High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/680/2015dismissed

Karamjit Kaur v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2015-10-05Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik6 pages

"#$

$%&'& () * * +","-.&#+"/, ***00$11"(# 2$,'/' 3#"#$

/(."4"(5 #6$,' ***$'0 (5$(#'

*76$#6$,$0 ,#$,'

1 %"10"0$,'-"84$"11 9$5# '$$#6$./5:-$(#;

* 4$,$ $,,$5# #6$$0 ,#$,' ,( #; <*76$#6$,#6$./5:-$(#'6 /154$,$0 ,#$5&(#6$&:$'#; ,$'$(#) '*5&#& &,56",=5> %"#$=

,#6$"00$11"(#* 6$0,$'$(#"00$"16"'4$$(0,$ $,,$548+","-.&#+"/,= - #6$,

#6$ 5$%$"'$5

#" 3&(:6= "::,&$>$5 ":"&('# #6$ ,5$,

"%?/&##"1

#6$,$'0 (5$(#'0"''$548#6$1$",($53$''& (' /5:$= "#&"1"= * <* * ' 0$, #6$ '#"#$-$(# @6&4&# 7<A

#6$ "00$11"(# ,5$5 48 ('0$%# /,0,$$# 3&(:6 ( *B* = 6$, '

#" 3&(:61$ #6&'6 /'$ C* <* "

#$,#"D&(:-$"1'"##6$6 /'$

6&' ,&$(53"#("-3&(:6*( * <* =3"#("-3&(:69$(## /'$

#"3&(:6"#C* "*-*$

/(56&',

-1 %D$5*#9"'

E* <* "#"4 /#* 0*-*='6$$(?/&,$5 -3"#("-3&(:6= &(

,-$5 6$, &(

,-$5 #6"#

#" 3&(:6 9"' ( #,$'0 (5&(: # #6$%"11' (- 4&1$06 ($*(#6$4"'&'

'/%6'#"#$-$(#=$",1&$," @6&4&#7 A9"',$% ,5$596&%69"'

9$548'#"#$-$(# @6&4&# 7<A -"5$ ( *B* * ( #6$ '"&5 '#"#$-$(#= #6$ "00$11"(#'#"#$5#6"#6$,'

(9"'"9&#($''&("( ":"&('#"%%/'$5

"1D", 3&(:6

, % --&##&(: ,"0$ /0 ( "19&(5$, +"/,* ( >&$9

#6$'"&5 "%#=",4"('3&(:6'

/..",3&(:6=.&#3&(:6'

/..",3&(:6"(5 "/.&"-3",/0'

/..",3&(:6= &##/3&(:6 '

.&# 3&(:6= "1D", 3&(:6 F &(D/ '

.&# 3&(:6= 3"#("- 3&(:6'

",4"('3&(:6="11,$'&5$(#'

"(5,"1"+6","/,6"5 4$$(#6,$"#$(&(:6$,'

(*36$ /,#6$,'#"#$5#6"#"?/",,$16"5#"D$( 01"%$ 4$#9$$( "1D", 3&(:6 "(5 6$, '

( "(5 "(

, "(

$(%$ /(5$, 3$%#& ( < C 9"' ,$:&'#$,$5 ":"&('# 6$, '

#" 3&(:6 "(56$,$-"&($5&(%/'#

/,- (#6'*36$9"'#$,,& &$5"(5 '6& #$5

#" 3&(:6 # 6$, ($06$9G' 01"%$ "# -4"1" 96$,$"' 6$, 5"/:6#$,&(1"9 3"(5$$0 +"/, "1 (: 9&#6 6$, :,"(5'

