High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1933/2014dismissed

Sudhir v. Vinod Kumar & ANR

2015-09-22Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal,Mr. Justice Arun Palli10 pages

!" # $

%& &'()( * + ,-.(/

00&11% 2&/)-) 3( 4-5/ %.&/

&)0 &%) * 67 # , , , , 67 # , 7

"/&)&%*/ ,&&04 %192 '%& /%.&00&11%

:.&%.&/&0 /%&/) 1 '100&/)5;<&11 =&% )&&%.&>-?5&%@ <&/&&//&% %.&&0 /%&/ / %@ :.&%.&/%.&>-?5&%). -1<&/&0 /%&(%.& (?&)%@ , , ,9#

.&00&11%,-.(/) 1&29=. ()%.&62('%(56( %.&')&.)(1&< %.%.&)&00&1)( &

.&)(00&1)/()& -% )5&! %& +/&?()%&/&%0 1('&,%%( (%;!%&.< /%.& &'&)-&/,&'%( )99+9+9

A ("&1 &6"6 /). /%B<&)(&)9,&'%( + %.&/5)'%9 + /(5(100&1

.) <&& (1& / 5 (;(? %.& >-?5&% ' 2('%( %&

/&/ )&%&'&%&

%.&1&/& %/(1 -/% /' 2('%(?)&%&'(?/&)0 &%

3( 4-5/) ./%,(?. /%.& &'&-&/,&'%( ") =&11 ,(5(1/1;/(5(100&1

.)<&& (1& /5 (;(?%.&>-?5&% ' 2('%( %&

/&/ )&%&'&%& %.&1&/&%/(1 -/% /' 2('%(?)&%&'(?/&)0 &%) % A(%.&)( 00&1)0&/%.&'./?&)/5&( & /%.& &'&-&/,&'%( "1) 3( 4-5//&)0 &%

(

/&)0 &%)

% (

.2&<&&' 2('%&)&%&'& /%.& &'&)-&/,&'%( ) +9 9 +9 +9 A /& =(%. ,&'%( " ; %.() ' 55 /&/9< %.%.&00&1)/&<&(?()0 )& !(%.&')&=)/&?()%&/& %.&)%%&5&% %.& ' 501(% 2(&/":

+) 1&2,(?.

'' /(?% %.& ' 501(% 2(&/9%.&5//(?& .(); -?&/</ %.&/,-.(/ 4-5/00&11%9=. ()2 '%&9=)% <&) 1&5(D&

+ %.&; ''-//&'&( & +%< -%C 059 %.& . 1-5) %.& /& >019 ,-<.).9 .-0 ,(?. E "00-) -0%(5E.&/?-0%4(1/(3( ) #?%"193(;F.()</ %.&/) ) ./%,(?.9&/E !->() ;15,=5(%= ) ) >01/&)(&%) 2(11?& &&?9 &2(71) &.,(?./&)(&% &.-=1 A

-F =0&/) )'5&% %.&(/. -)&( -/2&.('1&)

.&;=&/&/5&=(%.61%.()66?)()6 >013( =&/&/5&=(%.0()% 1)(%.&(/.) 11 %.&5&%&/&%.&(/

. -)&<;0 (%(?0()% 1 %.&%&501& .()</ %.&/,-.(/ 0('F&.(5-0% F.(5<;0-%%(?.(5('/ 3( 9.-0 ,(?.93(;F&%'

1) .&1 -%%./&%)% F(11%.&5 :.&%.& ' 501(%)(&%/(&% /&&%.&</ %.&/ %.&' 501(%9%.& %.&''-)&(1('%&()%<1 =)9<&)(&)9)100&%.&5=.(1& <-)(?%.&;% F=;.()</ %.&/ >010/ '1(5&%.%(')& %.&5%%&/=)/&0 /%&% %.&0 1('&%.&%.&;= -1F(11,-.(/ 00&11% .&' 501(%1 ?&/&0 /%=(%.%.&0 1('& 0/;&%.%.()</ %.&/,-.(/<&)2&? %/&&B<&)(&)9 '%( <& %F& ?()% %.& ''-)& % %.& %(5& ''-//&'& ,-/&&/5-/%(=&/&0/&)&% %.&<)() ( /5%( ?(2&<;2(&/9! /%.& &'&))5&%( &< 2&=)/&?()%&/&<;,54-5/

.&1&/&%/(1 -/%2(& /&/%& C(%.&')& -% =.('.

