High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2369/1994allowed

Nasib Singh Etc. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2016-01-13Mr. Justice S.C. Datta6 pages

! " # #"

# $ ""# % & ! " # #' "

!"#$% &$&'( ## "( ) #*+ !$,"# - " ) ..&

*+ !$,"# % " # '#"

# )/ ## !-*+ + & &$&'()"

# '#"

# .'1 " # !# !"#! 2345466 7

#81# 9:

'#!

& " #

* ..

# 1 !# #,"

4;7: % " # & #

< *!

,"+ 4632 7 ##

%"# = - " # 4632 ,":

" 1 ."1 '-# " !#,*# !# !"#! 4645463;

& " # '#,

#! 1" "& **#* <= '" + " # '#!#,#9

"##" % " # '## " '#"

# -

* ! - # 4>546> 1 !# " # 1 / #,1 "& % < 1# ,"+ 46> 7 ##

%"# = - 46> ,": # " %##! " # 1 " * '"

% " # * & #%%#,"#! " 1 " # .1""

3 !"#! > " ! 4;

% )& 46> 1 1 !#! ! #$# "& "-

% * ! - "

%$1 % #$# ?

*# !#*

- " " # 1# % 1'*1 #+ " # **#," ,"

" # '#,

#! 1" "&

,*1!#! " # * ! %##! " !#,*# # % 45 = * 6 .* 1'*1 ''#*

#$ - % *#!

" "

!# 1" % "

45 = * ! 6 .*+ 46 = * ! 4 .* - 1"

@#! ! **""#! " #*

*# '# ! '#

!#* $##! 23524635 ! 55463 <# #! ,1 #* % " # '#"

# , "# ! " " " # #.

* %"# !#!1,"

46 = * ! 4 .* ,

1# "

'# - #$# 1"

@#! ''* ,"

- .!# & " # '## " '#"

# 25463; " " # **#," + A * 1 !# #,"

; ! 427: % " # 4632 ," #,"

457: ! 457: % " # 46> ," % #8#.'"

% 1'*1 # .#1

4>; = * 4; .* %. " # 1'*1 * !

'&# - ,,#'"#! ! " # '#,

#! 1" "& #8,*1!#! " # # # 1'*1 # % 45 = * 6 .* %.

" # 1'*1 * ! " # 1 ! " " " # * ! !

& " #

* ! - #%# 55346>; ! ,1*!

" " 1 $#"

" # $# .# " <# #! ,1 #* % " # '#"

# , "# ! " " #$# " 1 " # '#,

#! 1" "& '#! !# " " # %# ! #%%#,"

& #8#.'"

# * # 45 = * ! 6 .* # -1*! ,

,* . *& " 1 1"

@#! * & #8,*1!

46 = * ! 4 .* '"

,1**& - # #' " #

/#,"

" " " # **""## % 1"

@#! * ! $# "

.'*#!#! '"

1# " " # , "# #!

& " # '#"

# #!

#*"#! #8#, # % 1 ."1 '-# 1 !# #,"

4;7: % " # 4632 ," '"

,1**& - #

''#* - '#%##! -

" # "

'1*"#! '# !

"#. % #,"

4;74: 4;72: . !"

'# ! % 4> !& " % *# ''#* - " '-# % , ! "

" " # ,.'#"# " 1" "&

" # #$# " % & !#*& ,#!#!*& ''#* - % *#!

" " # !# % " # '#,

#! 1" "& #,"

4;74+2+ ! : % 4632 ," # #8","#! ## #*-(

! "

# $% " ! &$% $ $ ! $% '(("$ )

$% +, #$ - #) $% $ # $% "

# ( $ $% '(("$ &"% #)

) ) ! " ! . $% $ $% '(("$ ) $$

$% ( #$ $% / # $%

# +# #$ - # % # $% $ $%

(( $ * $ ! &## $ "

& #) # (

$% ( $ ) 0

! "

# $% '(("$ *%$% "$

" ! &$% $ $ $ !

) ( & &!"$ ) * $% +# #$ #) $% $ # "

# ( $ $% ')) &"% #) ) ) ! " ! . $% $ $% ')) ) $$

$% ( #$ $% / # $%

# +# #$ - # % # $% $ $% (( $ * $ ! &## $ "

& #) # ( $% ( ) 1 /// 2

! # $% '(("$ & &! "$ ) * $% 3% $ #) $% $ # $% # ( $ !# $% ')) $ "% (( $% (

( $ $ # &"% $% ')) ) &"% % ) ) # $ 3% # $% ')) % (( ! # ( 4 ///

5 $* $%$

$% "$

$% #

&! "$ $% , "

( ')) ) & )$ $ ) "

(( # $% " # " # &$% $ &! $ $ % ) # $% & # # )(# $ $% (

( $ $ # &"% " ) &"% ( $%$ % ) ) # $ 6 '#1* % " # $# -1*! ,*#*&

,"# " " " # '-# 1 !# #,"

4;7: % " # 4632 ," ,1*!

" $# #!

& " #

* ..

# %"# 1,

"# !#*&

#- % " # #$"

.!# & *# 1'#.# 1"

*+#,

(-% %.

/ %&$ #0 * 1"# ! ! 1 #C1# " /1!.# " % "

( %&(2 !

$$)

/ %&$

,, (! )& 3,

(-% %.

/ %&$

(! 4 )50 -3&(6&-% %.

/ %&$ 78,,,448) -% %.

/ %&$(& 3 7 *" 90 /-3&( -% %.

/ % *"

*# 1'#.# 1"

,# "

"*#! *+#,

($-% %.

/ 255574: 7 *: 44 #$#! #*-(9 : #,"

4;72: % " # ," '#,

#! '# ! % 4> !& % %

''#* ! #,"

4;7: '#,

# '# ! % 5 !& % %

#%# " # ..

# ? # " # "- 1 9#,"

'#,

#! $#& " '# ! % 4> ! 5 !& #'#,"

$#*&+ " - ** # *# " *! " " " #

* ..

# .

"#! '-# " # "#"

#$ %"# *'# % #$#*

&# 3 # "#" '#,

& "

$B ,#

& " #

* ..

'## " ,#

!# !# " !

,*# & # " *!

" " '# ! % #*& #$# &# # *# " # %," % " # ,# " #

,1"

" " # C1#"

!#, !#! - #" # " # '-# #! " # %," ,1." ,# -

# *# '# ! ,# -# **- " # ''#* ! #" !# " # !# % " #

1" # !# % " #

* ..

* #" !# # !# % " # **#," !"#! 4;46;2 #"#! ,"D

$ #- %

! # ,#

" # 1 #C1# " /1!.# " % "

,# "

"*#! 1 * !;

<($-% %.

/ #'"#! 25527: 7 *: 2;

# #' "+ " # " # !+ $# #* #! 1' " # /1!.# "

% <(-% %.

,, (! ,

%&$(-% %.

/ ,, (! " , "# ! " "

% %1! ,..

""#!+ " # 1 ."1 '-# ,

# #8#, #! " & "

% "

, "#

,,#'"#!+ " # 1# -1*!

# - #" # & %1! - ,"1**& ,..

""#! " # * ! "! "

%$1 % " # & B

46> " ## & '#,*1!

" $#"

" # ""# ** %# ' " 46>; -## '"#,"#! ## - , **# # " "

B " & " "

" - %1!1*# " #8#, # #C1# "*&+ " # "

% " # !#, #* #! 1'

& " # #' " -1*!

# "","#! " " # ,# " # %# ! # + '#"

,,#'"#! ! " # .'1 #!

!# #" !#

5 >- ', 9>,

"?'>