High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2446/2010allowed

Dharam Pal v. State Of Haryana

2015-03-11Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh12 pages

!" "#$#$ % &'('

# # ) * % +' %,%#

"!#$!%&$'

(" & )&*+ &$$!( , ! "

-.,/) '

1 !+

, !

"!'!

-.,/) '

!.$,+

,3'

3/ "

"'%#

-.' */ $%0,1 2 # # %# --(%$' ! 030) * % 4 '%# '5%$,# 2 %67(,6!%# %1$2#$ % %, , '%#%2 , #, '', 5* 2$ /(,60 $' 01$,8 $2 0# %# '5%2 %1$2#, %2 (%$' 5(%, 2#$ %'9 %, "1%#$ (#$ %2#0:;;

$% # , # ' <# " 2#< %, ' 5% '%#%2, #

(%,6 $6 ('$!$'

%!%# $ , %* 8$# $% 0= 8$# , (#2 (' $*0# 2#' # %'# * # # +

, #,(%, 2#$ %'9 %, # "2#8 '6$'#, # "

$2 # #$ &)$' 6 $%'# 22(', %# !" 08 8 '

'#, '>$%2#$2$#* ,0 (5$1$'$ %0+ %$ %# 6 #$ # # ,! %,, % !

(%# = ' %$6 6 #$$2 #$ %

! $% %# " $%6 $%2 '$%6# , 2#$2$#*2 %%2#$ #(58$%'# ,$%# %,08 $2 8 '# .% % '5* $! ! % + 7 ? ( 2 ! $% %# 8 ' % # $%#'#, $% 6$1$%6 ' $, $6 6 #$$2 #$ %# # 22(', %, ''(2 !

1, % $2 #$ % 6 $%'# # 22(',# %'2# + !' ?(! '# #$%6 # 2#' $,$%6 #*8 '2 %'#$#(#,(%,# ,' (#* !!$''$ % %, ,(#, $5 '$, 0+ %$ '3 @##,$2# 7 $%# $,$1 2(%2*% #' # ,% !$% #$ = 2 86$1%5*# ! $% %## %'2# + !' ?(! # (#$%$#$ ' %, *$%6 % # $% 8, # # %'2# %,, 1 # 2(%2*% #'# # 2 ! $% %# %,,$2#, $!# %, 1# ' ! 22(', %,! %,5*6$1$%6'$6% # 3(! $ $%6 08 8 '! , ' , 88$#%''3(! $ $%6 8 ' '

,$2#,# ''# '$6% # # $,$%6 #* #2$# # !

(%#5*# 22(', %# !# ! $% %#A % !

(%#8 '6$1%# 22(', %#0# ' , 8$#%''

3(! $ $%6 6 1'$6% # $,$%6 #* %, $,8 '2 %,(2#, 2(%2*% #'8(#$%# $B($,8 '

,$(!2 5 % #8 '

,,, %,$#'2 (#(%,$%# $%.$' 2 ' #*8 '# .%$%#

''''$ % %, %# 5 '$' (B 0# +8 '6$'#,5*

$%6 22(',8 '2 6' #,(%, 2#$ %9 ,8$#

2#$ % # "2#0# 8 $2 0 ,,% #6($#* %,2 $!,#$ % $% , # 1$#'2 'C !$%, '! %* ' 8$#%''' %2 !#$ %1$,%20'# #!%# 22(', (%, 2#$ % " 8 ' 2 ,,0 8 $%0 ,%$, # 6 #$ %' %, ,,$%% 2%2 22(', %# ''# #,$% $'

'# #!%## #+ 7?(! %," 8 %?(! 1$, 2 ' 6 $%'# $!

