Rakesh Kumar And ORS v. State Of Haryana
!"
!"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.,/01! "!
$%&'( )*+,-(2)'3,40,$51 # $ % &' ( $ )' '
$ % &*' & '!"
!.,/01! "!6
$!"#%
"
"
& '
" " "
" '
( "" )* " ""
+ ,!"#-./ ! 0! ( 1
( + 2
()*
34!% ( 4!% ( "(4
+ #
"+ %+ # *1/ #"1
" /!
) !
"+/
(5 (&(52( 67 * 1/ 0 /
"
/" !
"8
67 !
"# % %
9 /
" *%
( ! "# % %
" *
67 !
"# #! % %
1*
9 /
" *%
( ! !
"# % %
"
%
67 !
"# #! % %
1*
(
9 /
" *%
( ! !
"# % % %
"
1%
&67 !
"# #! % %
" .
%
9 /
" *%
( ! !
"# % % %
" 13
/1"" !
/ /!
* / /!
&
+ $ 0:
;+/! *#
1
0 #, !(
/
/ 1 %/ 0
<1 %")* /
%
7$ "
!# , #" ") 3 ")* "% % !!)
/)* % *%%) / ! 1 / " 0"!
%1 )* "
0 #4
! 92"
* )!
59:%
# < % *%%) ")!# % 0 #
" / 1 1" #!
" ! +1 3 !
" / !0
"
"
* &
1 ( 10( %!"" 6 #
( " ")"*
%1 !
# /!
! "(1
% *"/ "7$ 1 !% 0 #
% # 0) 3 ")* %)/ !
"
* &
)!
( " ")"*1 /%
"1 !
* %" / .
%
/(1 " ")"*7$
3 )* % * !
0 / /%
#!
" < " ")"*1 )!
%!
* #1 )*! 3 / / !%"
7$ % / *
) / %
0 " /
(-. 7;29+/ #
$ 0(% =6(-. 7;
'9(1 # "!
"+/ 5 9
67
5 )*6 / %4!% %"
*( //%
")*<
4!%
"
) 7 0 0 " %
>!
" 0 # , !
/ / / % =+? %1 !%% " =+?
%0
") " ")"*7$ 1
3 )* "7 (6 / #(+/ % %(+7 /( 1
") 1/ 0
0 " / 6 / %4!%
#1 /
0 !, #" (
"/ "7$ (%1 "7 / / "0% % "
/
( 1 * 1/ !
" #9) !/ !
")3
/"/ !# )
# %!
"
)"
1 / 0 "
" / 5
//!" "1 "!/")*+
) + #(!)
"+
/ # , !( # 1 1
/%
( -. 7;'9 < % " " / !
%
( -. 7;'9 ( # "
# 0 0%
/%% / % 6 !!
/ " / !
%
( /
3
"(1 /1!" /%% / %(1/0"% // / %
)!
"
%
>!
"0 #, ! !#3 /(-. 7;&9( /0"
"!#
(-. 7;
'9( //0* 1 " 5
( //!" "" / " )!
0 0%
/%
(
% *( +!
1 , #" ( + %(7
$ , #" (,
@
) ( 34!% ,!# %(4 + # % ( 4!%
"+ %+ #
+ # /%% / % 6 0
1 /%
"/
1 !
! /%
/"
%
: /!
.
!%)1
!
/
%
1 /""!
"+/
5 7 *" / /!
" ""
* 1 * % /
/ "! 0 * *1 / 0 /
"
/"( /"
)0 < /(
:
? " /!
# )
0%
#!"
/!
0 / ? "
/!
# +
0%
#!"
/!
0" / )* "
) "!)
"! $!"#%
" ! ) 1 '
; 0 " "/!
"# !#
$!"#%
"/"0*/ ! * 7;
% "+ # "
(-. 7;
9 7;5 +7 $ 4!% " 0 " / )*
"
(-. 7;59 //"
/
"
( 2 &
-+6 % "
""0 " / /
*3 ( " / )
# %"
= /+/ / ?
)
*( "!)
