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes / No Whether reportable :

Yes / No