# $%$%6# %, %, '5% '*$!$2 #, ' # $% 8 ' $, " 8 % ?(! %, + 7 ?(! 8 1$%6 2 ,$ #$ %'8$# ! $% %# " $%6 22(',$% $',%2C !$%,+ !' ?(! 0$1 'A 0 68 % '' 'A %, $%6 '

% $' 1$,%2, !5 # # '$,'0# 22(', %#8 '2 %1$2#, %,'%#%2,5*# #$ (#1$,7(,6!%# , #, 0 8 $2 $' '(572# ! ## 2 %6 $% # '%# D %,2 (%' # %#2 %#%,'# ## %# ' '*5%$!$2 #,$%# 2 ' '# 2 ! $% %#8 ' 1$%6 $%#'#$% %,6$1% % '08 '0 8 '% #$%1 1,$% %* ! %% %, ' % 2 %2% # $%2 ' # , # 2#$2$#*0 # 0B('#$ ,! %, 5$5 %,$#' 22# %2, '% # $' # D %,2 (%'(# 2 %#%,'# #$# '% #5% 1, %2 , # #2 ! $% %#8 '2(#$1 #$%6# %, !#+ 7? (6$1% % ' %, 1 $, C#%'$ # , '# #!%#' "A %, "

% ##('#8 # * '# * %$6 5 (' # 2 ! $% %#D %, (%' # %# '

2 %#%,' # # # ! #$ %# ,$2#$ %' %, ,$'2 %2$' $% # '# #!%#' 8$#%''' #$ (# '% #2 %'$,,# ,%2'#(5*# %# '+ !' ?(! 0,$1 # # % $5 '$, "A 0 '

1, %2 ,# 65

. # 1 $2# '

8# # %# #1*, * ' $, $5 '$, 8 '% #1%'%#$%# $2 #$' '

# 6(!%# %,2 (%'# # ''# #!%# A

0# $2 #$ $%2 '$%6# , # 2#$2$#*8 '! ,(%,# ,' #$ % %, !

(%# 8 ' 6 # , '$#, 5* ( $%6 0 ' $ ) 5 %'D 0D8 ' %,(#* %# #, * %,# %#8 '%$#

%2%,8$# # C#%'$ # ,% 2 %2%,8$# # $ C#%'$ % # , % # %,0 %, 2 (%' # %# %#%,'# #%$# # ,! %,% $#' 22# %2 '5% 1, %,0 # 0 1$'$ %' # "2# % # ## 2#,D %,2 (%' '

$,( %# 7(,6!%#' ) %<5# C (#$%# 2 ' &'&"3&""5" &

!#&*&'& /033"

&+.

5"4!% 3'43/ !.

!#6 &$&:++$!$% 05 '7& &.++&&!5" &

,+*'"

!!# !$3% 4 9++$!$% :0 &

!# .'-&+5"!

&'3'/ :9 / 0&*&&-5" &

!# 3D

#:0 # $' (# $% &(&'6.)&5" &

!# .'-&+ ++$!$% 90 &" &$3'/ 5" &

!# .'-&+ '', %$%

0- , ')$6 (#$%# 2 ' &')./ &8 $.

&',&'!

5" &

+*'"

!!# !$3% 453/3$&'% &','

3 !.

3!'4!3)+& %, )$! 2 " ,' )$6 (#$%# 2 '

&$3 3'/ & &5" &

!#3)&% &$ &, "

$!'

90$%'( # $'2 %#%#$ %' D %, 2 (%' # ' %,%#

# # '(5!$#' # # 7(,6!%# #$ (# $' 8 '

%, %, $' 5 ', % 2$ #$ 1$,%2 !

(%#8 '2 1, !# 2.# 22(', %#5*# $,$%6 #*$%# '%2 ' , 88$#%''

%,# 22(', %# '# C $% '# 8 !