<" %
=+?( "!)
7;:
) +
4!% " 0 " /)* "
(-. 7;:9 //"
/
"
(
& &
( % "
""0 / A 1 )0% /
" )3 )
# <" %
=+?(+!
& 7;'+
) ""
1 !)
"+!% (11 +
/ 0 # 6
/ *
(
""
/ *
" # 1 1 //!" " 1
' "!/")* %)+<(7 /+
3
"" "
" /
* )!
/ % <1 "/ "
"1 /.
" )* " 7!) / 7/!
< " /%
(-. 7;'9 <10( //"
%( /
% 1 "0 % <"
" + $$
"
"
) %
/1 / # "(1/%%
"
%!"7$
"1 -. 7;'9( 1 /"" <" " %
/%
(-. 7;'9(
//!" " #1 % *%%)/%%
"%!" 7$
"1 )/ # <1 %"
"1
-. 7;'9(1 /"" < " " %
//!" "
%
! ")"!/"
"1! "
" / # "
%!"7$ ) /
/ " #!
"1 -. 7;'9( 1 /"" <" " %
/%
)!#
//!" "
""!/" %) /
"B! / % 3 B! *% %
"1 -. 7;'9(1 /"" < "%
" " /
" / !
%
(-. 7;'9 (% ")* //!" " <" !##
//!" "/ " #!
/ //!"
"%
1 / */%%
/ %
" "" ")"*7$ <" "
%
(-. 7;'9 < " "
/
%
5
("!/"
//!" " ) /
" 1
%
-. 7;'9(1 /"" 6 /.
)* "
" / /!
( "%
"
1 !%% " )* +<
<
0 /%
#!
#1 +7
% 1*1)!
/%
#!
" 7;
) C "+ #""
1 $
0
//!" 4 !" " / !
%
-. 7;9 <# /0" !
/ ) ##
?5D
:
" "% /
" / //! / //!" !"
" / !
%
( -. 7;9 < # /0" 7 /3
0 / ) ##
<5& & '%0 #, ! 6 / .
(""
!) /1
1
%
//!" //!"1 "%
//!" 7;2
) $0 %
1
<""
2
( 1
0 # , ! /
/ 1
#"!
* 6 %
%(/ %% %
"
7$ "
!# , #" 1 %!"")* % *%%))/ ! "%!1 )*4
! )!
5:%
# +%
"1
)*2"
* ( % *%%)
B! " )!
7$
*)!# ) /3 +1 / !)* % *%%) +1 1" #!
% ! %"
*(1 %!"")* % *%%)
(" ")"*
( "
0 #, ! !
" 1 %!""
%
9 % % .
1 / "!/
%
# "
# "
1 # 0 )*
* / ) #" % *7$
2
)!
( 1 /%
/%
#!
" " ")"*7$ 1 / " !
")"*
7$ 1 !
)!
#* 4 1 !" 6 /.
( "%
" " %
/%
1
0 #, ! 2
<
"%
!)%
"(-. 7;29( %
# 0 )*/
% <" " 0 * %
*
7;&
) 7 0 4!% ""
#1 / / 1
/%
#!
"0 #, ! * 3
")!
) "/ "7$
1!
//
( *1
///! /9!, #" * 3
"! 0% ( )3 )
# " / !
" 1 5
//!" "# /0" /
3 /
%3
" "% )* /%
#!
" #, ! +
/+
) 1
)!
#
!1
)
" //!" "1 "!/")*+
/ 5
0
% /
7;
-<+
+ #""
+6+!)
"
//!"+ %
" 3% )!
"0 # , ! / *% "" / !
%
(-. 7;
9
-. 7;
(/ 0 *( / //!" 3"% /
///! /1" ")"*7$ 1 !
)!
#" " )"*
:
7;
5+6+!)
"""
//!" 3% " " / !
%
(-. 7;
<"% /
/1" " )"*7$ 1 /%
")*! #3 //!"+ %
!" " / !
%
(-. 7;
9
2
'
7;
: +6 C " 4!% ""
5
(
//!"4
" //!"4 !" " / !
