High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2375/2010disposed of

Jagtar Singh @ Tari v. State Of Punjab

2016-03-09Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik22 pages

! "

$% %

(

% (

(

)

# *

)*# )+, -.

*% /01.

/ 022 33333 - / * 01 2

/ 32 04 " 0 5&* 67 6899

'$5 .

)5 .''

''9 .-.7 " ( :5 &*1 " &#:05&* " 5&* 67 6899 -+!.; --)9 .-.7 " 3&0 5&* 6 899 .!

9 .-.7

" 35 &*1 " < 5&* 6 899 .')9 .-.7 " 3#5&* 6 899 - .9 .-.7 "

5&* 6 899 - -9 .-.7 " 8 053:5 ===== / 022%/% > 1 % ** * ? 5 9** -.1* &** * * !)+9 > 86 @>8@7 !)+98>8 *-.

.-.5* 1 * >$0* -.5...A9 * * * !)+9 >8 > 0 5 > B *

C * * * !)+98>85* 1 * > 0 0

5...A9 > 0 > *

& *1 * * 0 * !

)8 1& ** # 5

5 , :, 5 , : 35# , # 5 1 " 5, : " 5 " , , 8 5 # ( > 1*D *

& 0 ** , < 1 * * **& <5: 3 5 # 5:& 3 * 5 *

* * * # E .- .-

..!5> # 1 ** # * #1 *& ** 5 5"# 5

**: -71 " * 9.)99!'

! 1 D 0 # > * *0 C * 5> # DFB * 51 5C> !.- .-

..! *1 * !)+95!)+9 !)+98>8 -.4.. "

5 ** " C 1**0 * > # * 1 1 *5 ** * # *0 10 * ? .

..!5> # 5 1 (8 " < **1& & * / 0*

5 0*& * * > * *0 1* " 1#0 * #1 * #5,

5FB9 * & 8 51 *0 --4.. "

5 ** " 51 ? ** * * # * (: : FB9 *

**"# 1 & * ** 1 0 1 ** 1

0 1 81* 0> #

** 1*0 * ? * *5-..* > * *0 -5...A96-*7 $..#> * *0 $..A9* 6

$*7 & 1*& # &*&0 FB *&* *0 1* *&0 FB ? 0 FB G # FB GA- 1 *& *

* *0 1 *51 @ @0> #

*FB - FB (A- **&01 ** 1 C * **"# 5- .# > * *0 $..A96 %.5...A971 *&

01 *6FB 7 1 @ @ 1# * & FB 8 C * ** 5-.%# > * *0 $..A96 $ 5...A971 *&

1 *51 @ @

& # & FB 3 C * ** 5+#> * *0 -5...A9* 6 +5...A971 *&

1 *6FB $751 @ @75 # * & FB F ** "# 5 1 ** 10> # .) .-

..! * 1 ( * 1 3 5 * FB

1 * *&#> * *0 * $..A96 -5.

5...A971 *

1 *6FB .751 @ @ # * &*&0 FB HHA- FB 1 ** 5"# 1 ? 5 0* FB IIA)5IIA- FB IIA%.+ .-

..!*&0 -..

# > * *0 $..A96 $.5...A97 1*&0**

- !#> * *0 $..A9* 6 %'5...A971*&0 **"#

!.#> * *0 $..A9* 6

.5...A971*&0**

01# &*&0 FB IIA+5 FB IIA-! FB IIA'* & * 3 * 5**: - * 01 & #* *0

1 ** > * 1 * > # 5* * * * **# * 5 5, 5( 3 &

6 * **:9>>7 ** 5 , 5 , 5# , 5 1 , : 5" , 5 # > 6 * ** :9>>>7 ? 5 0 * *& .% .-

..!.

..!5 #> * *0 5 ' C&05> 0 * *&#* *0 * &*:9>> **1 > 0 # * *& **1 & ** 1*D5 *D 8 (1&5 9** *1 * FB *& --5...A9 --# -5...A9 )# $..A96 !5...A97

1 *51 @ @ # * & FB ?