(%#8 ' (%,$% $' 2.#5(# ' $,# , '

) ,# 6(!%#' ,1 %2,5* %,2 (%' # %# '8 ' # # %, 1 '

6 %# (6 # 2 , # 8 (# ! $% %# " $%6 8 $ $%6 '"A '# #,# # %8%## # $2 ($%#%,%# "

$2 %, 8$##%

! $%#8 '! , 6 $%'# 22(', !" '# #$%6# $%# # ,! %, = 8 '! , ! $! 6##$%6# 8 ., % ) (# '# #,# # ,# .%# 2' %, % '5 %6$%6#

%+ 7? (08 $2 8 '5$%62(#$1 #,5* $! # '#$6 #* ' ) ' '

'# #,# # 22(', !" ,! %,,= '5$5 6##$%6# ,$%2 ', %, ' ,$,% #8 %## 6$15$50 1, % $2 #$ % # %'2# + !' ?(! $% # $' 6 , #0# 2 ! $% %# 22 ! %$,+ !' ?(! 0 %'2# # #

$2 (#* !!$''$ %0 $' 08 ,(#,+ !?$' %0 '$, 7 $%# $,$%6 #*+ !?$' % '$, '8 '+ !' ?(!

%'2# (## $$%$#$ ' %2(%2*% #'6$1%5*# 2 ! $% %##

%'2# &$6$ %2 %2 ''

C !$% #$ %0# 2 ! $% %# ''# #,# # $'% !, '% #$%,!%#$ %$%? ' 3$,8 $6 ,$%6 %, ' )(# '# #,# ## 2$#'6 ,$%6 *!%# ' %*8 '% #5 (6 # %# #, *) ' '

,!$##,# # #'#8 '

,6, 6 $%'#$! '$#$ $% = 8 $2 # %8 ',(2,#

= 5*# %,8 ', '$#,1$,2$#8 $2 8 '*$%6 # $'

(') ' '

,!$##,$%2 ''

C !$% #$ %# # %'2# + !'

?(! ,$,% #'$6% %*, 2(!%#$% $''%2 # ' '

5% ,!$##,5* $!# # .%83(! $ $%6 5$%6%$6 5 ( # '# * ') '

'(5!$#'# # 22(', !" 8 ' 1$%6' #$% 5$6 %# 2%## 58 ! %*2.'8'$##$%6 %,# 8 '% #1$'$5# %*5 ,* !# ! $% ,) ' '

,!$##,$% 2 ''

C !$% #$ % # # ,$, % # ! . %* 2 ! $%# # # $6 (# $#$'$%'$# 6,,! %, %,% 2$!$% 2 '8 '6$'#, 6 $%'# $!#$# #, # 3(! $ $%6 8 $ $%6 '"A ''# #,# # $'

'$6% #('8 5# $%, %, 2(!%#C'" %, "

; )(#

'# #, # # 8 ' '# %,$%6 (#'$, #

! % # 6 # %, ! $% %# " $%6 '., $' $ 5(# 22(', ! " ,! %,, = 8 $2 8 $, '$6% 8 ' 6$1% 5* # ! $% %# %, $,$%6 #* 2 , ## 2 22(%2) '

,!$##, $% 2 ''

C !$% #$ % # # 2 ! $% %# " $%6 8 '

'$,$%6$% $'%$6 5 (

,)(# '# #,# ## !!5' # $,$%6 #*8'$##$%6$%# $1 $2 %# ! $% , %, %2$1$%6 '$6% # * 2 ,# # $2 # 22(',08 '0 ''# #!%#

2 ! $% %#0# !!5' # $,$%6 #*8'# %,$%6 ## 6 #

# 3(! $ $%6 ' '

'# #,# ## ' # # 22(',8 '

1$'$508 '0 ''# #!%# 2 ! $% %## ' # # 22(', 8 '% #1$'$5 !# 6 # # !" . ' "

%$ "A 8 8 '8 .$%6 '>$%#

$2 ($%#%,$%6 %6$% ,(2, $6$% 2 , 6 ,$%6 ' %2#$ ,$''(, 6 $%'# 22(', !" ) ' ,!$##,$% $' 2 ''

C !$% #$ % # # 8' #$%6 # C#%'$ % , # %' !8 '8$# =E %, # '%$ $2'5(## 2$2 '# 8 ' 1$%6% 2 %2%8$# $# + !' ?(! A 8 8 '8 .$%6 ',$18$# $5 '$, + !?$' % ''# #,# # #+ %$ #9 ! %, 2 , 5 2. # ! % %, %%#*8 ' '

! ,$% 65

.$% # $'6 , ) ' '