%
( -. 7;9 # "
# 0 0%
/ % < #
/0" / //!" % "" / !
%
(-. 7;9
//!" # /0"7 /3!
0 / 7;
' 6 / 9+< % 4!% ""
=6( -. 7;
'9(1 # ")* % <0 ///! / /%
#!
"0 #, ! #1 < 4!%
) 7 0 < / "
" / " =+? % "7 3
") " ")"*7$
%1!
/ </ 0 %
"
/ ( *1
!, #" (
"/ "
7$ (1% "7 31 )0% (
" / )3 )
# %1
""0 %)* "7
< "!#
!, #" 5
(7;'+
) + #!)
" "*+
/0 #, !"!/"/%
-. 7;'9( # 1 //!" " ) % <
#
"
" "# /0" //
( " 1
3
6 /.
(
# / "%
"
"! # 0
( 1 !
"
1 %!"" < "
1
! < " $
" "
1
%/0*(10( *!" $
0
/ /!
/ *
/ %
/ 0"
7$ "
!# , #" ") 3 ")* % * %%) / ! 1 / " 0"!
%1
& )* "
0 #4
!92"
* )!
59:%
# " )"*
%1 !
# /!
! " <" ")"*1 )!
%!
* #1
(7;'+
) + #"!/" //!" ") /
#1 1
/%
(-. 7;'9 <% "" / !
%
-. 7;'9 ( # "
#
" / //!"E 0 0%
/%% / %
; 0# !#
%
7;'+
) + # <
# / *"" .
/
//!" " "!/")* %)+<(7 /+
(
3 <
" / "
* % <1 "/ "
"1 / .
")* "7!) /7/!
/
/%
-. 7;'9(1 "0 % <
"
/ / % " / !
%
% ")* //!"
" -. 7;'9 6 " / !
%
( //!" "
* "% " %
3 *1
"!/ % 0)
/ 6 / /!%
/("!/" % /
<10( %
( /"
)0(7;'+
) + #
"!/" //!" ")+<( 7 /+
(
3 6 /
"!) #"" / !
%
//!" " 7;' " 1 "
%
-. 7;'9 6
%
(
5
( "!/" //!" ") /
& //!"4 / / "(1 3" " 0 / !
# " ")"* ( " / !
%
( -. 7;9
%
) # " )*
)
C "
)*
" "
1
# //!"
1 3" 1" 7 /3
0 / *" ")"* < " / !
%
-. 7;9 <
%
1 # " )*
) C "
)*
" "
1
//!"+ %( " / !
%
( -. 7;
9( / / "(
1 2
/%
1 "(/ 0" // % //!"
" 1 / "
* "3 "7$ ( //!"
",
1
"
31"
%
# ")*< "
) +
+ #
)*
" "
# //!" 3( " / !
%
(-. 7;
(
1
! </ 0" /
% //!" " /% ! //!"+ % ;
/"
!, #" (% //!" " *
3 /
3 % ! //!"+ % < //!"
",
@
1
/%
#!
"1 7 /3 F
5 /!
0
!
"%!"" # /!
! " < " ")"*1 /%
"
!
*%" / .
%
/ <10(
/%
%
7;
'6 / 9+< %4!%
"! 0
( 1 !
1 %!"" < "
! :
/ /!
7$ 1 "% "
% !!)
/)* //!" 7;
'6 / %4!%
#1 /
0 !"/ "7$ (% 1 "7 / / "0% % "/
( 1
)3 )
# %1
= /+/ /?
)
* .
=+? -. 7 //"
(3 1 " / "
. ) : //
* 4 ( ("
"!/! "
)" / . )
"5
//"
-. 7 () "
/! " )" / " . ) ')3 )
# -. 7( # "
#/ # /! ")# 0 ) /0"% . ) /) 1 %
" #%
* '
#
= / +/ / ?
)
*( +!
(
3(-. 7( /%% 1 " / . ) %!
/ !"*
//!
( * 1/ !" /!
