Ajit Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!"
#!$%
&&''("
) #"("
(+ "%
&"
" , !"
#%(-(.
(" * (&&''(" #%(.
/.
(+ )!0 12%(0 .
(" * &" 3 .
5
("
6% -&'(!"
7, 3
(" 8
# "! .
9:.
9 .
:.
, ("
'! #"("! 3("
5(!-('
#!$%.
!"! "
("%(0"
$!".
&* &"
(&&('
0!$ ""!$ (!
$-"
("
6%+;
'( !"!('
#! $.
("%(0"
* %"
<"!('
"< ( = !"" &" $ & "! -!(+';
*(!' & $ !'"
+; ((+' +"
! ( % $($ "(&"
+ !
:.
% $"
&! '( -( !$
0(('
:
-('( !"
(" !''($ %(0 0%6(( *
'"!("! *- 5((!'
#!$% 6% ( & (-(+(!
* ;(
8
&! (*(! '( +!$ "(" 5((!'
#!$% > " (**!(!"
*( &!$ % + "! !* (- %! +"% "( #!$% " 0%(( /!(6(!
(*(! '(
&" 3 * %"
<&"? '(!-!$ 6%!& (*(! '( 6 !"*!$
(*(! '(.
"% 5((!'
#!$% *!' !!'
!"
($(!"
&" 0!$ &-("
"!
@( !!'
$ 5 !!!.
("%(0"
! ("
:
!-! (*(! !"
@ 5((!'
#!$% &* ( (&&('
'( !"! "
$.
/ (& ! ("
"
(! &( '( !!'
$ "(! &" *- !"*!$ !&!$ &'(!"!** *- !& " '(
("
(+ "
&- -&'(!("A(&&''("
( -&(! #("(- #!$% (- (*(! '( * (- (';
6(& 6 &"
(*(! '( &" '( % ".
!" +("";.
$( " ;'!.
"!'.
*'!$ +.
* &'("!
%(! + 6%! % 6 ';!$ ("
(*(! '(.
"'';
"( " -(0 36 B''(
'
'
&" (-($ "(!$ & 6%!' % '!$ "%(" '*"
&'( ("! '
"
- !"( ( % !.
&" "%6 !"!('
% "
*- "'';
(-($ !"
$"
$!" (*"(" 7, 6%! %
'-!(" !" &'! &" &'! &"
&" +* ,''(=( ($!"(" 6% --!"" "!('
'( #! $
-&'(!("
(&&( +* '( "!('
(
#("(- #!$% C .
#%(0 "'( !
C.
#!$% C9 (&&( ( ; 6!" -&'(!("
&&"
%! ""! & "
!"(''("! % "
"% % %' ("! ' >(-! (! 6!" ! '
!$ *(+! (" % "
&&'! !"
9 @( "!('
!
$-"
("
( = !"" (''
A&" *!' &"
(&&('
0!$ ""!$ (! (*(! &( "!('
" &&''("
("
*!"
!"( ! "
- ( (&&'! ("!
# "! 8 0!$ '( (&&('.
%6 +!$ &!" "
!(" + % "%! ".
- = ! (&&'! ("! :
"#"$!% & %'
@( "!('
*!!$ "% ! (-';
! &! !& " '( !! -( ! !"
!!! '(;
7,
= "! &! !& " '(.
'( "!('
* "% +"
(+ "
&! !& " '( @( "!('
* (''$';
$"
&! *- 5((!'
#!$%
:
6%( (&&('
9 +* !"! "
$ *!'
(&&''("A -&'(!("
% "
+ - &(";
+!$ "%! *( "
06'$ &&''(" "%;
( &! '( "!('
* "% ! !"
#!$%(&&''("
%! "("-"
+* !!'
'(!- & %( '( 6%( +* !-!('
".
% &'( % $"
!& " '( * -(($-"
'"!("! & &
(**!(!"
6%! % &'( ( D>
!! (" %( & %( '( *- 5((!'
