Satbir v. State Of Haryana




    
  






 

!""

 

# $"

%%&& ' #  

()











%  !"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.,/01! "!

 $%&'( )*+,-(! ,$2( 0,$310,21) * 

#
#"+',
! ,

+
%%&&

#+'$+
#"-+,
" "&
! 
.&,
()

!.,/01! "!4

 /+"
%%&
"
" " ' 
-"
+
0'-1
 
 



 
2  


$)
&
" "&
#"
3'-,

+"4",
"
#"


2

 ,
4+$)
!!'
# $"
4 !+-
4" +

"

+
!
%'"+$&
'
#! "
5
 4" +
#! "
5
6*

&  
!+-
'
#! "
5
6*,
&-
4" + !!!'
+"1
#"-+

+"
%%&&
# $"
4
!"! 
  !

+
!11""

!
%'"+$&
'
#! "
5
6* 
'-
"-'
"1%"1


&"


%)
"



,7
 "
'&

%)1

",

' +
'-
"-'
"1%"1
 +
1 +
!!'
+"1
#"-+

+"
4
!8'" 

+ !+-
1
-"
+1
 /+
%!' "
 )
"
+

5 2  ,

&%+"!

1-
4
!"
1
.&
(%" &,
+"4",

*&"!
* ,
3" +49,
+"4",
" "1 "-
+
#0
4"

# $",
"

9 &),
+"4",
4
1" 
"
.&
(%" &,
+"4"
4" +
$'

 "0'"
#+
4


*.6#,
+ 9

!""-
"1 ", #6
1
:"+
&-
4" +
;(
+
#"-+
%!

.& (%" &,
+"4"
/+)
$ "
'88

<

!+
*.6#, + 9
"1&
4"

#'9+$"
4
'
%

+
$)
 #0
=+
+
4
9

19
  1 ,
+
&
+
+
+'$ 4
"-
"
1)
(
+
&
 
"&"-
&


2  , #'9+$"
+'$

"1&

 +
1"&)
11$
4
'
%
*.6#,
+ 9
"1&
-
+
  1
!

+
!
+
+
4 "

"&&-
-
:&
(
+'$
4
"-
"
6"
1) (
" "&4


 #0
4
1"

# $"


+, "

"&&-
:'!+
:&,
" "!
3"
(
" "&4
4 ""-
"
9
&)
#+
4
 '
$)
+
+'$
# $",
+"1 #"-+
$ +

# $",
" '


+"1
#"-+

+"
4"

+"1 #"-+

$"-"-
"'"!"
4)
/+)
+
"

%'
+1
 1
+"
4)
$'
&&
"
"

5 2  

&%+"!
1-
4 !"
$)
+
+
#0
4
$'
 
%'"-
9
"&

+
>6 4
-" 
6 "- "
4
!1%& 

!+&&
4
%'
'%
  !1%& "

&&
+
!

&
1&" "

/+
%!' "
?1"

'1$

4" 
"
'%%
 +
!
/+
  1 

+
!!'
4
&
!
'
#! " 5
 * 
/+)
"
+
!

+
%!' "
/+
!!'
?1" +
4" 
"
!
!!'
+"1
#"-+

+"
4 !8'" ,
+4,
# $"
4
!"! 

 !,

 "! +"$
(!,
+
%
%%&
<
!'&
%%"-

$+&

+
%%&& +1 &)
-'
+
+
%!' "
+
"&

%
" 
!

5 !'&
%%"-

+
#  
+1 &)
-'
+
+
%!' "
+ %
" 
!
$)
$&
'$

'%% 
+
0'-1
 

+
&
'
$&4

=
+
+
&
!'&

+
% "

-
+'-+ +
0'-1

!
)
!'&&) @ *=
1
"4
 ""
+
+
-" 
1&
>6,
;? *

*=5
+1
#"-+
+
%%
+
" 
%&
*=
#6
 
#"-+
%
+
" "- "
4
 ' 
 +"1


2  
#*
(8' 
""
+
! 
!!'
# $"
4 %'!
$)
+"
$ +
0$"
"
+
%&"!
%

@ 2  
*=

:'&%
*!+&,
+
!'! 
+
% 1 1 ?1" "
(
&
+"
"!
$)
"&"-
"" ,
;? *@
!!"-
 +"1,
+
!'

