High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/173/2017dismissed

Mohan Lal Ravat v. State Of Punjab

2020-01-22Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu16 pages

! " #$%&'$!(

" )"*+"(

! "

+ $

,- $

! " -(

! "# $%&' () %*$ +,!,%&'

('$ ( (#/#("

(011

/ 012

$ (#/" 4

(

5$ (#/" 4

6 6("'/" 4

5 +7/""+ !

! " # $ %

! '

( )

* + ,

- .)( / *+, - -

!!!!!34

(

*+, -

* 5 6 %

!!!!!34

)

*+, -

7 !.

8 9 8 - * $

'! , :

2#4 "4$$4'7(! ;

9 $ % 8

;

%, 2#4 !<-4'"&

= 2 4

* 5 > ,

= 2 * 5 ?

< %

: % 2

6 %

5 %

2 $ -$, $ % 9

(! - :

= 2 * 5 9 ?

;

2 @

& (!!

090 -$,

* 5 9

()!

090 -$,

- & !! - :

-$, 2 $

9 ?

-$, 2 $

6 %

')!

090 -$,

'!! (! : &7

&7 - &7- &7A

& (!!

090 -$,

: 4 ( ;$(" $!

7( $

7 4 ""

" 4( :* "(" 4

4 ( "

4" 7 7( (

( 4 : 7 4 (4" " 4"/ (4" (!

54 8 " 4

(# !

$* # " 4 ( (" 4 #( 9 " 4

(# !

4 ( 4 & " " 4

( " #

# "#$"4 "*4

* 1 & < 5! (# ( (" 8 2

7 " <4# ( ,4 (4 / "( 5 # 7( < -$( (# "

(4( 7 (# ( (4 !

$ "

(# 44'(# 4 !(# #((

6 99 4$ $ =7 5 ( 4 7' 5 # (# 7(

4 "( 4 5 7/ "( (" 4 5 7 " < $($/ 4' !(# #(( 62+0 4$ !(" 4 : 4' "( (" 4' 5 "(4" < -$( (# ' 74 4' 5 > (" $ " ""

4 5 "(4 " ( $ &' $ : ((# # 7( "( "

((# " ( $ , - $ 5 ( "

4" ($ 5 (" !

44 " $* &' $ " , - $ * #"(# ( "(#( " 4

(# 5 (" !

44 " " (4( 7 $ ( ;(4(# !4 ( 4 ( ( ( :( 4 " 4

4 7 > (" ! 4 "

4" :* " # (# # 4 4 "

( 4

#?"

(4 #( 44 " ("

* 4 ! 4 "

4" ( 4

#?"

(4 : / 7 4' = 7 ((# "(

4' 7 ((# 4 "

4' : ((# "( "(4 " ( $ + $ :

((# 4 "

4' "(4 " ( $

7 : 7 " ( $ )"* +"( 4*(# 4'4'

( !4' " " ( $ -( % -( 5 (" #"(# ( "(#( " 4

(# $ 5 (" 44 "

!* " (4( 7 $ ( ;(4(# !4 ( ( ( ( 4' :( 4 " 4

4' 7 > (" ! 4 "

4" :* " # (# ! 4" ( 4

#?"

#(44 "# 4 $$ 4 !4("

!* #?"

(4 : / 4 4"

"*/ "( 5 4" !

8 5 "(4 " ( ("(* 5 " 44 "

!* " (4( 7 $ ( ;(4(# !4 ( ( ( ( 4 " ( 4 " 4

4 7 > (" ! "' :* "

("4 ( ($ 5 4 "" 4 $$

&' $ @;+ : $$

44 " , - $ 7 @;5 (# 4

4/ 8 !# 7

" *(# !4'

4 : !# 7 " 7( (4 (

!4' 4

: ( 7 $ " # 7 ""

$ 4 : 7 " "

44'" : !# 7 4 (" * ' : / "

7 $

#$ 4 $ 4 !# " 4 " $ ( $ 4 : / 4 !# 7 7(#" 7(

(# 4 08

'# * ' 7 4 "

$ 4 !# 5 $'" !# : 7 $ 4 7 !

