High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2010/2012disposed of

Parveen Kumar @ Sonu And ANR v. State Of Haryana

2015-07-20Bench- 48 pages

!!!

!"#$%#$&%#$'()*$+$,%-#.(/)0$&$1.&%$)2,%#$)2*$-%3 $-

! !

! "

.45!

!!!

66.4!

77(-$)8&9$$, (+8&.,($$18: $#%8800(8,) 8*)2-# 8(-#2: '8;<$&$7.,927%$) (,)$& $7%2.,5= &$8) <2%# $7%2.,56 8,)<$&$-$,%$,7$)%.(,)$&*. 4.&;$8&-8,)%.18;8 42,$.4>$87#8,)2,)$48(/%%.(,)$&*.84(&%#$&1$&2.).45+.,%#-

!!$87#! 77(-$) 8&9$$, (+8&.,(8,)$$18: $#%8#89$

7#8//$,*$)%#$80.9$'()*$+$,%.47.,927%2.,0;1&$4$&&2,*

.48,)877(-$)8*)2-# 8(-#2:'8;#8-7#8//$,*$)%#$80.9$ 7.,927%2.,0;1&$4$&&2,*

66.4!

%2-%#$78-$.4%#$1&.-$7(%2.,%#8%877(-$)8&9$$, (+8& $$18: $#%88*)2-# 8(-#2:8,) (,,8 #8,8,)-.+$.%#$&(,:,.<, 1$&-.,-<8;/82)%#$%&(7:)&29$,0;"87##28,)7.++2%%$))87.2%;.4 %#$2)20(,)/$-8,)%$808*-!

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

" 8'2,*# 8<8%<8-%#$.<,$&.4%#$9$#27/$! !

,-1$7%.& 8%;8 8&:8-# *.% 8 -$7&$% 2,4.&+8%2., %#&.(*#

.,-%80/$(,2/ (+8&%#8%/..%$)2)2-4&.+8&2)808)<$&$:$1%2,%#$ *.).<,-2%(8%$)8%6()#8*8&$/#2!"A 8+$-# #8,)$&

5 <8-18&%.4%#$%$8+4.&+$)0;,-1$7%.&8%;8&8:8-#!"A)$1.-$)%#8% %#$78&)&29$,0; (,,8<8--%.11$),$8&%#$-82)*.).<,! (,,8 &$+82,$)-$8%$)2,%#$78&!#&$$1$&-.,-,8+$/;877(-$)$$18:8*)2-# 8,)8&9$$,*.%).<,4&.+%#$78&8,).1$,$)%#$-#(%%$&.4%#$*.).<, 8,)$,%$&$)2,%.2%!#$;-(44$&$))2-7/.-(&$-%8%$+$,%-B!8,)

&$-1$7%29$/;!CA0.B$-.42)2-8,)A$+1%;*(,,;08*-<$&$%8:$,2,%. 1.--$--2., 92)$ +$+. B!! <. %$8 08*- <$&$ 8/-. %8:$, 2,%. 1.--$--2.,92)$+$+.B! !" .,-%80/$8%2-# (+8&-1.:$80.(% %#$)2-7/.-(&$-%8%$+$,%+8)$0;8//%#$877(-$)! (%,.&$7.9$&;<8- +8)$.,%#$08-2-.4%#$)2-7/.-(&$-%8%$+$,%-2,)292)(8//;-(44$&$)0;%#$ 877(-$)! " .,-%80/$ 892,)$&%$-%242$- %#8% 877(-$) 8*)2-# 8,)

(,,8-(44$&$))2-7/.-(&$-%8%$+$,%-! 8-$)%#$&$(1.,%#$%&(7:<#27# <8-/..%$)<8-&$7.9$&$)2,%#$%8%$.4 %%8&&8)$-#.,6!6!!#$;

8/-.)$+8&78%$)%#$1/87$.4.77(&&$,7$! A!

#$ 877(-$) #89$ -$% (1 8 1/$8 2, %#$2& -%8%$+$,%- (,)$& $7%2.,55 &!!

!%#8%%#$;<$&$2,,.7$,%0(%%#$;#89$0$$,2+1/278%$) <2%#1/8,%$)&$7.9$&;!

#$ %&28/ .(&% #892,* 8)9$&%$) %. %#$ $92)$,7$ ., &$7.&) &$%(&,$)842,)2,*%#8%%#$877(-$)7.++2%%$))87.2%;8/.,*<2%#.%#$&-! C!

#$ 1&.-$7(%2., <8- 0.(,) %. $-%80/2-# %#8% 429$ .& +.&$ 1$&-.,-7.,'.2,%/;7.++2%%$))87.2%;!

