High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/593/2014disposed of

Subha @ Subhash v. State Of Haryana

2020-08-27Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu37 pages

! " #

$ %&'

())*+,+ -.

# #/

$ %&'

&* 0 1&#!

2!32&. 4 1&#!

22 2 #

$ % &

( ) &

$ "%

$ )

+++ 2 2 .!# ,* !-./0-!1 2 3 4,* !--!1-2

) "*

502

, 6-. 4

44& "4

& 000.02027 4 & 2/

8 # ,9 :8#,:; & - <

& & =5008#, " 8* * * > =50.8#, " 8* *

.5- &

"*8* *

* > =5028#, " 8* * * > =5278#, " 8* * * =508#, ? 8* *

5- &

"*8* *

@* 6 &4 & & * 1 ! ) 44 4

4 &A

6& &

*& AA $?4 & #&

4 *

,,'

) &

) ) #%8$

$?< ,

& ,,'

* &

& "

" * (

* 6& *

#%8$

4 ,

" "

* (

* &

* B@# 0/ 0

" & 1 & & "4 ** * &91 & &1 ";< // * " "1 "

( "

* 4

" * &

1 "

& &6#68 # & ) 4

&&* " *

.#$ &

, 6 4 " && 6

& "

C & ( & 4 " *6 & &

6 * & 4 B52D0. & * *

"& & &

* 4 & "

& &( " $ 457 "

&* 50* &&

* & " * & 57

" * 4

C 9 ;

& * ""

"*4

< " #68 &

*" 4 * & *6

4 (

) * & * & & 6

( 4 4

" 6 & ) & * " " 6#68 & " * ; * *

,,'

* E*

4 #%8$

(

*" * *

& 57

& * * 2 <

* E8 & 2D2/ 0027.8#,4 " < 0/ *

4 &

) )

& 08#,4 #& " & 72,#,4 & # * * ) 4 " & && "4 0/ & B52D0. *4

( && 1 4 4 0/ ! ) 4 ./ && # 84 4 7/ &&

, D/6* "

& 6 & "

4 . 8 & 3 ) 3'

*3?

! * "1 3$

! " '

& 4& #& * <

0D ?

3 4 & "

*4 , " "

" 1 4

"84 $, # *'

* "! ) $ " *

& & 2D000.00227. 4 & 2/ 18#,4 *

& " "

! )

$ " *

& & 8#,4 *

7 6&

@ * * 4 6

* & 00,#,4& 6 "

&& "

) 9& ;4

) & 64 F "

(6 ) * ( " * & ) D 6@ * 44 !C1 "

" !C 1 " & / 6 4& & & & C & "

" ) "* & #C

//4

& 1 & & " 4 ** * 6 * " "1 // &

( "

* 4

" "4 " ?

#68# & ) 1 4 ) D-/

6 & ,

. * C 4& " 4 '

" 44 " & B52D0. & *

1 4 4 &&* " " & " ( 4 " 4 6 *

4 " * * * * (4 " 4

* "

* * " (&

" & 4 4

(& 4 & " & C #C " 4 * 4

5 "

"# & ) 4

C #C & # & *

"* " & ) 4 &(

)

4&4

) 4&4

4 < & " ) 4 " 6

( * "

* " '

"4 $ & 64 && & 6

* ' $ ( * ,, '

* 9#C;4 *&-"

@ *

,, '

# & ) 4 #%8$

(

% "

#C4 #%8$

(

* ** (* 1

4 # '

! " ) 84 #

4 * "

6 4& " & *4 **

* 84 1 #

4 , &

) # & #

) # &

) * ** * 4 &

) # & ) #

) 4

- < " 0/& * *

4 &

* B@#4& "

:: !

"&@ *

& " "

> * * 1

* B@#

4 " 4 * *

& '

' $ & ( ) ,,'

4 & 4

* B@# 4 4 &

5&&

4 & 4

* B@#457 4* *

# '

! " ) # 84

) 4 & 4 B@#4 4 &

' * *

* B@#

4& " & *4 & 4

* B@#4

& 0

4 ( 4 * & * &

" & & & * "

" 4 ( 4 *#&

4 * &

" "

4 & & &

5 & .5 * " & " &

6 4 & &&* " *

' '

* * * * 4

& & "' $ 4( 4 * && & 4

* 4 ** ,,'

2.*

6 &&* "*

* "#681 ?

$ ' *

1 ?