,(2, $6$% 65

. %, * 8 $2 $'CA=

$!$ * $%6 A

' '# #, # # 2#$2$#* %%2#$ " $%6 ! $% %#8 ',$'2 %%2#, %,( % , '$# 2#$2$#*2 6'+ 7? (8 '# 2 %'(! #

$6 ! 1$%6 22 (%#

;

" #(58 % $2 #$ % $%2 '$%6 ,8 '! ,(%,# ,' #$ % %, %

9 (%# = 8 '6 #, '$#,1$,2$#CA

= !# '# #!%# 2 ! $% %# " $%6 "A 0$# '

5% 1, %2 ,# # 8 ' '' %,8 '2(#$1 #$%6# %, + 7? ( %,1% $, C#%'$ , # ' '

5% 1, !# '# #!%#' %8$#%'''# #"A %,"A # %$6 5 ('1% !(' '# #!%# "A 0$# '5% 1,

%2 ,# ## 8'# 8 ' 1$%6% 2 %2%8$# # C#%'$ , %,% 22 '$ %8 '# # %## 2$1 %*$6 6 #$$2 #$ % !# 2 ! $% %# '# 2#$2$#* ,8 '% ## 5 $%2 ', 5* $! $!$ *0 $# ' 5% 1, % 2 , ! # '# #!%# + !' ?(! 0 8 8 ' 8 .$%6 8$# # # % $5 '$, # ## ' $, $2! $%, %# ( !9 !# ! %,# ' $, $21%8 '% #'%#$%# $2 %# , # 22(%2 $!$ * !# '# #!%# $%6 A

0$# ' '

5% 1, %2 ,# # % $2 #$ % $%2 '$%6 , 8 '! ,(%,# ,' #$ % %,# !

(%#8 ' '

, '$#,5* ( $%6 0 ' $) ' '

'# #,# #) 5 %'D 0 D8 ' %,(#* %# #, # 6##$%6# !

(%#, '$#, $%2 '

# , ! #$ 2 %# ,$2#$ %'$%# '# #!%#' "A %,"A "A

" $%6 ''# #,$% $'2 ''

C !$% #$ %# # 8%## + %$ # $%, (#'

!8$#%''03(! $ $%6 !# $!$%# @ %, 8 '# .%# '$$20+ %$ 08 '03(! $ $%6 "A ''# #,$% $'2 ''

C !$% #$ %# # % #: !0 8 ' '.,5*# 2 ! $% %## !# $!$%# '$ $2 # ! %, 2 ,# # 5 (# !8 2 ! $% %# " $%6 8 ' '

'%#

#$' '##,2 % 2$!$% 7($'(,%2# #2 %1$2#$ % 22(',2 %% #52 %$%, %# 5 '$' $%%2' %2

; '

(, 15% 1, 6 $%'# 22(',5* %, '

% 5, (5#$# 5*,$2#1$,%2 1%5*2$2(!'# %#$ 1$,%2 '# ,2 6%#1$,%2$%# $'6 ,5(#$%# '%#2 '%$# # $%.1$,%2% 2 %'$'#%2*$'# $%# '# #!%#' 8$#%'''-2 1* # $%#, !

(%#$'% #'($2$%## 2 %1$2## 22(',(%''# $''(5'# %#$1 %,$ 51$,%2 % 5'%2 %*'(2 1$,%20$#2 %% #5' $,# # !

(%#8 ' 22#, ' 5$5 $'1$8 '5%# .%5*) %<5# C (#$%# 2 ' .&- )&$5" &

9 $ 3,)3'3"

& 3!'::9: 9 $!$ *# /(,6'%2 $%&"3'/& &!5" &

!#', & &, "

++$!$% : ' ,# #$#$'% #% (6 # #'

!2(%2*% #'

8 %,, 1# (5$2'1 %## ! .$# 22# %2 6 #$$2 #$ 5(#$#$'# 5 1,5*# %# ## !

