← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/208/2014dismissed

Ramesh Kumar v. Sunil @ Monu And ORS

2015-07-0712 pages

            



 !

!$%&%"'

( )*)* ,!&- ********11!22'

3&*

 -!0& ********!&1"'5!'

 (

6 7 *  ** 6 7 *  

 0!&!' ( 0*'5!0 2 "8

59"$ !

112%$' :11!22' * ;;;;;;

  

10!&!'

11!2 <!!'

10!#!00!5 11!22'  $",12%''

=%'& >/5=,!'

5 !5

?*?* @ 1&&!5 &*'%&-

55% %"'2 !&&%"'&

/5=!

1!$%2

"'%1

$A/% %'= 0!&1"'5!' &$$/&!5 !&&%"'& &!

"*@) 5 !5 @* *

0%&%'= "/  "*+ 5 !5 * *

!$ %"'& @B@

@BB

?

@)B 

"2%$!

  %"'

'/0* 0%!# #$ & $&!

0!2!9'

5!$%&%"'

11!2 0!

* *

$",12%'' ,!&- :"

-'!

, '

=0%$/2 /0%& =!5

8!0& 0:"

3%22=!

/,0 %& * "'!1

,!

  <%0 %'=-

.-/<0/ /&  '5

'/0

C-!0!

10!&!'

2"'=C% - "'& <2!& C'

D!&- 1 0"22%'=*

!

0!$"05!5 E* $-%250!'

%*!* C"

&"'& C"

5/=- !0&*

%& !25!0 5/=- !0 /> ,00%!5

8"/'=!0 &"'

-!'

5/=- !0 %*!* =!5 0"/'5

8!0& 8"/'=!& &"'

% !'5!0*

& /58%'=

$2&& "9!0',!'

$-""2 9%22=!*

0"/'5 ?( *,*

58 /&/2 ="'!

&$-""2* "C!9!0

C-!'

5%5 0! /0'

-",!

!9!'

# !0 $2"&%'= &$-""2

@( 1*,*

-!8 ,5!

&!0$-

</ 5%5 #%'5 '8 $2/!*

!

#/22 &/&1%$%"'

$$/&!5 &"'

.0%&-'

0!&%5!' & "C'

9%22=!

!' %$!5 C8:D%5'11!5 5/=- !0 %*!* 10"&!$/ 0%E*

%& 5/=- !0 ,8 D%'528 <!

0$!5 2!=2 $ %"'

,8 <!

D!'

=%'& #"0!&%5 $$/&!5* '

#"0!&%5 11!22'

$",12%''  ,!&-

%'% %228

$&!

@B@ @BB 0!=%& !0!5 "2%$!

  %"'

'/0 9%5!

 "*+ 5 !5 * *

"2%$!

&C/'= %' "

$ %"'* '

+*B*

,"9!5

>"%'

1! % %"'

"* "* ?@B 

10"9%5!

-!, 1"2%$!

10" !$ %"'

C-%$- $$!1 !5*

'

$",12%'$!

"05!0

-!8 D!1

10" !$ %"'

-",!

"2%$!

7%'!

"'%1 * '

*B*

0!$"05!5

/5%$%2 =%& 0 !

& 2&&

"'%1 *

-!

,!5%$"2!=228 !E,%'!5* &/112!,!' 08 F+ >!&-

0!&%5!'

9%22=!

/,0

%& * "'%1

0!$"05!5*

'

<&%& -!0!"#

?

 55!5* '

$",12%'$!

5%0!$ %"'

*)*

10"5/$!5 "/0 * %'$!

5!&%0!5 C% - 10!' &

&"

$/& "58 -'5!5 "9!0 -!, $"'&!A/!' 28 -!%0 10" !$ %"'

1! % %"'

5%&,%&&!5*

0!&- 0!$"05!5 C-!0!%'

22!=!5 D%5'11%'= 01!

0!&1"'5!' 

@ $$/&!5*

!'$!

@)B  55!5* '

@*)*

00!& !5*

!

,!5%$"

2!=228 !E,%'!5*

'

+*)*

"*@ ,

B*)*

"* .0%&-'

00!& !5* '

B**

$$/&!5 !!0> 00!& !5* !$!&&08 %'9!& %= %"'

$"'5/$ !5* &% !

