High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1909/2014dismissed

Rajender Kumar Batra v. State Of Haryana

2018-12-05Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu11 pages

!""

$%&' (()) & * +, ( !"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.,/01! "!

$%&'( )*+,-(! ,$2( 0,$310,21) - . - ./&0! (*"/1*10! 0 1(()) (2/0(& ,! 2)0+,

!.,/01! "!4 31&/1

56)" &(" !07& )!&) 1(()) 8& /& 1'" (() 31( (()"" " & /" 1$&/' #

7," ")*" .&/0%&&91 0"*"!

0617,(()) $ %&' 6 !1/ 6" 1 " 1 ! (&"17)&*! "

;- +6!"! ! &*! "

;- &/"'("' )" (," #0

:"&) (,' "0 & 1&/"'() "'("' "<' 1 +6)!"! !& *! "

;- &/"'("' (""<' 1 (,"

:"&) (,' "0 & 1&/ "'()"'("' ("' 1 1 1 !6 &!!& ),

31! 1(!& ""& 1))" 1 !'()" *&91$ *"/16" "))/*1"/1 +6/"!&) &" 7,("

7& 4

- 1 )7"*"/1 1*"/16/"/' 1""))/ -6+&01)$ =1 1,!17& 1)9")' '"))/*1"/10! 7"/ >

6& 31/"6 =1 1, ( 1"?6"6 1!0,&/'6& 1 "? 3167& '91"7, -)"!6"' * ' *&91$ *"/16! 17"61"!1@;6 /" 317,6 ( ' '<'" " ; "/ " 6!'() !1))6(& &( !'() ")) 1!) ')" " 31(!& "<'"&'76" "&(( 1! 31 ' 1!!&6)!&*! "

- +1" 1! 1(!& " +6!"! !0 "!7 +!0 1( (() > !&) (("/ 71) 1 (()) 1' ),/& 1 1(!& "1") (" ! > !&)(("/ 1* 1' ),/& 1 1(!& "1 (" !7,7)&7 &(( 1$&/' 1)& 7)6 =11)!&) 1( "/ 1&/1 1$&/' !,!&)), -= 0>, 7)0( 1

11 (" (!)6" 1@*>01&7!"( 161 +

-= )9'1!)"!9 1(1 /(1 17,0 A< - A< - #0 5 5

-= 7)"1%&'"')6" -= >$$'( 1 5 5

0; "/ "/ "!'(()"! "0A< - 40( ' '<'" " 1 7, ; 6 1-2;01 9 -=4+*$,%&' "" 1 5 5

011 / 13))-)B+ 0%)0 7 " 1 /3C /"/ 1!"/ ") >

+ '(()"! "0"A< -

0 1/0*&,- (3)) -)B 31/1 1! ""/ /3C

1"' 31 011 1 *;*17*"/1 + ( 10A< -

-= *&91$ *"/1( 1

7& 4

- 01)/6" 1 )7"*"/16/"/ (61&"))/1) $'1""))/ =1 1,!17& 1)9")' ' "))/*1"/10 1, "!!(9 1 31,!' 1! 7,6" 1! .& 76 ),"/" 1! 31," "!,&96( 31," )'))&' 9") +6!)1 ") 18& '7, 1) -&7)"!-!& -= )7" *"/1 1 ) &(( 1 ! 1 (!& "

7)%'7"( 1 4

16 ( ( 0,7))0* - "!0%&&91 +7 " 1 !)) ")'7")

1("'

5 5

*; 1/*"/1( 1

01!" 1"' "7& 7! +)/6" 1A+1"*"/1 *;*17*"/1&1 1( 5 5

0; "/ "/"! ! 1 ' *&91$ *"/1&886 1()"! " +& 1 "" 1

( ' '<'" " 7,6/ !&! '-2;01 9 +& 1 "" 1 5

0% $*"/11(&!/" " ! >

7 1; "/ "/"!0" A< -

!!&6" / 7, 1; "/ "/"! +' "!)& ' 0A< -

0 1! 1

011("!9 &(''$20)1"!''" 1"'& + 1 (& &(1"7," 1! " "*117 31!!& 9 1()"!( , 1()!!!&! '! "6/ (( *1" 6)! 31!!& ! '1")""!)& ' @1"!)& ' 0A< - 406' +"!) 7& 19"061"!16&" 1'&1 16 1'" 1(" 31!!&) 9 1()"!( , 1()!'611 ("!9 1&96(

1&12,)0-= 1&1//6)-= ./"1=16" &(( 1! 1(!& " 31,6 !)1 ")

-= 4*&,- (1(0A< - -=

*!1')6!)1 ") -= "1*1'" 1' ")6" + "" 1 ()"!"!")1'(()"! "9"/ ") >

31,/ 1 ' 1 )), '

# ")61 A+*$,%&' !!"/ 1 1"!)!1!01"!)/" " >

1! 6'7)"

7& #5-

!!"/ -=* 7"*"/10 1!6/" " 1 '% $

-=4*;*17*"/1( 1

)(1"!

