← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2467/2006dismissed

Naranjan Dass v. State Of Punjab

2015-07-16Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma16 pages

     !   "  

 " # $%&'& ()* *+

 (, (" ''

 (# -'.'

# # .(, /  ' ($(#  0)  120 " !

3.$/4) 0'5$5. 6$- % # ($ 00 ( , 7 6$- % #  #5  (# 0"&(356 .(, / " !6  

 







      

 

   



   !  

      " 

# $% & !

"  $%& '  ( ) *%   + )+&

     

   !

 

     

       

             





        

     

            

   !   

"#

 $% 

     !  !  &   '  

  

      

 

  ( )   %% %   

 *  (

+

        

    

 ,      - .

 +         )

    )  * )     $ /       

   

    -

           ( )         )  0

   

   



 

     

#    %$ %       !)   1 -

   

 

     







   



       1)

  !   *)        2 



3        )   

  

 )



  0

  #

 





  !    4

,5

   6  )

        7-   

 

      ,

 !  2 



3         .





   -



    #   

 .  4

,8    )              

    '  9  +   4  

  !  

 &.   3       3    ,    &

  

  

    

 

     

    1)

 !   

,  



 

  +    



                 

!    

1)

   



      !)     1

     

1)

 ! 

   .

   



  ))     

           

         

   

               

 &         

     

       

         !)   

           

      

6 

    

 1)

 !           +!,2 5  .

   



  



  

          .



  

     

 



      # ,  

 





      

 

   .

     #   )  



 

:4

,4

,%%;   #        )              



  

 .

 



 

  #  



 .

    !

   

       

              #

) :4

,%; #     ! 

  #  

 .  4

,3 & )   

   







   





  





 



   !

 <%= :%;

!

 %=:; &   

  

        

 

 

 





 ,>%  1  !   .

 



   5   &   

  4

,&?  ,>     !     

 ?,>= 1)

 !   

,>$ '  9 

(      ?,>:  

,>$;5  2   9 

.

   

 

7!@ 5  1#! ?,>:    

,>";5  - (!   .



   

.

7!@+!,2 5  ?,><:   

,>";5  1#!      .   .

  ,>A: 

     

 ,><;  +!,  2 5    .



 



,  -

      "   $ $  ('(  

  



    . /  

     "

!

 "

  

      !

  

  



#/

 



 

 

  0   "

  1  2*

  

 

3

"

   

   

 

   

      

!  

 

   

 

 0 "

 4 *



 

 0

    4*   /

  5

  . 

 

     





 

 / 

  

 6  "

   

 0 "





(



   (

 "

  

 7  -   

   6  "

(

 "

/ 

 



 6  "

  8

      

  0   "

  0   "

 

  3



 !

 

     



  



 !

 9

      !

   

 

 

     !

   

  

 

 8 !

    0 "

   

 



/ 

 

   !

     

     /   

 

 

   





 

      -

, "

 '

    :

  '    ,  (

   "

     "

!



,$: "

 

        

(        

  

  

 



   .

 

   

 1

    

 

  

         !

          

 

          

         

0 "

 

 

.

    

   

 

  

 $  *

    4* %;-'

&

  !



   

   









 /

47 <



 4



! !

 !

;-'



  !

 

 7  



    

8!

  !       !/      



   = 

  

      05   5 ($  9' # #  4 (   :

;  :;++:

; .             !

                   

  !

    !

    >      !  !/!

/ 

  !

 !/!

 0

  

  !

!

     

    

       

  )

        

 

    

 

  !   





     .       <5 ($9'# #: -#  "5&; =:

;

 :;:"5&&35 .#;>>6 ./ '5 /# (- ( 9'# # .,  #  :?;  :;*>>:;6./ & 9'# # @   =:?;  :;?*:;

(

!

  

    

  

',0 "

',$3

  ',4  ?

  :  

  ',  9

 (     

      !       !

   



  

 



  

 

 

(   



 

  8 !

            

!

 !

               

  !

  !

  

',

0 "

   





7 -

 



!   !

 

    "'.          

!     !

    

 

    .  

   

         "   

  3

  @$    !   

      ',  9

 (                 $@ 2    .                

!    



 !  / 

        = 

  

      9  9(7 # .//  9'# #'(#$/4('%# 

&%   >= .     

        3

 "

  

!  !

 !

 

    !

      !

 

.     

  !!

 4





       





 =    !

  @.$& &9'# # .(, / 

:

;  :;>* (

  !

    

    !

       !