#684 & " * " * ( 44 '

$ 4& "* 6

D* 4

& && & * && && 4* ) 4 & )

' ) " & ) & 4

* * , &

* & 64

D5/ * 2 6 && &&

* && & 6 & && &

.-7 *

.-7*

( & 4 &*

#& &

" ** 4* &&

& 4& "

64 ( )

4 & " " & "

64 * 4

) &

) * (

" . #C'

4 *

" " 1 & & " ) *

" "

&4 -- 0 < // & -02,-277 * " 1 $ '

* * 4 - - 4 ) *

4 *6

) *1

.*< 4 " & 4 & "'

50*6

-27-..27 " " & " ( 4 & "6 &

4 " " 6 4 # 84

) ! * ) ! "4

" ) * *

& 44 "4 ) *

44 & " * 4 & 4 ) # 44 " * 4 & 4 * ) * & 4

&& @

& ) (

* 4 # & 4 ) * 6 ( )

9#C; &&* * & 84 #

, 8 ) 4 % "

* ) * ! 44 "

(

* 4 " $ "

4 * *@ *

4 &

4 & && & & #& &&

* &

&#&

( ( " **B@#, 8 &@ *

( 4 *

* && & ( 4

50 && &4 "

& & 4 && &

(4 && & & * #C && & 6 &'

70#$1 ?

#68 & ( )

9#C; &

&#& &

& & '

#& &

* #68

,, '

) *

) 9#C; " , -

<* # ( & *, ( 4 && & 7 #C0 "

& 1 & & " 6& " ) # 1 *

" "< // & * " "14

( & * & "" -27-..2.4& 4& 1 ?

#68 ) # $ 4 4 *

" * *4

" 4 '

*& *C & $

& & * *'

4 & " 4 64 @& " 4 &&

( " 4 *

& < *1 4

& "

* 4 @&

6 $ ) # " 4 * & (*

(& * &

" 4 '

C & " , & & * *

( * *

* 6 "

" C &

4 & " '

- & * & 1 4

" & 4 * ( " & & *4 * & 6

-0* &&& * 4& 4-78 4

.50* -7

" ) $ "

4 4 4 " )

4 4 4 " &( ) "

4 " ) # "

4 *

) *4& * ":?

$ * ! * 1 ) '

! " ) #

84 :64 & * "$ $ * 4

6 " ) $ #,'

4 *4 % "

&& 4 6

" * ) 4

6 4

(

$ "

6-7 * ( 4 4 ) '

1 ! "! * ) 4 4 (

" " * &

4 "

&4 &

* D 6 4 && 0/ " & 0/

* 4 &

0/ < 4

( & &**B@#!4& "

, "

4 &

) * " " / 8 &@ *

* & $ "

0/ 4( " &

&& &&

&4 "*

4 ( 4 * && & * ( 4 * ! "1 ! * ) * ) #

* && & & 4& & * 4&

& * ( 4

&94 & 4

* B@ !14 4 &; &

4 ( 4 *94 & 4

* B@ !14( 4" * ) *84

! " &

;8 4 (

* && &

*647 & "

* #68 * * @& 4 6 4 & "4 " 4 &4( 4

& 6 4 ( & " &&

& & 4 1

*" & ( #C2!! (% "$<,,'

B@#B4

0/4

,,$ "

"& * * ) # 1 * "2. 6 4 " "

"!#

!# $ % & '

( ,

4 &* * "&&( ) 4&4

* *

& &

& # * 4 )

4 # * 4

* *4 2

) * * * & 4

B@#B@# B@#0 4 "B@#2 B@#.

8 &@ *

) 2 & ) 8 ) & )

( ) .

& "" "

6 ) 0 " &

*4 &

6 ) * * *

* " &

0 #C.,

//4

& *& ((

"4 $? 4 ,, '

B@#E "

" )

& * *

4 #%8$

A & * ( 4

4 *

4 < 0/4 4 * &

B@#% & "

" 6& &

* ( "

* *

* B@# *4&

* * B@#

* * #&

"4 85<

(# 8

* & * &4&

( **B@#18

(# ( ( " & * **B@#, < * & -B-2D0. "4 * ( 74

( 8

(# **B@# < /8

(

* " -27-..2.**B@#!< /8

( # "

" & &&

& &

4&4 ( & & "% $ ) & " * &

&& " 4 "

(# &!

" &

* B@#'5 * 4&

4 " & 4 " * "$4&4

( **B@#?5

" &

* * # 84 "

# # 84 , 2 #C8$ '

( " '

, 85< #&

* &

1 ?

