← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/682/2002disposed of

Banwari v. Shri Mahabir And Others

2019-01-10Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages



        

 

!"!#$



%  

            

 

  

& $ '&'

#() #*+

&

'".

'

-) *+

&& ",# /    

  #0 &!* !#12& !"!#

-"

3!#4 #)

  (,

!#!#& ",

 !#12&!

""2"

56)!(!# ( &+ )! 2-

3,-

#   %%%

( 2#"

- & !-  !#!#4" 

!#4 # &6# !(0)!- !!#4!""2

 !"  + -6  &42

 #  &&

,,&

!#   

!(#6    #0 &!*  !

 ( 6  #  5  ,""!5-   !&(  !#!#4"     &!52# -*

!#4#

*

 8 9

!"

2& &42

&  #!#4+

&!# 570!

)2 #6

#4!57,-

!#* &"

!# !"-!

5-

5 & 0# !#"

",# " &## (!#!#4 & 12"

! 6)!" - !( & #)   (,

!#*!

!"

&42

 !#12&   5

 !"

5-  

   9 #  )!"

 !"

6) "5

#,&+ 56&: 1*& ), ! ;2&4 #* ",!

-*  

   )  &!52# -  ) "   (

&  (2#   "

*

!#& ",

 !"

6"2 !(* 8

&"

!" 2& &42

!"  (,

!#<2

!"

656 ,,-6!#4(2- !,-!

&(

) 2#"

- & ,& !#4  !#"2&  (, #6) " "2,,&

!#!#4"  -#!""2

!#4 # &6#

!#<2 3,-

==,!# #)2#

>2- #& !#12& 5 #"2&

#+ (!#4#( !#&

 )!" ,,& )!#4 ( !#&

"2-  0)! )* &2 3"

&2 3 !#"

 &# & 1

,&!+ #56

+!

!( ;) -""2,,&

 !#!#4"  -0!

)& &

""(   (,

!#

& 2#"

- & "*, &2"

&53

#& &"  !#4 "25(!""!#"(

56 2#"

- &

"*!

!"#

&6 &

,!

2-

",-

!#,    -

,,-!

!#0!

)& &  2&& !#<2 !#) &&

#   %%%

(*) "

 &()!")2"

0)!-

&!+!#41

,5

&!#4 ? 8@ &4!#4 -!

;

!#)2#

&"( 0&3""# ")  &""

==,!# 

#)2# >2- #& *

&2 35

&!#4 ?@8@0)! )0 "&!+ #& ")-6*# -6

)!4)",

 &()2#

!# &#"

!#4 &2 3* 5&24) )!"1

,#32 ,& -#4"!

52 & 

&2 3  )!

 1

,  2   0)! )  &#  ,& !#    1

,  0 " 

--6

/ &2") ?

#)!"&!4) - 4 )!4)0 "5&3 # &((!-  

"2"

(2- !,- *"

&!2"!#12&!

"#+ &!2", " )!"56  ",# #5 - !- ,-6

#!

&( "& !"

!#,  ,,-!

!#) 6& !"

,-

0) #& ",#

#

&

==,!#

--  "2 #*  &(+!--

)&!*

( !#&

0!

)2 "-0!#40#)!"1

, #0!

)2 &!#4 "

# ( !#&   ",# "4!#4 &()2# +!--

>2- ## ( !#& )  &(-!#3& #) 2# 2 6 "-0)!"+

( !#& #-6

# ( !#& #"

!#41

, 

&!#4

!#&

",

",# ,,-!

5& #5&24) )!"

&2 3 -

#!)!"5 +!

52  2-#  # &-)!"1

, #"

&2 3!# &2 3

",# )

""57 , #!#4-!#  )!"

!#!# )!

*) 02- ,"

 --0!#4

$ A#   %%%

(*  "4!#4 -!

 ;

!#*  )2#  #  1

,  5

&!#4       ? 8@B)

#

&>2- #& &2 30

# (!#4 &(,,"!

")-6 ## -6

3 1

,# -

##32 )

&2 3"

&2 3!# (61

, &( &# C   &

 &(  )!"  &"" 

!#  &

"  --0"$ A'6) #!!""!

!#5

#)-2 #.!--

D

&! "

 &((6) #!

%/  (

-- -# 1

,

==,!#  >2- &

() &2 3"

&2 3!# (61

,#

2&#!#4  ,!# 0 &"  >2- #  &    "

0  &2 3 (!#4 &(,,"!

 &( !"

'61

,0

+ &6"-0",

) &2 3"

&2 3 (61

,0)!-  (!#4#32 0 &"(6

C  &2"

-  &( "(

!#,    - ,,-!