( 9$(# # 6$, 0",$(#"1 >&11":$ "(46 ,"*

#" 3&(:6 9"' ,$'&5&(: "# -4"1" 4/# 9$(# # >&11":$ "(5,"1" +6","/, C*<* "(5 6"5 #"D$( 6&' 5&(($, "# #6$ 01"%$

3"#("- 3&(:6 "# E* 0*-* $ 9$(# # 6&' 01"%$9&#6"0, -&'$# % -$# 3"#("-3&(:6($@#5"8"#C* "*-*

/# (#6$($@#5"83"#("-3&(:6

/(5#6$6 /'$

#"3&(:6 %D$5* ( '/%6 '#"#$-$(#= #6$ 0 1&%$ '#",#$5 &(>$'#&:"#& 0, %$''H ,$% ,5$5 '#"#$-$(#

3"#("- 3&(:6 "(5 % -01$#$5 #6$,

,-"1&#&$'* # 9"' ( *B* = #6$ 5$"5 4

#" 3&(:6 9"' (6"&(#6"1IJ"1:",6"#69"8&*$*"1 (:'&5$#6$4"(D'

6"D,""("1*#9"' (*B* #6$"%%/'$59"'",,$'#$5* 6$0, (,$1&$5/0 ("5&'%1 '/,$'#"#$-$(#-"5$ 48 "1D",3&(:6 C*B* # #6$$

$%##6"#5/,&(:(&:6##6$86"5 #6, 9(

#" 3&(:6 &(# 6"D," "("1 "(5 9"' 5, 9($5 &( #6$ %"("148-$"('

($4"# (=96&%66"'4$$(D$0#% (%$"1$5&(#6$ 5&#%6$'($",4,&5:$

6"D,""("1&(#6$",$"

>&11":$6"&(#6"1= 96&%6 9"' &( 6&' $@%1/'&>$ D( 91$5:$ "(5 0 ''$''& ( "(5 6$ % /15 :$# #6$ '"-$ ,$% >$,$5* ( #6$, 5&'%1 '/,$ '#"#$-$(#

+/15$$0

< 3&(:6 9"' ,$% ,5$5 C*B* &( 96&%6 6$ '#"#$5 #6"# "

#$, #6, 9&(:

#" 3&(:6 &(# 6"D," "("1= 6$ 9"' 5, 9($5 &( #6$ %"("1"(5"##6"##&-$#6$# ,%6/'$548#6$-9"'D$0#% (%$"1$5"# " 5&'#"(%$

"4 /# # '#$0' &( #6$ 4/'6$' # 9",5' "#&"1"

-#6$4,&5:$

6"D,""("1*#9"' * B* =#6$%",

5$%$"'$5 9"' #"D$( &(# 0 ''$''& ( "

#$, #6$ '"-$ 9"' ,$%

- #6$ 6"D," "("1 48 #6$ 0 1&%$

1&%$ 3#"#& 6"::"* 3/4'$?/$(#18= "( #6$, 5&'%1 '/,$ '#"#$-$(# @6&4&# 7 A &' '"&5 # 6">$4$$(-"5$48 "1D",3&(:6=,$:",5&(:,$- >"1

**1"8$, "(5"'0$"D$, -",4$",&(: * !CEEE4$

,$#6, 9&(:#6$ '"-$&(# #6$%"("1* ( % -01$#&

&(>$'#&:"#& (= #6$ 0, ( 9"' 1"/(%6$5":"&('#"%%/'$5 "1D",3&(:6"(5+/15$$03&(:6=4 #6'

.&# 3&(:6* 6$ -"#$,&"1 9&#($''$'

#6$ 0, ( 7 3/D69&(5$, 3&(:6H 7 3"#("- 3&(:6 "(5 7 6"( 3&(:6= #/,($5 6 '#&1$* 00$11"(# "00$",$5 "' 7< "(5 '/00 ,#$5 6$, '#"#$-$(# "(5 0, >$5 #6$ ,$% >$,&$'* 7",.&# 3&(:6 9"' $@"-&($5# 0, >$#6"#",4"('3&(:6"(5"-3&(:639",/09$,$ '#"(5&(:($",#6$%","(5

#"3&(:69"'%,8&(:&('&5$#6$,

#6$ 6 /'$* ( "001&%"#&

, '/-- (&(:

#6$ '"&5 "%%/'$5 ",4"(' 3&(:6 9"' '/4-&##$5= 4/# '/4'$?/$(#18 9&#65,"9( ** B* ( 6$, #$'#&- (8 7<+","-.&# +"/, '#"#$5 #6"# #6$,$ 9$,$'#,"&($5,$1"#& ('4$#9$$(#6$"%%/'$5"(56$,'