(%#8 ' $, '

6 #$$2 #$ % #$' '

% #,$'(#,# #1$,%2 %%#('#,8$#%''

2 %% # 5 22#, 8$# (# 2 #$ % 5(# # '# #!%#' '(2 8$#%''' B($,# 52 #, 5*# '# #!%#' # 8$#%''' ) %<5C (#$%.+&)&'3&'8 &

!#&)3$ &,.

,3'1;;<9:93:=; ' , '(%,

F 1$,%2$%# $'2 '% , (5# 1'# # '(! +' = 8 ' $, 5* "A # # %# (# # 2(2$ B('#$ % $' 8 # # %# , ,! %,, # ' $, (%# '$6 6 #$$2 #$ %# '

8 %* $2$ 1 (#

"A %,8 # # ' $, !

(%#8 ' $,5*"A %, 2$1,5*# %# '2 %'$, #$ % '

8$%6'(2

$2$ 1 ( - 2$# +' = 5* # %# ,!$##,5*# %#8$% #5'($2$%## '#%6($# (%, 2#$ % 2#$ %, # 2#0$%#

: 5'%2 %*1$,%2 ,! %, %, 22# %2 # (%# '$6 6 #$$2 #$ %F ) %<5 C (# $% 5 '7& & .++&&! 5 &

,1;;>92:93:>? ' , ' 8'

%# 5'%2

,! %,0# B('#$ $'$%6# '(!#$ %8 (,% # $' 2#$ % # "1%#$ (#$ %2#0:;; 1$,' $'$%6 '(!#$ %*$ ,! %,$' 1, # ,' '(%,

F "'(!#$ % 8 (5$2 '1 %# 22#'

6 #$$2 #$ # # %6 !(% #$ A 0 $% %*#$ % %2(%$' 5(%, 2#$ %9

2#$ % 2 (' 2 ('5 '(5 '2#$ %

2#$ % $#$' 1,# # % 22(','

% '

22#, 5# $%, ' 6, # 22# ##!#,# 5# $% $!'0 %* # '

%0 %*6 #$$2 #$ % # # %6 !(% #$ % %* 1 ( 5# $%6 ! %*'

%0$#' 5'(!,0 (%'' # 2 %# * $' 1,0 # # 22#,

5# $%, 6,# 22# ##!#,# 5# $%# # 6 #$$2 #$ # #1 ( 5# $%60 '# 2 '! *50 ' !

#$1 8 ,'(2 '$'!%#$ %,$% 2#$ %9

0 '# 2 '! *508$# (#2 %'$, #$ %'$, #$ %8 $2 .% 8'# 5$% ,B( # ) %<5 C (# $% &

!# & &&"

& 8 '*&'

(&&@)&' &!&',

,3'91;;:193:

2A? ' , '(%,

F %,$'(# 5*0# ,! %, $6 6 #$$2 #$ %$' '$% B( % % 2 %'#$#(#$ % %2(%,# 1$'$ %'

# 2# $1$%6 ## 2 %2('$ % '# 8 # # $%6,$%#' % %2 1$@ ,! %,0 22# %2 %, 2 1* # !

(%# $6 6 #$$2 #$ % 1 5% ' #$'$, % #0# 2 (#!('## .$%# 2 %'$, #$ %# 2#'

%,2$2(!'# %2'5 (6 # %# 2 ,$%# $%#$#* # ' $,( '0$%,$'(# 5*0# '(!#$11$,%20 '$' $,, 8%$% 2#$ % # 2#0!('# '

5# .%$%#

%'$, #$ % 5(# # % $% '2# # 0 $# $' #$#0 # '# %, , 5(,%

% # 22(', 1$'

< 1$' # '# %, , 5(,%

%# %8 (,,$ 0 810# 22(',$'2 ,( %# C $% '#

8# !

(%#$%B('#$ %8 ' (%,$% $' ''''$ %0# (%, #$ % 2#' !('# 5 '# 5$' , 5* # % 1%8 $$%1 .$%6# 1$'$ %' 2#$ % # 2#0# (#$'B($,# 2 %'$,# C % #$ ,5*# 22(',0$ %*0 %* %# # (2 '# % %, %2 5 5$$#* %, % # % # # (2 '# %

5* %, '

% 5, (5#F ) %<5C (#$%33"

&+."%&"

9". &:

5* 2$%6$ %2 %# $,2$'$ %$%.&-&$"%&"

9". &: '

,# #

F ! 2 1* # $%#, !

