Menka v. State Of Haryana & ANR






   
  

 ! " #$%$&'(#) *+ ,
 

--.%/ 0 1 

   1 .%/ (' 2-(  1
111   2-(  1
1

 

     




   !"  #




  $
%%%%%%%

 

+ &'

'

()*+, ",)$$-.'

    /", ! * '

  $' 0"  ,

) ,)

 "'"   .1..12.23.41($+ (,+ *  .356 (

 
7568+    .$.56  1    6 

)9":

 

 $-$(

 
7:6:

8+  .($+( +  "6  " & ' (   

+

 ;<; (

  
76&

8+ $ #"%' =5> <1(?94+;-$-. * ,   ) (?9 2+   9
  

$
 *"  55 *" ,# 6 ,>* > ! 

**  ;$-.'*-)  ,   ' " ---@-- )   , * 

 7A8 (

 9
",)+* , , * :

   6 ))

 '  , (# ) 6 , >* >  ! +   0"  ' "     , ) ,   

"B' *     , '

 ) *  "



' "

& *)  

 *

* "  : '

( )=5>+, 

  '   * &'

 

 , * )   & ) 

, ) " * '

  *

'   )   "  " &       *      * )    ,  "  :,,  "

"  # ) ! :"  '



 * * ' *

*',  !)&  * * ,   ))  '    ,  '

)

   )  !      

  

   ", ,    ,

"&)*,'

9 "
,'

 )   '

 >)   

  *  

,(?9$$+*

 : -;-$-.         6  C ! 

  

)     (  + ' ,  >
-2 =
3423  ) *  

 '* C'   6 *  D>5 6 * !   :

 

)  5 ',  

.


"'

* "

 "  '" "

 * "  5 ',*

)"

 ', ) '


'

  ! 6* #    6 ,  !  *     !)("

+')  ",     ' "    '    ) ) '"   *     7" 

)8& 9
*)

 *    7"  ))8 & 9
* )!6*#    6 ,  !   --$-.  5 ' , ,      '  C> 9
 (C>  E@2@.  --$-.+ *   "

       * ) * *

"

, 8     '

C> &@$1@$-.@! C  -;-$-. , , "

       )  5  C>   "

      * )  " *  *)* *  "  '

 &  ,   9

* "  ))

)  -$-. (?9$+ * ) ' 

9
 ' *   

, ' , DD? <  -$-. *

  5  ) 

)  ,  !) ("

+   '  , ',", ( 9
+ )*)  )      '"!) )

'  "

: -;-$-. !) *   '

    ",  *  *

" ,"  "D 

# , ! 

5 ' ,  # )  !  

3
 $-$-..-$-.3-$-.2-$-.'"

)' 

9*   "  ))    )  8'

  1-$-."')  (?94+ 

5 ', * ",) 

 ** "'   ))& 0"      )&*    )) 4-$-.'""   , '

 ) ))'  ) " '

 )*

 ;-$-. * 

)'

,=5> & ) (?91+   * , 

 "   13 6  6 )

"

(

 
76 68+  '

    /"  ,  5 6 (D" + !   $--$-.*    *
 FG" B) "  , H

*       *  -;-$-. 5  ,    ) ,   ) , '"     

 * ,   , * 5) )

( 9
+* *" , , )

)$@.   &* '   

 * :65 , 

) '

B*'   ) 

) , )'

 )*  "

 ) *7""     &  5     ))'  * *) *   )

5"  ,  "5   '

* , 7   

 

 



! 5 

2
   ) )   5   * **)  G" B ",  "H

*  5 ,  "   1@4    " )     *    G" D  "*   ,H

* 5   )"

   " ) 

  '

 *  , 7"#

$  

 





!  G"  B "        , )   

, H

* 5    ,)  ,  G" B " )

, , "

)  *

) "

 "H

* A

, ,) )5 ''

",

))  "5*  )  "   G"  B "        , )   

, H

*  5  ,)    , I & ) * , '

  9  '

    /"  ,  5 6 (D" + !   $--$-. 5 *   )'  "

   )   9   ,  '   )  J  *      9     ,"

  ),) '

 &  * ,  )   9)

) D    (B2+   :

 ! 6* #    6 , 

1
 !   $--$-.   9
 * ,  )   9)  -<-$$-.

