High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/362/2014dismissed

Reshma v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-04-25Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary10 pages

" #$ %&

'() *+, -'.' ",,

/++0 ,(' * ' +0+,' 1# 231 " "1 431 " 1

'+,# 1"$&"+$ 05 6,7$,( 1 8($)+&05 6,

,(+, 18$997&00$,$ +&/+ 1"((.$&05 6,

' +0+, &&+0% 0/:,0;.' !

1 & ($'$'' .,

<.09)+,

6 +5$6,$ +0 '+,+6 ''0 :/ ,( 00$,$ + "''$ +' .09& ).+ 9 , 90($ ' 7 ' $+6$ 19$',,& .5+$.',$6 0&).+9, 6 +5$6,' +0+, !

,( 6(9' .+0 "6,$ + 0 7$,( "6,$ ! +0 , +(+6 '+,+6

$)$'

+)+,

,(' %

' ! 7 6 +5$6,0

))$''$

+6.+0"6,$ 07$,('6,$ ! +0 '+,+60 , .+09 ,( /' $9 .' $)$'

+)+, +0 , / $+

'=&> 6( 7$,( 0 .,6.'&7('&' %7'6 +5$6,0

))$''$

+6 .+0 "6,$ +' +0 0 7$,( '6,$ + ! 75& 6 +'$0$+9 ($' <.5+$$,/ 5$0

0 0,0

?? & '+,+6 ,

% 7' 00 , : 0, :/ ,( $+6$ 19$',,& .5+$ .',$6 0& ).+ 9 , 90($ +($+9+0.'$+9,(6 0&,( $+6$ 19$',,'0' % + :,$ + ( +, ($+ $0 6$)$+ 6 )$+, 9$+',,(' %'7'1+ (3& ,(,(+",,$ + .'

$6&

$6",,$ +((6((.$

+,(9,$ +'$+,$,(,((.':+0$) (0 ,@+ + 6 +,6, ,( )+9 6(0

' % "

+. A ($@( .+0 )&

% =& ,( '$0 ' % 5$'$,0 ( ( .' ,

@ ( (.':+0 +97$,(($), $$9,,()+9 6(0 + / "$+9( (0 '+ ( (.':+0 $) 7$,( % .+0 26 6@&'((09 +, ,(

$0'7$,()'

((.':+0 75&'(6 .0+ ,

$+0((.':+0,(5+('

+6 .0+ , $+0($) , + ( .& 1 ($+0& ( : ,($+7& 7($ ,.+$+9 ),( $0'(0'+,(' %,/$+9, $)) ,$) )$'0:/1 ($+0

,,6,0 '5 '

+' +0 ,( 6($0+& 7( 7

/$+9+:/ +'$+91 ($+0 &' , % 0 7/ ) ,( ' , 5$9 $'0 ,( +,,(,( 6(0:

$) 7'/$+9+ )+9 ,$+,( 6(0($+

),$ +7'9$5+, ,( $6

$6",,$ +((6((.$90$+9,('$0 .+

,.+,$+6$0+, +5$'$,$+9,(6

66.+6& ,( $6 6 00 ,( ',,)+,

,( +,& 7(. +&

) B 0,0

% = .+0 "6,$ +' &! 9$+', ' % 7' 9$',0 ( ', ) ,) C)$+,$ + ,( 00 :

06'0$) 7'6 +0.6,0, &

(,@ 75&,( $6$+6 .'$ +7$,(' % 0$0 + , $+$,$, +/ 6,$ + 9$+', ,()& 7( 7 +/ ,(,+$+9 ,( +, +0 ( )$/ )):' ( +0+,' % '

.'0 0 9, / )@' $@ D()& $,,E ,6 5+ ( 6($+9 ".$+,+0+,

$6& ).+ 9 + = +0 ,( ,$ + .)+ $9(,' ))$''$ + 0$0 + , ', ,( $6 )6($+/ $+, ) ,$ + F(+ +;.$/ 7' )0

) 1+ ( 3& ,( ,(+ ",,$ + .'

$6&

$6 ",,$ + ((6((.$ 90$+9 ,( ',,.'

,( 6'& ( '( 70($':$'(7'5/(+'$ +,(,,( '$0 ",,$ + .'