' 5 " A $

2 * ' # 7( $ 4 " 4 7 ' ( ( : / "

(# 4

44 " , - $/ ( $ 7 4 " 7(4 7 7" ( !4'

4 " ( (4 : ( $ 7 (" !* 44 "

,7 - $ 7( ( !

"* : / " 7 $ 4

#$ $ 4 "

( $ " 4 " $ ( 7 $ 4 (# $ ( $ (4 $((# ( $ 7 7(#" < 4$ ! 81 '# < 7 " ( 4 : / (# 4"(# 7 4 $" * 7 ' ( ( : / ( "

4" ($

44 "

!* #"(# ( "(#( " 4

(# 5 ("

44 " * " (4( 7 $ ( ;(4(# !4 ( ( ( ( 4' :( 4 " 4

4' 7 > (" ! 4 "

4" "

* " # (# # 4 4 "

4" ( 4

#?"

(4 #( 44 "

" ! 4" ( 4

4 "" 4 $

44 " + $ @; : 4 $

44 "

7 4 "" (" @; $

44 " )"* +"( ( @;, $

-( 7 4 "" (" @;= : / "(4(

/ (4 * 4 "

4" 4

44 " )"* +"( 7 4*(# ( $ ( 4'4' 7(4 7 ( !4' =( $ 7 ( !4' 4

(4 5 " 7 $ 4 #$

$ 4 "

( $ " 4 " $ ( 7 $ 4 $((# ( $ 7 7(#" < 7

" 1 '# < 7 " ( !

' 4 (# $ ( (4 4 ( : / " 4 7( ( !(# ($( B5 B

(;" ( !(# ($( B-B 4 :

' ( ( 4

( $ # 7( 4'4' " $ : / "(4(

/ 7(

(4( "" !# *(# ( 4' " $ 7 44'"

(4 !#

$(4 4 4 8 '# 7 4 " " 09 (4 !# *(# " $(4 4 !# ( 4'

7 " : 09 !# 4 (" * ' 5 $'" !#

$ 09 5 7(

(4( $(;" * '

4 !# 7( " " " 7 $ 4 #$ $

4 !# " 4 " $ ( $ 4 (# $ ( (4 " ( (4

4 : / $'" 2 $ 4 $ 09 " 09 : / 7(#" 4 !# "

$ 4 !# 08

'# * ' (4 "(# (4 !# 7 4 " " 4 " $ ( 09 !

' 4 : / " 4 7( ( !(# ($( B5 "

(;"( 44!(#($( B-B@( 4 * 7 ' ( (

$(4 4 7 ' ( ( (" $$ @; 5 " > < 7 (4 ( A< 7 #(" 5 "

4" ( 4 * # 7( 7(/ 44 "/ A $

2 " $ 4($ !

<4 ( - $ 5=/ (4 ( ((( 9/ "( <4 ( - $ (4" 4 * "

" (4 $ : / <4 ( - $

(;" ( !(# ($( B-B 4 "

$ 4( : / 4 * 7 " (" 7( 5 (4 ( ((( 9/ "( 5 4 "" $

7( 5 !(" ( 4 *

5/ (4 ( ((( 9/ "(

4(# $ (

<> #(

(

( * 5 "

4" 4 * (

" 5 "/ 6 </ "( : / " (" ( 4 * 7( 5

(4 ( ((( 9/ "( : 2

!(" ( 4 * $

5 (4 ( ((( 9 "(

4(# $ (

<> #(

(

( * 5 "

4" 4 * " 44 " (

" 6 </ "( 5 $ " (4( @;AA !

