Gurpreet Singh @ Gopi v. State Of Punjab
!"#$ "%&'&#(
))) * + , ,-+ * + ,++
./0"123 !"
#$
%& !" ))) ++ 4
'
" ( & )" ! "*
(
&
( " ! "
" +,-.+-/0
&
!
1 1 &
" ! " "(( "
" 0-+
023#4 "5#6+++ -7/-+-//
" 0-+
023 #4 " ( % "
1 "
8* $$"(%"
(1".,"%!&#( ,"(!"(%"1!# &/#.#0'56.&'#(5"(!
&("
(1"$ 07!#$ 6 35"(!#$$&("
023#4 ' & /- ---)* 5( # 0-+#4 #( ( +- ---)* 9( ' 4 "
" " &
+ " ! -7/-+-//28--
"( *:
1
"
1
1 &"
"( *:
" "
& /+*/0&1&
!
"; # ( ; &
1
1 ; "
4( * :
1 !
( < $& 1! " (* = ( " ! 11 1 " 8,! !"#$0(9 2 ! 0.5&!,&(/:; <<= .&5&( 7 > > * *1 ? ( ;
;
?
(
;
1 "
-3/-+-//,8-- (
? (;""( & 1 *;
%! 1 "(
!
? (;
;
%! & "( *:
1 "
1
( " &(# ") @< "
=#
< ")A*/-> 1 " ( =9> :
="( )A*/>
( 5# =9)+>1
& "# ")@<
=A*/-> "
"" "
" # $"
=9>1"
"
&1 &A*0? ( ;
(
= >
! " (* 1;
" !
"
!
" BB 1; "
!
"!&((9: 1 1 & # " ;
@ 4 %!
< ( ( " &&# " 1
: 5
?
1; " !
"!&((9
1 &#;
@4 %!
* =9C>""" "1
( " " 1 1" 4&1
1 @4 " < -7/-+-// ? (; " ( "
1 ( &((1 !
! % & " (* /+*/0& * *1? ( ; 1 !
1 (< -3/-+-//,8-- ! " ()
1 & "
! (1
&"
$ &1( (
"& 1
1 ( ! " (* "( ;
"; "1 ! " ()
" " -2/-+-// ;
%! 1 ? (; " (? (;
-7/-+-// (
"(;
1 &! " (1&
"& !
:
! % & ? (;
1 1 "
" "" "1 $"
$ & 1"
&! " (1 ? (;
& * *1=! " (* >1( & ""
?
! % & 1 ;
! & "
" =9?>
-7/-+-//1(! & #
< "1 $( "< " 4 ! @
"
"
*((9( & ! " (*
1 &91 "(( < -./-+-// *((9( &! " (1"
" &? %""(
%% =A*+>
%
:=A*//> !
* (9(
9%# ? &
1
("
"
" " " !
";
"
4 1 &9
" &
";
1 1"" " &9
! " (* *(( 9( &
"& " $ 1
"
! "
$ 4 ( " 9( :
1
! " < -./-+-// #
< " "
"
""
( &( ( (
9* " " ( (& ""
1" < /-/-+-// "" *
1
>
"
((=9>1 < ///-+-// ) "" " ( =96>
"( "! 1 " 1 1" ! "
!
" BB 1 1; " !
"!& ((9<
1 &#;
@4%!
* =9<)/> ""!& 1 < /0/-+-// )"" 1 " 4 " =9'>1(! 41 $;(
)"" 1 11 !
9')/
" ( )"" 1 ;
( 1" ! " &
1
" BB 1 1; !
((=9>
1 &@4%!
'
"&1 1 @4 " < +,//+-// ! "1 & @4(
< "4 ( "9( &
"
1 ! @4 " 4 ( "9( +2/++-//=95>
"!
1
!
! " (* (D 1 "
!
! ! " ! &9 "
!
; ""
6/E
=
-0-/+-/+=9> "
" 023#41
" 1 $" " ( 1 1 " " *
=9A,)>""" "1 0 "( !
