← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/867/2018dismissed

Mohinder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2022-12-09Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari9 pages

  

        





  !"#$%& !$%$'%(#$%&)    

 

 

 

 &  *+

 , ,

,- .

  *+

 , .

+- 

 !"#  $ %&'( ) * + &'*,- '* .

 ' ' &(

(/!

,

,- .

 /  

&'''* !"&* )'*( '& )'* +* )'*'

2 34 5316!"& ''



'

  -7&'87 &7  *.(  (

'

7

193 +56 5314(:&&  &('* + *& :+  ++*'&! *'

;<5=;44 +& 7(( *'

<> +& *'

+7&'+

?++* *(5315-&'++ & *8& *8.(&2 +''  +* )'*'

 '&**

  )(&  &*'  : 5316( &    '      *   '2      &

 * )'*-.!

&*-. +'2' 2: ++'! '&&'+?*2#, ++* 2' 2 '   +  + "2 ++' =  >  7 

*(5315 '

 2' 2 + :)@  A3(333=, 

+& 

'

 2' 2 + '?2 & =;<57 '

 2' 2 +  "  1333=, 

+&     + 1A" ;

&  &  !')  *-.  +  '2' 2 :

 * *"(!&'

'* "!"& * )'*' &*" +')' '

' +&*(:(

 ! ++ '&!

)'2 !')*-.

+'2' 2 <

&  * )'*  !* 2   ')  + 2  &  )'*  + * )'*'

-.(!'!* 2 ')+ 2&!

)'2  *-.(&(' *& '&'!+  &'7  0(1'0230(45!$'%#

& ' +& *'

*!* 2* '&  :&'*&?&'!' =5''   &'+ 2

2'% ' & ;1 3A 5314(&2'

&'&&' !

(&'  !

1>,14"'2"(( :& * ?'"&' ;3 3A 5314(&&  &!'*%, %' !

:

% & 2!

6 33  '* '

)' ' &'* &!

A ;3  (  &' ' &(& * 22':  +*:'&&' +* +'' &'2'

2 +

6 &'&  *&+ &)'*'2(!*   *&'2  ;1 3A 5314(!

;

33  (&)'*'2:!  &!"'!&'

' & )' ' &+ 2 : & &'!

&" &'2 2''7')' '($ &'+ &'2'*2(+ :&&:+ 7')' '(   &":%' & )'*'2&( &:"& '*2&2 &!' +& 2  ++  !"  &  * 2'(  &    *  :    ' '&** %" 175017$%8!$(#7%5  >

' ')' '

(  ! ' &* *&B

+)'*'2 &*":'&& + * !' '2'

$ :%'  '** "

&* + :'*  &': &**: (&'22  *&22 :

+  * 2'

  +  ')' '

  !" &  ')' '

++'** *(' & -.(&''++'2')      *'

  14;  7  (  !+   &    ''



'

  -7&'87 &7  *.(   !702 $'!1!$(#7%5 

+'' '2+*'*(*&  *'

< > +&7  *(5315(( *'

;<5;44 +& 7!*2+2( '&**( :&'*&&  '"((*'2'

     +  &   *'

  *(  &   *'

?2'):' +* 2'

+* '  +&  ''

  +  &   *'

  :'(  &    ''



'

  * *(: *' ( *'

;1; +&

9 7  (  !  &'(  &  **  *'2  +  '2'*' (  ( ' **

+* *'

+&'((!*2 &  -.(!"&'  * *(& *  2%&+ )'* +* )'*'

(( 2&* C &:'&*-.-.( (& ,'3:7 7$% $;1<20!%#($'% 2;$!1<($%"7(1088220%1

-1.

&    *   '  +   &  * )'*, &2!2''

!+ &'7 (&'*&)'*'2 ' ' &:'!

?(&+ (&'

-.(*' '& (''  &' :&'*&?&'!'  =5('' (&** !' !* *')"!'& -5.

  &  +&  !2'  &  &  '+'*' -.

!"&  *:' &)* ':'&   '2 )2((2!'&2+ &')'

"* 2':''  &(&!2'& '**!'  &2 +& *:'

& ,'3:7 7$% $;1<20!%#,101 $'% 2

& &&(& * &  &&*''

+)'*2!"&7 )'*' ('2',:

&"((&'  C'"'+* !' 2!"&'7 

('20!=71%  1$1<$(('!!%( 1;

D, 2/' ' &' &:'!

?D,;

'  &'  ?2''

,',*&'+(  &  ) '*  &  !

  >=4  2 & ' &'' ' &:'!

?(&&  & 

> *& 2'*'* &!

)'& ' %!"&'2 !

:!" 

 ' & +&*& && 2!

"

*2%&'2  &&  + &' ' &(' &'2   )''&'& (!&& '*&&& : + 2''(:&+&%&&''&

+ 2&! %

(:&&)'*'2(:& '2"

*&'(:'&* 2" +&** +&% &  &  %  &  **     & 

(    &  :  )"

 '!''" +&'!!

' &)'*'2*&'  :)(&** & &'2 :"(' &'2 !' &*& :%'( & &  +&**(:'&''2'

 &*& :%'&& **:* 22'' * &)'*'2((&&' C' !  &'7& :%''2!"&'2 !   &  ' &    +&  '+'  &  !

  53=;A     & * * & "&**' !