$6 7 .0 ,7$', ( ',,)+, +0

,(,

,(7$,+'''., + +6,$

,( $6&,( )$+,7' $0 ($)$+/5$0+67'0( ,&,( % 7 '.)) +0 .+0 "6,$ +' > 07$,('6,$ +! &7('&1+ (3&" 7' '.)) +0 .+0 "6,$ 0 7$,( '6,$ + ! , 6.$+9,('+6

'$066.'0& ,(6'7'6 ))$,,0, ,( .,

"''$ +' + $'

),$& 7(+$, ,+'$0 ,(, ,( 5$'$ +'

"6,$ +' G HG5H +0 G HG5$H

,( "6(0.0 ',' I "6(0.0 $:' G 5+,$

, 6$,$'H6,& ?B?7,,6,0&,(6'7'''$9+0 , ,(0'$9+,0 ., , ($+9 +0 .'$+9 ,( 6 0' + ,( $+,

6(9& +

,(66.'0&+)/&1+ (3& " 7' 0$'6(90& 7('& ' % 7 6(9 '(,0 .+0 "6,$ +' +0 0 7$,( '6,$ + ! 5$0 0 0,0 ?% .$+9 ,( +0+6/

60$+9'& ,( $6 (0 $+$,$,0 ,( 6 '. 60$+9' :/ $$+9 ,( .+,6 , B 7($6(7''

00, :,,6(07$,(,( )$+,6'

+ 0 , 5 ( 6'& ,( +, C)$+0')+/'

.7$,+''' (+,$$+6$)$+,$+95$0+6 7' ., , ,( % + 0 +6& ,(/ C)$+0 $5 7$,+''' ,($+9+06 .+'

,(,(,$'& ,(,$ .,'7' $+6$19$',,6 +5$6,0+0 '+,+60,(' +0+,' %&'0,$0:

5&$+ +$+9,

,(<.09)+, , )/ : 5+, , )+,$ + ( ,(, 0.$+9 ,(+0+6/

60$+9':

,($' .,&' +0+, !1+9('6 '0($'/'+0$'+ ) $+,(7 0 +0& ,(

& 5$0 0 0,0 B %& ,( '+, ;.($)',

0:,0 3+06 .+'

,(+,9.0,(,,( $).9+0 <.09)+, +0 0'

'+,+6 :'0 '.)$'' +0 +<6,.' +5$+60 7$,( 5$0+6 5$:& ,( ' & +0 % 7 6 +5$6,0& :., ,(, +5$6,$ +0 '+,+6 0) +',:/ $' $+6 +'$',+, 7$,( ,( 5$0+6 +0& ,(

& ' +0+, +0'( .0(5'

:+6 +5$6,0.+0"6,$ 07$,('6,$ +! +0'+,+60, .+09 $

$)$'

+)+, +0 ' % '( .0 (5 :+ '+,+60, .+09 $ $)$'

+)+, 3+0 6 .+' $+9

,( ",, (' 9.0 ,(, ,( $).9+0 <.09)+,

6 +5$6,$ + +0

'+,+6 6, +0 9/ <.',$ $0& ,(.'& ;.$+ $+, +6 3+06 .+'

' &+0%(' 9.0 ,(, ,( 6 +5$6,$ + 6 00 '

& $' :'0 6$,$

5$0+6 ( '+,+6 ,

' +0+, +0$''

+ , +,(C6''$5'$0 , 9$5$+9 . ,( .9(, . 6 +'$0,$ + , ,( 9.)+,'05+60:/+06 .+'

,(,$'&7

$+0,('+,6 ),/)$,''

,('

+' ,

7 "

' ,( 9.)+, ,(, ' % "

+. A ($@( $' , : '+,+60 , .+09 $ $)$'

+)+, .+0 "6,$ + $' 6 +6+0& ,( ') $' )$,''& $+').6( '& ,( $+6$ 19$',,& , 6 +'$0$+9 ,( 6,' +0 6$6.)',+6'

,( 6'& 6), ,(6 +6.'$ +,(,.+0,( 5$'$ +'

"6,$ %G HGH

,( .5+$ .',$6 G +0 ,6,$

($0+H 6,& G

'( ,& J6, 2H& ( '( .0 : '0 + :,$ + (, ,

& :/ +/ ',,6(

$)9$+,$ +& 6++ , : '$0 , : '6.,$5 +/'$'& $+').6( '& "6,$ + %G HG9H

,( 6, $+,$ 5$0',(,,( 0)/&$ $,'

,($+@' $,&0$6,,( <.5+$ , : '0 + :,$ , '+0 ($) $+ '6$ ( )

$ 0 + , ) ,(+ ,( /' )@ $, ) 6& ' % 6 .0 + , (5 :+ '+, , '6$ ( )

) ,(+ ,( /' +'$0$+9 5 6,'+06$6.)',+6'&70 + , $+0 +/<.',$ $6,$ +, $+, 7$,(,('+,+6,700 :/,( 0:$+99/'.',$+: ( ,(9.)+,,(,' +0 '( .0 (5 :+ 6 +5$6,0 +0 '+,+60 .+0 "6,$ 07$,('6,$ +! $''

'.:',+6'' (5.,$

5$0+60$6,',(,$, ($' ', :,(&

% = ,( 06'0 $) 7'

$',/ '+ :/ / "$+9( $+ ,( 6 )+/

' +0+, %"

+.A($@( 75&,($'7$,+''7'C)$+0 $+ $)$+/ 5$0+6& :., 7' 9$5+ 9 :/ :/ ,( '6.,$ + ,'.)) +$+9

' %+ ,( 5$0+6

F! 1 ($+0& ,( 6,.)