" /2044=
> 1 ""
4# (
4 5 -.-/+-/+ =9A>
&"" (
= >! " (*
(
)"" 1" ! 1 9 =@ >" "
?@( @
1 ( " " ( 5 +E-++-/+ =9F>
( 1=94*/> ( " " (
1= >=9'*/
'*+> )"" 1" ! 1 ( 1(; 9 4*/" "4 ( 11 )""
(; 9'*/ " "B'B E
" "" 1"
* "(( "
" 0-+
023#4 &
" ( , ' " " 9( A*/ :
="( > A*+%% <# ?
: A*0? (; = * *1) ! " (* > A*E( ( A*,%
=%( > A*3@
?
4 (
A*2@ 4 %
A*7 # ";
A*.@ 4 ;
A*/-# "
=#
< ">
A*// %
:= "< ">
5 =9A
9F>
!
(
1
"&
""" " !
" 3 "" !
" ( "" !
" 0/0 44 1 " 1
" (
( )!
"1 ( ! (""
"
& ( " ? (;1 !
" 1 * *1=! " (* >
( 1 ! (& ? (;11;
# "
& ( " "& "
"
"!& 2 # "!
" "" 9( 1 < ;%A*/
:
&(%A*+
9( (%A*0'
"" "
"!
" 7 < " !
" ' 4" ! "
" "" *
= > "(( "
" 0-+
023#4 !
( " ! "
" +,-.+-/0
! . A ! " 1
"
" "&9( !
"! " /- " "
' 4 (
( 1 "
!
"
" ! # " " "( !
"
" !
" '
" "( !
" ! (
;
1 '
1 " " "& ( 1 " "A*E( ( 1 ( 9* " " 1
& )""
"" '
9
! " (* ! ! )""
"" !
( "* &9(
" %6
1 ("
(D"! ( !
1! " (* 1 ! !
5 " 1"(
" '
"!
""" )""
" 1 " "&
& !
" " "( " !
1 1
&
("5 & 1 " "" 5 9 1 (5 "" " &!5 =95 9A
9F>1 9( '
( ( (
<
&A*7#;
""" "1 & "%( 1 " !
"&"
"& (&
" '
& ( "
1
&" ! " !
"1 ( & " ) "
& $ (
( " ! " " "
( " ' 4 ; " "!
" (1 &" @ "" !
" ( "
" ( " & ! " &
1
" $ &
( " ! "
$ ( "
& "$ "
! ( // <
" ! ( & " ! " &
"
" !
!
"A
" "
( ( A*/ :
="( > A*0? (;= * *1! " (* >
" "( !
" & " ! "
"" "(( ! " (
( '
"! 1
& " & ' 4 !
'
" 1
&" ! "
" & ' 4 "((
"
" 0-+
023#4 /+ !
" "
" ! " " ( & " "( !
" /0 @ B(4 :"(/ "113 ! ,! !"#$ <<=,< !
8*
/E # 1 7 @"". "113 ! ,! !" #$ << .&5&( 7= 1 1 &@ B(4 1 " " "( !
" "
!
"( & 1
8 !
"
!
"
#!
$
" %!
&
'
/, # ,! !"#$ !':#AB05 .,.&C '! C << .&5&( 7= , 1 "(;
!
" "( !
"
!
" &"1 " ! "" ( "" #1 " "( " (
! &
"( !" " (" &1 & /3 A ( ;B-&77'*&.%05'! (!& 7 C&1"(%"*: 6!".@ & 1 1
" & ! "" "( !
"8=/> " & "("&!
&
"
" 1 "(
(G=+> 1& &1 9 " &" 1 "" &G=0> " 1 "" "( !
" !
"(
" 1 " ( G=E>
& " "&"(
"( 1
" " ""
" 9 & & G
=,> & ""
"$ /2 '
" ! " " &
" "( !
" & "
1
" "( !
" 1 &@ B(4 "; /.,+ /7 # (05 (!#C&(1 ./0(1A . ! ,! !"#$ <>, @ B(4!
8*
( &
/. " (& ( " @ B (4 ,: . 1 &.1:&%: (1, .1 !,! !"#$ : . ':!.
