M/S Larson And Toubro Ltd. v. Stat Eof Hy.

  
  
 

   

    !

"# $%" &'


  !
    !
"! #$%$&'



#!(&)$$*+(,-)./('$ #'0$*$'1'1&$#

% (2'(!1&3,((,4(#-$*5'+)./('$$&$#(,-(#+(&(  ()**#$+$,-(.+ 0$4#1'*$'1'1&1% 1,$)%$$61&375(%01&3 12*53&$)#)$#% *(%%$)8+'0$%%$%%1&35'0#1'+(&)'0$**$,,('$5'0#1'1$%40$#$8+ '0$/,(12 %'/6'#(&% $#4(%)1%9(,,4$)(&)'0$'#(&%(/'1&4(%0$,) 1&'$#9!'('$%(,$ 3)%5%$)1&$:$/5'1& 4#6%/&'#(/' 0$#$,$.(&' (/'%(#$'0(''0$(%%$%%2$&'+$(#1&.,.$)1% ;;9;

0$*$'1'1&$#4(%$&3(3$)1&'0$85%1&$%% 2(&5 (/'5#1&3- '#()1&3(&)$:$/5'1& '5#&6$+/&'#(/'%(&)0()(2(&5 (/'5#1&35&1'('

(#1)(8()5#1&3'0$#$,$.(&'+$(#-'0$*$'1'1&$#$:$/5'$)(/&'#(/'41'0 ((<(%'0(&.$#&2$&'&)$#'(61&3 #)$%13&1&3-$&31&$$#1&3-%5**,+1&3-

(8#1/('1&-'$%'1&3-/221%%1&1&3(&)35(#(&'$$1&3 *,(&'% /&'#(/'$$ ('0(2(#6'( 1&$%-(<(%'0(&0$3)%4#'0
=->-?= @94$#$%'/6 '#(&% $##$) #2(#+(&('/&'#(/'%1'$(' (<(%'0(&0$%%$%%1&3 5'0#1'+ 1&(,1%$)'0$(%%$%%2$&'& ?=;;?-0$,)'0$/&'#(/''8$(

 )1.1%18,$/&'#(/'(&)'(:$)'0$3)%%$&' #4#6%/&'#(/'5&)$#'0$
$&'#(,  !(,$%  (:  /'-  ;?>  A #  %0#'-  '0$  /'B  0$  %' **$,,('$ 5'0#1'+)1%21%%$)'0$(**$(,&;;>**$(,'#185&(,2$''0$ %(2$ ('$&? ;;C0$#$.1$4 1,$)4(%(,%)1%21%%$)0$#$,$.(&'

*#'1& '0$'#185&(,#)$#1&(**$(,1%75'$)8$,4

D0$#$ #$1'1%751'$/,$(#'0('
!/'1%(**,1/(8,$ (% (#(%%(,$ 3)%5%$)1&'0$$:$/5'1& 4#6/&'#(/'% (#$/&/$#&$)(&)'0$#$1%&8(#&'0$12*%1'1& 1&'$#9 !'('$%(,$%'(:1&'01%/'0$ 1#%'(**$,,('$(5'0#1'+0(% (,%3&$1&''0$75$%'1& *#1/1&3 (/'#$0(%#130',+ 8%$#.$)'0(''0$#$1%%(,$ 2('$#1(,(%1%$.1)$&' #2'0$ *#1/$75'$) #)1

$#$&'1'$2%1&8#$(65* *#1/$% &.1$4 '0$%$8(/63#5&)-'0$%$/&)(**$(,0(%&

#/$(&)'0$%(2$1%)1%21%%$)E $(#&$)/5&%$, #'0$*$'1'1&$#/&'$&)$)'0('1&%*1'$

=>'0(2$&)2$&'''0$
&%'1'5'1& &)1(-'0$#$4(%&(2$&)2$&'2()$ 5&)$#'0$/'1&'0$#$,$.(&'+$(#-'0$)$ 1&1'1& %(,$4(%(2$&)$)8+ 1&(&/$/'-