**&01FB 9** &5 *1 * FB *&$.#* *0 -5...A9 )#* *0 $..A9

( 6 $!5...A97

1 *51 @ @ # * & FB ,, **&01FB << 9**( 35 *1

* FB I*& .#* *0 $..A96 -.5...A97

1 *51 @ @ # * & FB J **&01FB G 9** # * 5 * 1 * FB >*& .#* *0 -5...A96 .5...A97

1 *51 @ @ # * & FB **&01FB < 9** , 5 * 1 * FB *&$.#* *0 $..A96 $5...A97

1 *51 @ @ # * & FB H **&01FB 9** 5 * 1 * FB FF*& .$#* *0 $..A96 -5.

5$..A97%

1 *51 @ @ # * & FB CC **&01FB ::

(* FB IIA-- .+ .-

..!5 *1 1 * *&- #> * *0 -5...A96 - 5...A97 !!#> * *0

$ $..A96

5...A97

1 * # * & FB IIA-

**&01FB IIA-

*&#> * *0 1 :& > 5 #551 5FB I J 1 * * *0 1* 8 & & 1 * *0 D 1 #

* * * *0 & 5 * ** * 9 **1 8 < * 9** * * * * 9** * 9** & * &* * * !)+9 >81 * *1 H ** *5>1# # *1 * 9**1 * 1 * * **1

& *D** 5> C * **

:& (

# * 5, 5 0 1* * * * !)+98 * 5 0 0*

C * ** & 5 01* * * * !)+9 !)+98>8 * 5 0 0 * # * & *5 ** * - 8 1 *5 1 5 *

* 1 ** * * * ** , 5" , ( 3 # * ** ** * > #

* 5 ** * > # 5 & *0 ** 0 > 0 # ** 5 , 5" , (

3 &0 *D0 8 * 5 * & 9**

* ** &B )31 * 31 & 9**3/ 8 5B 0** E3/ 1 5B 0 ** E 3/! B 0**, E3/$: 5B 0 **# * E3/' 3/), B 0**,

* & * *5 8 * .!

.-. *

.-. 9**5 > & * * * *

& * 0 * 9** E 9**

& * &* * * !)+9 >81 * !)+98>8 * !)+9 149

! "

$% & * 51 * 1 * 0 B -.05 1 *& * !)+98>8 B '05 1 51

* * !)+9 >8 & * * * !)+98>8 H * * !)+9 >8 5 9*** * &* * * 5 ** 5

* 8 * C * 9 5 * & B** &*** & 5 * * !)+9 >81 ) 9** F& 8 053:5 5 * 0 1 0 * "#

:& ( # * 5,

5 *

* *

C 9** 9 5& * * !)+9 >81 5 , 5 1 5, # 51 & *D0 8 8 * !)+9 >8

51 * 8 ? 9**5* * !)+9

>8 0 &

* * #* *0

$.*1*& ** & *&0 FB E **"# 5#* *0

%.5...A91*&&*&0 FB 8E ** 5#* *0 $ 5...A9 1*&&*&0 FB 3E ** 5 # * *0 +5...A9 1 *&&*&0 FB FE ** , 5#* *0 $5...A91*&& *&0 FB H .5...A9 6# * *071*&&*&0 FB IIA %E **# * 5 .5...A96# * *07 1 *& & *&0 FB E ** 5 -$5...A9 6# * *07 1 *& & *&0 FB ?E **( 5 -.5...A96# * *071*&&*&0 FB J

5 ***& #> * *0 & & #5 15 1 # # > * *0 *&0* > # * *0 ** *1 *&* 1 0 &*&> #* *0 & & # & *# * 5* & * 0 &0 5 1 5 *

' 9**D 5 *5* * !)+9 >81 *5 1 0 * 9** & * 9 1 9** 0 *0 8 *10* 9**

1 * 0 & 81 * * 5 * * !)+9 >8

* 9** & C0 1 1** &0 * 9 * * !)+9 >85 *E* 0 * 1* *

** ** * *&* 1 0 *& * * *0 & & * 0* * * *0 / * 0 & 5* 1 * & * 9 *9** * 5 * * 9** &

* &* .! .)