"% /"/ !"# )
#
". ) /
1 ) !(
/ /!
7$ 1 3 ")* "% #% !!)
/( 0"
/% /"
*1 )!
/%
#!
"(
1*1)!
# %!
! * /%
#!
" =! 1
" //!"/%%
/ %G3 " ")"* !
/ G 1" 7 /3 F
0 /
"3 " ")"* * 2 / ) " / /!%
0 " / 6 / *
/!
/% /
/ /!%
/ %!
./ ! 0 *
1 " #!
&
!
%
?
1,!
55&5(4
< # ! "
/ %)" " +/
-0 " / /
"" 0 /!
)!" 0 #!
//!")* "
) "!) / 1! " * 1 /!
!//"" 0 %1 /
) //
)" # "
. //
(!
//!")*0 ! / 3 1 "## "
#!/ (
*.
1 /% # " 0 ! " 1
"
/ 0
# $!"#%
.
"
) 18 !!
/ /!%
/ #"%! )
) ")*
*0 " / / 0 " /
" / /!%
/ 0" %! ) / / ! 0 / 6 1"( /
/ /!%
/
) "%! )/% 0
) "!) )!
#!
//!" ;
!
! " ) % # 3 /!
/ ( 1
0* 3 %! ! / 0 " / ""!/" +% 3% * 0 ) "% 0" 3% *) %"
3 6 "
/ )% //!
(!% (
$!"# B! " 0"!# " /%%
/!
! 0
( !%
/ "!/
/!
/ 6
(+/
: -0 " // 1! ")/% (1 / 1 1! "% 3 1 / 0 /% )% " # /
" "!%)
+/
-0 " // (1 // )
1
* / *1 3 1 "#
*
5
)!" 0 #
! % !( / %)" " +/
-0 " //
"" 0 /!
)!" 0
#!
//!")* "
) "!) / 1! " * / 1 /!
!//"" 0 %1 /
)
//
)" # "
. //
( !
//!" )* 0 ! /
1 "# # "
# !/ ( "
* .
1 /% # " 0 /! " 1 "
/ 6 11
+/
-0 " // " # % /
./
/
1 / 1! " ) % ) /!
) /
1 / /!
* 1 / 3 1 "# //!" 6 / + %)!
0 +
$% &'
+ :
:( < E) +!% !
" #
/ !8 *"1 # !
/ %
/
)!" /!
"+/
/
"" 0
"!
* /
*( " # " % /
./
/ 1 / 1! ") % )
*
"
* " /!
/!
) 1 / E/ *E 3 1 "# //!"
"1 / /! "01 !
" /!
* / 0 / 1"IE/ *E
6 %
%
*./
*1 3 1 "#I
?" < E) +!%! " #$ % "& %
$
+!%! 5
0 "
*1 /!
/ ) 0" )!"
:
# " !/ 1 /1 1 / 3 1 "#
//!"% *) //!".
%!)$/ /
*./ 0
# $!"#%
.
") 18
/ ( 10 "
+ ,!"#/"" 1 # ) ) *) %
"
) )
0 / ( /!
/ ! ") // " 6
! ( / "+ ,!"#1
// < #! " 0
% 6 03" +/
6
-0 " //
!#
#8 I /
"" 0 /!
)!" 0 #!
//!")* "
) "!) /
1! " * / 1 /!
!//"" 0 # %1 /
)
//
)" # "
. / /
(!
//!")*0 ! / 3 1 "# # "
# !/ ( "
*.
1 /% # " 0 /! " 1 "
/ I
:
+/
6
-0 " / / "
0 /!
0 / )* "
) "!) *1 /!
/ )
0" )!" # " !/ 1 /1 1
/ 3 1 "# //!"% *)
//!".
% /!( /
./ "! ( # (1)!" % * ) %"! //!")*
'
% *)
!1
' /! #
*% * #! /
) ) //!" 1 #!
* /%% ! /)!
* 1
" /
1
! / (10(# 0% *)(/
)
!)
( % 1! " " * / / !
/!
