Jogdhyan v. State Of Haryana And ANR

  
 

      
   



 !"#$# %&'("!) *++ ,,!)- / / -!- %0!"!)!!)'!)%-(  *

)-/ 1  231 4 
4 441  531 4 
 1 


)-  14446,,$ )6%'.%7!- 86-( 146-6) !9+!,$'.%7!- 0%-( ,,!)-4

1 
$4 7%9+,!6)!)-6/!++ ,,!)-

-(6/% -4 6/ !&&6 ' %0 -(   : '&9 )- '!- ' 44 +!// " -( ''6-6%)!, //6%)/ '& ;<7, /6.

% -0% 6)% /69 !&!6)/- =%9 )>$ ?  @/( -!$ !7A 6--6)& )- %4$ )!9 ,"$ !)'(66)&($ )'

 7-6%)/
!)'
4 0!7-/6)!)!%87%9+!///(%)%00 )) //!" -!6,/!

/-!- '!/

,%8

  ) 44B$ -(  9!6!&  %0 

-! '! &(-  %0 ,,!)-8!//%, 9)6C '86-( )-%44( 7% +, (!' -8% 6// /4  - !% )' 4 !494 %) 44$ ! +(%)679 //!& 8!/ 6.

&!'6)&-(

-!4 0- ( !6)&-(6/&6 0) 8/$-( ,,!)-!,%)&86-((6/0!96,"

/ !)' ,!-6.

!7( ' (  9!-69%)6!, (%9 4  ( !' %'"%0

-!8!/0% )',"6)&6)-( .

!)'!41!@/%0 %+ %)( ) 7@8

)%-67 '4( ,%%'8!/%%C6)&% -0%9 (  9% -(4   

',  %0 / /+676%) 8!/ !6/ ' -(!- 

-! 8!/ /-!)& ,!- ' 86-( -(  ( ,+ %0 %+ )- %4$ !9 6)&($? ,'

+6)&(!)'-( 860 !: ; -(!)6>4
-/

-(!- !,6  %) -8%-(

 %77!/6%)/ '600

 %0 %+6)6%) (!' 7%++ ' +

-8

) -(  +!-6 /4  .

) /(  8!/ -! )-

)-%4%)-( + 96/ -(!-(6/,60 (!'

)/+%6,

"& --6)&9!6 '86-(( 4 ) -( !/6/ %0 7%9+,!6)-$ <4 $ 0%9!,
 8!/

&6/-

'4( 6).

/-6&!-6%)8!/7%99 '4-!- )-/%0

.!)- 86-) / 8

7%'

'4 
)A /- +%7

'6)&/ !)' +%/- 9%- 9 <!96)!-6%) %0 '

!' %'" 8

 7%)' 7- '4  ) 7%9+, -6%) %0 6).

/-6&!-6%)$ 7(!,,!) !&!6)/- )- %4 8!/+ )-

 !1!&6/-!- 40- 7%9+,"6)&-( +%.6/6%)/%0 7-6%) $-( 7!/ 8!/7%996-- '-%-( % -%0 //6%)/4

  )- %4 8!/ 7(!&  /(

' )'

 7-6%)
!)'6)-( !,- )!-6.

 )'

 7-6%)
 %'

'!- '4B44
)%'

-%+%.

6-/7!/ $-( +%/ 7 -6%) <!96) !/ 9!)" !/ 060-

) 86-) / !)' +,!7 ,6!)7  %) -( '%7 9 )-/<4 -%<4$1!@!)'1!@4
) '

)- %4 <!96) ' 1 @ /( !'!. !/ = !)' - )'

' '%7 9 )-/ <4$ <4 !)' <4D4 -6!,% -!)!,"/ 6)& !-'

-!6,4 %8 $ 6- 0% )' -(!- -(  %0 +%/ 7 -6%) 86-) ,!7@/ 7  !)' ) ,6!

 !)' !77%'6)&," !7A 6--

)-%44 !7A 6--!,%0 )-%46// :

7-9!-- 7(!,, )&

-(6/% -4 3 !) ' 7% )/ , 0% -(  !++ ,,!)- / 96-/ -(!- -( !7A 6--!, %0 )- %4  8!/ )%- ' %) +%+ !++ 76!-6%)%0 4(

-!-%%@+,!7 86-(6) )"

!/%09!6!& !)'$-(

$6-8!/!5'%8"'

!-(5 !)'-(!-( ( / !)';

)-%4>8!/ /+%)/6 0%-( /!9 4%)/6/- )- =%&'("!);!++ ,,!)->!)'

= (!/(? 9!$ %-( %0-( '$7% +, '86-(-( '67!, $ 7, !," /-!

,6/( ' -(  69+,67!-6%) %0 -( !++ ,,!)-6)-( 769

  =  (!.

 &6.