< ,='
1
1 " "( !
"
1 " ! "
"(
( &" " "
" & "'
"
" 1 @ B ( 4 " ! " " " "( !
"(& '
&8 !
)
"
!
&
& #!
%!
&
&
" *!
+- :
! 1! 1
" ! " " & " "( !
" & "
1
" "( !
"# 1(( "1 !
" " "( " "( "(1 " " 1 "&
" " &1 &
"" " "( " " " !
"&
& "
9" !& & ! # 1 ("
!
""( ! &
" " " 1
" " ""
("
1 1
( & "( ! & "" +/ '
" ! 1
C (""!: A.&':( (!,! !"23('6"%!#.#$ #7&%"
=,=
:07!,! !"#$ "7:&&(&'!.3#$#5"$$ &.'(. 4 , ++ @!
" ( ( & "
"" " 1 " " ! "
!
)""
(
8* = > '
" " "( !
"
"( " "( "
" "( " & ! " (* 1 (
,8-- -3/-+-//A*0? (; * * 1 ! " (* " "& ! " (*
" ""
1( " ! < 9 &=-2/-+-//> ? (;
1 1 ;
%! "
!
1 " (
(
! " (* @1! " ! "
(
! ! 1 A*/-#
< "
1 (
&(
&? (; ;
%! ! ( & #
< " =A*/-> ! 1 1(
! " (*
"(;
1 "" " &
( :
=A*/>
"
>
1 & ( ( -7/-+-//?
: # "
! " (*
1 (
"!
-3/-+-// " 1( " " "&" " (1
" -2/-+-//(" 5# -7/-+-//
" $"
$ & ! " (* "
"
" /2, 44 ( ? (;=9>1"
-7/-+-// 1 ( ;
1
; * *1=! " (>&
1
# ( ( & =-7/-+-//> ( ? ( ;
" /3/ 44= ;*H>1" & #
< " ( " ) "" 1 !
! & ! " ( 1$ )"" "(( ( #1 "( 9"! " "( " "
!!( )"" "(( "1
" & ? ( ; ( "
" /3/44@1! 1 ? (; 1 *9 A*0 -3/-+-//
1 )""
(
" ( $
)""
=
08--
1&"; 1 ("&"& )"" " " " & ( & %A*+
$ ! "1 " "& -3/-+-//
1 ? (; )""
!
" ,-)*"
& " ( $ & ! " (*
1 1=+,> ,8-- -3/-+-//"
( ( " "
1 "(";! " (*
A*0? (; "
"(;
1 ! " (* 1(
! 1 " "& &! " (*
1 (
! 78--
; ( 1 & A*0? (; " "& 1 "
"(( "
1
(# !
"*9( A*0? (;
1
1 " & 1 !
! & ! " ( '
;
%! ! " (* 1 " " 1 1 9( & "
"&
1 !
"& 1 ;
1 # " 1
?
;
"" ( ? (;=A*0> " -7/-+-//
$"
1 " "& ! " ( ; & ( ;
1
! 1 ( &A*0 ! "
" 1
? (;
" (
! " ( " = > 1 !! "(( "
$
" 1!
"
; " "" (
" ! &&
= > < " "( "1
! " "!&
(
= > ! " (* " ! !
1"(
1 (
" "
& 1 (
1 ( " " !!( "(( "1 1 @1! " "!&
(
= > ! " (* ( 5 & 1
"( #
"& " " ( 1!
"9" '
1( &"
"&9( &
! "
& " " ( ( (
( &A*7#;
$ !
""" "1 & "%( 5 ! 1 1
" 1 =9%/9%,>" "& ( ! 1 " "; "& ( ( ! #
< "=A*/->1 " 1
=9%/ 9%,> " "& ( ! 1 """ " =9%/9%,> 1 ! & 1" "; 1
! " (*
;
( ! " (* ' 1!" & " " 1 "( #
< " ; " "; ! " (*
1
= >5 1$ " "; (
! " (*
;
# " 91 $ ! " ( 1 &("
" ( ""
$ " "! " ( 1 "
"
1 "( 1 &
( (
"
! " ((
!
