High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/461/2006dismissed

Anurodh v. State Of Pb.

2022-09-26Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan20 pages

##$$ %! & '(

# !) (* !

+, !"##$$

- "$$ +-+& '(

....

##$$ / !""!$(*$!

0 )+ #$ !+1 " 234

4!! ) &*"!# ( +67 "! !!!!8 +&$ 2$& + 1 " + "$$) " 5

(

7# + " !:# +&;"!$ *+-# !+"< # =;) "!+<" *$ !#!9 % ' )9

+ ##$$ / < ,! !<"""<(; !9!!

# " ,!* + " < !) !)! 9#! 9 ! *! #* +

$"! !"! !)9#$9#! 9 !#!> 9 "

!$*+"+#!"#! ,!

! " 5

+ 3 ?!( )" # $ ?

"! !!!!"3 ,) ) !/3 &$

2$ & +1 " $ ) <" 3 $$ )" "!#$ $"$#;:# +&;"!$ *==!@ &< A 9!<' <""#$#!*@(

7# +" <#9 )!9"1"!"$ )#$() ", ) "!)"" @"<##!" "( # " 9 "!#! $!<! B !( +<""

" $@ " 3 # " " < !!* ) 9 !( "#$()+ "" !9"9"< !!* "!""() " "!)")" !" #! )C!!)!@" #)"!" #! 9)C !@99 "!)!D> &<#!#!+<""<) (* " (* 3 $$ )" &< A 9!

# <

:"!!+"3 !B "

- !' )"+&(*9; ) $#" $$"9!!,"# &- !' )"!" "!( = # @"$" *" !9"9"" !+" 9"!)C !!)! $($$( " !#"

&- !' )"@ 99 "!)!<#!#!@"!!

!" ! &- !' )"+"3 "!" " #$ () " + <"" < "!

<!## #$*" "@"3 #!<9#$ )!9 "!9"!,!"! ( )<)"+"! 9 ( ;) 6 )!9@"9#$ "! "!<! ,! #!#!$+$<""$"3 ", ) !# 8?8 "&- !' )"", ) !# 8-8@ #9 $9#! <!; "D> &@" " ! #!#!*<; #$# ,!,!*99D> &+ (*&< A 9!+ # < 3 $$ )"

(&- !' )"@"3 " ,!"$! 3 $$ )"

:" $ #! *,$#!9!$ !# " !( ?<! )$*!! " #! ! $+#!#! )!B 9 99 '9$" D> &2+) (*" (*"< @)! !!<!!, # " ,99D> &-

:"3 ! BD> &"#$ + "( <""!9$23D> &/<!)!(*34" )"

:" ,) ) !#!#!! )"#$ "#$!,!* D> &D !!9 <

! !

" #$ + " 3 ,) ) !

#! " $ )<"< "#!#!*(! 34" )"+<"< )?

"#$

,! "+34" )"# "< $", ) !# 848 "9#$#!$ ( $;#!$( 9#$ $9#! "D> & :"!!+!(*34" )"+

"3 #"#!#!*<"?A $# )"

" >* 6

+"#!#!*$ ) <""9#$$9#! "<!!,(*3 $$ )"

!9 ? A $# )"+ 3 "!) 1A?4 " #$ !#! )"9(!0+1 " @3 $$ )"

" (9 ##$ D> &? <""$!

0#!!

D> &?/ !#! "#!#!* " !0+ 1 " +<!#<"?A $# )"

+ 9#$ #!$ $ ) <" 9#$ $ 9#! "<!" ,! ($ $, )"(*? A $# )"<"! )"; !9" &+1 " ($ $, )" "!!# "!$<"?A $# )"

+ ($ $, )") !, "

!$ 9#$#!$+9#$$9#! " ; (*"&+1 " ;"""9$ D>9 !+& '(+&$ ?# "!$"! " ,!**+ ! !