) D  ! D,  (B$+  D"

,  ,   ,   *    " ,   $  !) ("

+  !) ("

+ * 

  $--$-.    $*

 $2-$-.)'

* 

 -<-$$-.'"*  '

"

 * ,    , 

)    ,    (7 8+,   $* 

 "' "   .1..12.23.$..41($+(,+$-
.356  .(+ (+(9+(9+.($+( + 6&

  1 :6:

 =, )     $*  ,
     /",! 

 "' "   .1. *  .356  .11 *   .3 56    .23 56    .41 ($+ (,+  *    .3 56   .$.56  1 :6:

  .($+( + 6  &

  >  $    "     ,

) ,) ,"  )  5"

   " 9) 9
 BJ  B$JB.J )  B3JD   *  "

) 9)  B2JD ! D, *  "

) 9)  9
B$J    )*  "

) 9)    $  B2J 5 "'  , *  )   *   , B1J5 ,,:

5 B4J"

 ,   D  B<   > !" /56 !  * 

  ) (?91+   "     13 6 6 

4
 B;) ) 

)**  9)  ")*     : )    "       

),

")  ,,   $* "  ) )   ..6 6 *   ,  *,

 '  ) 

 ' 
     "   9    "   ), , * )   '

6 "

 ',"  , "    >  $ 9) *   &    /",!   ,      )  

  ",)  $$-. 0"   $  ,

),)

,,   ,    0"   $  ( 9+ )"* B    "

  "

  " 6 "



*   C  "

 ," " 

  * "

 '

           

,    ' "   )) '

  $   

  *        )   *  *  ,  B3

  )    &   

    * 

 9
'""           9
        "

 

"      $ )) *         *  *, '

)B

  *

<
 '  " * ' )"  "5 *   

")  ) 9 " '  * " 

 D  (B2+  " " ' 9" 

"

* )* " * * *    )  ) 9)    

") 

  )    9     6 "

   "   , "

9
 "

 "   *  )

)) 5 "

   * ) ) " , *   , ,  

  "

,     ) &)

)*    ,*'"'   =    C'



      ) 9)  9* "

    "

,  ' &     "

 )   9 '

* "

  "

' 

")    '"&

 *    "

           *   ) 9         

 ,

  $

,

 

* *  , 5
  

   
   





8'"

)6 "

* ", 

   )  )  '

  *
 %

& !' '!( !

 

!#!' ( # 

)!(! (( ! '$

( 

*

& !

 

 ( !!



)!(!

;
 !(

   !# $

 

(!+ !

 

,!#

 &  -!(

( 

-!' (!(# ( * . #  &

'

  

#

 -!

&)(

+ 

 !

 

(( #!(

 (!# & !

 '!(!#

 



    ! !

!#    !&



 '!( !

 (! # 

 !(!



!-

 

!

   (( #!(* . (

'

&  

#  -!'



(



(!(# (

!

!

!( !' !$   

!

#!$   $

!-!!$ ! 





 !

! (

-

 

#

 !# !

$$ # !- ) !(  ( $*


( (!-



!

#  ! !

  (

& !

 '

!

   



  ( 





&$  '!(!#

+ (!#

!



 )!(! #! 