 +
4
$'

+"
!1%&"! "
/+
$'
4  1 1
"
 '
/+
%$$&
"1
+
&%
$ 4
 +
 ' %)
4
%"

$
$ 4
 5@
+'

 *=@
(
1
*9+
+
&
+"
"!
$)
"&"-
"" , ;? *
/+
! 
+
+

+"1
4
&
%!&
4+"!+
4 9
" 
%&"!
%"
$)
#6
1
:"+
"
11,
;? * *=
#6
1
:"+
%
+

5 2  ,

&%+"!

1-
4
!"
1
*&"!
* ,
.&
(%" &,
+"4",

+ !
+
#0
4
1" 
4" +
$'
"0'"
#+
4

 *.6#,
+ 9
(
!+
.&
(%" &

+ 
*.6#, + 9
(
1
"1&,
" "&4

#0
(
!
+
  1


"1&,
;? *
* 1 1
?1" "
4
!'! 

 *=

*%
:'1
+
&
&
+"
"!
$)
"&"- "" ,
;? *

(
%
<,
;? *

(
  
+
+
% "
4

!!"'
$'
4
"" 

*= 
"1&
"
+
1 "&
4" 
#+
%
+
+ +'$
4
"
1)
(
4
% 

("
 1
#0
4 1"
4" +
!!'
# $"
/+
1"-
$ 4
#0

# $"
4 &1"A
$'
@ 2
)
$!9

/+
"&4

#0
  
+"- +

$"-"-
"'"!"
4)
/+)
"

 &
+
"%' 
#+ !"
&%+"!
1-
1
"-+$'
#+
!1

94
+
#0 4


"
#+
&-
4" +
+
$ +"&4
#'
!1
 .1
(%" &,
+"4",
4+
+
1
#0
"
+
+%" &
 9
$'
+
"!"
#+
&
+
&&
+
!!'
%
"
+
!' 
+

"
#+
" "1 
$'
+
"!"

+
+'$
(
!1  
9"-
&
6
+
!?1" "
+
  
+
&


#0 4

@
)

&
/+)
4
B
9"&&

&
(
  1
4 !


2  

$'
7 
* 
"
*.6#,
+ 9
*=

"0
#"-+
"
+
$ +

!
#0
( %
+
+"
" 
4
&""-
"
9
&),
+"4"
(
"&4 4
1"-
1)

%!+)
"
+"
-
4
!
(
- "1 "
$'
+
"!"


2  
(
4

*.6#,
+ 9 
" ""
+
$)

#0
>#<
%
"
;? *

%
% ,
"'

"&
4  ! 
"
?+"$" 

$'!+

1
% "&&)
$'
+"

?+"$"  1
$9
%"!


!&'
-&
$-&
&-
4" +

!%% 1 &&"!
"-

@ /+
%%&&
+
&
%'!
=
1
+ !!"-

+"1,
+"1

# $"
4
1
+"
1+&&
!!'
+"1 +
&
+"
"&&-
$'
52
)
$!9
/+
4
"%' 
$ 4
+"1


!!'
# $"

%!+)
4
!
!!'
# $"

+"1 4
+"
$ +
"
& "

=
9
+
4
"-+$'

!!'
# $"

+ )

"!" ,

+"-
",
+
&
4

+
+'

# $" !!'
# $"
4

%
(
!1
& 

# $"

 +
"  
+
!&)
9
+"
4"

.&
(%" &,
+"4"
<
!'&
%%"-

$+&

%%&&
+1 &) -'
+
"
4

!

!!" &
"
!
#0
4
!9"- 1&

-
 
#0
+
"
"
+
+'

+
%%&&
6
"

+"1 
?%&"
'
4+
!"!'1 !
+"
4"
+
"
/+
!

+ %%&&
"
$&"

%
>#<
% ,
;? * ,
"'

"&
4  ! 
"
?+"$" 

?+"$" 
6
"
4

!!" ,

!

"& !'&
$
'

?+"$" 

?+"$" 
6
"

!
4+
#! "
@
 +
;"!
!
"
 ! 
*= 
"1&
+
! -"!

&&)
%
+
#0
+
&
+ +
1
"
4+"!+
+
4
%'

"
#+
"
'

$'
"0'" /+'-+
+
"
1
&)
"
&-"-
+
% ,
+4,
+
1
+ $
?%&"
$)
*= ,
4+
+'$
4
"
1)

+
4" 
 +"1  /+
%%&&
+
9
+
%&

&"$"
9"-
'%%
1 +
  1
=
9
+,
4+
4
+"
"-+$'
=
+
&) "!'
+
!
"!