/()&)/5&'./?&)?()% %.&&1&2&''-)&&G'&0%5/,(?.''-)&

=. (%() )%%&.))('&(& /%.& &'&)-&/,&'%( ) A9+9 99 +"5/,(?.=)'./?&).&&%& / %.& &'&-&/,&'%( " 3( 4-5//&)0 &%

(

) ./%,(?.%%.% %(5&=)0/ '1(5& &&/.<&&&'1/&))-'.2(& /&/%&

&=)1%&///&)%&)&0/%&%/(1 =) ' -'%& ?()% .(59 ( =.('. .& =) ' 2('%& )&%&'&() =)-<>&'%5%%&/

.&1&/&%/(1 -/%)%&/' )(&/(?%.&&2(&'&

5%&/(1) /&' / 2(& /&/ %&

' 2('%& ,-<.).9>"19.-0,(?.9>&).93( ) #?%0193(;9 &/,(?. &2(71/&)0 &%) % A(

/%.& &'&)0-().<1&-&/,&'%( )+9 9+9+ A/&=(%.,&'%( " ;)&0/%& /&/ 0))& 9 %.&; =&/& )&%&'& % -&/?

/(? / -) (50/() 5&% / & ;&/9 <&)(&)9 0; (& ) +9H (&-1%%.&/& -&/? )(501&(50/() 5&% / %./&&5 %.) /%.& &'&-&/,&'%( +H "B-&/?

/(? / -) (50/() 5&% / & ;&/9 <&)(&)9 0; (& ) H (&-1%%.&/& -&/? )(501&(50/() 5&% / &5 %. /%.& &'&-&/,&'%( +H "B-&/?

/(? / -) (50/() 5&% / %./&& 5 %.)9 <&)(&)9 0; (& )

H (&-1%%.&/& -&/? )(501&(50/() 5&% /

+ ;) / %.& &'& -&/ ,&'%( H "B -&/?

/(? / -) (50/() 5&% / )(G 5 %.)9 <&)(&)9 0; (& ) H (&-1%%.&/& -&/? )(501&(50/() 5&% / & 5 %. / %.& &'& -&/ ,&'%( + " -&/? /(? / -)(50/() 5&% /)(G5 %.) /%.& &'&-&/,&'%(

A" 11%.&)-<)%%(2&)&%&'&).2&<&& /&/&% /- ' '-//&%1;

3( 4-5//&)0 &% (

) ./%,(?..)<&&' 2('%&<;%.&1&/& %/(1 -/% 2(& /&/ %& C

/ %.& &'&) -&/ ,&'%( )+99+9+ A/&=(%.,&'%( "

;)&0/%& /&/%&

9.&.)<&&)&%&'&( %.&)5&5&/)/&)0 &%)

% (

.& 00&11% ,-.(/ ??/(&2& ?()% 'I-(%%1 ''-)& /&)0 &%)(%.&/&)0&'%(2&00&1) /%.& &'&-&/ ,&'%( ".)(1&%.&0/&)&%00&1) 7&/&' -)&1 /%.&00&11%.)' %&&%.%%.& 1&/&%/(1 -/%).2&=/ ?1;.&1%.%2(&/": + ,-.(/":

''-)&. %F(00&,-.(/=(%.(%&%( % ' 55(%.()5-/&/ %()' %&&%.%,-.(/":

)%%& %.%>013( 0-%0()% 1) .()%&501&%.&;/??& .(5<;.()' 11/% =/)%.&(/2&.('1&) :.&,-/&&/95-/%( .()</ %.&/2(&/(%&/2&&%/(&% )2&.(593( 9 ,-<.).93(; %.&/)?2&<&%(?% %.&5%./&%&& %.% ( ; '%( () %F& ?()% %.&59 %.&; = -1 F(11 .(5

'' /(?% 1&/&' -)&1%./&%% F(11=)5&9 /=.('. %.&/&)0 &%)(%.&00&1)/&1) 1(<1&% <&' 2('%& )&%&'& /%.& &'&-&/,&'%( " :&.2&?(2& -/%. -?.%-1' )(&/%( % %.&5%%&/