#"3&(:6* 6$ 1$",($5 #,&"1 /,#

/(5 #6"# #6$ "00$11"(# &' ( # ,$1&"41$ "(5 #,/'#9 ,#689&#($''"'#6$,$9$,$-"#$,&"1&-0, >$-$(#'-"5$&(6$, $",1&$, '#"#$-$(# -"5$ # 1&%$* (18 #6$ /,#

/(5 &-0, >$-$(#'"4 /##6$, 1$

#6$"%%/'$5"(5#6"##6$&(> 1>$-$(#

#6$"%%/'$5&("%"'$6">&(:% --&##$5,"0$/0 ("19&(5$,+"/,=

B 4/# "1'

"%# #6"# '6$ 6"5 ( # :&>$( #6$ '#"#$-$(# #6"# #6$ "%%/'$5%6"'$5#6$>$6&%1$ ,6&'>$6&%1$9&#6">&$9# D&116$,*(

"%#=&#6"'% -$ (,$% ,5#6"#"( 9"'1 5:$5":"&('#6$,'

$(%$/(5$,3$%#& (< C"(56$,'

(,$-"&($5&(%/'#

"4 /#

/, - (#6'* 6$ /,#

/(5 #6"# 96$( '6$ -"5$ 6$, &,'# '#"#$-$(# ( < * <* '6$ 5&5 ( # '/'0$%# "(8

#6$ "%%/'$5

6">&(:% --&##$5-/,5$,

6$,'

("(5#6"##6$>$,'& (( 90/#48 6$, 9"' "( "

#$,#6 /:6#* 36$ 9"' "# -4"1" CA *<* "(5 6"5:

($# >&11":$ ( E* B* *6$,$

,$='6$5&5( #6">$#6$

&,'# 6"(5 D( 91$5:$

#6$ &(%&5$(#* 6$ /,#

/(5 #6"# #6$,$ % /15 4$ " - #&>$ ( #6$ 0",#

#6$ % -01"&("(# '&(%$ 6$, '

,$-"&($54$6&(54",

$9- (#6' ("% -01"&(#

#6$"%%/'$5* 6$ /,# ( #&%$5 #6$ '#"#$-$(#

7CJ"D6" 3&(:6= 3= 96 5$0 '$5 #6"# 6$

/(5 #9 4 5&$' "#&(: ( * B* =

($9"'

"0$,'

(":$5 8$",'"(5 #6$,9"'#6"#

8$",'* 0/41&% ( #&%$ 9"' 0/41&'6$5 &( #6$ ($9'0"0$, ( * B* "(5 +","-.&# +"/,= "00$11"(# %"-$ # #6$- ( E*B* "(5 &5$(#& &$5 #6"#

6$,'

#"3&(:6* 6$1$",($5#,&"1 /,#

/(5#6"##6$,$% >$,8

4"# 5"(: :

# ,$% >$,$5 &( 0/,'/"(%$

#6$ '#"#$-$(#

"1D", 3&(:6 "(5 # ,%6 0/,'/"(# # #6$ '#"#$-$(#

+/15$$0 3&(:6= 5&5 ( "00$",# 4$-/%6% (>&(%&(:*3/%6#80$

# ,%6$'"(54"# ('",$ $"'&18 ">"&1"41$ &( #6$ -",D$# "(5 % /15 $"'&18 4$ 01"(#$5 /0 ( #6$ "%%/'$5* "##$-0#9"'-"5$# :$##6$ &(:$,0,&(#'">"&1"41$ (#6$ 4"# ("(5# ,%6% -0",$59&#6#6 '$

#6$"%%/'$5*6$ /,#

/(5 #6"# #6$ 5&'%1 '/,$ '#"#$-$(#' ",$ ,$1$>"(# (18 # #6$ $@#$(#

>$,8

4"# ("(5# ,%6*3&-&1",18=,$% >$,8

"%%$''

,&$'