=
9
+
!!"-

+"1, 
+"-
+
"

+
)

"!" ,
+
&
'+

+
+'
 # $"
(
4

%
" 

+
!&)
9
#0

.& (%" &,
+"4"
#  1

=
9
+


"%" !"!

@ &"$"
"

'$&
-
4%
6
!
+
!!'
"&

%
+
%&
 &"$",
+"
%!

+
%
!
$
'&
'


6


%
%&

&"$",
+"
<+"%

(C$&
+ #'%1
'
"



 
 


2

#
 5, +
+&
+
!
+
%!' "
'!!
"
"!+-"-
+
$',
"
" "!'1$

+
!!',
4+
% 
+
%&

&"$",

%
"
4" + $&' 
! " )



?!&'
+
%"$"&" )

+"
%!

+ %&!

!!'!
/+"
<+"%
+
+&

'

D =
1'
$
"
1"
+

&"$"
"


?!% " %!"&

-&
"-
"
+
6"
*&

 )
 +
&4
6
"
&)

'&

"!
!-"
" #! "


+
;"!
!
+
! 
4+"!+
 "!" 
4" +
+
!
"
"'

&
6&&'  " 
-"
'
+
%""
"
4 +
%'!"-
"
+" ! ?

E/+
8' "
"
4+ +

!11" 

!"1

&!' 

! "
 F
+
!
+

+
 ,

4

<+ "
& E
5
/+
< "
4
&"$"
1
E&4+E

+
4
" '

!"!
4+

!!'
9
!'

!
&"
+
4+
+
!!'!
9
%&!
+
4
 
4)
1
+
%&!

!!'!
+
"
"
? 1&) "1%$$&
+
+
4'&
+
% "!"% 
"
+
!"1
6
" 
$"!
&4
+
"

!"1"&
!,
"
4+"!+
+
!!'
" &&-

+
"&"! 
%+)"!&
"0')

 +
%, +
$'
"

+
%!' "

%
+
+
!!' 4
%

+
!

+
% "!"% 
"
+
!"1 /+
$'
4'&

$
&
$)
+
1
!
+
+ !!'
+
% 
+
!

&"$"
/+
%&

+ !!'
"
'!+
!

$
!"
&)
4+
+ $'
+
$
"!+-
$)
+
%!' "
 "! "&)

'
!
+
%!' "
'!!
"
"!+-"-
+
$'

2 "
"
"!'1$

+
!!',
4+
% 
+
%&

&"$", 
%
"
4" +
$&' 
! " )



?!&'
+ %"$"&" )

+"
%!

+
%&!

!!'!
=+ +
%!

+
!!'

+
!

!!'!
+ $
 $&"+
 "! "&)
$)
+
%!' "
+'-+ &"$&
"!,
1&&)
+
!'
4'&
$
&4
 $&"
)
!' "!

+
!
+
+
4 &4+
4+
+
!!'!
+%%
'
"
+ "!
'!
$)
+
!!'
"

'!+

8'&" )

 '!+

 
+
+
!'
1)
  "
1
$& '$
-"-
+"
%!

+
!
4+
+ !!'!
9
%&!,
+
!!'


4'&,

'$ ,
$  " &

+
$"

+
$&
'$
>
+ %'%,
"
4'&
$

'
%%" "

$
&"
4 + ,
"
'!+
!"!'1 !,
+
$'

+
!!'
"  +
+)
6
&&4,
+,
+
 "!
%
" 8'"

 $&"+"-
+
%&

&"$"
/+"
'
+ $


&"
!!"
"
'+
 +
*)
 #  

G *
F
#  

++ 

"- .-1
*"1%& H  /+
  1

*= 
"1&
"
'&)
!$ 
4" + 1"!&
"!,
!!"-

4+"!+
#0
"
'

$'
"0'"
/+ %!' "
+
%
+
!
-"
+
%%&&
$)
$& '$
/+
"

!!"

'

" 
4" +
+
4&&
 0'-1


!
$)
+
&
"&
'
!!

("
#"-+
#"+' 












3'- =+ +
%9"-7



I7




=+ +
% $&




I7