← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/39/2015dismissed

Gurmukh Singh v. State Of Punjab

2023-09-12Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari14 pages



     

 

 

!

"#$% &    

    



' ()' ***+, ()' *,) +  

   ! "

#! !  ,) +   

  $ %

    & 

           "    

        

'( $) ')$*  +&         "       





 

,)'!,)(-.

  '(





 / 

 

. "   ,)'-.

% 

       

 

'!)))0/

 &  

    - ,)(-.

%

 - "&

  

'!)))0/  

   &  

    - '(  %

 -&

 

'!)))0/

 &  

    - '

 +     & , . /1+

!+ 



   "    &     &            '2 $) ')$$  



&   " 3- 4 ')(  '2 $) ')$$ 

 

,)'!,)(-.

  '( !+

      !  % %

%  56 7$0



 / 8 -

"



7 

%  9+

 

-&  :&   

 +  ,)&



4    -" 



 

    &+ & 9+

     ;

        

 + & -"



  +            

   9+

 

   & %  %

    !  &    

+  

$!(<!)))0/:

9+

              :   

+ </=   % &!

9+

 +  + !+         "   % !  +  

$!(<!)))0/                0

     0 % .        

 +   +    

%++&            

 -     & &!              

 &    &+&  +  

 ,$<:  "  

 +

+     -

"  &   &               & 

!        9         "   !          - ! 

 



&

/ /+!+   >    >

-    

  

   +

 &       : &   "  % +

+ 9+

+ & 





 

 9+

& "

 

   +   

 ,$<

   +&     +  & & -!  & 

&

/ /++  "

  +  + &

 &! +  $) ,)

"



  & :  & !-+

       ?"

  

@ ) * * ;



" !-

0A;   B7=C

   3-

     "  %  .   A      D     56 7=0.       

  !+   

  & 9+

   

  !  

+&   ,$<+ +

&     &9+

!+ +      

 +   

 >>

+ 

"

"& 7*09   %         +    

 "      

&    +   

 EF  "

     G   7*0 % +     %!-;   

*&    ,$<

  !+

 

"

  G56 7*0 %   +   + " 

   56 7=0    ;

        ! -;

      +     A.

  %   /    

+  



%  +       

 "

       %!  

,$ $) ')$$!  + 

 A+

 "   

  "     '

$$ ')$$!

 

   !+ 

           ,$<     +   $)   "   

    6  !  " %.

& 6 " +   -    

  56 7=01!" +   

$) "  + + 

"

56 7=0

  +  " &



 / "

56 7=04  



" + 



  $=$.  .

    "    !  

    $(, .  .

+    -D  &   A;

 *) < %    -D     

          6 "& &.

!     .    

 "

          $( '

')$'

% .  

 

,)'

,)(   -.  

 

     '(          

    +   &

    = -  "   ! 6

 & $$+ 

   !

   .      "      "    

   

 

& *'*** *) * ( 1 

  

 &/+ 

7$1+

7'+    + 

 &         

   +     

B  "&C   %!         " !   

       G  &  

            & + 

&  

%

   

   

  1  

      +   1+

  B7$C+ !         

 &   

   



  !



 &/+ 

  

                         

 A   

 &  "   "     !    

$!(<!)))0/       +        "               +   

      &    

  1  

        +     .

+  B7'C       6 +  + +    

  & &

A+"!    +

"    &  & +  & "    & "

 " " A       A.       B7HC!    

 "         A.

    "   + 31 A+"! A.  + 6 &

%! +   + 

+ 

&

 

   &

    &31  A

   

A.  +    !

! 

  

;

     

!        

  

  &             

     %     +    

                 "

!  +  +  &/ + 

""  

 +       &    &

 "

/6  

                             7$ 1+

7'+    &  "

  +    . 31  +  + + "

  + & 

"  %!

 "    &

   ) ** 7 

 

   !+"6      $)   "      "

!  +     /1+

   !  +  

 + 

6 7$!   



 &    & '2 $) ')$$ 9+

 + +     " 

          

$!(<!)))0/  +   +    &         !      