12'

12$!

"$$/00!'$!

10!10!5*

$&!

10"1!0 8 &!'

"0!'&%$ $%!'$!

7<"0 "08*

# !0 $",12! %"'

%'9!& %= %"'

$-22'

!$ %"'& @B@

@BB

?

@)B  #%2!5 =%'& 0!&1"'5!' &$$/&!5 /< %9%&%"'2 =%& 0 !

'/0 &/<,% %'=

0!1"0

)@

"1%!& $-22'

!'9%&=!5 ) &/112%!5 $$/&!5* %'$!

"##!'$!& $",,% !5 $$/&!5 !E$2/&%9!28 0%<2!

!&&%"'&

-!0!#"0!

$&!

$",,% !5 !&&%"'& 2!0'!5 /<%9%&%"'2 =%& 0 !

9%5!

"05!0 5 !5 *?*

# !0 -!0%'= 2!0'!5 $"/'&!2 10 %!&

2!0'!5 0%2 9%5!

% & "05!0 5 !5

)* *

$-0=!&-!! !5 0!&1"'5!' &$$/&!5 !$ %"'& @B@

@BB

@)B

?



C-%$- -!8 12!5!5 =/%2 8 $2%,!5 0%2* &/11"0 % & $&!

!E,%'!5 ,'8  C% '!&&!& ',!28 F

F # -!0 $",12%'' ,!&-

F@ !!0  %

F

 0 %'=-

F+ >!&-

FB 0% ,

'&1!$ "0  ##%$!

"'!1

F) ><%0 %'=-  

"2%$!

7%'!

"'!1

F 0*&-C'%

!'%"0 !5%$2 ##%$!0 

"'!1

F?

0*3%D& !' 2 /0=!'

 "'!1

F  0*'>8 ./&-%D

F

 ./25!!1 %'=-

F

'&1!$ "0 .1 '

%'=-  **% 8

"-'

F @  >!&- 0# &,'

 ##%$!

"'!1

F

C'

  %0&

F 0*/&-1 /'%

 

"'!1

F 3%D& !-0C 

%9%2 /0=!"'

##%$!

"'!1

F )  2% ,

**50

"-'

F  "'& <2!

&-"D

**% 8

-5/0=0-

F ?

  <%0 %'=-

 '/0

F  0"> !9%

** % 8 "'%1

F

 05!!1

* 50

"'!1 F  '5!0 %'=-

 '$-0=!

 

"'!1 *

0!2%!5 /1"'

%'% %2 $",12%'

E*

1"2%$!

10"$!!5%'=& E*:@

'5"0&!,!'

 2% %'=- 0!=05%'= 0!$"05%'=  E*:

 E*:

5 !5

*B*



"'!1 E*

##%59% 5 !5 *)*

E*

112%$ %"'

,"9!5  0% , ,!5%$2 !E,%' %"'

E*

0!$"9!08 ,!,"

10$!2 $"' %'%'= /'5!0C!0 -'5!5 "9!0 5"$ "0 # !0 ,!5%$2 !E,%' %"'

1"2%$!

E*

112%$ %"'

,"9!5  0% , "&&%#%$ %"'

!& !' 2 /0=!"'

"9!0',!'

"&1% 2 E*

0!1"0 !' 2 /0=!"'

E*:

01 0"G',$-  "*B+ 5 !5

*)*

0!=05%'= -'5%'= "9!0 $/& "58 $",12%'$!

5%0!$ %"'

E*

 "*B@ 5 !5

+*B*

E*

&% !

12'

"$$/00!'$!

E*F @:

112%$ %"'

,"9!5  0% ,

 "'!1 0!$"05%'=

E*F

:

05!0 5 !5

*B*

1&&!5

/5%$%2 =%& 0 !

& 2&&

"'%1 E*F

:

E*F

:

5 !5

*B*

E*F

: E* "05!0 5 !5

*B*

1&&!5



"'!1 E*F

:

0!1"0 0!=05%'= 5! !0,%'%'= =!

<! C!!'



?

8!0& E*

<%0 - $!0 %#%$ !