#!$% 6%( ( +* "!('
% $"
'( * -(($-"
'"!("!
"!('
* "% * !&!" (''$ (**!(!"
* !% 5((!'
#!$%.
! "
$"
'( "(* %! (-
@( "!('
& "
-( ! !"
* ( & -&'(!(".
% "
!"('' ("
!& " '( (+ "
-"% &! (''$ ! !"
6%( ( & #("(- #!$% #!$% (''$ ; 6!".
% "
" " ("
!& " !" (+ "
-"% +( 0
#%(0 "'( !
6!* 5((!'
#!$% 6% %( '(!- + ( ; 6!" & +* '( "!('
% "
+ $%"
!" ("
(+ "
&- (;
! !" 2% "
-! + "
+"("!('
"(! "! +"6 "("-"
-&'(!("
(''$ ; 6!"
2(' %( #!$% 6% '(!- %( *(+! (" (''$ % "
& +!''
+0 6%! % !"% %(!$ !('
-+ +(!$ && ("
>(-!("! 2(' %( #!$%
6%! % -("!('
* &"
( & (
!
!
"#$%&'( )) )
# "#$%&'( ) ) * "#$%&'( ) # + , )
# ) ) ) #
# + ) , # ! + )- @( "!('
& "
!"(''("! % "
!" " "! * -("!('
"(! "! "( !**"
6!" +!'' & *(+! (" (''$ % "
&&'! !" +("";
6 * +"* '
( "% "! !";
!('
-+ (" (''$ +!'' !(! +!''
+0 @( "!('
* "% * "% -("!('
"(! "! ' ("! (''$ ("! ' ! % ".
$( ;'!.
+!$.
!" +("";
"%! " "! & *6 6!".
% "
"; & ""!$ 0 !'
6%( ( & ; 6!".
&"
'' " "(6 $( "%6 !"
% "
$( "
*!
@( "!('
= "! '(;
$!"("! 7, %' '(;
(; *("('
"% ( %( !" "! -+''!%-"
' ! & "! ";
&! -!"; %( '$ !**"
7, ($(!"
&" (''$!$ " "! "(!$ & "%*"
: ($!
'"
('
!-&'-" ! ' !**"
( * '(;
'$!$ 7, ("
!**"
&!"
"!-
+* &'! "(" -&-! "('0 6 $!$ *-
8
B6.
!$ "!('
"0 "(! ";
"( &'! !( "! 6%!' ("!$ -("" &" &'! (;
! !" %"
" %"% (( && " : #%(-( '( '
* %-"';
($ -("" (! "% ! (-';
! ** "
*!!$ !!'
!-!('
"!('.
!! -! (!("! "("-"
6!" !!! '(;
'$!$ 7,
@ '
" '( !"! "
$.
/ (& ! ("
%( "(! &" *- !"*!$ !&!$ 5((!'
#!$%A&'(!"!** *- !& " '( "% '( "!('
"(;
""' '(6 *!!$ = &! !& " '( C!"% & "
(!("! "("-"
6!".
% " -! (!("! "("-" ("
!"!(" "!('
C!"% & "
'(;
7,.
% " ! !"
= "! "0 &'(
7, $!" 8
! (*" '(;
(; + ( ""'-"
"('0 6
& ( "
*(!'
""'-"
& !$.
&" *!' -&'(!"
&'! "%!"! 2% .
((+';
**! !"';
>&'(! '(; @( '
&&"
%! (+ ""! !" *''6!$
$-" B<+' # &-
6%! % ( ! ( +'6 , ) *!+ ", - "!( % % %& . /01102 3 340115/20050110 "&"
367 ( $ 74 6%!' ('!$ ** "
*!!$ !!'
!-!('
"!('
%' % ! * *
. /)0 1! *
2
* " (3 / 0
* 1, ,3 /0 2
4$4
5 ,
! * ** *
*3/ 0* !
*
1! * *
* , *2
*
# 2
)2
) 1!
* * )6 1!
!
