High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4595/1993disposed of

Municipal Committee Karnal v. Ramesh Chand & ANR

2016-03-28Mr. Justice A.N. Jindal6 pages

!"# $#%&'&()!*%+,- !"# $#%&'&()!*%+,- !"# $#%&'&()!*%+,- !"# $#%&'&()!*%+,-., / ., / ., / ., / 0(&%&1!233&""##.4!*(!2 #"&"&(#* 5#*'0'

!3#'++!($!($!("+#* #'1($#("'

) ) ) ) 6 78 88

6 78 88

*#'#(") *#'#(") *#'#(") *#'#(") *840($0. $9%!"#

*"+#1#"&"&(#* *4 !('!2. $9%!"#

**#'1($#(" :::::

:::::

. #"&"&(#*+!' &2#$"+&'1#"&"&(0($#* *"&%2#,,/

"+# ('"&"0"&( ($&! '##;&(< ! =*&" &( "+# (!"0*#

%#*"&*!*&%+!22#(<&(<"+#!=!*$$!"#$

((#>0*# ?

#'1($#(" +!$*!&'#$!(($0'"*&!2$&'10"# @A'#*9&(<!$#3!($("&%#%+!22#(<&(<+&'"#*3&(!"&(+# '!&$ $&'10"# *!&'#$ @A *#'1($#(" ( =!' *# #**#$ !$B0$&%!"&( " "+# ($0'"*&!2 *&@0(!2?%03?7!@0* 0*". +"!;@A"+#!11*1*&!"#9#*(3#(" +#%!'# *#'1($#(" .&(@*&# .=!'"+!"+# =!' !11&("#$ !' %"*& +!*!* (

-- !($ +&'

'#*9&%#' +!$ @##( "#*3&(!"#$ (

-- =&"+0"

%312A&(< =&"+ "+# 3!($!"*A 1*9&'&(' "+# ($0'"*&!2 &'10"#' %".

C6 %"6 *'+*"

, #"&"&(#*?!(!<#3#(". &( &"' =*&""#( '"!"#3#(". !9#**#$"+!"*#'1($#(" =!'=*;&(<=&"+&"($!&2A =!<#@!'&' #10"A33&''&(#*+!$!11&("#$'&>%"*& +!*!*' *'&>3("+'!($"+#'#*9&%#' "+#'!&$1#*'('

=#*# "#*3&(!"#$ ( %312#"&( "+# '!&$ 1#*&$ !' "+# 9!%!(%&#'=#*# &22#$01"+*0<+#312A3#("#>%+!(<# ( "+# 12#!$&(<' "+# 1!*"&#'. 22=&(< &''0#'

=#*# *!3#$@A"+#($0'"*&!2*&@0(!2?%03?7!@0*0*")? +#"+#*"+#&310<(#$"#*3&(!"&( '#*9&%#'

=*;3!(&'&(9!2&$E , #2&# F !*"&#' 2#$ "+#&* #9&$#(%# &( '011*" "+#&* *#'1#%"&9#12#!' +# ($0'"*&!2 *&@0(!2?%03?7!@0* 0*" 9&$# !=!*$$!"#$

!('=#*#$"+#*# #*#(%#&( !90*

*#'1($#(" !($ +#2$ "+!" +# =!' #("&"2#$ *#&('"!"#3#(" &( '#*9&%# =&"+ %("&(0&"A '#*9&%# !($ @!%;=!<#' #(%#."+#1*#'#("1#"&"&(@A"+#1#"&"&(#*? !(!<#3#(" 7#!*(#$ %0('#2 * "+# 1#"&"&(#* +!' '0@3&""#$ "+!" *#'1($#(" +!$ =*;#$ =&"+ "+# 1#"&"&(#*?

!(!<#3#(" ( $!&2A =!<# @!'&' 7#!*(#$ %0('#2 +!'

0*"+#*'0@3&""#$"+!"*#'1($#(" +!$("=*;#$ ,$!A'=&"+"+#1#"&"&(#*?!(!<#3#("!($8#%"&(,

"+# %"=!'("!112&%!@2#""+# !%"' "+#1*#'#("%!'# 7#!*(#$%0('#2+!' 0*"+#*'0@3&""#$"+!""+#1'"' %"*& +!*!*=#*#!@2&'+#$&("+#A#!*

#(%#.&"=!'("

1''&@2# * "+# 1#"&"&(#*?!(!<#3#(" " *#&('"!"# *#'1($#(" !'(1'"=!'!9!&2!@2# 7#!*(#$%0('#2 **#'1($#(" .("+#"+#* +!($+!''0@3&""#$"+!" +!$!$3&""#$&(+&''"!"#3#("

"+!" *#'1($#(" +!$ =*;#$ * , $!A' =&"+ "+# 1#"&"&(#*?!(!<#3#(" 8&(%#"+#1*9&'&(' 8#%"&(, "+# %" =#*# (" %312&#$ =&"+ @A "+# 1#"&"&(#*? !(!<#3#("@# *#"#*3&(!"&(<"+#'#*9&%#' *#'1($#("

."+#&310<(#$!=!*$=!'2&!@2#"@#01+#2$ ("+#1*#'#("%!'#.*#'1($#(" +!$=*;#$ =&"+ "+# 1#"&"&(#*?!(!<#3#(" *3

-- "

-- '1#* 4+!B!(8&(<++&''"!"#3#("+!'