!!'/ 5/=- !0 $",12%''

,!&- E*F B:

0!$"9!08 ,!,"

10$!2 $"' %'%'= /'5!0C!0 11!22' $$/&!5 -'5!5 "9!0 5"$ "0 1"2%$!

F :

$"'#!&&%"'2 &  !,!' &

.0%&-'

E*F :

E*F : 0!&1!$ %9!28

112%$ %"'

,"9!5 1"2%$!

!5%$2 ##%$!0 ,!5%$2 !E,%' %"'

11!22' $/&!5 E*F:

0"/=- &% !

12'

12$!

"$$/00!'$!

F:

7 $$/&!511!22'

E*F?:

E*F

+: * -!0!# !0 $$/&!5 @ @ 0!$"05!5 C-%$- -!8 5!'%!5 12!5!5 -!%0 #2&!

%,12%$ %"'*

'

-!%0 5!#!'$!

-!8 !E,%'!5 "'& <2!

D!&- F

 C'

F

'5!!1

&&%& '

##%$!

-%0,'

  !

"2%$!

",12%'

/ -"0% 8

F@

= %'=-

/1!0%' !'5!'

"2%$!

2C2

F

 -!'5!0 %'=-

",12%''

0'$-

 ##%$!

F+ 0!2%!5 /1"'

2"9!

2! !0& 22!=!528 C0% !'

0D 0D

 E*H

2! !0 C0% !'

'&1!$ "0 !'!02 "2%$!

"- D '=!

"- D /1!0%' !'5!'

"2%$!

"'%1 5 !5

@* * E*

 "*

@ 5 !5

@*+*

E*@

05!0 &/&1!'&%"'

 '5!0 %'=- 1&&!5 -%0,'

  !

"2%$!

",12%'

/ -"0% 8

08'

E*

$",12%'

C0% !'

0!, %'=- 3%22=!

/,5 

'=!

"- D

"- D E*+

0!$"05!5 1"2%$!

E*B

2! !0 "*? 5 !5

*

C0% !'

/1!0%' !'5!'

"2%$!



"- D '=!

"- D E*)*

# !0 $"'$2/&%"'

0%2 -!0%'= 2!0'!5  2!0'!5 5!#!'$!

$"/'&!2

0!&1"'5!' &$$/&!5 $A/% !5 9%5!

%,1/='!5 >/5=,!'

5 !5

?*?* @* ==0%!9!5 C% - &,!

$",12%'' ,!&- 10!#!00!5 10!&!'

112* F!

-9!

-!05 2!0'!5 $"/'&!2 11!22'  $",12%'' * 7!0'!5 $"/'&!2 $",12%''

0=/!5 #%'5%'=& 2!0'!5 0%2 0!

<&!5 &/0,%&!& $"'>!$ /0!&*

<!!'

C!22 <2!

10"9!

,%'"0 5 !

"$$/00!'$!*

-!0!#"0!

$"'&!'

%# '8

5/0!&& -0!

%,, !0%2 "0 #$ $"'&!'

!8!& 2C*

F

$ !="0%$228 5!1"&!5 0!1! !528 01!5

#"0$%<28*

!'$!

2!0'!5 0%2 !00!5 $A/% %'= -%,*

!02%!0

2"& % & !9%5!' %08 92/!

&""'

11!0!5 F

2!0'!5 0%2 5%5 110!$% !

#$ &%=' /0!& D!'

&",!

<2'D 11!0& 10! !E #%2%'= &",!

1! % %"'

"/0 *

0!,%'%'= $$/&!5 "&*

<! !5 $",,%&&%"'

$0%,!

-/& 2!0'!5 0%2 "/=- -9!

$"'9%$ !5 -!,* # !0 =%9%'= "/0 -"/=- #/2 $"'&%5!0 %"'

&/<,%&&%"'& ,5!

2!0'!5 $"/'&!2 $$/&!5 ="'!

-0"/=- , !0

C!

5"

#%'5 '8 ,!0% 11!2

) 0!&"'& #"22"C(

 5,% !528 #%2!5

10" !$ %"'

1! % %"'

$"/0 %*!* %&$*"* ?@B 

+*B*

C-!0!/1"'

-!8 10"9%5!5 1"2%$!