%<8-%#$78-$.4%#$1&.-$7(%2.,%#8%877(-$)8&9$$, (+8& .,($$18: $#%8800(8*)2-# 8(-#2:'8;8,) (,,8

#8,8/.,*<2%#.%#$&(,:,.<,1$&-.,-#2'87:$)%#$%&(7:.<,$)0;"

6 8%:,24$1.2,%8,)7.++2%%$))87.2%;!

$8&,$) -$,2.& 7.(,-$/ 811$8&2,* 4.& %#$ 811$//8,%- <.(/) -(0+2%%#8%%#$&$2-92&%(8//;,.$92)$,7$%.$-%80/2-#%#$.44$,7$.4)87.2%; 8//$*$)/;7.++2%%$)0;%#$877(-$)! /$8&,$) 8&;8,8 <.(/)-(0+2%%#8%%#$)2-7/.-(&$-%8%$+$,%-8,)%#$&$7.9$&;.4%#$/..%$) 8&%27/$-2,7/()2,*%#$%&(7:8%%#$2,-%8,7$.4%#$877(-$)<.(/)*.%. $-%80/2-#%#8%%#$;#89$7.++2%%$))87.2%;!

#$$,%2&$$92)$,7$.4"8,)"6<8-%#.&.(*#/;-78,,$) 0;+$!#$;#89$-1.:$,80.(%%#$)87.2%;7.++2%%$).,%#$#2*#<8;0; (,:,.<,1$&-.,-!#$487%&$+82,-%#8%%#$;7.(/),.%2)$,%24;%#$877(-$) <#.487$)%#$%&28/! 8%#$&%#$;#89$7.+$.(%<2%#8,8--$&%2.,%#8%%#$ 877(-$)<#.<$&$4872,*%&28/<$&$,.%%#$1$&-.,-<#.7.++2%%$))87.2%;! .<2%,$--#8--1.:$,%.%#$487%%#8%%#$-$877(-$)18&%27218%$)2,%#$ 7.++2--2.,.4)87.2%;!

"-1.:$80.(%%#$)2-7/.-(&$-%8%$+$,%8//$*$)/;-(44$&$)0; %#$877(-$)!(%2%2-%.0$,.%$)%#8%,.&$7.9$&;<8-$44$7%$)08-$)., -(7# )2-7/.-(&$ -%8%$+$,%! #$&$4.&$ %#$ 8//$*$) )2-7/.-(&$ -%8%$+$,% -(44$&$)0;%#$877(-$)0$4.&$"/..-$-2%-$92)$,%28&;98/($! 5!

.</$%+$%8:$(1%#$$92)$,7$.4"A 8+$-# #8,)$& <#.-1.:$80.(%%#$8&&$-%.4%#$-$877(-$)%#$)2-7/.-(&$-%8%$+$,%- 2,)292)(8//;-(44$&$)0;%#$+8,)%#$&$7.9$&;.4%#$+8%$&28/.0'$7%-! ,-1$7%.&8%;88&:8-##8)&$7$29$)-$7&$%2,4.&+8%2.,%#&.(*# .,-%80/$ (,2/ (+8&!#$;#89$8/-.*.%2,4.&+8%2.,%#8%/..%$)8&%27/$-<$&$-%.&$) 2,%#$*.).<,-2%(8%$)8%6()#8*8&$/#2!"A<#.<8-818&%.4

%#$%$8+4.&+$)0;,-1$7%.&8%;88&:8-#<8-<82%2,*4.&89$#27/$%. 8&&29$8%%#$*.).<,8-1$&%#$-$7&$%2,4.&+8%2.,&$7$29$)0;%#$1./27$! 77.&)2,*/; (,,88&&29$).9$&%#$&$8,)%#&$$1$&-.,-<#.*.%).<, 4&.+%#$9$#27/$.1$,$)%#$*.).<,!#$1./27$18&%;#$8)$)0;,-1$7%.& 8%;88&:8-#-$2D$)%#$/..%$)8&%27/$-4.(,)2,%#$-82)*.).<,! 6!