& && & & B@#G . #C7 ! '

* $<,,'

B@#4

//4 $& <

,,'

7.**&"

@ *

". 4& *4 "

< @ *

4 " ) 4 *

)

' !

! ' !

+ !

' !

/ -

, . ' ! #

/0# 1 2 3 0 !

4 0# 2

3 0 # ' 0# 2

3 0 56 ' +

! 0 #

7 !

0 !

H- * #

4 4

- * 508

) $?6 ) 4 " #CD !1 I 1

0/ *

*4 *

" & "

* *

0/ "& @ *

4 &

H-

B@#4 *4& "

H-

*B@#5 B@#5 7 #C/ , 1 4

" &

B@#6 4&

0/4 $,

" & 4 * 85<

(# 4& E?$ / D #C , <* # ( &

B@#="

" & E?$ * / #C8

0/4

85< <

- B@# '

* 4 * ,

" & E8 B@# 4& "

&* " *$,#&

$ "

) * " *

%$ "

& 08#, &

4 " &* !!" 6 & %$ "

& A & "B@#B5 4 " B@#HA *&

& & * * @ *

* 4&4 & &

( **B@#1

& ( " * * &

( **B@#, & -B-2D0.

"4 , * 4

( * **B@# " ,

" * < *

( 27-..2. & #C " 8

"**B@#! 0

" &

* *

" &

* * ( "

* & 4 "

& &

" 0/ ! ) ./

# 84 7/ , 0 8 &@ *

4 ( & && &64 *

5 #

& && &'

- 4 * & 6 *

) &

6 * ,4( &

" "

& ) * * &

$ "

& 6) *

%$ "

& A & " A

& *

" "

& 4&* " * & 6 4 " " 4 '

4 & 4 &* " * '

0 #C * '

* 8 & 5< #&

//4 <#&

& "

& <

84 * &

B@#I

& " & 4&(

& & &

< *

# * &

* B@#J

" & * && &*4& & & &

& " & 6

4 * &

* B@#4 &

& " &

* && &*

4 * 6

84 " & * &** B@#11!

B@## " &

B@#. *

4&4

( & &**B@#!! && # " & * && 022D7 * 4&4

( & **B@#BB &&

" & * && 02,.7. * 4&4

( **B@#%% "

& &( 4

4 4&4

( & **B@#)!

"86 84 #

" & && & , 00 8 &@ *

" &

( 4 && & 44 & 4 &&*

* 02 #C0 " $& &

9 ;

/4 & "*& &

*& & @ * 27 ..2.< @ * " *

"" " 4 4" 4 ( & B@&

4 & & B@# 0. 8 &@ *

* "

& &

" 0 #C28

/4 #&

(# <) * "

& 6

" & 27-..2. <4&4

( & **

B@#! < 20 !

" "

* B@#

4 " & 4&4

( **B@#5 07 #C.8 '

0/ 4 , #&

(# 85<

* " "

* 1 0D #C,

//4

" "

& 8 & *'

* "

" "

84 " #

# &

* &

0/ #C78'

4 <#&

& < / ( " * &

1 ?

& & && &4 ,$ '

* &

* 4 * ,

$ ( , 4

,<*# ( "$& & / & ,#,

& & "

& & 70,#, 2 #CD$ ('

* 6<$1 ?

** & * /2DDD20

& & "

% "

$ !

& *

//. < // ** /2DDD204 "

* 8$B8 0./00/.

& &* * /27.0/7. " 1 * "

& *8 4

./< // **4 " * 8$B8 0..7/0/7 &

* * /27.0/7.B@#CD5 2 #C/,

$ ('

* "

& B@# 5 8 $ "

#&<

& 0/4

2 E? B@#H4 & B@9

;B@-9 &(;@ -094; @ -29

; 4

4 "&

4 *

" 4 "

" " 4 & & 20 !C1 "

" * "

** $ & ,**

*C .< 0/ 6&& * *.-44 & #& (*4 ( 4 "

"$ 6& A 4 ( 4

"4*" " '

* &

( 4 "

( "'

& 6 ( ** 4 "'

"4 64 "" 2-. 6& *4 <

(# #'

22 8 &@ *

. '

& 4*

& "

& " 4

" 4 2. !C1 " 1 ?