@##( *#1*$0%#$ &( !*! "+# =*&""#( '"!"#3#(".

*#'1($#(" +!$%312#"#$,$!A' '#*9&%#@0"=&"+ @*#!;' # !2' !$3&""#$ "+!" ( ("&%# =!' '#*9#$ ( *#'1($#(" @# *#+&'"#*3&(!"&(!'+#=!'!11&("#$ ($!&2A=!<#@!'&' +#G0#'"&("+!"*#G0&*#'%('&$#*!"&(&'"+!"!' *#'1($#(" +!$=*;#$=&"+"+#1#"&"&(#*?!(!<#3#("

-- "

-- ( $!&2A =!<# @!'&' =&"+ @*#!;'. =+#"+#*+# &' #("&"2#$ * *#&('"!"#3#(" &( '#*9&%# #'1#%&!22A &( 9&#= "+# '"!($ "!;#( @A "+# 1#"&"&(#*? !(!<#3#(""+!"(1'"=!'!9!&2!@2# **#&('"!"#3#("

*#'1($#(" "&'"+#%!'# "+#1#"&"&(#*?!(!<#3#("

"+!"1'" %"*&+!*!*+!''&(%#@##(!@2&'+#$ ("+#%!'# 0(&%&1!20(%&2.&(!!<!*.#+'&2 0(&%&1!20(%&2.&(!!<!*.#+'&2 0(&%&1!20(%&2.&(!!<!*.#+'&2 0(&%&1!20(%&2.&(!!<!*.#+'&2

&'"" 0*$!'10* 5#*'0' *#'&$&(<

&%#*. 7!@0* 0*".

&'"" 0*$!'10* 5#*'0' *#'&$&(<

&%#*. 7!@0* 0*".

&'"" 0*$!'10* 5#*'0' *#'&$&(<

&%#*. 7!@0* 0*".

&'"" 0*$!'10* 5#*'0' *#'&$&(<

&%#*. 7!@0* 0*".

0*$!'10*!($!("+#*. 0*$!'10*!($!("+#*. 0*$!'10*!($!("+#*. 0*$!'10*!($!("+#*., 8 ."+#022 #(%+

"+&'0*"+!'2!&$$=("+# 22=&(<1*&(%&12#')? & 4##1&(<&(9&#="+#*#%<(&'#$1=#* "+# ($0'"*&!2 *&@0(!2 " $&*#%" *#&('"!"#3#(" ( !%%0(" "+#9&2!"&( 8#%"&(, ? %"

"+#'!3#%!(("@#$#(&#$'2#2A("+#<*0($ "+!" !11&("3#("' =#*# 3!$# @A 10@2&% @$&#' !<!&('" 10@2&% 1'"' !($ =#*# (" &( !%%*$!(%# =&"+"+#*#2#9!("'"!"0"*A*#%*0&"3#("*02#' && +#'#""2#$1'&"&( 2!=!'+!'@##('0<+"

"@#!$$*#''#$@A"+&'0*"&'"+!""+#1*9&'&(' 8#%"&(, ?@#&(<3!($!"*A!($(!%%0("

9&2!"&( "+#'!3#."+#*#"*#(%+3#("=02$@# 9&$!@&(&"&!'& &"=!'(#9#*&(1#*!"&(!($.

"+#*# *#."+##312A##=02$@#$##3#$"@# %("&(0&(<&('#*9&%# &&&+#*&<+" *#&('"!"#3#(".+=#9#*.&'("!( !0"3!"&% *&<+" !' '0%+ !($ =+&2# $&*#%"&(< *#&('"!"#3#("."+#7!@0*0*"=&22+!9#""!;# &("%('&$#*!"&(9!*&0'!'1#%"'!'""+#(!"0*# !11&("3#(". "+# !9!&2!@&2&"A ! 1'". "+# !9!&2!@&2&"A =*;.=+#"+#*"+#!11&("3#("=!'