!#

-#40!

)

""

!#!# )!

# &""

!#  #0 &!02-

!#-6&

-

 2&& !#<2 3,-

== ,!# &2 3"

&2 3!# 1

,# 2&#!#4 0 &">2- #& )

") # ,&2 #6"!

,- &4 ,& (&

,-!

2&!#4!#+ !4

!#  0 &*!

!#"

& #!#4+

&!# ""57  2#

!(#6  #0 &!&

5-!"),-

 & ",# #& !"

0&!

  3!#4  !#   #"!

!# 

"  -! !

  !#  &""

!#  #0 &!*!

#"

-65 -

3,-

==,!#  >2- #& 0)!- 1

,0 2&#!#4 0 &">2- # )

!#4"* ") "5

#&!4) -6) -56 -*   5-!4

#"2&

#+ !" (!#4# ( !#& 0)!-

&!#4 ( !#& 0)!- #)!"0 6 &(

&! >2- #

4!+ #"

&!* ## -- 4

)!"-!

6 &

 2&& 

""* !"# ) #4

!(#6 

#)!"1

,#32 &2 3"

&2 3 !#"

8

,56 (!#4# 32  3!#4  2(2-

!+ 0 

!& 2("

"!" 2""

!#5 * !#!#4"  -)-!#4

5   # &6#  5 ) &" ## 5 2-

0!

)52 #

 8 9

!"

89!#!#4"  -#!""2 (! !

&!#4-6 )!"5&!#4" 2& <2 2(  (,

56

- ) -)  (,

!# "8 *

*

!- 2# &$ (,

!## 2#

" *

(,

!## 2#  , !# "2 &!#4 "

*

(,

!## 2#  !"

)24)  !

##  5

&(!# 0 &* #! 2#

&(!# ")

  "2   "(  !"

6*  -2(, "2(!" 2# &!"

6)

"

*

(,

!#  #  2#    ",

#",&

"

*

) (!

)",!

- & !

6" '

- 7, "& !(52&"

- & 5 !&( &;2& 1> (51EB F0  ,&+ #

2&  !#12&6 "2"

!(  ,"

""0 --!#4

&(!

6 &!4) )!4)!#(!- )

"2# 5- 0 -3 ) 5& "!##&!4) - 42,, ?/#

&!& ",

0)! )0 "2, & ! !

-*

"&

&) -

02##&!4)

,!##  !#+-+!#4  -("

 0)- )! 3# ""*  & ")  5-

!#4  0 "  ,& '2- !,- 5& "!#,& # &!4)  2,, &# 3*G!#4,& *

&5& "!#,& #&!4) 2

)2"*"2, & ! !

-52



&)

"&

&& !+!-",!

-*

&7& 6 # 2&

)  & &( !+!-",!

-*

,&+ 7& 6& ,&

4!+ )!( >

,!#4!#+!

0 #

2&  !#12&!

""2"

 2,- ) &!

#!#&,

* - ") --5  (,

!# & !#  #  "2 &!#4    2#    " 8*

 E !# -  (2#   "8*

F) -) "2( "

*

 &",

#",&

 "

!"& 5 !&( ) -) "# #6 (,

!# &-"" !# ( 2&!#4 &! 

#& + &6) ") --5

-"" !# ( 2&!#4, &! 

#& + &6

 " *%

&(# ) & &!  0(# )" "

 ( "/*

&  :   1*  & ), !  ;2&4 #*   -  ",!

-* 

,&+ !"

6"2 !(

02- ,"

",

  &

2& ")

(2& &!4) # &

2&

&!4) )0

3# "" &!4) )!4)*)!, #3#

!4) )!,,0 &4&

.H 7/H9) &!4) 3#

"

! # ""0!

),0 4&

HD 7/H 9

-!"I H 9 02- 2& ,"

3# "" (2" - !(,&+ "0!

),)6"! ,6 #+!

0 #

2&

 !"

6"2 !(0) -!4)

  *!#

 12"

02-5 "

&+ *!  !"

 (,

!#<2 !"

6

 "*

&,

 ( "/*



- (,

!#!""D*

E *

I

8*

I

*

I/*

I/*

F # - ") --5

@ @89 

- (,

)!"2& "89#

"5

)!() ") --5

(2# -#40!

)!#

J@89, ##2( &(

 ,

!--

-!G

!#(!#2" (2# -&

6, !!#+!

0  &, 56

-

#+!

0  !" 2""!#(

!# 5+

-!"

-6 --0 !

&(" E 3) '!

-F  24



% () #5!(5&