" '

0/4

" ( <

(# "4 .- "" 2-. &* * 6< A 4 ( 4 "

* <

( 4 "

6 &4 & " 6& (* < ( "

* & *

" 4 & " & 4 &

& &

" 2 % ? ,

4 "&

8 9;

# & #C #C0

& & 08#, *

27 6& 4

* B@# #C &

4 ,

" & 1 & & " 4 ** * & < // * " "1 "

( "

* 4

" * &

1 "

& &6#68 # & ) 4

&&* " *

.#$ &

, 6 4 " && 6

& "

C & ( & 4 " *6 & &

6 * & 4 B52D0. & * *

"& & & &

* 4 & "

& &( " 4 $ 457 "

&* 50* &&

* &

" * & 57

" * 4

C 9 ; & * ""

"*4

< " #68 & *" 4 * & * 6

4 (

) * & * & & 6

( 4 4

6 & ) & *

" " 6#68 & " *9 ; * *

,,'

* E* 4 #%8$

(

* *

& 57 & * * 2D C " , #C * *

& & ) & *

4 9#C; " 4 * 4

5 "

"# & ) 4

C 9#C; & # & *

"* " & ) 4 &(

)

4&4 &

4 ) 4 " '

4 < & " ) 4 " 6

* " ' "4 $ &

64 && & ' $ (

* ,, '

* 9 #C; 4 *&-"

@ *

,,'

* ,,'

2.*

6 &&* "* * "#681 ?

$ ' *

# & ) 4 #%8$

(

( % "

#C4 #%8$

(

*** (*

4 # '

! " ) 84 #

4 * "

64& "

& *4 ** *

84 1 #

, &

) # & # &

) # &

)

* ** * 4

) # & ) #

) 4 2/ 6

& **

* B@#8

* *

#C' $ "

"4 && & "

( *

* *

57 "&* * &&1

4 " , "

* 58

* B@# *

4 & " & *

4 " , E &@ *

4 & **

4 ( 4 * &

* &' '

* * *

* 4

& & " 4

* * , .

& &5**

& &@ *

* * 4& && &

& B52D0.4 & * " ) &

* # & ) 4

" &

* .

& & & ) &

#C' #C0 " . #C'

4 *

" " 1 & & "< //

"4 $ '

* * 9 - - 4 ) * ;

4&* " & -02-,-277 * " 1 6

/ & 4 & "'

50*6

-27-..27 " " & " ( 4 & " 6 &

4 " " 6 4 # 84

) ! * ) ! "4

" ) * * & 44 "4 ) *

44 & " * 4 & 4

) # 44 " * 4 & 4

* ) * & 4

&& @

& ) ( "

* 4

# & 4 ) *

6 ( )

9#C;

&&* * & 84 #

, 8 &@ *

( 4

* && & ( 4 50 && & " "4

& & 4 && & &

* #C && & ) *

) .0 #C0 "4 & &

( & * "14 &

* 1 ?

#68 ) # $ 4 4 *

* *4

" 4 '

*& *C & $

& & *

4 & " 4 64

- @& " 4 &&

( " 4 * & "

* 4 @&

6 $ ) # " 4 * & (*

(& * & 4

" 4 '

C & " , & * * ( * *

* 6 "

" C & 4 & " '

- & * & & *4 * & 6

-0* &&& * 4& 4-7 -7

" ) $ "

44 4 " )

44 4 " &( ) "

4 " ) # "

* ) *4& * ":?

$ *! * 1 ) '

! " ) #

84 :64 & * "$ $ *4

6-7 * (

4 4 ) '

1 ! "! * ) 4 4 ( " " * &

4 "

&4 &

* 8 &@ *

4 ( 4 *

&& & & * ( 4 * ! "1 ! * ) * ) #

* && & .2 6

#C' ( 4

-0 & & 4 & #C #C0 "" ( 4 *

4& " & *4

) * #C C * 4 ( & &

& ( 4 4

* & * & * 6 && 4 & *

& : *

6 & # 84

) ! * ) ! "

, #C#C #C 06

3 #C #C0 .. 6 * & ) * , A & #C0 " &

(

. &&

* & 00,#,

(

) 9& ;4

) &

64 F " (6 ) * ( " *

& ) 6 &&

& 4 &&

E @ ) #C

( 4 4

.7 6 & & ) &

& ) ) * #C &

*& & #C #C0 & &

4 ) # "

4 * .D #C2!! (% "$<,,'

4 "4 !

"& * * ) # 4 " )

"!#

!# $ % & '

(

) * * * & 4

B@#B@# B@#0 4 " B@#2 B@#. $ #C

" & ) 4 &(

)

4& &

4 ) 4 " '

4 #C0 "

" &

4 6 & " ) #C &

*& & #C7! '

* 4 *&- "

@ * 4 " ) )

' !