"#$ " ,!!#? A $# )"

#!!#!D> &E!,!9""9$ D>9 !+& '(+&$+"9#$#!$< (" "! !9#$ ,) "!!9$+"$$

) " <#!#! $ " !

#! ""$$ +#"!<! ##$ " !+ ,) !

!#" " !+(!, )"#!9

"!)! !

"<$ ) +"<"!)"! )$*+<""+"#$

) $* $9!$

! )" !, +"#! >9 "$$< )<

&F?A $# )"+<"<#?&$ 2$& +1 " 5

<"<"93?!( )""#"#!#!*+<""<" " ,! 3 $$ )"(*"9 " >*!"# !##! )

" ! <"! )"!#"#!#!*<"

? !"!" "< "" ,!"9#$ #!$ ($ $, )"$ )<"9#$$9#! "

!"# !#) ); !9" &+1 " +<"!) )" $ "!#" !$<""9 ",!**+# "!)! ? !"!

+"") " ,!9#$#!$+9#$ $9#! " ; ($ $, )"!" # !## )"!$ ""9$D>9 !+ & '(+&$@ ($ $, )"9#$<""! ! !

"" ,!!#"9 "9* :" < "$ )"#!#!*!9 <""9 "!

"9#!<""9 !$$< *

&F 3?!( )"+<"<" )"#$#!*+ <"" 5

(

7# " !#" ! ):# +&;"!$ *+==!+1 "

"!,!* !( !9"9+# "!)!

""<"!)!" ,) (* "9 #!, ) ,! 9 ) " 9#$ ,) +"$$ <#!#!(*3 #! $< ! )"

&F=3 $$ )"+< !,!* ##!" #! !* 9!$#

&F34" )"+<" 5

<"$"$ )! ;

3< )?

&$ 2$& +1 " #!)! )"#!<"!)!3?!( )"#! )" $ )<"< #!#!*(!"9+",!* ) " " # )"< $", )9#! 848 " 9#$#!$ ( $;#!$(9#$$9#! " D> & "!! ! ) 3 # " #!#!* <" ?A $# )"+# "!)! ? !"!"!$!

!#! B(*3?!( )"+""!!!9$23 D> &/

&F7&- !' )" <"#! "#$() !!(*" "( !"+<""<

"! "!)!( !! )( "!$! !" C ! !( !9" < !

&F ($ $, )"+ " !!! " 9#$ #!$ " "9$ D>9 !+ & '(+ &$ # !)! ) *"#!#!*$ )!9 " #

$& & !"), #&F&<

A 9!G&## !"! ", )( )< ,!(*"

:" #! !$ # ,! 9 $ ) !#! (* "9$D>9 !+& '(+&$D> &E

! $ ! #! , + 9 " < !! ! == !

& + <"" $$ " !9 ) ! 9 " #! , ##! ) ) "9<!# " ( " "$$) )"""( #; #!9"" "!!

$$* ,$, " 9! !,!*"(

!9"9

! ) " ! " , + " >9 4) 9 9 "F+<""";

< !"+<"<<!; ) !!<"/ ! ! "9" "< <!; !"9@

(

# +<" !; )$ "+"*9" !*#!9+" 3 #!$ )<"? ($#$ 9"! !!" @"< !"!* B ! !9"#$$<"<"9!+<"""*$"9 ""*< $$$<" )!9; ) B !*@"#$ $; !"<""9 :"< !"!"

+"9;

<"9"( #$ " " "!<!,!!9" (*"#$ "#! !"! )!) 9 +$!

!$ !" , " 9 (,+<""$"9))!,

""$"#! ##$+ <""<; # =

+ <" <9!!) $!"! ) !,!* <* ! )"# *"##$

##$ ! =6 !

& ", )( $(*"##$$ / ! # " 9#! 9 ! )"# *##$+"9< $$< , !! 5

!9 ) " ##$$ < # ! )"# *"##$ "< 9($+ ('" !