#( <

#(/ $

( $

#$ 7 "7 $ ( $ 4 "

$ 44 " )"* "

( $

#$ 7 "7 $ ( $ 4 "

$ 44 " , - $ <

#(/ $ 4

#$ 7 "7 $ 4 !#

* '/ ( 8 !# : 4 * 7 #( " (

#( 7( ($( B 5B : / "(4(

#(/ " (" ( 4 * 7( ((4 ,?(/ "( ;4 7 $

( $ " 8 $

* ' "7 !* ($ < ( 4 ;$(( / " " "(" ' 7 7 4 " 4' 7 ( $

44 "

($( 7 ( * 7( #" 4 :* ("

( ("" 7( !

"* 7 "*

( ( (4 4"(# :* " "

4" 4

44 " ( 4 !" 7 4 "

$ 4' " 4 ( (

: 7(#/ 4 "

(#$(7"*7((((#( !# 2 & + ( (# " ( ("4 !* ((#

("( @;& C < (

("(/ ( 7 " 7 " '

( (4 ( ((( 9/ "( 9 2

( - $ <4 " (" 4 * 4 "

$ : 4' "

4 9 2

/ (

$' (4 :' 7"/ 8 !#

$ 4

* ' 7(#(# 88

'# 4/ 4

( $ 7(#(# 1 '# " 4 "

7(#(# 81 '#/

$ 4

* ' 7(#(# #$ 4/ 0 $ 4

( $

#$ 4 = 9 2

4 * # 7( 44 "

7 ""

< 5! (#

( * <

5! (# #( " (" 4 * 7( ($ ( ' ( #

" 4 "(( 9 2

= "(4(

< 5! (#/ ""

4 * # 7( A $ 2 ( #

" 4 "(( ($ 2

< 5! (# #( " (" 7( ($ 7 $ 4

( $ " 8 $ 4

* ' # 7( $ 4(/

$ 2 ( #

" 4 "(( " $((# 4 * 7 " (" 7( "(4( $' 2

1 =

' 7 $ 4

#$ 4/ 8 4

* '

#$ 4 7( ($( B5 B/ B-B " B-B/ 0 (

$ 4(/ 0 4 (

$ 2/ 44'" " !*

#( " ""

(# 7( "(4(

4' ( " !*

(4 $$((

(4/ "(/

" ( 4 * 7( $(4 @;$(/ -/

((#( 5

(# " (" 4 * # 7(

$ , 2 7( $(4 @;$(/ -

< ( 4 ;$(( / " " (#( 4 *

2 "

4 (

A $,

27" ("7(($ & 5

(# " ( ("4 !* ((#

("( @;&C 44 "(# ($/

( " ("

7( ($ 4 * ( #

" 4 "(( '(# ( $ ' < 7 ""

($ " ( $ 7( $(4 @;$(/ - = $ "/ "(4(

( (#/

4' $

(4 $$(( / "( " " (" 4 *7($(4@;$(/- &0 < : ' " " " 9

7 " (4 ( ((( 9/ "( = "*/ 7 #(

((#(

4 &8 < -$( (# " &9 < -( - $ "

" $

& < 5! (# " $ ( 7(4 44 " 7 ""/ 4 " (# 4"(# 7 $" (44 "47(7 &1 $( - $ "* ( (" "

4(" (4 $# $ <= < 5! (# 9 2

( $ !( 5 4" <= 5! (# 7 "* :4 $$

44 "&'$74 ""

( ( 4 5 " 4 ("4 ( ($ : $$ ( @;+ : / 44 " , - $ # ( 4 4*

4 5( $ @;5 7 4 "" !* ($ : / 4 7 4("

( 4 "

$ (

4 "( !* &' $/ ( (4 !# 7 4 " ( 7(4 * ' 7 4 " " $

#$ 4 7 "7 !* <= : $ 7 " 7( !(# ($( B5 B " $((# * '

4 !# 4$ ! 08

'# ( 4 !# : $ 7 " 7( !(# ($( B5 B !* <= 5 ( !(# ($( B-B : / 4

44 " , - $ 7 4("

= 4'

* 7 4 "

$ 7(4 ( $ 7 4 " :7 $

#$47"7"$((# ( $4$ !

