Sarabjit Singh v. State Of Punjab





    
  



  

 

!""

#

 !

'(
)"
$%"


**)) + $  

,+ &%









* 

"#$% &'()*"+,-./* #0.123#"$#  &'()*"+,-./*4#).-#-"# ,


,-"

'(.
! .

(
**)) 
/
$
01).
" " )
! 
0 ).
,+ &%

#0.123#"$#5  2("
**)
"
"

 " + 
'"


(
&+'-
 






 


 .
 
%3
) 
" " )
$" 
4+'.

4) (.
"

$"


5 65
**))
$%&"
$"

'(
)"
$%"

1
!('
1" (

"

(
 !
*+ "(%)
+ 
$! " 
5.

5 .
#7

5#
8,
/
1
! "! 

  !
+ 
$! " 

5


5
8,

+  
$! "

5
8, 2
+ '
"'+
"-*" -

)"


*3
"





.6

"

+)

*3-

"

.
 + (
+ '
"'+
"-*" -

1
3 
$! "

5
8, 2
+ '
"'+
"-*" -


*"

" 3


*3

"





7.6

"

+)
 *3-

"

.

+ (
+ '
"'+
"-*" -


 
3

 (
(
  !
1


+
! !+ )3 2(
!

(
*!+ "

+ ())
"
(

#  5

'(
!-*)"


'
!
("
  -
1" (
$8
&

'(

(
!
(
(
1

!* 
%3
*"
$%&"
$"

)"
$%"
1
("
% (.
1(
1
3+ '

("-
/
1
)""

'
1" (
(" - (

 (

5  5

%+
5
* -
 
:"

'
-).
(

 !-*)"

) '
1" (
("
-")3
1

)*
/"
* 
)*
"

* 
-

%+
# 
 -
"

(
- '
(
(
(":

(" - (


 (.
1(
1
3"

'
;

 
("

'
(".

(
!-
+

("
-

 
"


(
-

("
- (

 ( /
1
(
("
% (
$%&"
$"

'(
)"
$%"
1
 !:"

'
("
- ( <+)1
<+

 (
$ '(
1" (


<+)1
<+
"
(
* .
1(
("
 (
$ '(
1
"+)3
"

&+
/ "


("
 (

- (.
(1.
$%&"
$"

'(
)"
$%"


 
("-
1" (


/
!+
("-)
%3
 "

'
"



-
$%&"

'(
)"
$%"

13
-
(
*
) '
1" (

2(
* - - 1
! +! 
2(
  - 

(
1"


1
!
2(
!!+ 1
 
8  "' "
1
!-*) 

!())
1
*+
+*
  !-*) "

))
(
!)
-)" "
2(
*!+ "
=-"



- 3

(" 
1"


"

+**

" 
!
2(
  -

(
!!+
1
)
!
+ $! "
55
 , 
/
 "
(
!

(
*!+ "
/
1 ! "! 

  !.

 "!
%
/ !.
(
*
**)


> 
!+ )
**"

'

%()

(
**))

(- )3
'+
(
(
*!+ "
(
")

*
" 
!
>  !+ )
**"

'

(
$  
(- )3
'+
(
(
*!+ "
( *
" 
!
%3 
 %)
+%

+** 
(
&+'- 

(
) 
")
+

?
(
(
) 
!+ )

(
* "

' 
(+'( (
&+'- 
!
3
!+))3 ,?

$"

'(
*
(
(
1
!* 
%3 *"
2(3
1
1
% (
2(
-

("
% (
"
$%&"

5 '(
/
1
3+ '

("-
/
1
)
-"
$%&"
$"

'(
1 )""

'
* )3
1" (
("
-")3
/
1
)""

'
1" (
("
 (

- (


):"

'
 
(-

5  5

%+
5
* -
 
:"

'
(" -).
(

("
* 
1

)*
"

("
*! "
-

%+ # 5
 - .
(
(
(":

("
 (
;


/
!-
+ 
("
-

1

(
-

("
* 
/
1
(
("
3+ ' % (
$%&"
$"

'(
)"
$%"
-
1" (
:"*
1
"

)"! "

'
"

&+"
 ("
 (

- (
<+)1
<+
/"
- (
!))*

(
'+ '(
)
"

)"! 
"


("
 (
1" (

/
!-
1

!+
("
* 
$%&"
$"

'(
!(
("-
1" (

/
!+
("-)
 
 "

'
"



-
$%&"
$"

'(
) 13
-
(
*
/
1

(
*)"!
  "
) '
1" (
+:( " '(
,)"!
!
("
  - .
@= ,
2(
- "
%("


(
"

!"