.&1&/&%/(1 -/%.)' )(&/&%.&I-&)%( =.&%.&/%.& '%) %.&''-)&5F& -% &'&-&/,&'%( " / -&/,&'%( +" %=) %('&%.%(%.&)%%&5&% %.& <)() =.('.!=)/&?()%&/&9(%.<&&11&?&%.%%.& ''-)&<-'%&,-.(/%0()% 10 (%%.&;'-)&.-/%% %.& ' 501(%.() %.&/5(1;5&5<&/)9<&)(&)9 =.&%.&; %/(&% /&)'-&,-.(/9%.&''-)&.&1 -%%./&%)% F(11%.&5 %.&; =.(1& <-)(? %.&5 % F =; ,-.(/ % %.% %(5& %.& ''-)&>010/ '1(5&%.%,-.(/= -1<&F(11&9(')&%.&

5%%&/=)/&0 /%&% %.&0 1('& 2(&/":

+&0 )&%.% =.&%.&;%/(&% )2&,-.(/9''-)&3(;9.-0,(?. 3( (1('%& ()% <1 =) % %.&5 )100& %.&5B <&)(&)9 <-)&%.&5 .&;%./&%&&% F(11%.&5(')&9%.&;%/(&% )2&,-.(/ 2(&/-/%.&/)%%&%.%=.(1&%.&''-)&=&/& 1&2(?9>01 .&1 -% %./&%) % F(11,-.(/9 (%.&0 1('&=) ( /5& /&/% )'&/%(=.&%.&/%.& &'&-&/,&'%( " () 5& -% ?()% %.&''-)& /&)0 &%)9 %.& )( 0/ 2()( 5;<& %('& ,&'%( "/&))-&/*

:. &2&/ F(0) / <-'%) ; 0&/) ( /&/ %.%)-'.0&/) 5;<&5-/&/& /5;<&) ()0 )& ) % <& 0-% ( ?&/ <&(? 5-/&/&9).11<&0-().&=(%.(50/() 5&% / 1(& //(? / -)(50/() 5&% /%&/5=.('.5; &G%&% %&;&/)9).111) <&1(<1&% (&

.& 0/&)&% () ')& <-'%( ()5-'. ) )&'%( "&(&)6<-'%( 6% 5&=. &2&/<; /'&9 /<; &'&(%-15&)(-'&)9;0&/) % ? / 5;01'&9())(% <-'%%.%0&/) /&/% 5F& -% &'& F(00(? /<-'%( (%&/5) ,&'%( "9%.&0&/) F(00& / <-'%&()% <& /'(<1;%F& /&%('&( /&/%.%.&5;<& 5-/&/& /5;<&) ()0 )& )% <&0-%(?&/ <&(? 5-/&/& .&0/ 2()( ) ,&'%( "0/ 2(&) /&.'&

0-().5&%=.&/&F(00(? /<-'%( ())&&5(?1;00/&% % ' 55(%5-/&/ /%.&F(00& /<-'%&0&/) 5;<&) ()0 )& ) % <& 0-% ( ?&/ <&(? 5-/&/& .& 0-().5&%0/ 2(&() /%.&)0&'((' &'&)(('%&(%.& ,&'%( 5&/&1; %.&<)() )-)0('( % ' 55(%%.&5-/&/ F(00& /<-'%&0&/) = -1 %' )%(%-%&%.& &'&

%()0/(5/(1;%.&5 %(2&=.('.()% <&)&&)'&/%(&% 5F& -%%.& &'& F(00(? /<-'%( 9)%.&')&5; <& :.&/& %.& ''-)& ' 55(%) F(00(? / <-'%( 9 %.& 5 %(2& /=.('..&.) &%.&'/(5(1'%= -1(&&<& %('&<1&&%-/&% )'&/%(5F& -%%.& &'& %.& 5 %(2&()<)& 5&/&)-)0('( % ' 55(%5-/&/9%.& &'& (%&/5) ,&'%( "= -1 %<&5& -%

.&1&/&%/(1 -/%).2&.&1/ 5%.&&2(&'& /&' /%.%%.& &'&-&/,&'%( "=) %%%/'%& / 0/ 2& %.& ')& = -1 11 -&/ ,&'%( + "9 ) %.& 62('%(56,-.(/00&11%.<&&<-'%&( /&/% =/ ?-11; ' (&.(5 '' /(?% 1&/&' -)&1 /%.&00&11%9%./&%)% F(11 =&/& .&1 -%9 =.('. () &2(&% / 5 %.& &0 )(%( %.& 00&11%,-.(/":

2(&/":