'/6!" 1""' "01)/6" 1A+1*"/1 *; 1/*"/1!1 1( ?/"6 * ' *&91$ *"/16!0"A< -0 5 5

-1 /(16 / !)"!9 31 "!)" 7<0 1!" ! ""/9 ")0("!!) 10 67&)(0 6"1))6(& 61"!1! ""/39)0'( ,() "!!" 0'7")(1 6"'!6! 316 9" (" *)6 "< 31 ! (( , 6 (" 6" 1 + -)"! * "0 *117 3176! " & ,6 -2;01 9 ( ' '<'" " +)'(()"! "0A< -40" 1 "! ")+"/16,& 1" ,0)360'7)07 ""/ 1!1 ")1"!)

("/ 1&/1 13))-)B %) +)/ ((" () +" "" 1<1"7" (&! " 1& -=5 -9$ 11"9 !&! 1 ( ' ' <'" ")/6" 11" ' !!"/ 1"(""07, 6,&/&) ')!& 16 ' '"$&"

&6( ' '" & C"!6(

*;-1)*"/1( 1 " "/ "61 1"')/6" 1*; 1&("*"/1 1 31,6 1

4 1& !!& $ %&' % !!& (&! 1" 1 7 1"' + 6 31 !!& 6 " /

+'"!)& ' 0"A< -

0 1! 1

011("!9&(''$2 )1"!''" 1"'& 7,6(& " 1! " " (&"/9")"))/*1"/1 + ! '1" ("& ' +" 1 "!)& ' 6 !0 " A< - 4 !!"/ 1""!)& ' 011 16 19"" 1(" 319"!&) 7! *1" 6!'7, 12 3 " 17&1 +) 9 1()"!( , 1()!' 611 9 1&96(

31!"7!"!&' ")"! ; ( 1!7!"!&' ")"!0 1(!& "" !'() 1!1" # =1 '/' 1"!"!&1"7" 1 1(()) 1("!9&(''$206)1" +9")) 1"' +!3))-)B0%) #5-

+ 7 1 ! (& "/ 1 7, " "))/ *1"/1 6 6 7, 1 (()) ? % 31 /" "!&' 6 9"("'1"' 31(()) 1"((

31!&!

1(()) "&&&)& &) ; ! 7" 1 "!1 ((11" 01"(( " 1,@;6)/, !'()" 6' 1'""/!" 1' 1.&),0

4 31(()) 1'(()"! "9"/7")&"/ 1 ") *(!""! ' 1 7 ' " 1 (()"! " 1

16/"/ '" + (( %) 31( 9)" '1"' 31,7!'"),6" 11"' 1' 9 1 ! ) "/ 36(" "/71"9"((1"'/&(" 9 1! 6 +6 9 &96()! ; 6 6" 1/ ""!&) , 1 1!&)'/ )6,' 1"!)& !1 "@7&,0

31(()) 10 1&0'" 1"(!" 1 61 1!"'6!''" 31!061"!16"7, 1(()) 0 ! 13))-)B0%)

#5- 311"!) ")6&),(7,-= 4*&,- (0"A< 5 31(()) 1'"!)& ' 0"A< -

+ ! ' 1" )" "!)& ' 1 0 1 "!)& ' 0A< - 406' 31!"& ' '"$&" 31 01"7,67& , 1"!

-= *&91$ *"/1 -= )7" *"/1 1&/1 1 ")' 1)" ' 7& '" 1(! 1! 1" 31"<() "/"7, 1(()) 16 1! "7,1"'!1"))/*1"/116 17,6& 7& "1"! 31"(!""!! 6"1"96)/ ; "" ! 61*! "

4 1;"A"!! 0

56&)7 ! * /&/1 1 1 1(()) " % 1) )/,( 7& 1'""/1" 1! +'"") (! 7& ' 1

;

*&('& 5#0 1">1"(+?7) 1*&('& 11) 1 61'67&! 1'&0 17&! )!&) )) 1 & 61 1(( 1 ( 61 6 7&! =1

7&! 6" 11) 1""' "0 1& "$& "" 6"! 1 7&! 6 1'& 31">1"(11)&

31 6" 6 <'" 1 ! " , 1 1)( 6! &)),)""/ '" 7& "<' 1(" 1!!&! 31, = ''7 1-!1, 0= = 3&0 1 16" ")"9 1 & 1""!6&) 1)( 1! 16 1 1)( 6)""/" ),' 11& 61 1! , 1 "/1 )) 1 1 6" !&) , 6 1 -= -= 6 ,"/ '" 31 <("??'" ??!&) !'(),"/ 1("(1, 1!" , )"'" ) 31""!)),"!"7)' 1'" 61"!1= */*"/16!"7"1" (" " + " !"7 " &(6)" C"))/??"'" ?? >!&)'& ")& !