" )#! $ !*( " $!

0/ *)!+1 "

4<"##$"9 #! $"! )

3","!$!

$!"##$$ H ,+ $!

, - !$ ! " & '( () )"! )""!!

?! $$ " < !,!*+ 9$*+ &F 3 ?!( )"+&F=3 $$ )" &F7&- !' )"" $$* ##!"#! !*<"!)! ", )(

# !( :"*<!!>9 $ )" ("$" ( "* ;"!) $

("! *9!$# 4#!, 9*(< "9 "##$$ / / ,"( $$)!#!,#!9# (*<"""*9)"", ,$,"##$$ / " <! )$* #) "9$$* !" ,

:" ), (*"&F9 (<!"*!$ =

2!9"9 &F?A $# )"<"<"9 "#!#!*!9 #+ "#*3 "!)

1A?4&$ 2$& +1 " +&F=3 $$ )"+<""#! "#!#!*$ )<" (! 0+1 " " >*!,!*9, )##$ D> &?

<""0+1 " "#!!D> &?/""( $;

#!$ ;) 6 )!9 <#;"!" )

)!9 $*$<!#! " ! ! # +" <!" ,!3 $$ )"! *<$$ 9 &F ($ $, )"+"!!!"9#$ #!$""9$D>9 !+& '(+&$+9 ""#!#!*"!9 * 9#$#!$" !"""9$D>9 !+& '(+&$

:"!#!D> &E !9""9$D>9 !+ & '(+&$)"<""$ "9#$#!$<! )!<""9#$$9#! $ )<"" 9#$#!$ $*+< (""! :" +" #! "#!,$$ !* )! "

?<,!+$!

$!"##$$ " (9 ""#! "( ($#!,) $" (* "< ! ($ ( "! ! ,!$ !9 $ "#! ), )! ( "9 ( "! " $ "#! !* #!$<( ( !,(), "##$$ / +<""<<! )$* "9 :"!!+)! ) "( "##$$ / +" " $(B ""!)!9) "9 7

$!"##$$ ";"9# )

' )9 ,! )! +<""! "! !

!"#!$%&'%$()*)$"*$+

)$",-$+ "$

$.'/) #0) ! )$!

$!"##$$ "!),

" (*"3 <, 9 ""< $!$* !9( "$)$!)")"!" #! 9)C!!)! 9$!$*+&- !' )""

!9" $!!9"""!)"(!" #! 9"!)C!!)! :"!!+" !" C !!! !$$)$ , "

(( # "*#,

?<,!+39 , (* "

:"#> ! ' )9

!"#$%&!'$&(&#)*+($

$ , "(!," 7 "##$ #! $!"" <"!)!"!"()

*!9"9 &F ?!( )"+3

+&F7&- !' )"$ )<" 9 D> & 9 D> & > (*" +$!$*9 " "( $( "!)")"!" #! 9)C!!)! ""# )"!" #! &- !' )"+)C !

:"#> ! ' )9 '$&(&- "./!0

*" <"$$ )<" !"<"!"

"( !$$* !9"!)"(!" #! )C!!)! #! # < +" <"$( 9#$ 7 "$ )" "

!9 ( <! )

2 !"!9!+ #!' "< ",( " *9

39*(9 "!""$<

!B !"" ( !9 <! )( "!!)") "!" #! )C!!)! !!"!!# ($; <" 3' #!"" ,) ) ! <! )' ;#"!!"!

"( ), " "# >!(*"

"!#

:"!!+ " (' $; 9! ! )$* !'

!''

//!"2!

3* #)*!"!)( $+)!%0 % !*"$"4

$"* ".

.$5 !"# $"* ".

.$5 !% )" 3"6!7) !"#"!3%!//& !''

//!"2!

3* # $3/#"$ $.