-&2*#%;1.2,%$).(%0;%#$/$8&,$)-$,2.&7.(,-$/811$8&2,* 4.&%#$811$//8,%-%#$/..%$)8&%27/$-2,%#$*.).<,<$&$-$2D$)0;%#$ 1./27$1&2+8&2/;,.% 08-$) ., %#$)2-7/.-(&$-%8%$+$,% -(44$&$) 0;%#$ 877(-$)0(%08-$).,%#$-$7&$%2,4.&+8%2.,%#$;&$7$29$)!,.%#$&<.&)- %#$)2-7/.-(&$-%8%$+$,%8//$*$)/;-(44$&$)0;%#$877(-$)#8),.%/$)%#$ 1./27$18&%;%.)$%$7%%#$8&%27/$-4&.+%#$*.).<,!9$,.%#$&<2-$%#$-$ %#&$$877(-$),8+$/;8&9$$, (+8&$$18: $#%88,)8*)2-# 8(-#2:

<#.*.%).<,4&.+%#$78&)&29$,0; (,,8.1$,$)%#$*.).<,8,) $,%$&$)2,%.%#$*.).<,! #$1./27$18&%;#$8)$)0;,-1$7%.&8%;8 8&:8-#8/-.$,%$&$)2,%.*.).<,8,)4.(,)%#$/..%$)8&%27/$-/;2,*.9$& %#$&$! !

,%#$80.9$487%-8,)72&7(+-%8,7$-%#$)2-7/.-(&$-%8%$+$,%- 8//$*$)/;-(44$&$)0;%#$877(-$)#8),.%/$)%.%#$)2-7.9$&;.4+8%$&28/ .0'$7%-!#$&$4.&$%#$)2-7/.-(&$-%8%$+$,%--(44$&$)0;%#$877(-$)78,,.% 0$&$/2$)(1.,8-812$7$.4$92)$,7$!#$487%&$+82,-%#8%8//%#$%#&$$ 877(-$)811$//8,%-<$&$4.(,)2,%#$*.).<,8/.,*<2%#8&%27/$-/..%$)4&.+ %#$%&(7:)&29$,0;"!"A#8-78%$*.&278//;)$1.-$)%#8%%#$/..%$) 8&%27/$-<$&$&$7.9$&$)4&.+%#$*.).<,2,%#$1&$-$,7$.4%#$-$877(-$)! A!

,)$&$7%2.,6//(-%&8%2.,E8F.4%#$,)28,92)$,7$7%

A %#$ .(&%78,1&$-(+$%#8%8+8,<#.<8-2,1.--$--2.,.4%#$-%./$,*..)- -..,84%$&%#$%#$4%<8-$2%#$&%#$%#2$4.&#8)&$7$29$)%#$*..)-:,.<2,* %#$+%.0$-%./$,(,/$--#$7.(/)877.(,%4.&#2-1.--$--2.,! @!

#$&$2-,.$92)$,7$%#8%%#$811$//8,%-<$&$2,9./9$)2,%#$ 7.++2--2.,.4.44$,7$.4)87.2%;! (%%#$1&.-$7(%2.,#8-$-%80/2-#$) %#&.(*#%#$$92)$,7$.4"A%#8%8//%#$%#&$$877(-$)$,%$&$)2,%.%#$ *.).<,2, $/#2 <#27# /$)%. %#$-$2D(&$ .4%#$/..%$) 8&%27/$-! . $B1/8,8%2.,<8-.44$&$)0;%#$877(-$)8-%.#.<%#$;78+$2,%.1.--$--2., .4%#$/..%$)8&%27/$-!#$&$4.&$1&$-(+$%#8%%#$877(-$)#8)&$7$29$) %#$/..%$)8&%27/$-:,.<2,*%#$+%.0$-%./$,! C!

" .,-%80/$ 892,)$& 8/-. -1.:$ 80.(% %#$ )2-7/.-(&$ -%8%$+$,%+8)$0;877(-$)8*)2-#8/.,*<2%#877(-$) (,,8<#27#/$)%.

%#$&$7.9$&;.4%#$%&(7:! $7.9$&;.4%&(7:8%%#$2,-%8,7$.4877(-$) 8*)2-# *29$- &2-$ %. %#$ 1&$-(+1%2., %#8% 877(-$) 8*)2-# 8/.,*<2%# 8,.%#$&877(-$)#8)&$7$29$)%#$-%./$,%&(7:! %8,;&8%$2%78,,.%0$ 1&$-(+$)%#8%877(-$)8*)2-#8/.,*<2%# (,,87.++2%%$))87.2%;-2+1/;

08-$).,%#$&$7.9$&;.4%&(7:8-877(-$)8*)2-#<8-,.%2)$,%242$)8-.,$ .4%#$)87.2%-<#.#2'87:$)%#$%&(7:8,)/..%$)%#$8&%27/$-! =!