%* ,$1 2, ! # 2$2(!'# %2'(%,8 $2 $#$' $,$'% #'($2$%## 2 %1$2# # 22(',8 %# '(5'# %#$11$,%2$%# 2 '$'% $ 5 !2 1*5*$#'2 %% # 1# 2 6

# % 6 $%'## 22(',0$%# 5'%2 %* 1$,%2 # 1 *!%# 5$5 # '

8 # # # 22(', 1 (%# $* 22#, # !

%* .% 8$%6 $# # 5

5$5F

!"## ) %<5C (# ' , ' (%,

F1%$% 2 '8 # 5(,%$' %# 22(',0$#$'

8.% 8%0# %!('# 1# (%, #$ % 2#' $ %&

'()*+

,- ./ %, 0 1 (2 3(

% '&', &7&"

5" &

!# &*&'& ; ++ $!$%

0# $%#,!

%*8 '2 1, !# !$ %,% # # '

% ' 2 # 22(', %1'$ %8 '% #,5*$%,%,%#8$#%'' #8 ' ,# #%$# # ,! %,0 22# %2 2(%2*% #'C"# "

5* 22(', ! (5

$%6 2 ! $% %#$''# 5$' ,

%&'& &

3&'*&&375" &

!#6&'& &7&49 +2%#$!$% + #'$!$% ;0# %2 '8 '# ## 22(', ,,! %,,!

%* !# 2 ! $% %# 2#$%6%#* !(# #$ %$%# 1%(2 ,# 8 ' $, 2(%2*% #'8 2 1, !# 5 # 22(',5% # $2$' ,%2 1'$ % # # % ,! %, 8 ' ! , %, 2(2* % #' , 5% '(#$#$ ('*(# %# # 508 $# %#8 ' # 8$'%6 6, $%'

! 2#$1$#*8 ' , ('$55*# C (# !*!$%,0# 2#( '$#( #$ %$%# 2 ' # %,$''

!8 #$,%#$2 8$# '&',

&7&"

"%&"

% $ 6

7 6 % #

6 "

-8

, , 48%9

, ,,0) %<5# C (# ' , '(%,

F- 10# %(' % % 22(',$'% # ' 1* '# # # % #! *52 ! ,8$# ,%, %#$% 2$1$ 2,$%6F

%:9

'( (; #

".,0$# 8 ' $%,

F %# $'2 ',! %, $6 6 #$$2 #$ %5*# ' %,%# '% #5% 1,(# !

0 2#$ % # 2#$'% ## 2#, '# ' %,%# ,5%2 6, 2 !!$''$

% %2(%, 2#$ % , ,8$# 2#$ % # 2#F

%1$8 2#' %, 8 '$#$ % ',$'2('', 5 10$#$'

%# # # 7(,6!%# # #$ (# $' % # 5 ', % 2$ #$ 1$,%2 '$# '% #5% 1, %2 ,# ## 8 ' ,! %, 5$5 %, !

(%#8 ' 22#,$%$( %*8 ., % 5*# 22(', 6 #$ %' 6 $%'# 22(', %# 1% #5% 1,0% # %* 8 %# 2 #$ %5* %*$%,%,%#8$#%''5(# # !

#$1 6$1$%6 %*5$5 ' '

% #5% 1, 5%$# , (5#0# 06 '$% 1 ( # 22(', %# 22 ,$%6*0 # $' $' 8, %, # 7(,6!%# %1$2#$ % %, , '%#%2 , #, '', 5* 2$ /(,60 $' $''# '$, %,# 22(', %#$' 2B($##, # 2 6' !, 6 $%'# $!5*# #$ (# %#$' 5* ,$'2 6, !# 5 $='(#*5 %,'(%$' ,5* $! 9 :