Gurlal Singh v. State Of Punjab
!
" #
$
% $
& '
(
( $ ) "*+'
(
( ,-.
, /0.
,--.
1
, /0.
+ '
234 0( #*- ((56
! " # $$%&'($)$%*+*
# ! " # $$',*$)$%*++
)-!. " ! /// ((56 #( 1 -"1 # $$ %&'($)$%*+*2
3 4 # $$',*$)$ %*++!2
3 4!- "
1 " " *(*&%*+* " +**&%*+*!. "#!!- .
- " " " %+ "" ."
" " "5 2 "46 - " 1 1 +*. . +" - "- ! " # $$',*$)$%*++2
3 4 1
! 8 9 "
" 1
8 +'*'%*+& :-! - -- . : 4 1# 1 -+-4 774 (11 ) 8+ ,.
*9 :
--; ( <( ) =42! - ;"" +"- 1. #
!11 " +*. " < .! # """ - 10 < " ! ;"" . " =
!=
1
= -
- - " " +&*&%**> " " - "
"
" 1 !" 1 -".
1 "
?9;
! : ! 1
;-
! # !" - )@:
; -
1"." )$*%$ A$+'&'! 1 :
: -". 1 8" 1 " " =-" "! ." - " B 1 !C
!#. - 1 -1
=;:B - """
"". 10- - 1"." )$*%$ A$+'&'
".! 1 " 1"." " )-
;C-
;-
! 3 # !-
1 "1 1 0
=;:B - "" 1- )-
!
0 .1
1 1"."B <.! !- - 1"."!
" 1
?9;
! : ! 1 !- - !
" 1
!;-
! # !" = ")-
!=;:B
" . "" 1 1 -" 1-". 1 8" 1;" D ! ." "
1 EB"-
) ""8 "
" " 1 E" 11- !- "
- 11 . ""!
-. "
> - 0 11""
-!- "
- 11 . ""!
-. - C
!#.!"
1 "" - E" " - #. : " 1 8" 1;" " !- "
-".
!"" 1 "
" "1 1
. EB"-
) "" " " " 11@8#
" 11@8
-. !- "
- 11 . "" -. 1 "- B " ! "
-" " "
" " -"1 D1
"" !-1+* 1"
- 11 " 1 " --
!
- "
"1(>* 1 "
" 0 1- 1 "" 1 (>* 1- "" +&1 *>" -- "" "-- 1 24 1 2C40 1 -8 %F" -0 " = 1
- 1 " ".
- " ".11!- "
-. 1 1 @ 1"."- .
? "!. 11 !
!"" "1 =;:B
" -
+ "
" " " . "" !- "
" "@ 11- !- "
- 11 .
-. ""
". "" "" 1"" 0-1+* 1"
-1 1 " - 1 " " 1 -
(>* 1"
+G "- - 1 24 1 2C4 ( "- ".11!- "
- 11 . "" .
- =;:B
= 1
" " @ " 1! 1D=-". = 9 ) ""-1. @ 1.11- 1 ".B " !=;:B
.
!
;"" 1 ".- " " B +,*&%**>! 1 ".- "24 2C41 " " - "" 9 - - +'
11+'" - "
-" #. ".! 1.
8 1 # B " !=;:B
1 ".
" B %%*&%**>!
" 1 " !91 " " " - '*1 11 1 1
?10 11- . "" -. - B +>*&%**>! ""
"1 ! ".- " " 1B %**&%**>! +'11 " 1 24 2C4 1#-
" " # 1"@81 ! 1:" " 1 " ! "# 1"@81 ! 1 %**&%**>9 !=
1 ".
C" +,*&%**> ".
-"1! " +,'##- #1 #
" ""! #"
$ ;"" " %+
"!- "
. . "1 = " ! " 81 7$+= 1
!-
1 "" .: D=:-! "$81 ! . "
"".+FG1:B" " 1
+'*1 "".-F 1-.
1 "!- " 1 -":1 :B . 1 " " 1 1 C
"
%+G10 " 11 1+'*1 11. 1 " 1 : 11- ." ""- -
1. " 1:-! ""-+FG1 " 81 7$%!=
!- 1=;:B
%&" 1 C"
! B " ! " 1 ".- C" " 81 7$' # -
H - " " 1 "! %**&%**>! +'1" "# 1"@81 ! 1 B " ! " =;:B
= "81 ! 1 11 1- 1 ": ". . #7$F=;:B
!- - " 1! " " .
" D=:-! "$81 !
@ " " 1 +'*1 !- "
- "% 11#
" " 1 ! . . - : .- " " 1 :-! -1 "
1 "!- "" 1 : " 1
-0 " 81 7$GC
!- "
11 - "
E 1) !
! # " C ! - 81 7$& : +,*&%**>! ""- " # - ". C @87&;
". "" @87F;!@87F;: @87&; 0 " 81 7$,:-
!# !0BB"! 1!
-
"#1"." )$*%$ A$+'&'!
- "
- 19 -
;
!
! 1 3 1 +%*G%*+*! " "
)-
! - " # 1"@81 @8I @8J " " "
" " "! 1
! ;""-" " '+'## 1" ".-"1 1
" " 11.!
.1" " ".-"1 1 = " "!:#19-81 7$+ " " .. +(*&%**> - . #-
1 " .- .- 1!
1-81 7$% : -
3! # C = 11 !
;-
" - 7$+ ""
!
5 6!:
!-
!C # !:
)-
# 9 7$'! - - )
)$*&$>>'(
" = " 1 "- " 9 " 1 - $ "1 " " F% "!- "
" " "" " "- 9 " 1 " " !
".- .11 . "" "1"." )$*%$ A$+'&' 1 ".-11 "".
! "- " " 1
- "11 " 1 "- .
. $"1 " 1 . " F% "11 - 9 " 1 1 "! " F%- " ".- " 1 1 ""1 " "" "
! " F' "-" " F% " F' " " - $
!
!
"
"
#
$
$ "
!
" "
#
$
% &
"
' ()
*
'+ '
,(
"
!
" "
#
$
'
- '
.
+ +
/ " - ". " F% F' "! : 41# 1 K ) ; <( #9 ;
-9
BC
,D.
>
,.
,-+-4.
?
- $
*0' 1 ,2
,(* ,(( 3
'1
!
,(*,((
'4
3
& 3'5 *00,*6 6 728%*00,2
(00' 4
9
!
:;& ' ,*,(,2
4#
<% +<' 5
4#
=
>
,* ,(' > ,(
,*
"
4#
' >
"
'
(
<*00? @A,*,; ,(
'+ 1. 1
!! : 41 #- $"1 "" F%11
- $
?
*?' 4
5
% +2B' 4
! "#$$$% &&'()$$$ &&#& %*+, !
!
,(*,(( - ."#$$(%+ &&+*)$$( &&#& %((/,
!
,(*,((
'1
%
C
*
,(D
,(*' 5
,(*
'
4
!
,(*,((
"
' 5
" '1 !
' )
!
* (
,(
,('1
,('5
,(
'
1
,(
') !
,( !
'1 ,( 0
(??*'+ **' 4A3 9 '4 B'2
'
E % +*,' ) ,((!
*
'1
-'& *B
F
:
-'& *,-'& (*'1
9
,(('
''''''''''''''' *8' 4
A
,(*,((
'4*(
3 A
' 9
,(( -'&*,-'
@ & *B
,(('1 A
,(*
#6 - ,2
'1 9
A '
)
,2
!
,(* ' ''''''''''''''' (0' 3
5
!
,( B?
,('1
5
B'1
,(*
,(* '
,2
,(')
9
,(* ,((
9
'+ = "!1 " "".
!""!- "" . ";
" " 0 1"." 1. " "! "" "" "0 8 " F' " - " - "1- 8 2""48 " F' " "1 " F% F'
"-". " "! - " F' " "-<.
" F% "@ 7$+=! 1
!- - 1!1 " 1 -"+'* 1 ! -! 1 :B .
1 " " 1 1 0 " 1 1 1 +'* 1 11. 1" 1 @ 7$F=;:B
!- - 1! 1 1 " 1 - " - .-
- " " 1 :1.
-1 "
" 1 :-! " .1"1 " 1 . " F% "0 ". " ".
-1. ""
"."1.- " F% "!- "
1 -0 #- : 41# 1 ."1 "" F%- 8 .1! -! $"1 " 1 . " " !" ." " " " 18 10 ! - "
1 . " F% " ". " - D !. " ! = B"
")-
- "
E "!1 +%*G%*+*! "" -
)-
- . ! "" 81 7$%- 1!
1 # C !-
11
5 - 6 " - 7$+
5""6 0 ! !- -. 1"- ""!-" "
""" " "
1 ! " " " 1 " - :-!"
;" "
1 " "! " . :-! 1 " " - - < 1 "-. 1!".- -
" -
"1 ! "
1 . " F% "!" " " "" " 8 = - " ! . - 1 1 " " *(*&%*+* " +**&%*+*! . " #! !0 . "" "
!""1.1".! < . " " ! .!!"" . #.! .!- ! . 8.
1 0 "" "
,((
= D.
(
( # $
:1 ; I;
I;