1#*'#*02#'!($"+#'"!"0"*A1*9&'&('!($"+# 2#(<"+ '#*9&%# !($ "+# $#2!A &( *!&'&(< "+# &($0'"*&!2 $&'10"# @# *# !(A !=!*$

*#&('"!"#3#(" %02$ 22= &( %!'#' 1#*'('

!11&("#$(!'+*""#*3@!'&'!($!'$!&2A=!<#*' !($=++!$("=*;#$ *2(<1#*&$@0"'2#2A ( "+# '"*#(<"+ +!9&(< %312#"#$ , $!A'.

=02$("1#*'#@##("&"2#$ **#&('"!"#3#("!'

'0%+.#9#("+0<+"+#*#"*#(%+3#("=!'9&$ &9 +# '!&$ *#"*#(%+3#(" @#&(< 9&$ =02$. +=#9#*.("#("&"2#"+#=*;3!(!''0%+"G0!2&

*%2!&3!*&<+" **#<02!*&H!"&(!($(#&"+#*@A!( *$#* *#&('"!"#3#("."+#1#*3!(#(%A%02$@# <*!("#$""+#'!&$#312A##!($(2A+#=02$@# +#2$ " @# #("&"2#$ &( %("&(00' '#*9&%# ( "+# '!3# '"!"0' !' +# =!' =+#( +&' '#*9&%#' =#*# "#*3&(!"#$ 9 +# #312A#*=02$ +!9# ! *&<+" " 0*"+#* "#*3&(!"#+&3&(!%%*$!(%#=&"+2!=@A%312A&(< =&"+"+#3!($!"*A1*9&'&('!($"+##312A## +!9&(< !(A <*&#9!(%# !<!&('" '0%+ ! "#*3&(!"&( %02$%+!22#(<#"+#'!3#&(!%%*$!(%#=&"+2!= 9& +#$&'%*#"&( "+#($0'"*&!2 $B0$&%!"*+!'

"+0'+!9#"@#*#'1#%"#$!($"+#'!&$ $B0$&%!"* +!'";##1&(3&($"+#1*&(%&12#'2!&$$=(@A"+#

1#>0*".!'("&%#$!@9# 9&& # $ (" '0@'%*&@# " "+# 9&#= "+!" "+# 10@2&% !0"+*&"&#' %02$ %2!&3 ""!2 &330(&"A !($ 1*"#%"&( *3"+#1*9&'&(' 8#%"&(', ?!($ , ?

%"@A"!;&(<*#'*""!($'+&#2$&(< "+#3'#29#'(!%%0(" !%""+!""+#1'"'

=#*#(" &22#$01&(!%%*$!(%#=&"+"+#*#2#9!("

'"!"0"*A*#%*0&"3#("*02#'!($."+#*# *#.1#*'# "+#=*;3!(%02$("%2!&3*#&('"!"#3#("F 4##1&(<&(9&#="+# !%""+!"&"&'("1''&@2# "+#1#"&"&(#*?!(!<#3#(""*#&('"!"#"+#1#"&"&(#*!'"+# 1'" %"*&+!*!*+!'@##(!@2&'+#$!($%('&$#*&(< "+#2#(<"+ '#*9&%# *#'1($#(" .&"=02$@#@#B0'"

!($#>1#$&#(""<*!("%31#('!"&("*#'1($#("( &( 2&#0 *#&('"!"#3#("

%%*$&(<2A."+#&310<(#$!=!*$$!"#$

((#>0*#?

1!''#$@A"+#($0'"*&!2*&@0(!2?%03?7!@0* 0*"&'3$& &#$""+##>"#(""+!"&(2&#0 *#&('"!"#3#("

/ =&"+%("&(0&"A '#*9&%#!($@!%;?=!<#'.*#'1($#(" &'

+#2$#("&"2#$"*#%#&9#%31#('!"&(#"&"&(#*?!(!<#3#(" &' $&*#%"#$ " 1!A I .J? @A =!A 2031?'03 %31#('!"&("*#'1($#(" =&"+&("=3("+' *3"+# *#%#&1" "+#%#*"& &#$%1A "+&'*$#*.&(2&#0 "+#*#2&#

<*!("#$@A"+#($0'"*&!2*&@0(!2?%03?7!@0*0*". !&2&(< =+&%+.*#'1($#(" =&22@##("&"2#$"*#%#&9#"+#'!&$ !30(" =&"+ &("#*#'" K L 1#* !((03 *3 "+# $!"#

1!''&(< "+&'*$#*"&22*#!2&'!"&( "&'%2!*& &#$"+!""+# =!<#'!2*#!$A$*!=(@A*#'1($#(" 0($#*8#%"&(

%"=02$("@#2&!@2#"@#!$B0'"#$"=!*$'"+# %31#('!"&(!30("!''#''#$@A"+&'0*" #"&"&('"!($'$&'1'#$ .!%%*$&(<2A 8

!*%+,-., / !*%+,-., / !*%+,-., / !*%+,-., / 3!+!9&*