+ !

' !

( (:" 4 4 & & 4* ) 4&

4 5 &

H- * #

4 4

- * 506 ) 4 " 6 & &

&* *

* #C 8

( # "

" &

* *

4 " &

4 " &$*B@#?5 4 A

4 "4 "

00 & &( K@ &8 4

#C *'

* 8 & 5<#&

84 " & * & **B@#11!

B@## " &

B@#.

* 4&4

( & &** B@#!!&&

" & * && 02,.7.

* 4&4

( **B@#%%

" & &( 4

4 4&4

( & **B@#?

B@# E? B@#H4 & B@9

;B@-9 &(;@ -094; @ -29

; 4

4 "&

4 *

" 4 "

" " 4 & & 0 6 @ A

* * 4

& & 0 & *& *

* 4 & * & & & 2/8#, 2

@ & &** )& &**

* &

&& *

& &&

4 ** * * A &

&( * ** & && *

& 4& && & ( &8 & & *

&& *

& && %$ /

: *, $6! !

# ! ! !

# 8

! #

/ !

! ! !

, , ! 4# !, !'

! ,

, # ( 8 !

: *, 6! * /85! &0 *! 6 , ' * 9!!4! !

5 ! * ! :2*55% % 4 * !/ 8 5 '

# !

0 !

#4 !! !

, #

04 '# !

! !

4 !

# ! 6! * '# #6! !

! ! !'

0 !

#6! !

! #

# !

#4 '! 4 ! !

#!,

! !

06!

0 #

! #

# !

4!, !

! !

#/ !4'# !

# '

# # ! !

# !

! !!

! !

'# !

!, + #

!! , ! 4!

'4! !

#4! ! #! !

#4!

0! !'

! ; !

# * < ! < ! '

4 4

# # ! * /854 #

# !

# '# ! !

! '

! !

!, ! !

! ! '

( 2 !

3 6! !' * 80 ' *0 '= 5 '

#* /85

9 '* - !4! !

5 ! :2*55% >4?3 ? @ 6! 4 '

# #

# ! '!!

0 !

# ! !! !

# ,

, #

0 !

# ; !

4 ! 4 '#

# ! !

# '

! 7 !

0 7!'# !

, #

, '# !

! !

! 7

0 7!! !

, #

* !

# , !

# !

# ! # !

0 !

#( A!!! !

# ! !

0 ! ! ! ! !4 # ! 4! ,

!! !

, / ! !

) '* ;8B&

C''* - !B&! 5!&#'* +83( &

4 &

4 #C0 " & &&

" " 44 " 6 @

4 " & 4& * -0* &&4 &( & C ) * "

"*4

) # "

4 * C #C "

4 * " & ) 4

4 " )

) 4 " '

4 7 6 5

4 *4

B@#''

*" &

8 && * &

4 0 &6 && * & 4 4 2 &B@#??

" & 84 4 0D &6 && * & 4 L &,& * & &( 4 0L & B@#$$ "

*" & # 4 .L &,& * & 4 2 &,& * & &( 4 2 L & D 6

44& 4 " " "

" "*& *

4 & " *

5 &

& "** *( 4

( &

&** )&

* / && "

&** )& &

& "** *( 4

4 ( &

&** )&

* 7

&** )& & ) &

* " ( 4

&4 ( 7 &

& &

/ 4 *4 A

4 "4 "

00 & &( K@ &"

44 *

)

44 4 " &( ) 64&

M/@&*A &

N " * & OM@2&*A &

4 -&&

" O

** & &

4 #C2!! ( % "&

4 &* * "&&( ) 4&4

* *

& &

& 6 "

4 & ) ) * &

4 &

& *

4 ( 4"

) & *4

& & 02# 8 7 && # & 44

* ) !

" * *@ *

4 &

M ( 70 && & ) 4

*6 ) 4 " 72 & & ) *

3 7. & & & 00 0.028#, 278#, 4 & 2/8#, &

"" * * &

&6& &

& *

7 && ",* !-./0-!1 2 3 4 &A

& "

- & 08#, 4 & 2/ 8#, 1

& & & & 000.02 278#, 4 & 2/

77 ,* !--!1-2 4 && # &A

& & 08#, 4 & 2/8#,6& &

*& 08#, & 02# 8 6& & & #

& & 000.02 278#, 4 & 2/ *

7D ? //

* & & 02# 88#, $!32&' $2 2 '

+,+ -.

C ( "5 I C