(&)1& %5/0 /1#/52%'(&/$%&'(:/5,)0(.$8$$& 12*%$)&1&'$#9!'('$4#6%/&'#(/'%(,$% $(#&$)/5&%$, #'0$!'('$(#35$)'0('(%'0$#$4(%(1&'$#9 !'('$%(,$-'0$%(2$4(%,1(8,$'8$'(:$) 0$=>'0(2$&)2$&'''0$
&%'1'5'1&1&'#)5/$)( 1/'1&' 8#1&341'01&'0$ (281' %(,$- 3)%1&.,.$)1&$:$/5'1& 4#6% /&'#(/'  0$  $&$#(,  !(,$%  (:  /'    .(#15%  !'('$%  4$#$  (2$&)$) (//#)1&3,+-04$.$#1&'0$/'-'0$)$ 1&1'1& %(,$4(%&'(2$&)$)'1,,

0$#$4(%&)$$21&3 1/'1&(.(1,(8,$5&)$#'0$/' #'(:1&3'0$

 3)%1&.,.$)1&$:$/5'1& '0$4#6%/&'#(/' 5#1&3'0$#$,$.(&'

+$(#-&'(:/5,)8$,$.1$)5&)$#'0$/' #3)%%$&'''0$'0$#!'('$

#$:$/5'1& 4#6%/&'#(/'0$=>'0 (2$&)2$&'1&1'%$, 4(%&'

$&530''(:'0$)$$2$)%(,$0$1%%5$0(%8$$&)$(,'41'08+'0$5,, $&/0 '01%
5#'1& " /,0"!

"# $% ".112/0 & 30$#$,$.(&' *#'1&1%75'$)8$,4

D&.1$4 '0$(8.$4$0,)(&)#)$#'0('

A1B  &  '0$  (/'%  (&)  /1#/52%'(&/$%    '0$%$  /(%$%-  '0$ *#1&'1&3 ,''$#+'1/6$'%(25&'%'$:$/5'1& (4#6% /&'#(/' A11B0$!'('$ (#+(&(1%&'/2*$'$&'',$.+%(,$%'(:

&  '0$  '#(&% $#    *#*$#'+  1&  3)%  1&.,.$)  1&  '0$ $:$/5'1& (4#6/&'#(/'1&(/(%$40$#$'0$#)$# # *#1&'1&3 ,''$#+'1/6$'%0(%8$$&*,(/$)8+(&'0$#!'('$- (&)'0$#$1%2.$2$&' '0$$&)*#)5/'1&'0$/5#%$

1&'$#9!'('$'#()$(&)/22$#/$ A11B
,(5%$ ;9401/04(%())$)1&#'1/,$ >>8+'0$ =>'0 2$&)2$&'  '0$
&%'1'5'1&&,+$28)1$%(& $&(8,1&3  *#.1%1&  '  )$%  &'-  04$.$#- 
    (5'0#1%$'0$!'('$ $31%,('5#$',$.+'(:$%&'0$%(,$# *5#/0(%$ 3)%40$#$%5/0%(,$#*5#/0(%$'(6$%*,(/$ 1&  '0$  /5#%$    1&'$#9!'('$  '#()$  (&)  /22$#/$  0$ *4$#1&'01%8$0(, .$%'%$:/,5%1.$,+1&'0$(#,1(2$&'

(&)5&,$%%'0$*#.1%1&% '0$
$&'#(,!(,$%(:/'- ;?>(#$(2$&)$)-'0$ 1/'1&1&'#)5/$)5&)$#'0$!'('$

= /'8+'0$(#+(&( $31%,('5#$45,)&'*$#21''0$,$.+ %(,$%'(: A1.B$.1$4**,1/('1&=C ;;  1,$)8+'0$ *$'1'1&$#  1%  (,,4$)  0$  #)$#    (%%$%%2$&'  )('$) (&5(#+=-;;

-(/*+ 401/00(%8$$&(**$&)$)(% &&$:5#$941'0
 C ;;

-1%%$'(%1)$E &*,


 4
 '% .