) %  -(% &(-0 , 7%)/6'

!-6%) -% -( !& 9 )-/!'.!)7 ", !) '7% )/ ,0%-( ,,!)-!)' 7%'4 %)7 ',"$ -( !-( %0 

-! (!' -!@ ) +,!7 86-(6)/ )"

!/%09!6!& 4(

6/)%'

)6!,%)-( +!- %0 )- %4 -(!- '

!-( %0 

-! (!' %77 ' '

 -% (!)&6)&4  9!6) +%6)- 0% '

96)!-6%)

 / 6/ -(!- 8( -(

-!8!/!'%8"'

!-(!)'0!,,/86-(6)  !9 6- %0  7-6%) 
 % /(  8!/ 6)- )-6%)!,," 9 '

'4  $6-8% ,'

!++%+6!- -%/7!)-( 86-(7!

!)' !++ 76!- /!9

=%&'("!)$! -(%%0

/6'

/)!!-6)&-( 6)76'

)-/ %0  6,,- !-9 )- !)' (!!//9 )- 7! / ' -% (6/ '! &(- %)-( + 96/ %0'

9!)'%0'%8"!)'-! )-6)&

)-%40%/+%6,6)&( 9!6 ',60 $!,/%'

+%/ '-(!- )%'

9!)'%0'%8"8!/9!'

!--( -69 %09!6!& %0(6/ '! &(- 4( '%8"!-67, /8

)!/+ -( 6%8)86/(4  A !

,

-8

) (6/ '! &(-  !)' )- %4 -%%@ +,!7  !0-  %)  "

! %0 -(  9!6!&  !)' / )- A !

, (!'-!@ )+,!7 !0- !% )'-8%9%)-(/%0-( !,6 A !

,4

 8!/ !) !'96//6%) %) -(  +!- %0 -(6/ 86-) // -(!- (6/ '! &(-  ;'

'> 8!/ / 00 6)& 0%9 '

//6%)4   ( 0!7- 9%0'

//6%)!)'+%/-+!- 9'

//6%)8!/+%.

 

=4 !@/(+!,(!9!!)' =444!-(,!.6'

+%-/ <4 !)'<4 $ /+ 7-6.

,"4=(6, ,!

%!-6)&-( - 9%0 +%/-+!- 9 '

//6%)$ = 4 !@/(+!, (!9! '

+%/ -(!--(6/'

//6%)7%99 /!06-(%0!7(6,'-%-( ,!'6 /!)'&!.6-"%0-(!-6/-%-( <- )--(!--( +!-6 )-9!" '%!)"(!9-%/ ,0%7(6,'%!)"

%'" ,/ 4 =E4

+!,6$ '67!, 0067 $3 %/+6-!,$?  @/( -!(!/+%.

+%/- 9%- 9 +%- <4  !)' 0% )' )% 9!@ %0 .6%,  %) -( !' %'"%0'

'4

= (!/( ? 9!$ %-(  %0 '

'  (!' 9!'

"+%//6 00%-/-%'

+%/ -(!-(6//6/- ;'



-!>'6 '%)!77% )-%0'

9!)'%0'%8"$ -( 0!6, '-% +%.

/%4
)(6/'

+%/6-6%)$( !--( 06/-6)/-!)7 7!9 86-( -(6/.

/6%)-(!-'

9!)'%0'%8"8!/9!'

-( '6')%- /+ 760" -( -!6,/ %0 !-67, /$ !-(  !'96-- ' -(!- (6/ /6/- ;'

'

-!>8!/@ +-+%+ ,"6)( 9!-69%)6!,(%9 0%!

% -%) "

!%09!6!& 4  %-(  0%9!, 86-) / (!.

 +%.

' 7 -!6) '%7 9 )-/8(67()

')%--%

'6/7 // '$6)!/9 7(!/$-(

6/)%6)7696)!-6)& (  %0 =%&'("!) !)' = (!/( ? 9!'% /)%-+%.

-(!-!)"'

9!)'%0'%8"8!/9!'

)-%4$F/%%)

!-(G%0'

'

-!4 --( -69 %09!6!& $-( '%8"!-67, /8

)!--( 6 %8)86/(4( 86-) /'6')%-/+ 760"!)"!-67, /8(67(

 #

)-% )-%4$!-(

8!/!)!'96//6%) -(!- '

' 

-! 8!/ / 00 6)& 0%9 '

//6%)4   % 6)76'

)-%7 ,-"(!/

)+%.

'%) 7%'-%/(%8-(!--( '8!/7%9+ ,, '-%7%996-/ 676'

!-( +%/6-6%)/ %0 =E 4

+!,6$ = 4 !@/(+!, (!9! !)' = 444!-(,! 7, !,"  +%.

 -(!-  -( ' 8!/ / 00 6)& 0%9+%/-+!- 9'

//6%)4( &!.6-"%0-(6/'6/ 6/-% <- )--(!--( 9%-( 9!"7! / !)"(!9-%/ ,0%7(6,' %!)"

%'" ,/ 4( /$-( 9 '67!, $6)-( !

!)" 86-( &!'-%'

9!)'%0'%8"$7, !,"/ && /-/ -(!-

-!(!'-!@ ) <- /- +-%06)6/(( ,60 $6)!/9 7( !/$  (  ,60

7!9  96/ !

 8(67( 0%7 ' (  -% 7%996- / 676'

4
) .6 8 %0 -(  !0% /!6'$ 8  06)' )% 9 6- 6) -( )-!++ !,477%'6)&,"$6-6/'6/96// '4 ;4 441>  ;

1 
>    

 !"#$# ?