' &7 1 -= -=6&)17 ,"/6" 1 1) '" " , &!1 '( 6 7! 1 -= 1"')6!"! " '&!)"01!16&)196 1 )&('( ( "/ 1()"! !!"/ 1 !&)0-= " !1 / 1()"! " 7,< ),'"/ =1 -= " 1 !" 1 16 96,1'" " 1 1&&"/ 1 ""/1 16 "!961 1'"/791!))! 1" 7 12&'*"/16 "!11" !'! 17, C"))/-1""61"!1"!) 1""! + 1) 1( )"/1" 7 1 '" 1 7"06 '" !" ,7"!,!)"'"/1") 7& 1!!

&! 1"6,7!9' 1!"

!'! 1()"! +&"1 1' 1 ") 1!!&!196 ; 17 " 1 " 1"/ 16 1 -= -= 6 ""/6,' 1"1& &(6)" << << << =1"&),7 6&!" " 1/&' 7, 1)"!&) =)," 1)/)("!"()&'7 "* = /)"1'''&( 1 61'( 117&! 1"! "'0 616) '&0" "6" 1" 1)/)("! 1!& $& ""7),6(&'( "("/ 1! &)" & "0 1 )) 17&! ("7) 1'& *! " 1;-!&)7"9 1" 1 0&),( "!&)7&! "" 1!& 6" 11"<() " 61 )1 "6" 1 1"! "'&78& ),0" 61 11) 1" !" & 61 11"& 1' "/ 1< '! ! !

='"&)61 "8& ),1(("/ &"/ 1, -9"((" 1"/1 1!"7), 9& 1"/1 )) 1 ) 19"((9")) ;)/)("!"() 7)"6" 1 1'&&!19"(( 11&)!"),7"( "!( ' 1!"!&' !&' 7066&)7 (""/ $&"(&! ( ! "/ &!1 !"'")! "" " ;"! 6 ),6 ,&!1)/)("!"()"&) "/ 1'& 1" ! "" "9"))"/9"(("! & " 19 1 ;

5 *&('& #0 1">1"(+?7) 1*&('&

1 1) 1 61 1 " 1 !!& " 6 1 !"!&' ! 1 "!&)( 1"' " 1 !"' 1 ") (((" <() "/")60 1'!7!& (""/'""/)"97&")"/ 1!1"!"!&' ! 31" >1"(11)& D 1 ! " 8&" 7 31&/1)) 1"!"'" "/!"!&' !61"!1(" 1/&") 1!!&17(& 1"'0, 1 !1 /",<() "&*! "

"'")-!&<!( !1"/ 1' ") ; "6)) )")6 1 61 1 " 1 !!& " 6 1 " !"!&' ! 1 "!&)( 1"' " 1 !"' 1 ") (((" <() "/")60 1' !7!& (""/'""/)"97&")"/ 1!1"!"!&' ! ** 11 *&10

*5 ; 1! 10 1&/1 &'7!"!&' !6(& 1!!&0, 1 1'7)")" ,<() " 61 31&0" ")!"!&' ! 1 / /" 1"' E ; 1" !0 1(!& "1!'() 1!1" 31(()) 6( " 161 1!6&7 6" 17,&96( /" " 1!6" 1 '1" +7!7& ' 1 31!! 1 3))-)B%)

7& #5- 31"! "(7, 0A< - @& 1-=

7)%'7"( 1 17 " 1!)) ")'7")

1(" ' 5

5 5

+ 1 1 !)) ") 1 ; "/ "/"! -=

*;-1)*"/16 !<'"7&

1!)) ")7 ""A< -

+1)( 1 11 " $" 1 "( 6" 7& 7, !' 6 31 (!& "( 1!/" 1(()) 7,7)&7

31"&)(" 1" "/ " 31()"!1&) 1 9 1"/(" ' 1! +60 1"6")) /", 7" 1(()) 31(()) 1 /",<() "61 8& "6(& 1"' 1 "'!"/1" ' & *! "

- /"//" "!0 ! 31(!& "1( 1' " 31(()) 6 7&") +"7&"6&"/" ) 31!& '69"/ 1"', 31(()) 9"))&96((& 1"' " (&"/9")" 91" 1 1" )"7")" "

" !"!))" 16))$&/' 1) ")& 31"'" " 1(() 31'"17, "'" $"*1' .&/

+"*"/1*"1& .&/ =1 1(9"/: F: =1 1( 7) F: