High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/349/2006dismissed

Gurdial Singh And ANR. v. State Of Pb.

2022-09-06Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan15 pages

!"# $%# %# %"

&&##

)* & ("

&&#+!&&## , - $%. $$

*/""0

"2 %34 5/ "&&## ,0 !"# $%# %# " %## 5 5(!

)* &&## ,0 !"# $%. %# &&## ,

- $%. $$

5*%" /##$7# 7# 8" "*3#"

4!$5&#!"5

9: ,00 00

" !

" 0; ," "!$ ( 3%"&!* 501; %" """"

< 5"$ "8%(# "5

5 %##$

% 00

%" "" *"$8% %"/ !#-

/##$ % $%5%38"!

&&&3 %!

2 8%! 3 # " &"- =% "# %"

/ /)!$- 0

5%38" / % "% "8%%%38"*2 "- ""

% /"3 5 %3 8" !

"$ "$"!

-&" - " 3"

% &3

>% !#%"!

"$!"%""$"!

-&" - " &"03"% :

! %##5% %&" ! % 00

: !") $%(# "5

%" """" %:

/ $ $">:# $8%%"&## % &# 8 &" "*!

/##$ % $%

8%&"## $? "

% $%-"

%&# &"3 %8 ) %"8%?8% %&#&"3%"% "

" *"$ 8% "/ ! #- /##$ % $%5 !

!"# $%. %# - $%# $$

8" !

$ 8*$ %/ $ 5 %* 2" ? $ %&#&"35%3" #&83*!%38"&&"% % * !

& ?%" - %"&"!#"

8" +!"*!5 8%%%3 # ?%:#%!

%% !

&%$!

*$ &

%/ - " !* 8 "%% - %%!

%#$#"$%*

"% &" $@ ""$ "? *%% !

&$%" "% ! &" $@ "? &"

-- %"$"8"&"&" =%: "+! "## $ -$@"%

&" $#35( #8 " $%- -%"=%% !

8"&"!*"%( #8 " $%- 58% # % 3*%%!

$%%8 $@ "(!

)* /"

- !"%"% "%%*$

*%%!

5%8/"%!

%"$%*

"%*" -%"$@""$ " %% !

"& %(?

-- %"$" A!*3*%%!

8"&"&"=%

( #8 " $%- 5%: "%%8*$ 58%%8" !

&&&3%!

2?8 -&# 0

$"- %8"

&""-%%8*$ %"" * $8$%- 5 %*$8$%;2$ %"0 2$ ?8-!$ %# 2#$"-&3 %" 2#$"-&38"!

"%$!

3*$ ?% -&# *$ $" !&&&3%!

8" /" &"# ?% !%&"# 8" #8%% # :

/ $ $"*" $-&"

< <?% -&# #-&"

8 2 %? % # " !

8 % % /" & 8

% $%=% &"&"38 2 &#&

/"/"3-- %%!

8""" &""!#

+! !- 8" &"&" =% : "!+ % &#

5 %* 8%%"-#9:8 ""*3:("- $%=%:&"&"%"!$% &# %&#"/"3 "" - 8

;

"!"

% &# 5 % :

/ $ $ "

&"!%!

# $8%% &"&"3 8

*" :7

" $%5B%(# "5

58%/" % %""A% 8 #%/ $

"& <7<

-&# &"# 8## *!#2 &"# B &"&" &- # -&"

2&% &"&"3 % !

3B# &# "&"%%$%"&#"

% A35%B&"!%!

% &"&"3*"45

# $8% &&# " / "3 #"

"3""

" !

3% &"&"3 ! &8 /#*# )!#-#2% 5:

7 " $%2&% &"&"3 % 8 !

3 C00

% /"% -&#&"# 5 -&# #-&"

% 9"- ,

*#7!#8 $%"& $ !%"# 9D5 (!

)*5 % $"%

*# 7!#8 $% % !#

100

"$ $%2&"&""-%(5

*"!$%%"&%""-58%%%% /":

7 " $% &""&""/"-9D5(!

)*5% $"%5

#3 % -&# 8" !

* % &&&3 %!

2 "

-&# / $ %""-# 5%## $

% !

8 &"&" # %!" &" %%## 5& %"8" !&&# %!

" 5 / $!

C"( =% * "/ $%&"-%"$" !

" 0;%8 # $

*%%!

5%3 8"%"$ %" $#358%%5%3&# $!#3

#-"# !" $%!"

/ 5%&" ! A-

*#7!#8 $% (E05:

&"7 " $% (E 5B !2%- " $% (E : !") $% : (E %&" ! %# #! / &/# $-&#&&"!

5% -8 # *3""

- %!

8"""!

" 0 "(5 8%%##% "- $"!- &&" $ % &" ! / $

%-8"&!*%%!

*!%3 %##$

$%%38"

# #3 /#/ =%!

# 3/ %"

"%" $"$!- 5#"

"#!" /

*% % !

- */5 8%% # %- $$"/ %3%#%&" &&#58%%8 2 !&

58% 8 -""$!#"%" $ "/"3 8 "" "- 3 &&# !

" 1 "(%/ $* #*3%&&## >!

" !

%" -&" - !" $%& 3&&#5% - 8 ##8

C "" 8 ""

C "- $ &&## >!

8 !

& !" $ % & 3%&&# %38"""*"# *#

% $"+! * % 45

0 ,8%&&#% -!&" #%" $ 0 :-3*- %"%&&## , F- $%

. $$%A&"!" $%& 3%&&# /""

5%&&#+!%- *B8/"5%&" &&# !"// " &&## ,0 !"# $%. %# #3 0;

:%/%"#"

#"%&&## F!

5 #"

5"%(!

)** $ $%"!$%%""

B" % 8

"/"3 -#3 (E B !2%- " $% (E: !") $%%/!##3 !&&"% &" ! "3 8% "$" % !

%/ $ * !

"* 8%! 3&"-"# =%3 8""

A- # $% *%#%!

*!%3 !2 %"$!

!# * %" 3-"#& ,&"/!

-3*8 %- %!

F / % * ##$"

&"/&"-&*38%%%3-$%%/ /#/%!

8" $#3 & $

%-# #3 !"%" /

=%!

$/ *3% (E -!*8"%3"# 0C +! # 2/ % * &"/ % "- - 3(E0

*#7!#8 $%5%"""%

-&#&"# # $8%%""# 9D5(!

)*5% $"% (E :

&"7 " $%5% % B (# "5

9"-%" - !&#8%%"&"GA(G>09D5 (!

)*5% $"%5- !% -&" $8%% &"&"3 %2 &#" @!"*3%&# !"%"%% -&# &"# %"%%9D5(!

)*5% $"%8% #

- %"&"GA(G>05% # % -&# &"# ##8% -&# #-&"

"- % /"3"&"5

#3 % -&# 8"!

*% &&&3%!

2=% !

%/#!

"%"&

%&&&3%!

%""5 "-

; ;%5%38"*2

% "* D"

#"%&&## % &!"8"/"!

&# !&&" % % % -&!$ )!$- / $

%&&## >!

*# B "

$"!

28 %%"8 -&#

;

%5" " $%&" ! !*!# 0 B8/"5: 3-"

;

% # 8% & # @ " "!$ & 3%"& !* 9""3"" 5% &"/ "&"! !

$ $

' '

(

)

(

" *

)

01" 01"

2 31&"31,

)

=%&!"& $% &"/ 8 /% %

# " $ %!$ +! 3 "/" "* "

"*#- % #!

"# & #&&# !

!##32 # $-:

5%" -!*

-&# % &"/ :7 " $%%# &&#

GA(*"45

8%"$"& % &"&"3

%)!#-#2% D"

""GA( >0

%&&# %%!"&"# -&# 8 "- $ "* %* &"!*3:7 " $%5B (# "5

##% &"# 8"*" $ # -&"

< < <7<58%% -&" 8"!

##3

=% &"# 8" " * 2& )!# -#2% 5

/ "3--GA(8 # !*-*"#"

#%!$%% - / %% &"&"38 & %)!#-#2% *!"- !

3B:7 " $%5 *!% +!A&# "%% * $/ %"%"

%%"8 !$% & )!#-#2% G/ %"8 5

/8# !

*/5- !% -&" $8%%

-&#&"# %2 &#"%" @!"##% "% % 9D5(!

)*5% $"%=%""5%"!# * +! 3# 2/ -

$ E%"$"%*) %)

-- 8 !

%* &"&"*3%: 8## ( #8 " $% - 5 " !# $ -&# ;

5: % %

*) 8%! 3"*!

&"!

#"" %8 %8

&"-- %* &"&"58% %!

8" "- %""$%$%" "% ! &" $@"

"$ " %3%&$% "%""!

&" $@ " GA( !% -- 8% "$" !

- $%. $$ GA(B %--8%"$" !

!"# $%. %# %%-- "%!-*-"2*3 % " &/ !

*3 % 8

-#"#3 ( #8 " $%- %# &"&" &"-- "$" $ *%%!

GA(:8 8%" &!

!"# $%.

%# GA(48 8%" &!

- $%. $$58%% 8" %!-* -"2 *3 % " &/ !

*3 %

=%""5

* % ;

8 /# -

": *- %"% &"% ##85

;

%&&# &"

# "%%!

"%%*$" 3%"""" % &

=%""5

% 8*$ &

%* "%5%" !# * 3+! /# ;

" !% "!-

-""$!- &!"8"*3#"

#"% &&## 8 %*%%!

8"##" % -- 8" A&# %- $ "$!- - /(EB!2%- "

$%$"##3 %: !") $%#*%%!

*3 %% !

&%$!

3*$ %"&

%/ -

" !* 8 "%% - %%!

%#$#"$%* "% &" $@"" $ " *%%!

*3 &$% "% ! &" $@"B&"/-- % "$"58%%8"%!-*-"2*3%" &/!

*3%- 8## ( #8 " $%- $!"%"5%

%"( #8 " $%- "%%

&5%% # % 3*%%!

%%8 $@" % +!""-*%% !

*3 %8%%"%38 $% "% ! &" -%"$@""$ " *%% !

"& ( #8 " $%- &

$ %" "% ! &" ( #8 " $% - :

%" &5

--GA(: !

!"# $% . %#

--GA(4 !

- $%. $$5 8%%8"%!-*-"2*3%- *38

=%""5

* %% %-- 8" A&# % !

%" "$!- " *3 #"

# " % &&## 8 %8%#* $A- !

" 0"(5 +! %* 2"-%!

%%38"

% "* 5!

$$"&")!%-

$ : % "$!- *#2 $-"E%

A- !

" 0"(5##% "- $ "!- &&" $$

%- %&" ! / "* &! !% !

=% $" " "+!" *&! !

: "%!" 8%%" $"

$-&#" :

5 &+!

8"&! %!

%%38"!

% "* =%

%" &" !-& !

" ;%%%!" %## &" !-%A !%- # :

"- ;% 5 &"/% 3&" ! " !

"% 8%%"+!" !#&*#- # %!

5%!" %## &" !-%A !%- # *! %##* "% !

&"/%%%% !%- # 8%" & %%"$ %&" !

;

"- ;%5-3*&" !-5!

#% ""3 &"/5%%!

% --

"% " & 3 ""!$"& 3%"&

!* " "## !* 5"%&

8%%%#

"#3=%""5 !%&" !-& 58%%*"8

*3%!"

" $% "!- % &")! %8 %/* !

#"%&&## % !"%""$!% 8$%% "* #! $8$%%*$ 8 ;0

8$%%*$ !5% !#*2 *#8;

2$ 58%% --"#+! 3

B8/"5: -3 # $"- 8%#"

#"%&&## & :

* 3 !* / / /#*# ""58!#)!

*-"&" !-&

!-& %%8$% %*$ !% % "* "/"8!#-!*#

% ;

2$ %% $ 5% "* "/"8 -"% ;

2$ 58%%- 8% % --"#+! 3

"$" % %"$"!

2*3#"

% &&## % "

% $% & 8

8 A- 5-2 $%&" ! "3!*!#5% # 8%! "/ %% !"

!""## $%& '(

)

* 8% & 8

% * ) !" $ % "% "/"3 "* ? % % &&" 8

"% $%% $ !" 8"

&"!" *# 2 &&"

8% % % / %&#

2 5%* "/% !% 8 & %# $%

**#/% !-"!

$ !" /"!

&&"

%/ $" 8" -"#!#* $ *38

*# 2&&"

=% - 3%8

8 %#*!

"#*# 8 " :

% /"3 )!$- 5 "*#3 #>&# 8

" 8 * "/%8% %" ##$ 3 -3$

%&## # #3-&# %&&## %"8 " "%-& $

% &&## 5%"#!"%"$%#3 #!% A- & 8

"% "/"3 * $ 8 /" *3 % !

" 3!* %&" ! G/ %"8 5 %&

"&"8%% & 8

9!"%"-"5 & ""*" "!#&"!

"+!"- #8: 8%"&"/ 3 ! % & ""*" -!

* %"5% %&" ! ")!"$%#3

=% &" ! % &"/ %"$ $

*% % !

/#3 "-/#3 =%!

!# " "

3" *#"&#!

*#A&# "%"##$# -&#

"!#%3!

") &

% "* 8%! # "&"-%"*3 %8 $%%3"

!% "*

"$" % &"5%"#!"%* "/% %&"

#2%&" / " &# $3!%% 3*3

-2 $%-##&"3 A %!" $% -3%

=%)!$- %&A!" +

$ $%, - !""

.*- /

0,0

/! ) $!# % * "#!& 8%" 8 * "/ % "# $ " "!$ "

& 3%"& !* -"% !

5% !#&*#%-*!

%#" #3 /!#8%#%"-" #/

#"!

-& % 3* %" $% -3%

8## =% !

>&&## 8" !

"$ "$"!

-&" - 3"

% &3

> % !#%"!

"$!"%""$"!

-&" - " &"03"%58%% %- -!-&" "* "

--"#+! 3% "* G/ %"8 5% &&## >!

"&!

"3* &&#38%#/ %#%&&#%"*3-2 $%-2 $"!$ =% "!$&#"

%/ !

!##3 "3% #*"!" 3 #3!%%8" $!#&%!%3&&"

*# 8%"-#3 "

#3 3-&%3 * %8 %-# %

%!# &"/ * !

" &"!/ " !# " "!$ "2 $=%""5% 8"%&&## >!

"%" -8%#8" %" &""! %"

0 =%-&!$ )!$- / "" &

*3%"#!""8## " 5* !& &"&"

&&" # &&" / "" "&" #8 =%" ##$#3" "-3%" =% )!$- /

"" "!&%#8%" %&&# !

8%! 3-" % - -

" $#3

&&## ,0 !"# $%. %# *

*#$" %-*3% !"B *# ##%4!# $ "5

!"" 8"" $%-""

-2%-!

"$%"- $ ,

"3 - * %+!"" "

# $%&'

()%* $+!', &) % # *& $-.

&) %