1
(
("
 (
 "

+%1))
* 
$%&"
$" '(
+
 - 
- 3
-
("-
-
("
0,
A+ 
/
1
!=-"


8
(" !=-"

.
(
-" 
(
(
(

!"
3
"

&+3


#  5
$%&"
$"

'(
(
)

!"
3
"

&+3
/"
 (
( !"

("
*
/"
- (
(
!"
#7
"

(
*
/"
- (
"

(
*
/"
1"
<-)&"
<+
1
) *
(
(+
2(
!!+
1

*
1(
(
!- "
:

*)!
,?

&
2 
(
-"!)'))3
=-"


$ :( '(
"

$ 3-
/*" ).
4) (
/
*
>.
@= ,
/
 "! (
))1"

'
"

("
*

B 5
!-
 
+ +
1+ 

!
5
!-
- ')%))
2
,$
1
"
#
!-
)"


-:

(

)
"

2
!

# 1
" #
!-
) '
+ +
1+ 

)
*" )
'" 2
!

1
"  7
!-
+ +
1+ 

+%
- "%+)
'" 2
!

1
" 
!-
) '
)"


"

!"
1+ 

)
"

!(

!-
-:

)
"

!(
!"

'
"**)

!-
)"


-:

"'(
"

%- 
!-
+ +
1+ 

+-

)
( 
  "

-
"*

)
(+-% 5
!-
+ +
1+ 

)
*)-
"

% 1 = "

'

(+-%

)
(  
!-
+ +
1+ 
"

% 1
-")

"

'
"

' 
"'(
( 
 
!-
)! 
1+ 

)
*!

"'(
(+-% $(*
'
1*
1
+

))
(
"

&+"  +

"

&+"
1
:*
+ 
% " ,?5
$ '(
"
(
"

&+
1"


/
*
(
( (
1
 
-)3
'(

$%&"
$"

'(
"
)

$%&"
$"

'(
"
3+ '
/"
3+ '

1
""

* )3
'(
1
""

'
1" (
(-

5  5
(
1


)*

%+
5
* -

#  5

%+
# 7
 - .
!!+
$%&" '(
-
1" (

 
"

("
-

"

)"! 

%)1


("-
/
 !:
("
- (
/
"

)"! 
%)1

(
(.
.
)
- 1" (
:"*
$(
+!!+-%

(
"

&+"
/"
 '(
!- 
(
*

("

'

/
!(
(
!!+
!!+
)
"
  !:
("-
/

("-)
-
(
!!+
%3
+

'

%) "

("-)
"


 

(
-
!!+

13
-
(
*
/
1 +(

"")
/*" ).
$((:
-
1(
(
1


"") /*" ).
4) (
2( .
(
1
+ (


$ 3-
/*" ).

7 4) (
/
 3

$ 3-
/*" )

 -
"))
  5
2( !!+
1
*"

'
(-

'"
("-
- 3.
1("!(
(
!"
 
("  "-
/
(
)
-" 
"

("
!=-"

(
("
) +'( "

)1
<-)&"
<+
1
*

(
*
/"
1"
"
"

( (+
/"
% (

 (
) "
!-

(
*
,?#

( 
,:(
(
-"!)'))3
=-"


,?5 $ '(
"

"")
/*" ).
4) (
/
)
 "!
(
))1"


,?5
$ B 
(
"

!"
1+ 
  "

'
-
"



(
) 
=  "

'

)
!(:
% 

!+
"'( !(:
!+
1 1
+* 
- ")

%)"

*+)3
D3
1
" 
(
"

!"
!(**
3*

!-
D
 
!-
=  "

+* 
:+))
% 
*

*" )
'"
D3
1 "

+'"!)
*"


(
"

!"

1+ 
) '" +"

))3
*


-")
"

)
(+-%
$"E
#
!-
D

D
7
!-
D 3
1
"
 !"
1+ 
7 
!-
=
 
!-
=
7
!-
*


(
%!:

)
( 

"
- !*)
'"

D3
1
" C /
*
%
(
"!:

(
* " 
*( !*3

(
-
" @= ,?#6  ,?7
$8
"-)
$"

'(
*
(

#  5
(
) '
1" ( $8
&
$"

'(
!(
(
*
8
)" 
(
%)
-
(
*
**
(
*!)
)
 "


*"))1
1
: 
*"
2( * - -

%3

<+)1
<+
1
'
! +! 
2(
 %3
1
( 


(
("

<+)1
<+
2(
!!+
-
"!)+
  - .
@= ,?76A

*
(
"!)+
  - .
!!+

'(
'
!
 
%)
 "



+  (
(
% %=  ,?

/
,"

'(
*
(

#  5
(
1 * 

/
"

,)"!
$  " .
$((:
/
) '
1" (
$8
&
$"

'(
 (
*)"!
"!")
!(
(
*)!