* 2
*" ( # !
! / 0 *
* !
,(
78 , 7* *
*
* ( *
,7!
(*
1!
!
,
,
*7 , (,
*
2
5
9 , * 5
5
1!
* **, *
*
* * , #+'8 #+' "
+ -
% ) "
, ./019:290
8 :97 /019:2 ; /&2 4;60195 "&"
91:3 $ :03.
B?+' (" = "! (!("! "("-"
6!" %' )
! " 4
*
!
! *
** * *
1 ,* ,, , *
!
# ! * :
* ,
, * , ! *
* * !
! * ! ,
*
, * *
!
!
*
*
!-!'( !6 + !"("
% -) " +%"</97362 9 616 9736 /2 916 9736 :3=>
- - "
"?/0113294634/01912:/&2 631= "#@A <-
% ?/019123979/019125 /2;57= = "! '(;
7,.
B "!) '-
% < "
. /01162 7 976 0116 /2 9095 0116 "&"
:6: ( $ 973.
B?+' # &- %'
*
:
,
* ,
* , ;
! 2 * , ! ! 6<
, * ! 1
** !
= !
, !
,
! !6<
% ,
! *
*
* * "
! ,
*
* ! !
, ! ,
!
>#
! *, * 9!4 ! , !
*
#!-!'(';.
" &# -"$+-
% '"A B./019:290 :45/019:2;/23910195 "&" 346 ( $ :35B?+' # &- "%( %' ) * 5
, *
), ! !6<
, ,
! ! *6< *
*
*, , * * # * , ! ! 6< * *
)& * * * $% 2 * $ 1 !
!
* **
$%
*
5 * ! ! 6<!
* ?,2 *$
*
9 * * * ,
+>) >)++) $%*
), , ,
, * ** ! * !
)+>)>)++ /"#$70*
/"#$70
? @
*$ $ 1 ! **$% * *
! !
* 7 2 ! %"
" %"% +
!(%"# " ! )!0 1 2%(0 .
'( '
* &" " '( "!('
&( 6''
( !!'
& !$ ! "
"(0 &'( +"6 &".
"% "% ** "
" - !!'
& !$ (;
&( '( !!'
("
(** "
!-!('
& !$ & !('';
6%"% !!'
& !$ ! "
"(0 &'( +"6 &"
C!"% & "
'(;
'$!$ 7,.
% " "% &! -!";
+"6 +"% &("! &! 7, = "! -+ 7, 6 $"
$!" ($(!"
&" * " "! "(!$ & ($!
'"
('
= !&-"
6%! % ( ( D>:
2% .
'(;
(;
>&'(! , &&"
%! ""! '( '
* &" !" *''6!$
$-" B<+' # &- " B?+' # &- CB &"$+ D +-
"
,!+ D +. /01162 : 541 0116 /2 9919 0116 "&"
659 ( $ 537 6%!' ("!$ !!'
! ! !-!('
"!('
%' 4 !
**
* ** !
, *
*5 !
,** 4
*
*
*,
! ,
,
, ! * !
! , * !
* % # !
!
! * ! * 2
* 4 *
!
,
7 A2 2**2 *A B)+ 24<))
C(<)+ 24+C)+ 4 DE) )+F!
C/(<++ ) >)0 ) ( !
*
!
** *
9! 4 *
;
> >*
, *
* !
! , #
,*
* !
*
!
#*
!
,
*
) ( * ! * !
* ,
, ,
* !
1
* 3! , *
,
*
!
!
> >* 2
! , !
# 1 6 # !,
# , !
2
7 * , !
* -
, "# #+ "-
% !!
./019629990: /01962:/25170196 "&"
574 ( $ 903 = "! & -&"! ! +* (&&''(" ".
# &- %' ) !* 5
*
* * *
* * !
= ! , 4 # $ % &'# $ % &'(
)**
*F 4 !
*
! !
,C /244 &G3 + >)G30 * *
! *
! ,
*
* 5 ,
! 8,H 8 H )
* *
*
$
*
!2
!