$8"$0 !7$3 $++ % $+ * !% $ 7 $"#3 # )" '% * "

$+ 9!:

#$++)

%$%!9)*%! !3*)"9'% 63#)

$). ) +3 " ($; )<)" 9*( , "!( "!), "23 "!

9 "1 " #(*F4) 9+" "( <!; ) !!<"/ !! 1 " #! $, ) <!; ) & '(!99

># ( ,! <" & '( $ ) ) " >

! )<""( #; "9 D, "!<+"! 9 " ! (< ? & '( $ ) ) #!

;

< )? ! $* ! <"( )#; & '(

&F 3?!( )" &F7&- !' )")!$$* !)! )"!", ) !9" ( "!)")" !" #! )C!!)! F"$ ( )>9 ! ==!

& + " !,

)$<!""< ($ ! <"!)!"!

), "9(*"3 & !)!"!)"(!"

#! )C!!)!

D, "!<+(!,!$! 7 " ##$($!"()( )!!(*" +" (' ($

;

!/!+ %3* 0!*!"# #$( %3//!)"9!'$/)

$++)

% !"# "$ $ !0!" <3.!% !" )"# '

"# " 0)"

** % +$% * !/!()"9% .!)"

#0) '$/)

$++) )!/* % 0 % !"

*$+!.'

%)"90) !* '%$'

%& ) 3 9*$ )!9 <"$!

$ !"##$$ "!)! )$0 )" !$ )<"

"# ' )9 1 . */!'$&(& #(*1.0

*""(!,"<" !$ )!,!* ###*" ;+"#!#!*<$( $< " ,! # < ! )"9+ $" )"! !9 # +<"",!*($ 3< !"!(!,"$

$<*(" ,!" # < ( " ,) ) !" !B $* "3

! $<* ! "$ # < +<"" ## !9 "# !*)"!$$"#!#!*!"

2 !"!9!+"( "!$!#!" ' )9 +"9#$#!$ ( $;#!$<!$"#<"

<$+ 3?!( )"", ) !# 8?8 "! &- !' )"", ) !# 8-8+ "!! !" )" &$ +34" )"+" )?

"# "<

$", ) !# 848 "#!$@"!! " >*+ <" "#!#!*"( #! (!0+1 " +" !* )"9$"#!!"$ "#!$<! 39 ""#!#!*"!9 *+ "!!+ "! $ ( * B " $ ", ) (

9#!<"(*"#$$

= $)"# '

"# " $%%$7$%!)$")* % ! )$!

$!"##$$ +" "#! ( # "9 $< # $< !,!* !!(!

!9"9 # < &< A 9!

:"$ < " ! "+"!!+ ( # !!(! +9 $< " $ ( !$ # ##$$ / !,(B !",!* !

) " $ , 9 $!* (!,+"$< !,!*+ 9$*+&F 3?!( )"+&F=3 $$ )" &F7&- !' )"" !

,$," "<! )$*!#) "9 !" ,

:"!!+"!9 !(; #!

<"" # < )$ "" ! ' )9 +$ &!*+($'$&(& #(*1.0

*" " (!, " 9 " $ < !!* " 9 , !*,$ " *"!< "!9

(!9#$* "!$)

!)! >9 &< A 9!+"<),

#(*$!

$& ($&! !!"!"! ", )( < ,!(*" , "" !

( ! */!'$&(& #(*1.

*" <" # < "( ' ! )"!" !,!* !( @""##!< !" )"") !<!#! ! ($ ;##!<" "" ,"#$ !

; +"(!," "

< # "$ ) "

( ($, "

9! ) ! ,! ##!", )! <! 9!$ $() (*< ($ ;##! :"9 *" < < "$ ( !$($ < ! 3 " ,!* ' )9 +!($*$/#$< < ! <(!,"<" "! $$) * 9*) " #$$$$*9#$"##$$ "!< !