81 '# : 4 "

$(( 7 4 $"

+ $ /

/ )"* / -( 7 4 "" :* " 4 ("4 ( ($ :( 4 $$ 7 @; @;= : / $ 4'/ 09 (4 !#

* ' 7 4 "

7(4 7 $

* ' 7 "7 <

0 $ 7 ' " $((# * ' ( 4 !# 4$ !

'# $ " !

' 4 7 " : 4 "

$(( 7 4 $" 44 " )"* 7 * 4" 5 7 4*(# 4'4' : ( $ 7 4 "

$ !# :7 $

#$ 4 7 "7 " $((# ( $ 4$ ! 1 '# : 4 "

$(( 7 4 $" < ( 4 ;$(( / " " 4" !

8 44 " &' $ 7 "(

4 7 44 " , - $ % "( 74 #(4$((#

44 "7( 4' 0 & 5 ( - $ " "

4" # !

(4( (4 !(# )1

9 44 "(# 4 "/ ("

(47 " 8 2

"9 2

!* <5! (# 8 & 5 (# " ( @;& C/ @;& C /@;& C"@;& C 9 44 "(# 4 ( 4/ 4 7 "" : 4 7 "( !* &' $ " , - $ 7 # &' $ " , - $ 7 " !

( # (# ! 4" ( 4

#?"

(4 #( :* " ( 4 " ( 4 ! 4("

!* #?"

(4&1 $(- $ "*4" 5 " 44 " !

( # (# : 4 7 4" * ' 7 4 " 4 "

$(( 7 4 $"

: 4

, - $ 7 4("

=( $ 7 4 "

$ ( 4 "

$(( 7 4 $"

4( 8

, 4 7 4 $(" 7( ( " (( < 7 > (" ! 4 $(" 7( * > 4 7(4 7 $"

$ 44 " , - $ < 4/ 4 !" ( 4 "

$ 4/

4( 8

, 4 ( 4" ($(* 44 "

*(# 4' ("

( # (# : 4' 7 4" ( 4

&1 $( - $ "* * "

( ( ($ 4

& )"* 7

"' 5 7 4*(# 4'4' !# A $ !#/ ( $ 7 4 " 4 "

$(( 7 4 $"

A $

2 7 ("

4( 8

4 7 4 $(" 7( : 4 * 4 "

$ 4/ 4' " 4'4' !# " 4

44 " , - $ "

)"* 7 " (" ( $' : / ( 7 '

( * < * 7 " : $ 7 "7 : $ 7

4$(4 ;$(( 44 "(# $(4 @;$( / $ 7

" ! ( $ 7 4 * " : 4

4 ( ( 4 7 4 $(# $ =7 5 ( 7' < 7 (#" : 4' 7

7(# ( : * ' 7 !(# 4("

( 4 7 ( 4' :7 7 ( (

( $ : (# ( 4 7 ( 4' 7 ( 4 4(

(

* ' < 4 ! $" * 7 !((

4*(# * ' ( 4" 4' " 4

(# !

44 "

# "

7 ( < 4 * $$ / ( # 7 4 "" 2 * * ( ( $ 4 ""

" 4( $( (# ( # 7

" $' ($ ( ($

4 *

4 !" 1 < ( " 7 4 ( ( !("

9 7 4($ ( 7 4 4(

( !( (/ !4 7 4$ ! ( ( ( 7(( ( 4( ' 7"#

$ 7 (# ( 4 " 4' #

/ 7 7 4 4(

( ( ! "$(" 7( 4( (4 4

4 $(; " * 7 7

4 !" 4*(# ( 4 " 4': ( 4!*(474 4( 2 44 "(#*/ ( $( ( " $ "($(" + $ / # $ % &' $ "

!( :( !( !

" " * !

" 44" : (4 ( "(4" ' $ ( "*

"# $((#4($ "!*(

- ./ 01 - // (&2("34

&'(#C "

DC, & ! DC,