$)) ,$+9 ,( 06'0 $) :/ ' % 7' ',:$'(0 $' '+6 :

6($+9 ,( 6

66.+6 $' + , 0$'.,0 :/ ,( 0 +6 7$,+'''&

+)/&F +0"$+9(&"+6('7'F" 1+ (3&7( '6$ $6/0 '0,(,,( $(0+ , ),/C,$+9.$'(0 +,($5$'$,, ,(' ,

'() G+,H 0 '0 ,(, ( (.':+0 $) (0 +,0 $+, 6 +,6, 7$,( % "

+. A ($@(

)+9 6(0 .+0 )&

% =&' %5$'$,0 ( ( ) +0 '@0 ( (.':+0 , 66 )+/ ($)

$$9,$+9 ,( )+9 6(0 (.':+0 ,

@ %>

) ( +0 66 )+$0 ($) 7' '+ $+ ,( )+/

( (.':+0 :/ / "$+9( .+0 26 6@& '( 7+, , ,( $0' 7$,( )'

06'0 (.':+0"(+0('

+6 .0+ , $+0$) , ''$+9

+( .&1 ($+0&: ,($+7&(0'+,( %,/$+9, $)) ,$) $'(. +0 6/& ,,6,0 '5 '

+' +0 6($0+ +';.+,/& ' % + 7/ ) ,( ' , ( $6 7' $))0$,/ $'0

,( '$0 .+

,.+, $+6$0+, + ,( :'$'

',,)+,

+,&

) 7' 6 00 ( 5$0+6

,($' 7$,+'' +0 F! 1 ($+0 $' 0./ 6 :

,0 :/ ,( 5$0+6

-$</ 8(+97& 7( '6$ $6/ 0 '0,(,D,(6.'

0,($+,($'6'7')+.

',+9.,$ + G,( ,,$+9H +0 ,(, ,( :.+' + ,$60 5 ,( :

0/ 7 ',) ,) $+ +,.*E ( :: ,$),(,'0:,7+$+<.$'+00,(7' $+0' $+',+,+ .'(.'&$,$'7 50 +6 0,(, , ,( $+6$0+,& ,.,( 6) ., ) ,( ) .,(

'() G+,H +0

F! ($+0 7($6( ,(/ C''0 ' +,+ .'/ $+ ,( $+

),$ + 9$5+ , ,( $6 75&,( $60$0+ ,$+$,$,+/'.:',+,$5 60$+9'+0,7$',0,(',,)+,'

,(7$,+'''

$,' 7+

0', /$+9,( '$,$5+06 +6,5$0+6 (.'& 5$0+6 5$:

6 0 .+):$9.

.'/ 5$+6' ,(, ,( 06'0 (0 9 + 7$,( %"

+.A($@(3, +&(7'

.+0 00&,(,,

&$+($')+9 6(0 ' & +0 % +9 7$,( ,($ 66 )$6& $ ' ! G'$+606'0H(0,$0, 0', /,(5$0+6'( 7$+9 $,, :6'

:.+$+9&:.,,(,,

7'$+,5+0:/ ,('+6

F!1 ($+0($'5$0+6'6$:',(

' +0 +0 ,($ 66 )$6 ! G'$+6 06'0H +/ $+ 0', /$+9 ,( 5$0+6'( 7$+9$,, :6'

:.+$+9+0&,(

& ,(/ 6++ , : (0 9.$,/ .+0 "6,$ +' 0 7$,( '6,$ +!

(6$,$

5$0+6:/,(,$ .,+0 $+6$ 19$',, $+ 6($+9 ,( 6 +6.'$ + ,(, % 7' ',/ '+ $+ ,( 6 )+/

,( 06'0 $) +0

.+0 ).00 $+ ($' )+9

6(0+0' &+0%$+ 0, 0', / ,(5$0+6(0', $,(:

06'0&0 '+ , ;.$+/$+, +6:/,($' ., + 5$7

'$0 0$'6.''$ +& 7 $+0 + )$, $+ ,( '+, +0 ,( ') $' 66 0$+9/ 0$')$''0 G "1H 1 H $ %& 8