+ =&2&/9%.&)( %./&%))()' %&&<;1&/&' -)&1 /%.&00&11% %.& )%/&?%. %.&)%%&5&%) ,-.(/":

2(&/":

+9 /& /%.&0-/0 )&%.%(')&%.&5%%&/=)/&0 /%&% %.& 0 1('&9%.&%.&;= -1F(11.(5,-.(/ .&/& /&9%.&%./&%=)

%=(%.(%&%( /5 %(2&% ' 55(%%.&5-/&/ / %.&/=()& ) % ()0 )& )% 0-%,-.(/(?&/ <&(?5-/&/& .& 5 %(2& /%.&<-'%( ,-.(/00&11%=) %=(%.%.& (%&%( % ' 55(%.()5-/&/ %=)('% 1;% 0/&2&%.() 5//(?&%.%=)(G& / +<&(?) 1&5(D&

.&1&/&%/(1 -/%).2&%F&0 ))(<1&2(&= 5&/&1;<&'-)& %.&/2(&=5;<&%F&= -1 %<&?/ - % (%&/&/&=(%.%.&'I-(%%1 %.&''-)& /&)0 &%) /%.& &'&-&/,&'%( " ) /)%.& &'&-&/)&'%( +"()' '&/&9 (%5;1) <& %('&%.% %.&&G%%&%&/F(00(?( &

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

1) .&1 -%%./&%)%.%(%.&;( %)(?%. )& '-5&%)9 ,-.(/= -1<&F(11&9-0 =.('.9%.&;11)(?&%. )& '-5&%)

-&/0/&))-/&( /&/% )2&%.&1(& ,-.(/ .&/&%&/9%.&;

)F& %.&5 % 1&2& %.% %.&; = -1 )& ,-.(/ % %.&(/ 2(11?& .&/&%&/9%.&; 11 '5& <'F % %.&(/ . -)& % 2(11?& . ( %.& )5& ; % < -% 059 .& /&'&(2& %&1&0. &'11/ 5%.&0 1('&9=.('.'11&.(5%(2(1 )0(%19 !%&.< .& ' 501(% 1 ?=(%. >&&/ =&% % (2(1

)0(%19 !%&.< =.&/& ,-.(/ =) - 0/&)&% =(%. %.& 0 1('& .& 0 1('& ? % ,-.(/ 5&('

1&?11; &G5(& % (2(1

)0(%19 !%&.< %.&/&%&/9 %.&; 1 ?=(%. 0 1('& ,-.(/=&%% 0 1('&,%%( 9(%;!%&.<=.&/&0 1('&? %.() )(?%-/&))=&11))(?%-/&) >&&/ '-5&% .& 2&/,-.(/% %.&5 %()I-(%&&2(&%%.%,-.(/=)/&1&)&/ 5'-)% ; ,-.(/.(5)&1)%%&%.%.&=)%) 5&01'&&/2(11?&

&&? + +%< -% 05 %.&'(/'-5)%'&)9%.&(?/&(&%) /%.& &'&-&/ ,&'%( ".2&/(?.%1;<&&.&1% <& %5& -%?()% %.&/&)0 &%)),-.(/.<&&/&1&)&/ 5'-)% ; %.& ''-)& .&%./&%).&1 -%=&/&&(%.&/% 0/&2&%%.&5//(?& ,-.(/ /% &%&/(% ' 50/ 5()& .&/&=) (%&%( /%.%5%%&/&2& 5 %(2& /%.&''-)&% 00/&%1; ' 55(%%.&5-/&/ /) ()0 )& ,-.(/)% <&0-%(?&/ <&(?5-/&/& .&/&() %.(? /&' /% . 1%.& &'& -&/,&'%( "<&(?' 55(%%&

.&/&() 5&/(%(%.&00&1))/&?/)%.&'I-(%%1 %.&/&)0 &%)(%.&%= 00&1) /%.& &'&-&/,&'%(

" %.& 00&1) /& '' /(?1; ()5())& =&2&/9 %.(?)%%&.&/&().11<&' )%/-&)&G0/&))( 0(( (%.&0&(?00&1(1&<;%.&' 2('%)9=.('..2&<&&(1&<; %.&5?()%%.&(/' 2('%( )%.&)&%&'&)%.&1&/& -/% = -1 ' )(&/ %.& )5& %.& <)() &2(&'& 5%&/(1 /&' / , , , #

+ 7

, 5 > #