10" !$ %"'*

"'&!A/!' 28

<" - -!, C!'

10" !$ %"'

-",!

"'%1

B*B*

'

*B*

E* E*F

: 0!$"05!5 1"2%$!



"'%1 * F-!0!%'

$ !="0%$228 5!1"&!5 ="'!

C% - $$/&!5/'%2 * *

C% - "C'

#0!!

C%22 $"'&!'

,,/*

-!

2%9!5

,,/ C% - -%,

0!' !5 0"", D!'

$$/&!5/'%2 "'/*

 0"/'5

( 1*,*

B*B*

-!8 0!$-!5 10" !$ %"'

-",!

"'%1

$$",1'8%'= 1"2%$!

"##%$%2& 5%0!$ %"'

/1"'

-!%0 112%$ %"'

10"9%5%'= -!, 10" !$ %"'*

"C 2%9%'= C% - 10" !$ %"'

-",!

"'%1 -/&<'5 C%#!*

-!

C' & 2%9!

C%#!

$$/&!5/'%2*

-!

5"!& C'

C% - 10!' & 110!-!'5& 5'=!0 2%#!

#0", -!,*

-!

&-"/25 <!

&!'

10" !$ %"'

-",!*

'

&,!

58

,!5%$"

2!=228 !E,%'!5 1"2%$!

9%5!

7 E*F +: *



 %& 1!0 %'!'

,!' %"'

0**

%,!

,!5%$"

2!=228 !E,%' %"'

9%5!

7 E*F +:

5%&$2"&!5 =!

 8!0&*

'

*B*

% &!2#  0% ,

 0'$-

"- D

,"9!5 '

112%$ %"'

E* !5%$2 ##%$!0

"9!0',!'

"&1% 2

"'%1 "&&%#%$ %"'

!&

C-!0!/1"'

0*&-C'%

$"'5/$ !5 05%"2"=%$2 !E,%' %"'

5! !0,%'!

=!

 <!&%5!& 59%&%'= H8 9%5!

59%$!

E*:

!

-!'

$"'5/$ !5 "&&%#%$ %"'

!& =9!

0!1"0 E* C-!0!%'

"1%'!5 =!

<! C!!'



?

8!0&*

-/&

% %& !9%5!'

0!$"05 ,%'"0 5 !

22!=!5 %'$%5!'

%*!* C-!'

>"%'!5 $",1'8 * *

0*3%D&

!' 2 /0=!"'

"9!0',!'

"&1% 2

"'!1 F?

0!$!%1 112%$ %"'

E*

!E,%'!5 5! !0,%'%'= =!* !

&$!0 %'!5 =!

<! C!!'

) 8!0& 9%5!

0!1"0 E*:

%,!

% %& C!22 &! 2!5 -!0!

%& 2C8&

90% %"'

8!0& =!

!% -!0 &%5!

0!1"0 & =%9!'

<&%& "&&%#%$ %"'

!& <!'!#% &/$- 90% %"'

<!

2C8& =%9!'

$$/&!5*

& 1!0 0!1"0 E*

C-!'

0*&-C'% "1%'!5 =!

<! C!!'



?

-!0!#"0!

<!'!#% 90% %"'

8!0& =!

"1%'!5 0*3%D&

!' 2 /0=!"'

"9!0',!'

"&1% 2

"'!1 F?

<!

=%9!'

$$/&!5* "0!

&"

C-%2!

11!0%'= F

$&!

0%2 5%&$2"&!5 =!

?

8!0&  *)*

C-!0!& "$$/00!'$!

""D 12$!

* *

@ 7!0'!5 $"/'&!2 11!22' $",12%''

& 0"'=28 0!2%!5 /1"'

<%0 - $!0 %#%$ !

E* B: &-"C ,%'"0 5 !

%'$%5!' * '

&%5 $!0 %#%$ !

5 !

<%0 - "'!

!!'/ %& ,!' %"'!5 B*

??@*

"C!9!0

% %& '!!52!&& ,!' %"'

-!0!

%'& '

$&!

%& !!'/ 0 -!0 -'

%& &",!