(
<
" 1;
A*+%% (( "? 1 "
"
*((9( &! " (* " "& &
& ! " (
# ( ( " !
" " 1 & & ""
" (
#
< " =A*/->1 " 1 =9%E> ( 1
( "( &
" ( ;
%! 1
BB =9%E>'
=9%/9%,> ( "
;
%!
! " (* ! 1
" " ( "
1 1 " & #
< " (
"!&
( ! " (*
A*0? (; 1 1"
" $"
( &
& ! " (* " " (
1 !
1 "!&
(
= >! " ( # ! 1 ( ;
%! 1 " " ( " ! 1 " "!&
1" ( ! " (*
@1! "!&((
=9:>! ? (; ;
%! 1 1 "< & " 1 1 "!&#
" & ;
" "!& " & ;
"
! " (* " ? (;=A*0> 1 " " ( 1 "!&
( ! " (*
" 1 9" " 1
" "!& "
&
1"! ( ! " (* ( " " (# ! $"
=9> 1 1 "
" " " (
! " (* ! (
""!&
( ! " (* # " "!&
( ! " (*
" " ( %
" (
1; 1 ( 4
&"! ( ! " (*
(
1 5 &
(5 =9A>
9( 1 "
?@(
@
1 ( "
" "691 5 19( ! "( 1
( &1 # (&( "
?" @( @
1 ( "
" " # "( 1 "
"
%6" # " ( 1 " ( "
( "" ""
" " 1 ! !
( 5 =9A> ! ( "
( "" ""
" " !
" " 1
( '! 1 1 "
" " :@
4 " "#./" : .&3 ( (1 .' ! ,! !" #$ B". 7 4 < < .&5"' # " 4!
& & ! "" "'
" "" &( " " ( ! 119 """. 9!,! !"#$ 4 << .7 + >< 1 ( " "( " 45 1 ( '
4! " 1 I ( &J
I &J'
" ( & &" # " & (
"! ( ! " (*
1 ( 9 &
1 (
1( ( "# &
"
(
&"!
( ! " (* 1 ( ( & " " !&! "(( (
("'
" (!0D,0(&(B05 . :03 (!,! !"4 < .&5"' > < (
( 4"@
4 " &5 (/':0 : .& ! ,! !"4< =.7 + =< " "!&
( ! " (* 1 " " ! " "!&
("
1 ( = > " "( "1 ! " "!& ( 11 ( " " ( 1 5 =9F> & ( 1 ( " " ( & ! " ( 1 "!& (( =9 >#
< "=A*/-> 9( * * " "& ( 1 ( &
(1; " !
"!&((=9 >1 1 &#;
@4%!
# ( #
< "=A*/->
1 ! ( 1! " ! " " " " & ( &A*7#;
$ ! ! 1 " "& ( 1 ( &
1 ; !
(( 9 1 1 & (
@4%!
'
1 !
1 ( 1! " ! " & ( 1 1 @4%
=A*2> @4 " (@4%
1 1 *9A*2 " "&
(( " " 1 ( 1 1 ! "!&((=9 > (
"# ! 1 ( $ !
" "1 ( 1; 1 ! '
( "
(
"
'
#
< "=A*/->
9( * *"
( 1 ( & 1 1; " !
((9 "#;
@4%!
"*9( 1
" 1 =9%0> 1 " "
1
1
=A*/-> 9 ( & & # "
1
: "! ( 1; " !
"!&(( 9 "!&((=9 >!
"# "
=#<> #;
@4%!
( 1
&# 1
: 5
?
# ( " ("!&(( =9 > ( (
&! " (1 &# 1
: 9
1 "( "
"& " # 1
: "&1 @1! " ! # 1
:1 " " 1 & 1 ( & "
"&9( 1 < "( 1 & ( " " (&#
1
: 1 1 "1 ;
( ( "!& (( =9 > ( 1 1 "4= ; 9 4*/&5 >1
1 5 1 ( " " (5
"
"&9( # 1
: (
( 1 & ( " " (
>
-7/-+-// !