  +   & 

A  

 

  

 &

!

  +  ,$< 

"  +

 B7$C!+       

 



  "  +

  A  + 

!  +  



/ /++  B7'C

>>

+ ! +   "   9+

 

 +&   & +   ,$<  A    + 

 9+

!

 

 A+  &

/6  

 



/6   !"     !+   +    + 

 

$!(<!)))0/  &   /9+

  A        +   "          

/6   !

 

        7$ 1+

+&               %  "   6      

/ 6   



 / 87    +

!-+ &

 +&  -./ #$0-123. -45/ $--#/2 "2667 "7 8791*.$01 2$"  -1 $  $-

"  -1  1#7  #3  .4:201  *.$01 -1 #701#-1 /25 -+

 + -   

 - +  

%    @ $$ 9& "    !          7$1+

  "    "  -  +&!

6 +  +  7'

- ! 

&/+ 

+   + 

6  

  &!   

  

+   +  



    +

 

!

+       



+    

%  &>   > +   +&+  +      1+

    



9+

     +            &  

 "  

/6  



A+"!   +    +    !

  

&

 

/6  

- !

  +    

 " + "+

   &  

 ' );*<  $'

          7'  +   !     +    !+    

 

  

%

6   ! ; !. " A  ! 7<!+

  /   &

 '2 $) ')$$

+    +

/ 8$    +

$ < I$ <  + 

 

   

+ "

'

   +

< <I<

       

     

+  "

 - &  $  

 '       +       

&   

   +

,    +

$ <I$ <  

 

 * < "

      

+ "

*    +

, <I,

  

      

   



+ "

@ $, %   7$1+

7'+  

 B56 7<09C"



&   %   

 &  

/6   +   !

! "    &

 



     

          +        

     ! " &7$1+

7'

+    "&  3! "    !+

 + 

6 7= "   

  56 7=01  &

   ! " 

   ,$<

$) " 

3 

 

$) "   + 

 

+ 3

  1&      6  

%3156   &   

 !&  + +

  "      ,$< 9    

 %" 6 31



 / 8>> 

3) ,$< > 3>   .0$.0* & 9 

%+) ,$< > 3>    .0<  

 .0=    & >.> 

% ) ,$< > 3>   10$10$) & >> 

;

) ,$<       4 $)/9/)$'')



70$ & >5> 

3 "   ) ,$<  *)=' ;

   

           6        

   / $ 3) ,$<    .0$.0*

+ ) ,$<           .0<  

 .0=    "&    >>

>9>    ) ,$< 9    4 $)/9/)$'') 70$ 

EF

 '

% ) ,$<    10$10$)  >.>

  " 

@ $* 9 B56 7<09C

31 B56 C"" &

   +  + + " &

  

  +  



*)*  *'      <   *>+<* $<           "    !    "       !   

+           

   !   +  7=01



% 56 7=01 "  6   



        

   

      

   

 

        

 

  

      

                   

 

 !                       

"#$  %    



#&   

      #' 

    

#(

      )      

 # *+,- .

  (

 /

#$0 122# 3#'4  * 722# '&22# 0#%3*

*

$=   

      "  6    

    &  !



 

"& ,$<56 7=0 !

"      ! 

!

!

  !        6 "&   +         

  "&56 7=0 !

"&   ,$<  % ! "

 & "   

 "!    &

&    56 7=01!    "   "!

        "

   ""        "    "

 % !  "

 &   &     

 " + 

 &!"" &

+

   !  

!    

D     " &  "&!   

    &/+ 

    

  D    

     



$( % 

   + + &  

   

   !

!

  &   !!  

 

 

 3!

 ! / 6    A.     !+  

  !  && &/ + 

 

 



"



"   &

 $2 - " +"



! .  

&  &" &      "  

          '( $) ')$*  %       !



&!



  "    .

D &!          "    

        

'( $) ')$* 

$H ;  

& ') 

  



  ?**+,@ ?,) +@     

   &/$ 7  0

? 04 7  ? 04