Narinder Kumar And Another v. The Superintending Canal Officer And Others
!
"
!
!#$% (%)*+*&,
-. .
#/*,(%/ 012#/ #,&$3%/ ......
%$*$*&,%/+ 4%/+1+ 3% 516%/*,$%,(*,7 #,#8
''*)%/9
%/&:%61/ #,#8 */)8%9
%/&:%61/ &$3%/+
......
%+6&,(%,$+
; < .
5 5
/%+%,$ /.
5#,(%%6 031,7%/9 (=&)#$%
6%$*$*&,%/+.
/.
#=,%%$ 5*,739 5%,*&/ ! 1,>#?.
/.
#+@*,(%/ 5*,73 /%@#89 (=&)#$%
)#=%#$&//%+6&,(%,$ . . 5
.
<
.
/#A%/ '*8%( /$*)8%+ &,+$*$1$*&, ,(*#9 *,$%/ #8*#9 *++1#,)% ,#$1/% )%/$*&/#/* +%$$*,7 #+*(% &/(%/ . .
9 6#++%( !*=*+*&,#8 #,#8
''*)%/9
#>#+$3#,
%%(%/ !*=*+*&,9
%/&:%61/
+3&/$ ;! ; &/(%/ ..
-9 6#++%( 516%/*,$%,(*,7 #,#8
''*)%/9
%/&:%61/ #,#8 */)8%9
%/&:%61/
+3&/$ ;5 ;.
.
/*%'8A9
%%$#
#,* $3/&173 3%/ 31+?#,( #/*,(%/ 5*,73 '*8%( #1$3&/*$*%+9 +%%C*,7 &1$8%$
#81C61/
#>?#39 =*88#7% 8#27#/3 68%# $3%A 61/)3#+%( 0#,#8
&1$ $#C
?8&)C9 @3&+% @#$%/
@#/#?#,(* '*B%( 5%/*#8 +#*( /1,,*,7 8#+$ A%#/+.
#88%7%( #?&1$ C#/#2+ 6%$*$*&,%/+9 ,#2%8A9 #/*,(%/ 012#/ 1/+3&$#2 012#/.
))&/(*,78A9 +1?2*$$%( (%2&8*$*&, $3%A #/% 7%$$*,7 #,A @#$%/ &$3%/ +&1/)% *//*7#$*&,9 $3%/%'&/%9 6/#A%/ 2#(% *$+ &/*7*,#8 68#)%.
. 6&, /%)%*6$ +#*( #1$3&/*$*%+9 /%'%//%( )&,)%/,%( D*8%(#/ *,=%+$*7#$*&,9 +1?2*$$%( 3*+ /%6&/$ .
.
9 /%)&22%,(*,7 '&/@#/(%( 51?
!*=*+*&,#8
''*)%/9 ?&3#/
+3&/$ ;5!
;.
. <%#/,%( 5!
/%6&/$ . .
9 /%)&22%,(%( &?+%/=*,7
!
"
#$%$&$'$ $(
)
) ) *
!
'$
+ ,-
.
)
/
)
)
)
0
)
1 ) 2+
-, ,-$ )3 -$ ,-0 ) 3
)
))
!
""$"$ "$
)
4)))
"$
"
!
"$
"$
) )
) # ))
)
) !
'$ #
5
) * !
'$ ) 2 $
) 6 . 3%/%#'$%/9 61$ 8%#/,%( ! #'$%/ #''&/(*,7 (1% &66&/$1,*$A 3%#/*,7 )&,)%/,%( 6#/$*%+9 &/(%/ . .
.
.
%%8*,7 #77/*%=%( #7#*,+$ &/(%/ . .
9 6/%'%//%( #66%#8 8%#/,%( 5 3&@%=%/9 +#2% (*+2*++%(9 *2617,%( &/(%/ ..
-.
, #'&/%2%,$*&,%( )*/)12+$#,)%+9 '*8%( *,+$#,$ )*=*8 &1/$9 /%8*%'
+9 ,&$*)%( 3%/%*,#?&=%.
.
%#/(.
.