$8&,$) 8&;8,8-(0+2%-%#8%%#$877(-$)2,487%&$4(-$) %.18&%27218%$2,%#$%$-%2)$,%24278%2.,18&8)$!#$&$4.&$1&$-(+1%2.,<2// #89$%.0$)&8<,%#8%%#$;89.2)$)%$-%2)$,%24278%2.,18&8)$%.-#2$/)%#$+ 4&.+%#$7#8&*$.4)87.2%;!42,)%#8%%#$&$2-,.<$2*#%2,%#$80.9$ -(0+2--2.,+8)$0;/$8&,$) 8&;8,8!$-%2)$,%24278%2.,18&8)$27.,)(7%$)%.7#$7:%#$7.(&-$.42,9$-%2*8%2.,8,)8/-.%.4872/2%8%$%#$

@ <2%,$--$-%.&$78//%#$2&+$+.&;! )$,%24278%2.,)(&2,*%#$7.(&-$.4%$-% 2)$,%24278%2.,18&8)$2-,.%8-(0-%8,%28/$92)$,7$!#$2)$,%24278%2.,0;%#$ <2%,$--$- 0$4.&$ .(&% )(&2,* %#$ 7.(&-$ .4 %&28/ 8/.,$ 2- -(0-%8,%28/ $92)$,7$! ,%#$2,-%8,%78-$"8,)"6<#.8&$%#$+.-%+8%$&28/ <2%,$--$-482/$)%.2)$,%24;%#$877(-$)8-)87.2%-! !

#$,$B%G($-%2.,%#8%8&2-$-4.&7.,-2)$&8%2.,2-<#$%#$&%#$ 877(-$)811$//8,%-7.(/)0$7.,927%$)(,)$&$7%2.,6 ! ,81$&(-8/ .4%#$$,%2&$+8%$&28/-.,&$7.&)42,)%#8%%#$&$2--1$724277#8&*$8*82,-% %#$877(-$)(,)$&$7%2.,6 !(%(,4.&%(,8%$/;%#$%&28/ .(&%#8) ,.% )2-7(--$) %#$ 7.++2--2., .4 %#$ 80.9$ 7#8&*$ 0; %#$ 877(-$)! ,8-+(7#8-%#$877(-$)#8)487$)%#$7#8&*$(,)$&$7%2.,6 8- <$//%#$&$2-,.2+1$)2+$,%4.&%#$ .(&%%.7.,927%%#$877(-$)(,)$& $7%2.,6 !

,+;7.,-2)$&$) 92$<%#$1&.-$7(%2.,+2-$&80/;482/$)%. $-%80/2-#%#8%877(-$)811$//8,%-7.++2%%$)%#$.44$,7$(,)$&$7%2.,5= !(%2%#8-0$$,1&.9$)%#8%%#$877(-$)#89$7.++2%%$)%#$.44$,7$ (,)$&$7%2.,6 !

#$&$4.&$%#$7.,927%2.,8,)-$,%$,7$18--$)0;%#$%&28/ .(&% 8-8*82,-%877(-$)8&9$$, (+8&.,($$18: $#%8800(8,) 8*)2-# 8(-#2:'8;(,)$&$7%2.,5=&$8)<2%#$7%2.,56 -%8,)- -$%8-2)$0(%%#$;8&$7.,927%$)(,)$&$7%2.,6 8,)-$,%$,7$)%.%#$ 1$&2.)8/&$8);(,)$&*.,$0;%#$+8,)%.18;842,$.4>$87#8,)2, )$48(/%%.(,)$&*.84(&%#$&1$&2.).45+.,%#-&2*.&.(-2+1&2-.,+$,%! 77.&)2,*/;%#$ &2+2,8/11$8/-

.48,)

C 66.48&$18&%/;8//.<$)! 5!

77(-$)8&9$$,.,($$18: $#%88&$.,082/!#$082/ 0.,)-$B$7(%$)0;%#$+-#8//-%8,))2-7#8&*$)-(0'$7%%.%#$18;+$,%.4 42,$.4>$87#.,.&0$4.&$6!C!!442,$2-,.%182)<2%#2,%#$ 1$&2.)-%21(/8%$)80.9$%#$;-#8//(,)$&*.%#$)$48(/%-$,%$,7$! 6!

77(-$)8*)2-# 8(-#2:'8;2-(,)$&*.2,*%#$-$,%$,7$!$ 0$&$/$8-$).,18;+$,%.442,$.4>24#2-7(-%.);2-,.%&$G(2&$)2, 7.,,$7%2.,<2%#8,;.%#$&78-$!442,$2-,.%182)0;#2+#$-#8//(,)$&*. %#$)$48(/%-$,%$,7$!

(/;

(/8%2 !