.-.

* *-.

.-.50 5 5D "#

:& ( # * 5,

* 8 1 * * * && * * !)+9 >8 * !)+98>8 0 * * ** *1 1 1511 * & 9**51 & * &* * * !)+9 >8 !)+98>8 31 0 1* 9 5 10 35 &*5*

& 0 5*

6 & 7 # > * *0 $..A9 , :*9** , *D0 8 <#15 , * # > * *0 &

5 , 5

# 5, : $..A9# 1

& & > * *0 , 5 # , : &*D0 8 > *5 & * 1

& 1 ** & * # > * *0 00 * 5* 0 * *# #> * *0 ? *5 , :5 , 5

# , : & *D0 8 0 & *D1 & * 1 B*> #

8 &*1 0 * 10 *&*0 **5 * 1 0> # **:9>>>* 0 0 > # 5 0 1 *D%

5 &9*** *50& 5** , 5 , 5 # , 1*D 0* 01*D 1

& 0 * &

> * & # > * *0 $..A9

, :*9**1 * *&

*9** 105 #> * *0 ** # 1 & & * *0 > * #

> * *0 9** &

> *5 **1 #> * *0

01 *& #> * *0 1 &

0 & *& #> * *0 1 *&09* #> * *0 1 & 1*& #> * *0 # 1

& & > * *0

0 & *# > * *0 * 5 * * !)+9 >8 *0 8 * 00 >1 B0 * & 1 * * *0 # 5D * 0 # 1 & * 0 F& **D 1 1 0# 1 1 * * *0 " **& * * , 1 & 1 & * 51 & * **1 & # 1 * *0 1#> * *0 5 0*

( * &* * * !)+9 >8

> * 5 0 &* 5

! "

# $ %&%'

(%&)'$*+ "

*,% -%*,.%$/+0&/+0 ' )# --&'&+'1- *1 * * * ** * * > 2 *675 1 * 1 & * *#** 1

# *#5 * ( 0 9 > ** ? * 5++1 1 *& * !

8 10 D # 1 &

+.A9

* *0 1& 0 * (1 # 1 * *0 1* (* # 1 0 *1 1* 0 *

1 & * * * 1 * * # 1* & * 0 & * 1* > * 5*&0 $!5...A9#>

$ * *0 ** &

*1 * FB *&0

.$> #* *0 $..A91

-5.

5$..A9 *1 * FB FF 1 0 9** &

0 #* * * **5 0 &*& #> * *0 0& *1 0 # 5 B * ** 1 0* * #> * *0 > *- # > * *0 1 * &* ** 1 1 # 1 * *0 1#

* * & >10 * & 6/ 7 1 1 * * 1

* *&* *0 5 1 & 6/ 71& (8" < * 50 & 1 5 # * *

* 9** 0 1 1 *1 1 9* 1 5 *5 0* * *

8 ** > *51 > # 6/!7 (8 " </-75 1* * * * * 8 **

* ** 0 * 1

B 0 * & E FB I J& 0> *0 5# # K* *0 * * *0 *& > *0#5 1 * 1 * 1 # 1 *

* *0 * H ** *5* * *0 B &FB I FB J 1 * 1 * *& 9** ?*FB I FB J# * /#" > *0& * 1*& * 0 1

* *

K* *0 *&0 * *& **

* *0 1 * 1B > *0 5#51* 8 8 B * 01

*&0 F& & 1 * * *&* *0 1#

& 0 8 * *0 * 8 B 0 8 * 5 *0 8 -- 00

5 &* * 9** & 0* * C *&5 .!

.-. *-.

.-.D**

:& ( # * 5, * 8* * * !)+9 >8 !)+98>8 * * * * ** *1 1 (1&5 *0 8D & * & 81 * * 9**

C *&5 * &

5 , 5 5 * * 0# *0& *

* * *"5 # *05* 01

51 5# &1 *0 & * !

) 8 *85 * *1 1 5 * *0

3*; 5 5 * * 1 51 5 * * 0

0 #*# * * 5 1 *& 5 1 5 0 B0 6/ 0-225

/0"2.

$% % &