! 1! * 5
4 *
! * !1!
* 5 , ! + &'+ &'(**)
,* **)
*"(& - % & - % ( ,
)" $ .$ ' / 0' .$ ' / 0'(
,)
"0 ,9!4 III %
! !
> *
* *7 ! , , * * !
* !
!
- / 0 )
, 4 *
* 1 1 1 1 (
*)2"
4 C/244)&>& 0 FJ@ , *5 *
*
* *
! ,5 !
! *
*1 *
! ! *
*
*
! *1 ( ! *1 , * 5
*! ,
*
*
!
,
5 *
* ! , * , ** /27! 2 !2 * A$B7! 2 !2 * A$ /
0 244& C
244/40F0 *
,
! !
1! *5 *
, !
* !
* !
1! ,
!
* * - / 0 )* ! *
* 9! 4 ! 5 * > !
(
2
E! ! ! ! * * * >
! , + "
&-
< 'B& %!
' %. # !./01172 91 :19 /01912 9 /&2 55; 0117 "&" 964; ( $ :9:
6%!' ('!$ & !"* ("
(&&''(" "($.
# &- %'
9 + *
! !* C )
! ,
* 5
* !
H
* !!
* , ! * ! *
, *
,
, 5 * , !
- * !
*
.
5
.9!4 ' * * -
@( #"(" '
+-!"" #"(" "
*!' (&&('
($(!"
!-& $ ! '!!%"E "#"$! 8 7- (!$
$-" !" +"% '.
!"
( + $'( "% ( ( ".
%( *("
"(!$%"
( 0"
*- '( %'!$ *!!$ !!'
!(! !-!('
( +!!$
+!!$ ** "
*!!$ !!'
!-!('
&
& ("
!& ".
! *!!$ , ( !!'
& !$.
*!!$ ( - ' +(
& &&( ! 6%( ( !-!('
"!('.
& "! "(+'!% $ !'"
+; ((+' +"
'!
& & "! +!$ ( %- & $ !'"
+;
((+' +"
B<+' # &- "!- ($(! (" = "! ** "
!-!('
& !$ !(! !!'
& !$
"
$-" !" +"% ' ('
"(;
!-!('
& !$ !$ & ;
!-!('
& !$ "(;
!!'
& !$ !$ & ;
!-!('
& !$ !
$-" !" +"% !.
!"
6 ' + (&&&!(" '0 ("
*''6!$
$-" B<+' # &- "
, &!%" % ! - "%" % "# /97702 : 499. "% # &- %' ! !&'!(;
& !$ ( + '$('';
"! 6% -&'; ( = !"" !-!('
( 6%! % ( !**"
*- "% &("-"('
& !$
+ 2 * *
, , !
* *5 *
* ,** *
* , ! *5 *
!7
* , ! # , 1>
* - , (
'&" +%"<-+ %&#"
! #./977725 ;47 (*" ("!$ !" &! !("! '(6.
((
'(! 6 $ !'! & "
"(;
&("-"('
& !$ 6% !-!('
& !$ (- "
(''$("!
: ( &!$ +* -&""
" "%! ( = !"" !-!('
"!('.
%6 ! !&'!(;
& !$ % !-! *- ! !-!('
&( >&(" "
$! +!" (''6( !$ &! &! # &- %' ,
* ! * *
(
!
**
,
K , * ! * -* !
, 5, ** , * *
! *!
! , **
* ** ,,
,
# , 5, ** 5, ** , !
! !
# 4
*
, ,* *
*
5
* 5 , 1
* ! ,- * 1 *
* !
# !
22 * !
, !
! , ***
, !
* *
*
;
-( !";
"%
$ + % # &-
#+ !+< *) AD &-
% ./019925639.6%!'
('!$ " - &("-"('
! ! !-!('
& !$ '
*
, *
C /0 (1
!
,3 /0 ?
1
!
, * !
3 /0(1
!
!
3 /0 * ! !