5!# $%".11 /1 0#


. '01%
5#'*1&$)(%5&)$#

D$%525*5#/&/,5%1&%(%5&)$# AB
,(5%$%A<B(&)AB !$/'1&  '0$!/'- ;C -1&/,5)1&3*#.1%''$ -'$  '0$! /'-  ;C -  (#$ 

 

 0$ 
&%'1'5'1&  (&)  '0$ *#1&/1*,$% #25,('$)1&'0$
$&'#(,!(,$%(:/'-;?>- 1&  *5#%5(&/$    #'1/,$%  >;A B  (&)  F>A B    '0$
&%'1'5'1&'0('$:'$&'/&%'1'5'1&(,.(,1)1'+ /'

 ;F;1%5*0$,) B0$ .(,5$  3)% (,,1&3 41'01& '0$ *5#.1$4

.(#15%%589/,(5%$% /,(5%$%A<B(&)AB %$/'1& 

'0$!/'-;C -1%$:1318,$''(: A B&'$#9!'('$%(,$1%5'%1)$'0$%/*$ '0$!/'- ;C - #*5#*%$% ,$.+1&3 '(: A=B0$*(#'1/5,(#(/'1.1'+ *#/$%%1&3 3#$+/,'01&'

1&1%0$)  /,'0  8+  (%'  &)1( 
''&  (&5 (/'5#1&3
2*(&+ 121'$)1&'0$ (/'%(&)/1#/52%'(&/$%(25&'% '1&'$#9!'('$%(,$

? A?B '  1%  *$&  '  '0$  (:1&3  (5'0#1'1$% '  %*,1'  5*  ( /2*%1'$4#6%/&'#(/'(&),$.+'(:&'0('/2*&$&' '0$/&'#(/'401/01%/.$#$)8+&$#'0$'0$#%589 /,(5%$ /,(5%$A<B#/,(5%$AB !$/'1&  '0$! /'-;C  A>B&%*1'$ 41)$#)$ 1&1'1& $:*#$%%1&'(:&%(,$# *5#/0(%$  1&  /,(5%$  A ;9B    #'1/,$  >>  8+  '0$
&%'1'5'1&A#'+9!1:'0B2$&)2$&'/'-;F -'(:/(& 8$,$.1$)&,+&'0$8(%1% '0$$:1%'1&3*#.1%1&%

'0$
$&'#(,!(,$%9'(:/'-;?>-(&)&'&'0$8(%1%

.(#15%%589/,(5%$% /,(5%$A ;9B #'1/,$ >>(% (# (%/$&'#(,%(,$%9'(:1%/&/$#&$) ACB0$(:1&35'0#1'1$%%0(,,)$'$#21&$1&#$%*$/'

401/0 3)%- '0$ *#*$#'+ *(%%$%  ' '0$ /&'#(/'$$ 1& '$#2%   %589/,(5%$ A11B  /,(5%$ A<B# /,(5%$AB 

!$/'1&     !  /'-  ;C -  1&  '0$  (/'%  (&) /1#/52%'(&/$% %5/0/(%$ AFB0$&'0$75$%'1&1%#(1%$)-'0$(:1&3(5'0#1'1$% 0(.$')$'$#21&$'0$ (/'%(&)/1#/52%'(&/$% $(/0/(%$ 40$'0$#'0$'#(&%(/'1&1%(&1&'#(9!'('$%(,$#(&1&'$#9 !'('$%(,$ A;B:$2*'1& #2%(,$%9'(:A%58<$/'''0$/&)1'1&%-1

(&+-2$&'1&$)'0$#$1&B5&)$#%$/'1&%>(&)?#$()41'0 !/0$)5,$'!/'-;C -1%41'0#$ $#$&/$' 3)%(%%5/03)%0$$:$2*'1&)$%&'(**,+1 (&+ /(%$ (,,%1&(&+ '0$%589/,(5%$% /,(5%$A11BE

> 0$4#1'*$'1'1&1%(,,4$)0$12*53&$)#)$#%% (#(% ,$.+1&3 '(:&1&'$#9!'('$%(,$ 3)%5%$)1&$:$/5'1& 4#6% /&'#(/'(#$%$'(%1)$ /()**#$+$,-(0/(+(6 *(&,0 +7 -*+7 -*

? 

0$'0$#%*$(61&3@#$(%&$)

$%@ 0$'0$##$*#'(8,$

$%@