"!&((=9 > 1 (
1 ( " " ( 1 " ! & 5 & # ! I J ( IJ ( 1 "
( ( '
"( " " 1 I( J
I (
1J
"
! ( &"
" " & (
" !
" %( 1 " ";
" " ( 1( & #
"& " "; "
( & ( " " (#1
"( #
< "=A*/->; " "; ( "
" " (% *9( ( 1 # 1
:" 1 " &
&( ( " " (
" ( 1
!" ! " " " ! &
1!& & ( =">1 1 (& 5 & < "I( J1 & ( " " ( !
"!&((9 " 5 =9F> 1 1 " !
=
I ( 1J ( " " (
I 1= >J ( & ( I( !
( 1J1! ( " " ( & 5 =9F> "" # " ! " "( " = !> " -7/-+-// =9?> #
< " $ ( " "
" *(( 9( & ! " (*
1 ! " (1" 9 %
" *(( 9( !
1) 1 ( &9 & ! " (*
4 ( "9( =95>1" !
+2/++-//
(D1 "
!
1)!
" " " & 9 "
!
; ""
"
" 023 #4 1
!
6/E
-0-/+-/+=9> "5## " 1 "( #
< " )"" ( "&9( (
! " ,044@1! "
"1 & #
< "'
?
1 #
< " " ( " 9( & ( " " 6 9 ("
& 9 "
1 #
< " " ,0=/> 44 " "
1 ;* "$
( "" (;"
9(
& "&" "1
(& "
!
" 1 ! "((
""
!
9( 1 !
" "(( " ?& " +, +--, 1 9 1
" ,0 "
9 '
9
" ,0 &"+,+--, 18* -.& / 0 *#( *%/ => I9( J " 9(
( 1 "9 " (
1 (
"
& (
" ""
$ "
%6
"
1 ( ""
;
"& ""G => I ( " " J ( ( "
" 1 &( "$ "
"= >" + #
"4 " " /.,3 =/-+/.,3>
1 (
" J # "1 ! " ( !
& " (& " ;"
"& ( "&9(
"" ? "1 ! " (
"
&&" "( !
" ( "!
"( ( "'
" ""
!
"
"( "" & 1 " &"
" "
! " " # " ! " ( ! "
" ( "9( " & " " 1 %6
(D " !
1)!
! " (* " ("
(!
"" ( "9( & & & ( ""
&! " (*
"( (
=!> "
" "( " ( 9* " "
!!( "(( " $
<
(=A*E>@1! 1 ( 1 *9A*E & !
"
! " "( "
" " =! > '
&"" ( ! " (*
( & ( " " ( -7/-+-//G*(( 9( &! " (* !
1
!
"" -./-+-//G 1= > "! ///-+-//
(
)"" ; 4 /0/-+-//
1! ! "1 4 ( "9(
&
& +,//+-//
( $ "
" "( " &(
1 ("" " '
( " 1 " @4%
=A*2> @4 $ "
1 1 ( " & ( &
1 -7/-+-// +E//+-//
6/.
+/ 4 1 1 ! " 1 $ " ! ! 1 ! "
&
( " " ( ! ( & #
< "=A*/-> " ! ";
"
BB(#;
-./-+-//
"
1 $ #
< " (;
& " " &1 4 ( "9( & +,//+-//# ! 1 ( & (
1 ("" " +0 # ! 1 "
" "( " "
!
"! " " &" " " "( "
" "( "'
" !
" " (
& ' 4 " " (
" " "( !
" )""
(
"
( ( " ( 1
" !& &(
" " ""
"
! &
" " "
("
!
" $
"
""
(&" 1&& " (
((
1 1
! "(( '
" (
! ( " " " ""
" " ! " & !
"1 &(
"'
" ! "
! )"" &
1 +E $!
1
""
&
( " ! "
"
+,-.+-/0 & ' 4 &
)"" "$ "
! (& !
(
" 1 $
& " +,
" &
(06&(1".,&(/:."E 7 + 7&! !. 01/"
01/"
,
;
)
K)6 K)6