* !
1
!
!
! *
3 /0(1
!
,"
* ?
, *
* ( / 0 * 4
2
* 4 * 4 $ 3 /0 * ! 1
!
* *
* ! *
** !*#
1
!
!
,
3 /0 *#
!
*
* *
, ! ! ! *
*
, ( %(.
!!'
& !$ +"6 5((!'
#!$% &" 5((!'
#!$% *!' !!'
!"
0!$ &-("
"!
% &( (6(;
:
& (&&''(".
% $"
&! !& " '(
:
@( !!'
$.
("%(0"
!-! !"
5((!'
#!$%
8
:
! (*" -! 5((!'
#!$%
& -&'(!(".
"%;
$"
&! !& " '(
:.
"% .
"% ( * @? 5((!'
#!$% *!' (&&('
+* '( !"! "
$.
/ (& 0!$ ""!$ (! ("
:
&( @( !!'
$.
("%(0"
*( " !! (" !"
&!$ ( ! (" +"6 @? 5((!'
#!$% &" "
&(";
(*(! !" 5((!'
#!$% &( (6(;
:
( & -&'(!(".
% %( &! %! +"%
:
B( + &! '(.
"% = "! * @ 5((!'
#!$% *!' (&&('
($(!"
!!'
$
'(!-!$ % &! '( !
:
!!'
!"
!-!
@ 5((!'
#!$% *!' (&&('
+* '( !"! "
$.
/ (& !&!" %(!$ '(!- &! !& " '( % -(! !'"
! "
&("! !&(" & !$ &!$ +* '( !"! "
$ '(!- 5((!'
#!$% * !% ( (**!(!"
** "
%! +"% ' $"
5(-(+(!
(- +"!"
" "%! (- &'( 5((!'
#!$% ( "("
-&'(!("
$"
(**!(!"
"%! ** "
:
6%( ("
"!- ! !".
5((!'
#!$% %6 "("
,"
(' !& " 6%"% &&''("
%( & %( '( = "! $"
-(($-"
"'
!"
(*"(" *( " '' "!';
!! (" *!!$
'( "!('
( +(
& !&"
! *!!$ !!'
%( +(!$ "!('
($(!"
&"
("
6!".
("
.
!""
&("! (''$("! 6 ""('';
!**"
!-!('
& !$ !(! !!'
& !$ 6%! % '
+"6 @? 5((!'
#!$% &"
B(&! #!$% D' "! !( (&&( (
C &&"
& %( !" +("";
-&'(!("
!$!('
+!''
(+ &;
"(! %&0& +(!$ !**"
!0
@( "!('
!$%"';
'
! B(&! #!$% ("
+ '!
& 2(' %( #!$% C8 (''$ *(+! (" % "
+-!"" +!''
("
"!;
+!''
+0 &" %!-.
!"
* "% "! !";
!('
-+ (" +!''
+0
D.
(" "
! ' *6 +!''
,"
!! (" +!''
&" 2(' %( #!$% ( "
+ '!
& '(!- !"(''("! % "
(+ "
-"% &! (" (''$ ! !"
6%( "% 6!" > &"
#%(0 "'( !
'(!- !"(''("! -"% +( 0
#%(0 "'( !
'(!- % "
!"('' (" ! !"
!"'* ("
&-
"("-" !**"
6!" & !('';
#%(0 "'( !
& "(;
( % "% "(! "! "
-! 6%! % ' + !$ ! -("!('
"(! "! (+ "
>!" .
!**"
6!" ! ' !**"
' ("! (''$ ("! ' ! % ".
!".
" + @( "!('
+(! "("-" !**"
6!" * &'( % "
!& " '( "
"(+'!% (! +"
"%"! !";
& "! !
"(! "! "
"
% & -&'(!("
"6 ; 6!".
0 !'
& % "
"
!"
*! 6%( ; 6!" & "(6 $( '' " "%6 % "
$( "
*! 6% $( $%"
*!.