 &&*/

& 8' "

) 6 "

 '

  '

  5    9       )" '  "  * ",

   ))   " 5

 )    6 "

   

"     )      )    )   

    *  )   "

     )   

  0"   

) 

!,  '

   * * * 9)  )    9     *     ,            "    &     6 "

 * ,

" " * 

"K,  )  

9    

")     '

, 

-


 " )* ' ' " &



 9

)) )")' )

): "   6 "

 *  

 *   ),

)6  > )   6 C !  ' ,  >
-2 =
3423(  +)*

 '* C'   6 *  D>5 6 * !   :  

)  5 ',  

 "    "

 "  '"   "

    *

) 
'

  ,   "

 )      &  * ,  )  ! 6* #    6 ,  !  * 

9
* )

      !6*#  6 , !    "

 !) ("

+ *   )  # )    9)  * "

 -;-$-.5 

" * ,"  " " "



 '

 

5 "'  , B. *  "

    ,   


9)   *
 F5

C> 

  

 * )   ?

     DD>  =5> *

  ", 

)     * 

  

  : .$-. * 5  #   !      "

  9
)) &           )  , ' "   


 , "

 "

5 ) 0"

)     * " 



 )&   "

         )    *   "

* , ,  ;$-.5) 0" 

) ) ))'  "

  9
 , ,   * ' "  ;$-. , ,  "

'

)'"  "  , , 5 )   *   ;$-. , ,"

   ' "

*  ' "  I 5* "'   

"K)    *     B.   

'          -;-$-.  *
 F: ;$-.  ' " ---@-- ) 5  ,* )

 )  ( 9
+ * , , :

 6 ))

"' "

 6 ,    * *   ) "  # 

"'  "



"     *    *  "

)

) '  *  '

*  ,  

' ") 9
     )), " " 5* , 

 *  9
*,   &) '

* *,  *!)

$
      *  , )  !) &   "     *  

 ))  "  )  B 







"

 " "

 ) * )

  5

 "  " & ), 

" ))

"  9
5   **     ;$-. * 5 ,

 " 5 " )   )  # 

! 5

  ) )  )  ) ) )    ) 

D! * ) ) *

 *   !"#   '  ) ,"

I 5) '   *  )?92* 



 '

  5)?92  )   $  ,

* ))*   5)  )!)

"* *,   * 9
 &)    

)?92 ;-$-.*

'

  * "

'

  /"  ,  5 6 (D" + ! 

 ,,   )

 "     13 6 6 *  ,      )

  $      *   ))  *    5  )   )   *  * "   '

    "

, , *     , 

.
    "     13 6 6  * ,    ' * **, ,  *"  ' )"  "  9
    B     *  '

  $

,  9
    *   $ "   

 )  & 

9
    ,  ",

    & )    *  

 '

   /"

/"   !  -;-4$-.* , , **   

"

 , ,*

9
*" '

 '

&* '

* , 

* *,  5)   )   $'

,,    *  )   B



 *

 '  " * ' )"  "    *    "     &)   B3  -;-$-.    

) 

)        ",  ) *  

       *   *  , )   "  "    ",  (+ 

,  "   ;-$-.,     (?94+       6  C !   1-$-. , *   ) * " ,   )

 *  , " "

        ,,  " 

)    9


3
 *

' "  " * '

'

 *  9
* B 

     *

 '      ?

)

, ) '

    ;-$-.  ()  9+ *  ,"

 *      ) (?92+      )

  $ )* ,B3 &     " '

  )      ) *  )   $   '

 * )?92*

 ;-$-.  )?91

"   136 6 $--$-.  , * * )*

'

   /"

 /"      -;-4$-.  ?

      )   -$-. '

   9
   ,  *  ,   $ * )

     "    *     

 ( 9
+  !) ("

+ *   , ) * 

     

 ( 9
+ *         "  "   &      

   ) 5 ),*,  ' * *

 '  * ) B.* "  , 

& *   , '



"5*    $ *

 '  ' )"  "&  , '

      5 *   *   " 

   *

2
  9
 *  ', '

", '    !     ,

   !,  *   '

 

")    6 "

 )) 

* * , ) " ' 5      ,   "    * 



)   $&   '    , "    "     * ,'

 * 5 ',      

  &     "

 "     

") 

   "

)   $    '   )  5 ,,:

 " 

   "

 "  

0"  "

 "  

 *   ) )) .111 / .1

 

/     (#) *+ ,  ( ! 0*1*"