" -!0 ',!*

2!5 !9%5!'$!

10"9!

D'"C'

!!'/ "0 2%& ',!

!!0'/* 11!22' $",12%''

,!&-

# -!0

?

""

C-%2!

11!0%'= F 5%5 / !0 !9!'

&%'=2!

C"05 5/=- !0 $22!5:D'"C'

!!'/*

9!'

F

5%5 10"9!

<%0 - $!0 %#%$ !

E*F B: <!2"'=!5 "0 D'"C'

!!'/* !'$!

,%&!0<28 #%2!5 10"9!

0!$"05 2!0'!5 0%2 <%0 - $!0 %#%$ !

E* B: "'!

!2&!*

9!'

5%5 !E,%'!

'8 C% '!&&!& C-"

0!$"05!5 &%5 5 !

<%0 - !=%& 00

%0 - ! -

"'!1 *

!'$!

#0", '8 '=2!

$''"

<!

-!25 <!

,%'"0 5 !

%'$%5!' * "'&!A/!' 28

#%'5%'=& 2!0'!5 0%2 0! %'= ,>"0 5 !

%'$%5!'

0!

-!0!<8 /1-!25*

 & 1!0 $&!

$$/&!50!&1"'5!'

D%5'11!5:<5/$ !5 * *

0!1! !528 01!5 D%'= &!9!02 12$!&*

'

7 E*F +:

0*/&-1 /'% F 5%5 #%'5 '8 !E !0'2 %' !0'2 ,0D %'>/08 1!0&"'

10"&!$/ 0%E*

!0 9=%'

#"/'5 -9!

<!!'

5,% %'= C"

#%'=!0& !&%28

C-%$- ,!'& -<% /228 &!E/2 %' !0$"/0&!*

&!,!'

&,12!

D!'

#0", /'5!0C!0 &!'

"0!'&%$ $%!'$!

7<"0 "08 5! !$ %"'

-/,'

&!,!'

</ &,!

5"!& -!21 '8 C8

<!$/&!

&!,!'

<2""5 &,12!& D!'

"0 &!'

1/01"&!

 !& *

'

<&!'$!

'8 &/$- !&

% $''"

<!

&%5 -/,'

&!,!'

#"/'5 /'5!0=0,!'

"'28* '

E*

$ !="0%$228 5!1"&!5



 ="'!

C% - $$/&!5 C% - "C'

#0!!

C%22 $"'&!' *

-!

C' & 2%9!

C% - -%, C%#!*

-!8 2%9!5

,,/

0!' !5 $$",,"5 %"'*

F

$"/25 #$!

!& $0"&&!E,%' %"'

C-%$- $& &

&!0%"/& 5"/< & "08*

'

$0"&&!E,%' %"'

5,% !5 $$/&!5/'%2 D!'

," "0$8$2!

#0",

2% 2!

5%& '$!

#0", &$-""2*

-!0!

0"/'5  & /5!' & !E 0 $2&& C-%$-  !'5!5* -"&!

& /5!' & $,!

"/ #0", &$-""2 C% - -!0*

-!

5%5 $08 -!21

C-!'

$$/&!5

#"0$!5 &% ," "0$8$2!

<!$/&!

-0! !'!5 C% -

D'%#!* $-%250!'

2% 2!

-!5

C-!'

-0! !'!5 C% -

D'%#!*

<"9!

& "08 1/ #"0 - %&

<2 '

2%!

<!$/&!

% %& 1"&&%<2!

,'

D%5'1

1!0&"'

D!

-%, ," "0$8$2!

&%'=2!-'5!528 &",!

-0! *

 1!0&"'

$'

"'28 <!

D%5'11!5 ,D%'= -%,

&'5C%$- <! C!!'

C"

1!0&"'&

," "0$8$2!*

!'$!

<"9!

& "08 1/ #"0 - %& $",12! !28 #2&!*

+ 0"&!$/ 0%E #/0 -!0 5!1"&!5 0!&1"'5!'  $$/&!5 10D!5 ," "0$8$2!

-"/&!

9%22=!

%&'

#0", -!0!

-!8 <"05!5

</& !2-%* -!0!

" -!0 1&&!'=!0& </&*

-!