% "
+ "
2% -("!('
"(! "! !**"
" (-';
! -( &! ! & %( -(($-".
(+ %($ .
*!'!$ (&&('
@? !"( !! & %( !"(''("! (''$ ("! ' !!! ' ("! (''$ ("! ' ( 6''
"%! " "!.
"% !"
("
+ %' "% -! "(! "! "("-"
6!" 6%! % ( + !$ *(!' (&& !(" & !$ 6 "
&!$ +* !!'
- = (!
! !('
"%!";
, !-!('
"!('.
"(( &* %' - $ !'";
;
%!$% + '!
& & "!
,
$-" !" +"% !.
B<+' # &- %' '(;
$!"("! 7, "
*("('
;
(
@( "!('
&& '0 !" *( " ! -"( 6%! % '(; $!"("! 7,
,* ( >&'(! * '(;
( $".
'(;
( + !$ & "! ";
("
+ % (! !-&';
$ "% '(;
$!"("!
7, 2% -!";
+"6 &" &&''("
*!' !**"
7, ($(!"
&" (''$!$ " "! "(!$ & "%*"
($!
'"
('
!-&'-"
"% ('(;
-!";
+"6 +"% &("!.
!"
("
+ '(!- -&-! "('0 6 $!$ .
6%! % '" !" '(;
'$!$ 7,
,"
* "% !""!$ "! ("
&!"
"!- "" -&-! "('0 6 $!$ .
"% '(;
"0 &'( B6 !$ "!('
" '(;
"0 &'( ( "
!( "! &("
&'!
@( "!('
!$%"';
'
"% '(;
$!"("! 7, *( " ! -"( "
6(("
!$( (! '(;
9 B<+' # &- &("';
%' +*!"
+"
,* "6 !6 ( &!+'.
+*!"
+"
- "
+ $("
,"
+ * "% %' !* "6 !6 ( &!+'.
( = !""('
% ' "
+ "
(! B!$% + ( "% +' & -&"! !
B<+' # &- 57"+ "
&-
< 'B&
%!
' %. # !./0117291:19 6%!' ('!$ & !"* ("
(&&''(" "($ %'
+ *
! !* C )
! ,
* 5
* !
H
* !!
* , ! * ! *
, *
,
, 5 * , !
- * !
*
.
5
.9!4 ' * * -
&&';!$ &! !&' '(! 6 B<+' # &- = +!!$ ** "
*!!$ !!'
!(! !-!('
".
'(;
$!"("! 7,.
(!("! "("-" -( 6!".
6 *! '( 2!('
6''
( *!!$ 6%! % 6(("
!"*
:
-!(+';
*(!' & -( ! !"
%( *(!' & >!" % "
"% ("! '
2% -("!('
"(! "! +"6 "("-" -( !**"
6!"
@(!$ (! *(+! (" &&'! (''$ ("! '.
"% -("!('
"(! "! +"6 &!"! (''$ ; 6!" -!(+';
*(!' & ' ("! (''$ ("! ' ( 6''
( "%! " "!
2% .
'( "!('
*(!';
((+';
%' & "! *(!' & -( ! !"
' ("! ("! '
&!! >& "!('
"
';
&!+' !6 + "
(' !"
*(! ((+' ("
+ "- ( & (;
-(.
"% 6(("!$ !"*
" (+.
"% ('6(; & -&"! ! ( ( = !""('.
"% +' & -&"! + '!
& & "! & $ !'"
+; ((+' +"
'( "!('
&( "(!'.
( &(0!$ 6 *! !*!-!";
(!
2% -(!*"
.
!''$('!";
(&&'! ("! -! (&& !("! ! 6%! % ' -&'
*- ( &!! !**"
*- &!! *- '( 2!('
"
7!!$ -!"
&"
(&&('.
6 ( ! &!! '( (&&('
+ '! ( !$';
(&&'! ("! 0!$ '( (&&('
( 6''
( (&&('
!-! /2 /
C%"% &(0!$A( GA3