<%#/,%( )&1,+%8 /#*+%( $@& +1?2*++*&,+E '*/+$8A9 &/(%/*,7 '*,(*,7 /%$1/,%( @3%$3%/ F1%+$*&, +#,)$*&,%( +%)&,(8A9 8%'$ $*2% )&,+&8*(#$*&, =*88#7%E )#, ?% ?% /%+$&/%(.
.
)&,+*(%/%( #'&/%+#*( +1?2*++*&,+ /#*+%( ?%3#8'
6%$*$*&,%/+9 3&@%=%/9 (& '*,( #,A 2%/*$ +#2%E '*/+$8A9 ?%8&@ F1%+$*&, 6/*2#/*8A )&,+*(%/*,7 #+6%)$ $3%2+%8=%+9
%%$#
#,* &1$ 3&8(*,7+ (%%(9 %B68*)*$8A /%)&/(%( *)%) 3)+ 87 =%, ,#$1/% /%)&/(%( ;18$*=#?8% %3/* <#,(;
2%#,*,7 F1%+$*&, *//*7#$%( $3/&173 @#$%/.
'1/$3%/ ,&$*)%( '/&2
9 %B%)1$%( '#=&1/ 2#/C%$ =#81%)&88%)$&/ /#$% $#C%, )18$*=#?8% ,%3/* '1/$3%/ /%)*$#8 (%%(9 /%#(+ 0
3 ))
3
9 ) + , *)) + - :
$; ,:<$;9 )+ *))+ ,:<$; =+
:$;
)
)
)) +
. 3
3) 0 3))
)) 3))
6 .
6%/1+#8 #?&=%+#*( /%)*$#8
8%#=%+ 2#,,%/ (&1?$ $3%2+%8=%+ 0#,#8 )18$*=#?8% ,%3/* )&,=%A%( #88 /*73$+ &@,%/+3*69 *,7/%++9 &1$7/%++9 6#++#7%9 $/%% #8&,7@*$3 @#$%/ #8&,7@*$3 $1?%@%88 %$).
(*+61$%(
%*$3%/ ?%8&@
&1/$ @%88 '&/2+ 6#/$ 8#,(9 )#$%/%( @3%/%16&, @#$%/
@#/* '*B%( +%/*#8 .
. 3#$ #6#/$9 ?%8&@ '&1,( '#)$ +6&$ *,+6%)$*&,9 '&1,( /1,,*,7 '/&2 6&*,$
! +6&$ *//*7#$*&, 9 #?&1$ C#/#2+
,&$% C#/#2G
'%%$
'/&2 6&*,$ ;;
6&*,$ ;
;
'/&2 )&26/*+%( C3#+/# .
'1/$3%/ &?+%/=%( @*$3 (%2&8*$*&, 8*,C *//*7#$*&, )&2% %,( &$3%/ +6&$ *//*7#$*&,
. + /%7#/(+ +%)&,( +1?2*++*&, /#*+%( ?%3#8'
6%$*$*&,%/
)&18( 8%'$ (1/*,7 )&,+&8*(#$*&,E +1''*)% +#A +1)3 6/#A%/ 2#(% #,(9 $3%/%'&/%9 &))#+*&, 7&,% *,$& +#2%.
.
#=*,7 )&,+*(%/%( $&$#8*$A 6%)18*#/ '#)$+ )*/)12+$#,)%+ )#+%9 &,)% &@,%/ ?*77%/ )31,C $3%2+%8=%+ 6#/$ 3&8(*,7 )8%#/8A )&,=%A*,7 /*73$+ @#$%/9
9 (&%+ 8*% 2&1$3 +#A %,$*$8%( *//*7#$*&, '#)*8*$*%+.
. + '#/ /%8*#,)% >1(72%,$ )#+%
>*$*+ &?+%/=%( +#2% #668*)#?8% '#)$+ )#+%.
.
, =*%@ @3#$ (*+)1++%( #?&=%9 '*,( 2%/*$ +#2% #))&/(*,78A (*+2*++%(.
-.
%,(*,7
+9 *'
#,A9 +3#88 +$#,( )8&+%(.
5
!
-. .
+>C+ 3%$3%/ +6%#C*,7/%#+&,%(
"%+
& 3%$3%/ /%6&/$#?8% "%+
&