) ) 0 / )*
) "!) + " /
"+ "
0 +
&2::+
J( ! ""1 1 1 %8 I '5 /
* "/ 1! "1
1 #/ %! )! ")
/
//!"/
) )! *
) "8 / /!%
/ % 1 / / / ! #!
)" ! ") ! *
) " % *) "
! " /
/ /!%
// / "I%! ! "I
I% *)I
) " # %%
)!
# "
) 1 I% *)0"I
I%! )! ")0"I 1 ")* ! + 0 $ + ) ) " 0 +
1 )0
1 % "8 K &5+&5( I
*( % * /
//!"%! )
% *% *)#!
*)
/! /
/ 0 /
%
"
/) 1
E% *)E
"E%! )E
"" 0 "0 #! / $/ !%!/ / ! I
) "! ")/
*1 * #!
//!"(
*( *! " ).
)
*
* ./
//!" #!
*( 5 / /!%
/! ") / / ! 0
!
" /*( : * ! " ./ !" 0* ) * ./ )0"(
' %! ) /
0 " / /% 0
*
) #!
"
/ / ! /
1
/ /
//!"
"%! 1
!%
) ) *
%! 0) " )* //!" I 1 ! )0"8 I & ;/
! *!
"
!# / ! / *0 1")
!# * 3 % / /3 / / /
*/! * ! / (10 #
% *)(/
3 / # % / 0 / 10 ## /
%!
# / 0 / !
) 1
6 %! )/
1
) "! / %
$! /
I! / % # I 6
/ (
" ) * !)$/
3 //!"1 # 0 /
/(
0* / ! ( / !
" % /! ! / 1
/ * )% " I
?" < E) +!%! ' % %
$
+!%!
( 0 "
+/
-0 " // " 0 /!
)!" 0#!
//!")* "
) "!)
0
# '5
"& $!"#%
.
") 18 !" !
"+/
'5 +
; 0 %% "%
/ (6
+&22( ! "
/ 3 1 "#
* ( )!" 0 #
! % 6 % ) /!
0/
/!
*1 1 "# //!" +/
"" 0
/!
)!" 0 #!
//!")* "
) "!) +/ 1! "
* / 1 /!
!//""
0 # %1 /
) //
) " # "
. //
(!
//!")*0 ! / 3 1 "## "
!/ (
*.
1 /% # " 0
! " 1 "
/ +/
-0 " // " # % /
./
/ (
1 /( 1! ") % ) /!
) /
1 / /!
* 1 1 "# //!" + 8+ %)!
0 +
$%(6 &'
+:
:G+!/ + #0 +
7!
$ )(6
+ :5 G
"+ "0
@ + "0
0 +
)*6 / 7 /(
6
5+ 'L ..
..
..
& /! ) 1 0!
//!"
0 )"!/ "+ , 1
+ #4 6
!/
( //!" /! ".
1
+ 4 (
" "" "( 1
"!
"1
/ /!%
/ "" "
"1* /! " / /! " ) /0"
//!"9
" .
* /!
/ /!%
/ 0 / 0
%
!
" +/ 5 5 7 +!/ / "!/ 0 "
""
3 /
/ /!%
/ 1
" 0 / % )"!/ )*
//!" ( ) 1 / 3 1 "#
2
//!" ( ( */! " 0# 0 % .
6 !/
( ! ) 1 0 # * " !%
1 ) ""!/ ( # "
"%!" L 5 / /!
, #" (
7$
/"/ /* #1 //!" 3 ()!
/
1 !
!
% */ /* ) 0"
//!"
/)
0%
"!/" /")* /!
(./ " / !
%
% ")* //!"(1 / " / " / 0 1! "" /! ( /!
"
0" /
)* "
) "!)
1"
/B!
" * " / ) " 1 5:
<10( )
# 1 $!"#%
( 1! " )
%
"! /! 0
( / !" / //!"91
1 0 / %
% )
# / 9
!
* / %
/"
# /
# /*
"B! ) " 1 #
" #
* !
%
#
) /!%
# <!%
" #
* ) /
!