5%5 $08 -!21

'"0 5%&$2"&!

'8 1&&!'=!0* 0", !2-%

-!8 ="'!

,,/ </&*

'8 </&!& 10D!5

</& & "1& #0", !2-%

,,/

</ 5%5 $08 -!21*

!&1"'5!' $$/&!5 /&!5 "/ 0"", /&!5 C"0D 2&"*

'

<&!'$!

5%&$2"&!5 <5/$ %"'

-!%0 2'52"05 "0 '8 " -!0 '!%=-<"/0*

-!%0 2'52"05 /&2%,*

F-!'

$$/&!5/'%2 /&!5 "/

-!'

"'!

"0 C"

"$$&%"'& 2D!5 C% - 2'52"05*

-!

/&!5 10!10!

,!2&

,,/*

-!8 $,!

-'5%=0- ,"0'%'= -!8 & 8!5 -!0!

#0",

@*)*

+*)*

-!8 /&!5 %=-

C-!'

-!8 & 8!5

-'5%=0-*

-!

$$/&!5/'%2 11!0!5 "'6<2!

/& %$!

%=- "'6<2!

/& %$!

!'A/%0!5 #$ #0", 1!0&"'228* -!

9"2/' 0%28 &  !5 &%'$!

10!' & "25 10!' & C"/25 D%22

&"

,5!

0!A/!& 1"2%$!

10" !$ %"'* -!

&  !5 $$/&!5/'%2 & 8!5 1"2%$!

2%'!

"'!1

/1 "

/28



-!8 -9!

1"2%$!

10" !$ %"'

-!0!

1"2%$!

"##%$%2& C% - -!,*

-!

$ !="0%$228 5,% !5 5%5 5%&$2"&!

<5/$ %"'

1"2%$!

"##%$%2&*

-!

,"9!5 '

112%$ %"'

1"2%$!

10" !$ %"'

"'6<2!

%=- "/0 *

-!8 & 8!5 <"/ "'!

,"' -&

1"2%$!

2%'!* 0", <"9!

5!1"&% %"'

% %& !9%5!'

,12!

"11"0 /'% %!& '00 !

C"!#/2 & "08 "'6<2!

/& %$!

1"2%$!

1&&!'=!0& </& #0", %&'

!2-% -!'

#0", !2-%

,,/*

9!'

,12!

"11"0 /'% %!& '00 !

22!=!5

<5/$ %"'

-!%0 2'52"05

,,/*

!0 5"%'= &"

0!A/%0!& 50C '

59!0&!

%'#!0!'$!

=%'&

$"'&!' %'= 10 8 !' %0!

!1%&"5!

" -!0C%&!

C"/25 -9!

5!#%'% !28 0%!5 =!

-!0&!2# #0!!5 #0", 22!=!5 %22!=2 $/& "58 "'/*

9!'

" -!0C%&!

2"'= & 8 <"/ ,"' -&

,,/ % &!2# &1!D& 9"2/,!& <"/ $"'&!'

2%9%'= &!E/2 %' !0$"/0&!

C% - "'/*

,%&!0<28 #%2!5 10"9!

0"2!

'8 " -!0 $"$$/&!5

?

*

-!0!

22!=!5 $"'#!&&%"'2 &  !,!' & 0!

%'5,%&&%<2!

!9%5!'$!

<!%'= =%9!'

1"2%$!

$/& "58*

B "

" -!0 1"%'

0%&!5 /&*

) F!

-9!

="'!

-0"/=- >/5=,!'

2!0'!5 0%2 #"/'5 %22!=2% 8 "0 1!09!0&% 8 &,!*

'

9%!C 5%&$/&&%"'

<"9!

11!2 #%2& %& -!0!<8 5%&,%&&!5*





%'$!

11!2 <!!'

5%&,%&&!5 ,!0% &

A/!& %"'

0!=05%'= 5!28 #%2%'= 11!2 112%$ %"'

0!=05%'= 1!0,%&&%"'

12$!

0!$"05 55% %"'2 !9%5!'$!

0!

"'28 $5!,%$

-!'$!

&,!

0!

5%&,%&&!5*

**







 )*)* '%2