     

       

               

    

   

   

   !

   .           # #    .(, /  9'  @.'5   &(35

#5 (&   :

;   :;  => 

 .'5  @.<   9' # #  4 (  == ;

 :;> 



   >     

    !

 

    

  !

    "  

   

       

       

    

.      

   



 

    -  8 !

          !

  7!

           !

  ',?

!  

  8!

      -

!       

;-'

2! !

                

    

 

        

 

 >   

     ', 0 "





!!

3

"



!

?

:

"'9

(    

   ,    

 

  

 !

 -  

"

   





 !

   

             !   

  = 2

<7   

/   !

    4



    !

3

    9

 



     ' 7    

 !        

       !

 3

"

      .          5   

!/

  

/  

!/      ! !





        

3

"

   

   !   



 

    !          /      !       

  

  !   !

  

      !      

/      

/!   



  ',  3

 "

    !  !

     

         6 / !

 ',  ?

:  

  "'  9

 (           7  



5    

   

  

 



/     

7 -

      

    / 

 

  !       !

  5        !      

 

     

 

 





8





 

!

  

'

!

   ?



       !



 



 

  

  

 

       

      

   8

  

    

     

 ( !  

!



 =  

-       $            

!

@7   

                                       

                  ! 

    

#   $%

&

&# & &'

&%( 

  )  *      +,-#%      

   )  *   #  

        "        &  '"#.

      #'#                   &  '"#.

                #     

        &        '"#. 

                          /    ;-'

2!

   



           !

      



 



      

 

   05   5 ($1' 

%  &

     



 

 



  

       !/0

   

 



 



 "      ',  

  0   "

 

 ',$3

"

  !!

 

      

     





)   

 4



 !   5   

!/ 



/ 

 !/      

  

     

      !

 /   

 



   

  

  

  

 

    

 ./ &1' 

%  &





   



     

  

     

    

!

  

 

  

     

   

    

 

    

        

 

       

 

        

       



 ! 



 



 

     

!      

 !

       !

/

      

           

  ,  

      

!





     !

  -

 

   8!

    -

! 

   





 !  !   !



 

.

  

   !





    

 

   

 



/ 

 ./5 ' /# 

%  & 

    

     

  

 

 

 8!

    !

    

  8  



 

0 !

   

  

     7 

     

5     

    ',?

: !

 

   

    !

    

        

           -

   !  

 !

     

                               

   



  

<5 ($1'

%  &

       

      

 



 

   

     1     

 

              



 " 

  



    ',3

 

           

 

       !



    

4



  8 

       

    !

 

    





 



   !       

     (        

      

  ! 



 !

      

     !



  

     

 

   

        

 

     



  

 

     

 

  

  

   

>           / 

 

 

     

   !

/



 

    

  

    

 !  

        

!   

     

         !



!         

/             

     !           @.$&  & 

 %  & !

         

 

  !     

         !

 

 

/   ?         /   

-     

   !

  

  

 

 

 !

 -   9(7 # .//  1'

%  &





!   

    7  

   7    

  ;

 

!

 

   

 

 

   !

!

      !



 !



4 

 !  !

/7$      !

 ! !

8

 

       

 

 

   

 

               

     

 

                 



!

    ',?

: !!

       

    

 

!                   

@.'5 &(351'

%  &

      



" 

.'5@.< 1' 

   

 

   !

 

  

! !  

  



 

    

    

   

     

     !   

  

       8      !       !

 

    

!

    

 

 

!

   

  



    !

 ', 0 "



3

"



       

    



 

  !   !

    





      

   /

 !

',3

"



 6    

 

 

 

   !

. 

     ',?

: 

! 7!



     

 ,(



  



 

/ !







"

  

 !



  

 0 "

 

  

6  "

.    

5   !

  "

 

  6    "

  0   "

  

     

 





 

 8 



7 -

    



       



  0

            

 7 

            

   

  

 

    

     



 

 !



    (    )      (  

  / 

  

 5  

 5     

   "

)  





(    

  

  

       

! . 





  

 

 

   

 

<7



!   !

  8  

  



( 

  !

(

   

  

 

  

 



     (  

 

 5    !

 

   '  ( )      

 

  

  8   

  

    

      

  

 

 

    



     5

   

      -

  



  !  

  

    A   



(

 

   

     

      (

5     

  

 

 

  

    



.



  

  . 

         ((B?

   !



2

     

 

 8 

        (!



       (B?! /  

   ) 

  

 (B?

 

  .4*6 *+ : " !;

&#( "