6 #!
/
"/ / * +#%
/
#!/
)" % ")*) ) B!
5'
. (H # M( / !" # 01 !%
" #
* 6 )!
" "!
* +
/ !%
" #
*)!
)*
# 0
" / 6
& >%
(!%
" #
*!
" / N 0 ) M <!%
" #
* !
/
# 90 !
!$ (
) (
+
( ?" < E) +!%! 0 "
!%
" #
*(1 / /0 !!%
# (
# /
/ #
" ) * ,! !"
*( * %" " %
/
/
0 !!%
" #
/# " 8 # / " ( 7 /
" (
"
" B!
"4
" /!" $! !"
/ !%
" #
* ) " 0 " %(!%
" #
* !
1 *
!#/
%(1 1
!
1
" 0 " !
"8 H5 #
#!
" "
) "
!
" / ( &&' !
"" !
/ !%
" #
*1 / /0 !!%
#
"
# /
/ #
) * +!/ # ( 1
!%
# 1 " ) "( /
,! !"
*( *%" " %
/
/
0 !!%
" #
/# " 8 # / " ( 7 / " (
"
" ?# / 1 / " ! " %
# / ) !%
" #
/
0 !
/
# 7 / %!
0 1$! * #!%
" #
/!%
! ?# !
"
# ! /")* # /
/ 0 1( !# 1 "
B!
"4
" /!" $! !"
/
!%
" #
*) " " 0
" %(!%
" #
* !
1 !# /
%(1 1
!
1
-0 #
B!
*
" ) " 0 ! !%
" #
* 6 6 / / "( 1 0
B! "
3 !
" # / /
; 0 1
1 /#!
!%
#
/
7 6661 /
H=!
%
# L !/ # / #
" ) * # # 0
!! %
#)* ! / !" # 0 " #
* 6 ! 0
1 / ) " ")* ! # 0 /
# !%
" #
! %
/
0 ! " / !( !%
" #
*
/
0 !
/
# ;
" % /
0 !!%
" #
*O6 ) ! * !
")*
3KJ% ,! / +!%! 6 1
8 H/
0 !!%
" #
*
/
%
0 <!%
" #
*
/
0 !
!
!%
#
1 6 !
%
0!
*!%
# %
0
* ." 1 *8 ( 0 ! !%
" #
*0 %
0) /
# !
/
/ "( 0
0 / " %
# / /
# (
/ !"
# # !%
" #
*G "( !!%
" #
*
%
" %
*
%
/
# L
52 # !%
" #
/
! .
"")* / *%
+% ./ ( "!/") 11 / # 0 # % # 8 H !%
" #
/
! ." /
/%
!
/
# <!%
" #
* /
#!%
. /!%
# 6
% 6 $! /
. / # //"
- "( /
0 !
" %
0* # 0 # / " !%
" #
*
/
0 ! 0 "%
% # * % //"
! 0
( 0 /
(
" /!
* # /
) # (
#
!%
" #
* ?
*( !%
" #
* /
0 !
! / "0 %
/%% ""(1/%% 1 /# P"($!"# 0 "!
"0 (
" / *%" *
(
. /
0 !(
/ !"
/
0 !!%
" #
* .
/%% 1" % #
""!
) 1 " 0 "!
( % # % !%
" #
* " 0 "!
" / !%
" #
* L 5 !
#
6
( 1 % )
/ * %1! "/%
"1 # % <10(!
*( / * % 0
/
/(
/ (/
" # / ) / * % * % !
" * # /
"
) /
//"
# *( 1 " / +/
<% >0 %
7!
$ )(< *
(
"F *(
" # ( !
!/ 6 0
# /
9%
/
//!"(0 / %1
/0*%%(=6M( P!%%(
B!
" %/ )"!
" " %
7/"!( &5
"7!
$ )7 /! # > ! " / ! !/ ,!" / / 1 "" / 1 "
#1 / ;! "(
!) / /*(!
/ * % +) , -*
+ *, -* . */ 0/1 . 2 0/1