&

&+(&%&&! &8:'+ +&***& & +&)'*'2 & (( &') +&2 & +& )'*'2(&** )&)'*'2 ''+'&**'  &+(& &&! & +**&&& + &'* 22'' * &)'*'2 2& ! & +&**&'" &'?2''

,',*&'+(&&  )&')'

"22 & '*  1< '  +&* ,?2''

(2 D, ;('&'&" '

(!*22& &'2(   !)'

"  "  :  & (  2  + 2  &'2(  & )'' (  &  &  &  2  "  '+      '2 )2  2!'&2)',E,)'&')'

"22-.':''

 &(&!

)!2''

+&* + & +''/* 7 '"('  +&* ,?2''

( 2 D,;2%%' &&**:&

  &   (    &  &  :  &  )    &   '*    & !C"

  )(&'  %&'(&&) '2(&**&)'*'2!

&: '*!"&'2 !:'&  * &((&'  '*' &&**&'&''' & +&)'*'2 &?'* +&!

)%' '& *   ?2''

  +  D,;(    ' '+'*(    &"  * '  ' '*'2' "  *& '    '  &  **  "  &  !

) '*'2' "*& ' (?'&' '&**( &  *'!''"(!C":'&&) +&7 (&*  + &**&2 '&2 +&'++'**"&  &&'( :'&&) +&7 &*2%' +&* ,?2''

 D,;

 :)(&+** ('   ( &+ (  &  !

)  '*'2' "  *& '     ?'  '  &  * , ?2''

+D,;&** ! !* 2* *!"& +*

$!!$3$!017$%2%11$1< 101:%1$;-63?1<#8$ 717$%$; -90%#0%02? 7 $;1<1 17;7(017$%

 > &  2  +  D,;  '  +"  *    !"  &  ''

+D,< 

(& %&'C&':'' & * 22''

+&*!"&** &)'*'2 ) ' &  +'

* ,?2''

( :&'*&&: !/* (&2'*& 1>

* / '"' +&'+'*'

-.(2!"&

*:'-.( &) ***( &&'

 *')"22 ':'&"' +&' 2%'  "     '2 )2    2!'&2  )',,)'  &' *')"  *   2  '  :''  &2 (  &' *')"2'+'*'

-. ++ 2"' +"

',* '*'

',&*')?2''

-.,',*&'+ &'*')* ?2''

-.

 ":&&" ',*  '

 &'*')" *** C & &(* 2**' !2 &' *')"  2  '+'*'

-.

 &+ (    &  !'  +  & *')"2'+'*'

-.(!"*'! *:' &

***(  &(  &  *&    '  &  **    +" !'&

!5':%1  $;  1<  20!%#  ($'% 2  ;$!  1<  ($%"7(1088220%1 !50!#7%5%$%(717%5$;"7(17:0 8!$ ('17$%=71%  &'+ 2'

'* +& ***: 2 & '*!"D,1 D,1& )&'2%' ?&'!'

& * '  +&2('+"( +&)'*'2!"& '*( !'&* C& + *''  +&)'*'2 *'

:'(  " "+&'+*(&&'+ '+'*'

-.  +  &  *  :'    &  ***      ! '*  )(&*2!* +2'!''"( & )'*'2( 2%2('* C"'!(&')' '

++'*  * *(    *   &'  2(  !'      &  *'

  *'&'2 *'

:' &+*2 + )2'!''"*2!' &)'*'2' )!"D,15(  : ' & &+ ('"&!

)2!2''



+  &    *   +   &  * )'*,    '

'' '+'**

#7(02"7#%(

D,13,    $2  ' &(  '*  ++'*(  7')'  '(     '  &'  ?2''

,',*&'+(  &   )  &  '

(& '*!*2(' '  +' !' 2''&') +&)'*'2 &  &(&& &&* 2%"+'2 ''

!

&*&')'*'2 !' !/* "*'* (&' :&B '* +&*&')'*'2

&'2"(D,14 $&'& :('* ++'*(77($&'(:& :&B '* +&*&' )'*'2('' &:'!

?D,14((' &* 

+&?2''

,',*&'+(& )&2'*  ?2''

+&*&')'*'2( :&'*&?

=1''  +* *' & 2'*?2''

&) '

 +&!

" +&)'*'2 *&'(& )& ''

( :&'*&?

=1'' ( ''

:& +'?*&'+(:& +*'") '*(& &: '!''" +&*&')'*'2!' !/* * '*  &' ''

2!"D,14(  *   &*'! *** C& *'

*!"&

*:' &    

                 



 

     

  )('&++')':&'*&!*2 '

)'*' &*  +?2''

,',*&'+(&&2 *& ' (&&&2* *'

 +:!(!'*&' +

) ?'" &'  !'  +  &    :

 !C"(  &  !

) * *'

:'* &*(&  &* ! %&

' &

419 &7&2'*?2'* * &!

) * &*!*2 !*2*')&!

 "

* *(  '     '    2  * ''

    ?2''

!' 2!"D,14(C&'2* '& * &*(' ''

C  

 !' *'&*  +?&'!'1 &+ (:&&!

)

''

!* 2 !(&  &)'*!' *!"& **   ')  C  &  )  '2     !  '    & * */!* "(&' ''

&+ *  '

 &*'!":'** C&  +

 * C*(&' 2''&((& 2''2' &'2 )'*-.((* C&:'& *-.-.('2  &* )'*(++'2 2''

&* "('+"(!:'&'** *:'& :+&?'" +'

+'2''

+ &+''  +

&* !+ &:'& :     ,

,- .

    .

+- 

)    %)' & -<1<! 8047%5@!0 $%# &  @$ -<1<!!8$!1032 &  @$