%",&*$***1"8$,"(5'0$"D$,=5 ( #5&,$%#181&(D"%%/'$59&#6#6$

%,&-$*6$1$",($5#,&"1 /,#=#6/':,"(#$54$($ &#

5 /4## "%%/'$5"(5% ('$?/$(#18"%?/&##$5#6$-* 7$6">$6$",51$",($5% /('$1

,#6$"00$11"(#"(5 &(5 ( -$,&#&(#6$0,$'$(#"00$"1* 6$ 5$"5 4 58 9"' ,$% ( *B* "(5 #6$ %", 9"',$% -#6$ 6"D",""("148#6$ 1&%$

1&%$3#"#& (

/::"*6$ (18$>&5$(%$

#6$0, (&'#6"#

+","-.&#+"/, "00$11"(# "(5 '"&5'#"#$-$(# &' ,$1$>"(# (18 # '6 9 $(-&#8

"%%/'$5 9&#6

#" 3&(:6* 6$ $(-&#8 &' " 5 /41$ $5:$5 9$"0 (* 3&(%$ #6$ 5$%$"'$5 ,$-"&($5 &( %/'# ( #6$ % -01"&(#

"%%/'$5=#6"#% /15>$,89$114$"- #&>$

,#6$"00$11"(## &-01&%"#$ #6$"%%/'$5

,#6$

$(%$*6$5$%$"'$5&''"&5# 6">$4$$(9&#6 3"#("- 3&(:6 C* B* "(5 ( #6$ ($@# 5"8 3"#("- 3&(:6

/(5 6&' ,

- 1 %D$5* 3"#("- 3&(:6 6"' ( # '/00 ,#$5 #6$ 0, ( %"'$* 6$,$

,$= #6$ "%# #6"# #6$ 5$%$"'$5 9"' &( #6$ % -0"(8

3"#("-3&(:6 (#6$'#"#$55"#$"(5#&-$=&'( #0, >$5* 0",# -3"#("-3&(:6=#6$,$&'( $>&5$(%$#6"##6$5$%$"'$59"' ( # ">"&1"41$ &( 6&' ,

- *B* * 6$ ,$% >$,8

4"# ( "(5 ** 1"8$,= '0$"D$, $#%*= ",$ ( # #6$ &(%,&-&("#&(: %&,%/-'#"(%$'= 96&%6 ",$ '/

&%&$(# # 0, >$ #6$ %6",:$' ":"&('# #6$ "%%/'$5* 3/%6 >$,8 &'

, /#&($ ",#&%1$' (18= 96&%6 ",$ $"'&18 ">"&1"41$ &( #6$ -",D$#*6$",#&%1$',$% >$,$5",$9&#6 /#"(85&'#&(%#&>$-",D'*#&' &-0 ''&41$#6"##6$"%%/'$59 /156">$#"D$("'#$,$

#6$%", - #6$%","(5#6$(#6, 9(#6$'"-$&(# 6"D,""("1*6$-"(($,

%"/'$

5$"#66"'( #4$$($@01"&($548#6$0, (*6$$(#&,$ 0, ('# ,8&'&-0, 4"41$"(5#6$%&,%/-'#"(%$'5 ( #0, >$ #6$&(> 1>$-$(#

#6$"%%/'$5&(#6$% --&''&

#6$%,&-$*6$ 1$",($5 #,&"1 /,# 6"' % ('&5$,$5 #6$ $(#&,$ $>&5$(%$ &( " 0, 0$,

0$,'0$%#&>$# ,$#/,(" &(5&(:#6"##6$0, (6"' "&1$5# 0, >$ #6$%6",:$'":"&('##6$"%%/'$5* 7$ 5 ( &(5 "(8 0$,>$,'&#8 , &11$:"1&#8 &( #6$ ,5$, 0"''$548#6$1$",($5#,&"1 /,#=96&%6-"89",,"(#&(#$, $,$(%$48 #6&' /,# &( #6$ 0,$'$(# "00$"1* $(%$= #6$ 0,$'$(# "00$"1 &' 5&'-&''$5*

! "# $% &$ ! "# * * 5'