Mukhtar Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And Another
!"!
#$ % %
!" #
$
%%
!" $ &' % ( (()
* & '"(')'* "+,' -(!.
//0112/#3##'"
-!"#4.
//0122/#3## ' %'* "+,'- '"!'
* "+,' (!.
//0122/#3##'"
-!"#.
//0112/#3## ( !" )'5*
* 6'7 ( 8(".-,8 (()
*+ % ,'- (,::"('55"!-7('7+!*'*(; ' -(:'+*'*'+"(
*'"*,+*'* ,'"( # (!('+7-5" ,4<#-(..*7;
(!=8> '(8-
332*"'"323##3?*, 8 (--,* ,1#1*1#4*14*230*4<*4@-( .*<03 ,1#0- .'"""5'5"8"'5, ' '"' ''5'*5, , ''5'*'"*-,,'8"+"3@"'"@3##3?*
5"8" ,1#1*1#4*1#0*4<*4@-( .*<03*'"*'5-'55 ,> '5!,"8'8(-:*(,(7'-,:: ,:!: A /#'+"'7)(!' 1 B( 7((' ! ,': ! 7-(. 43##3##*(. *:'"(('-A',""
! "
$ % #
' ( * + ,- -,,.
/0$ ,,1 ,1,,.
2 2
+
'
0) %
#
%
3
*
'
4 5
1 6 % 45
% 2 .!
& &
7 %
% 7 45
7 45 % 8 6
' . / ,!,9
! 2 $
(
(
$ % #
' ( /0$ ,,1 ,1,,.
2 2
+
'
0) %
( #
%
3
*
'
4 5
1 6 % 45
% 2 .!
& &
7 %
% 7 45
7 45 % 8 6
' . / ,!,:
4 ('-:'""7;(. 43##3##*('+7 ,:!5")(7;(5'"'8',,"*'"*(5,"!(' 7!5',"," ! '5-(!*':"(. *7;( 5'" '8' ,,"* +'5 (' ( 5:C,:!:* '+"' (!*'"*(!"/,:!5''*'> 5 -7(*78 > '*7"(,:!:C5:78'
> 5-! ,,*78A," !',((+* (,:!:,:!5;"')*'"*(A(8' -'55 ,,"* ( !'5 '', ,," (-* ( 5'" '8'('!"('(5:C,:!:*"!"" !7;
(!*-=8> '(8-(
!'*'"*-':-
'7(+5 ';*'"*'5--:+,-"
*'"*-,:!
5* 78A," !',((*7"'8 2 "';*(5'", 5'!!'8-( '- 6'7*(' ,""7-(. *('(5-*',5':"7;(!*7( (!*,'78'"*':-(--,, "'8'( ',, "/!,,"*':
,('*( ,1#4*1#0*4<* 4@-( .*'/,:! "'75 0 )+* - ( ' 7 '8" ('-* ( '- !';*':'"7;(5'" ', 5*,'7',,!"7;(. (!/:'-"!558(+8 -'-:'"'8 :* "* !(-', :-'5'':*78:'"7-(. *7;( 5'", 5-(!*(''-!'-'! "
,?1..*'8'(',, "*
*'"* ( 8(',('8 7,:8-':"*7 (!, +",(';,::," ? (--,-('-':*':'")(A:+(:, 7;(5'", 5-(!*'"*'5(--,-(': :'"7;(5'", 5'!!'8-( '- 6'7*('( 5+'!'':','! 5'"'+",-(D75 !A. * "",'5"'*
*':
,(''! 5'C,, 8(*('( (!) ,4<#..*(,-,:! "8(5+'
--,*( 8(, 78:'"(!+- ,4<#..* '+"(8(. *-> '(8-,:'5!,"8*'C-
,:!5'*'(78",'""---:(!)8+',:'5 . *786"7,:"+/'/+(-',('"*-'!! '!!5,'( )+*(''57(5"(*('-!) +"(8(. *-()"!5 "*)(' ;5:'* 78!5',"(*;('7A,", ("-6 ,*'"* !+('7 -!,-';. ( 8('8(6',=-:
5'* ('7,:!5'"(*-, 78:'"(:'"'-
,4<#..*(,-> '(8-'
*,:'5!,"8 ,:!5'*;('5 7,+E/'/+E+'5"A,8*,:!" (!,!5*('-(',, "'"(,:!5'''('+'5"
5:*'"*)(( !(,+,-(',, "7,: :'"75'=.> 5;*('7:'"'"*(' 5(--, 8(7> '("*( 8(A,8-(!)+" ,4<# ..*' '"( *':
,('('-*":7";
--,'!!'8:
"*'!*"',;,*'"*)((--,' 5'!,'5' 5=+-. ! ,--, ,::"7;!
75,+'*)(5)=8(','!',;*( !,' 7 !:75; A," )+* ! +" A, - :7'8 !'*!5(+", !'*( !*(8(. '7'"* ( 8(, 8(:'"'- ,4<#..*(,*> '((
> '( ( ,:'5 !,"8 '!!'8 C( --, !' <
'!A',(5+'!''8'!(-(+",:'"7;( D75 !A. D,' !'
6
%
;
<% ) /0$ 3
%
2 !,
&
#
3 %
% =7 45
45
& /0$
#
3
%#
<
3
<%
%
% #
<
#
'
#
%# )
%
>
#
2
# 2 #
'
&
' # 7
)
%# %#
) % #
'
#
#
#
%#
<%
#
#
'
% 3
)
<%
#
%
) 4 5
<%
%:
@
,(--, ,1#4*1#04<*4@-( .
"*
*'!!'78'+'"'( *' '',(8 -(:7'8 !'-" !(8(. +", !' (-*(5:C,:!:*'+'5"5;"*6 78 +" .> 5;* + - ( '- --, ' / ,:! "'75*(. "":-',,!(,-( 5'" ', 5*('(. *:';( 8(, 8(:'"' - ,4<#..*> '((
'-:'()('(( !*( ,(',-(!78,+,"':')55'75'= > 5*("8-('5-(',, "*) 5" 5('':'"
( :5'*78,'
"(',, "*7") 5""-'("- ,
3
(:*':: !!('-:'"+)*'5 "+"-:(6 "8:""7;( 6'7'"';''8(. ,'5"'!"#
$ %
& '
''
&( )( '5* ( '7+ +) (' 7 '" (:(!*'"*7((':''55)" .> 5;*'-',,!8(!-(5'"'8',,"* (. !,"> '((
!'')55'(,,' #
,,"85;*(
!'*'"*(,,*'' - (':*'"*'5'55(,> '5!,"8*(,'8(-:* ''55> '("> '(! 1
!(,!;-("7!5',"(-5-(,," ,'
,(()
*- % %
0 ).
.
/ "0 1!#23/ "
$ "3
).
.
/ / /45 $ "3