!!+ !
8
)" 
(
%) -
(
*

**
(
*!)
8
)" 
(
%)

$ -
(
 (

**
(
*!)
2(
*!)
1
: *"
2(
* - -
1
'
! +! 
2(
!!+
1
  /
-
"!)+
  - .
@= ,?76A.
'"

'
! !)-



1
'
!
%3
("-
 "


1" (
%)
8
("
! =-"

.
(
*
(
(
(+

(
!!+
"
&" '

( (+

(
!
2(3
(

!--
(+
("

'
"

 ("
" !
 ,?


4 "

*)
$"

'(
(
! +! 
(
* - - =-"


(
%3

<+)1
<+
/
 "!
(
))1"


(
! B  !"
1+ 
%+

=
7
!-
1


) "

!

:+))
!+ "

'
(+'(
(

*"

+ )3"

'
% 
1
=*
 !"
1+ 
%+
=
7
!-
1


(
) "

:+))

-*
*" )
'"
9 )3"

% 
1
! +
) 
%)
1
*
( 1+ 

"! "
(- -
1
 - '
1
)! 
 !"
1+ 

=
#
!-
1


)
(+) % 
*  !"
1+ 
%+

=
7
!-
1


) +**
-
+ )3"

'
% 
1
!+
! + !"
1+ 
7
=

!-
1


)
-


)%1
9 )3"

'
% 
1
! + C

2(
!+

 (
1
(-('

+' "!
(!:
+

-+) "*) &+"
1("!(
"

"

3
!+

 +

+"!"

!+
 (
/ *
(
* - -
* 5 ,?
)"*
$"

'(
(
**
(
" 
*)

(
*)!
 !!+ !
# ,?5
$8
&
$"

'(
1
(
8  "' "

'
"!
!!"


("-.
(
1
*

('1 )-":"
(1:

E
,?

'(
)'
(
* .
@= ,
2(3
"" 
(
*
/
: %)
 "



(
%3

<+)1
<+
/
)



(
*)"!   "
,( '*(
1
:
2(
"

F+
*
1
**
2(
*  - -
=-"

1
! +! 
2(
!!+
1
 
!!+ '(
-
"!)+
  -
"
@= ,?76A.

(
%"
 1("!(.
(
'
!
:"*
 "


1" (
%)
7 2(
"

!"
(
%

%3
,?
'(

,?5 $ '(
,?
'(
(
! '"!))3
*
(
( (
(":

("
 (

%+
# 5
 -
/
 
("
-
/
1 !!+
"

)"! "

'
"

("
* 
/"
- (
"
 
#7
-"

+ 
!""

'
"

&+"
2(
!!+
)
!(
("-
/

("-)
2( !!+

13
-
(
*
$  -

,?
'(
"
+)3 !% 
%3
"

&+
1"


,?5
$ '(


,?5
$ '(
(
)
*
(
(
!!+
  
("
-

 !:
("
1"
1" (
:"*
$(
+!!+-%

( &+"
2(
  - 

,?
'(

,?5
$ 
+)3
!% 
%3
(
-"!)
" !
,?

&
2 

 "!

"


,?5
$ '(
!!"

'

("-.

(*
'
1*
1
+

!+
"

&+"
,?#

( 
,:(

(
 "!
#
"


,?5
$ '(
!!"

'
 ("-.
(
:"



1*
+
1
(*

))
(
"

&+"
/
*
> "
@= ,?#6


2(
* - -
=-"

1
! +! 
%3
,?

 4 "

*)
$"

'(
!!"

'

("-.
(
!+

 (
1
(-('


+' "!
(!:
+

-+) "*)
"

&+".
1("!(
"

"

3
!+


 +

+"!"

!+
 (
/
*
(
* - -
*
" @= ,?

6


2(
!!+
-
"!)+
  - .
@= ,?76A.

( %"

1("!(
(
'
!
 "


1" (
%)
+  (
( %
%=


A$>
*
"
@= ,G
2(
=("%" 
*"))1.
(" .
)1. % "3 .
(1).
* .
+ 1.
*&-.
(" .
% "3 
1  "


1" (
(+-
%)
 8
(
!-

(
!
(
(
(+

(
!!+

("  (
1
&"

'
2(
"



(
 (
,?5
$ 
))3
"-*)"! 
("

$"-"))3.
,?
'(
1+)
*
))3
'"


("
1
% (

  

  

                       **))
%3 
 %)
+% !!"

')3.
(
"

-"
"

(
**)
2(
-
"
"-"














&"
$(- 4+' #  

>)"
  












4+' ?( (
*:"

'6 



G6




?( (
* %)




G6