!"9#) "##$$ +"!$ !"!)"$* $ " >9 # < !" !,!*( )< ,!(*" ! * ( " #! D, "!<+"# $< ! #! <" " # < 2 !"!9!+ # !!(! ! $#! !B !9 $< 3 <"!#!, * " # !!(! 9 ( "!+ " " #! !' !)"$*

, + "

( %*)$""$ $"*)# % #7& %)!/$3% 1!

$!"##$$ " "" ##$$ / ">9 < F4) 9+<""" "( #; #(*"#$

!9"!*#!9/ !!+1 " !,!*<!9"9 " ,! " <! )$*( ) !(*"!$ !

:" $ $; ! 3

!*+ 9 F4) 9 9 ( , ) <!"*!$ 3 "!>9 +"9""" (9 *<! !#! "")"! "!<"!)! $$)$9#$ " " :" +"9 (#! !< 3 ,<",!<"$9 ) !9 ) , (*"#! ("!$<$$ 9 !*+

"9 F4) 9

(!$ # ! !

,! ) $*"

> *!.'/ '!%

/!#7

"* "$ !+ %?#!&*$+ %

$( %&% *3/!"/& % $3/#7 !"

*$+!.'

%)"90) *!.'/ '!%

/ ) " $;9! :"#> ! $% */!'$&(& #(*1.0

*"<"$$ ) <"!$ )!,!*5;) # 9<" 9#$<! "9$>9 !! *!,!*+"<,!+"!<

, "9#$<!9#!<"! *#!' < " +"$*< "$($" :"#$* )"9#$" "9$ D>9 ! < ( ! */! '$&(&

#(*1.

#!"$ )"<" "9#$<! " "9$D>9 !<" 5 " !+"#! ,

(, ")! "!< ##!,

" "!)! " ! / )!! "!# <! $*") $ !) $ !$"! !

$<!; ) 4! !$ !

""( "!$!#!" ' )9 +"#!#!*"!9 * "9#$ #!$"!"""9$D>9 !+& '(+&$

:"!!+"$*<* )"9#$ ""9$D>9 !+& '(+&$99!$

@ $"4 $"* " .

.$ !"# $"* " .

.$ $"!)")"9

'!%) 3/!%* $+ $++ "

)" %3"")"9 0) )* ! *3*') )$3*

)% 3.*!"

*)"

$3/#"$'$**)7/& $.

$8"$0 !7$3"!3% $+ $"%!7!"# ( "7 +$% 7!9$+

3* #0!** !% # #! $ " 9 )"<" 99D> & 99D> & "#($ ;<! $<"!)!23 9(!+<""<!$!$$ # " )"

" "< ",( 9 !

) :" 9 "<" "99<!#!#!+"3 < <! "23 9(!+<""<$$ #<" "$+<"";

! B"#$ ! !

$ )<"#*23 :" "23 $ #($*" )23<(!)! " ,!**+! B$99 ) C($ < 9 5

!)! !

( )$ 9 !

)+ >#! #$! $! $*9; ) <"!)! ! !( (!, ),! ! # $!,! *# ! ! ) 9!$*( " " ( 9 !

) ), ! * # ! 9

D, "!<+ +! */!'$&(&3* * 4*% (*" #!9 ! ##$ !$ =

+<(!,"$<

"# ,!*$!", "! *!#! !$$$)$* )"!" C !+", $$"!(*<$$

(9 9($ " ! < $ ! $$ "

! 9 <""! * ! #!' " (

" 3"!" C !< 9#$ "$< #! ! "!< *#($*", $$$;$*",( 9#!<"! !#$ ! )" ! "!"!C !+" + $("",

$($(9($ ,

:"#! "#!,"!)) " $ ,$* !9,$* :" $ ! ! * ! ($!#$ ($>#$ !"$$)$9#$ !

$" !# " !( <" *$ !

#!9"!(*"< )""< # "" ) B * !( +$ &!*+($'$&(& #(*1.

#!+ <$"$"<" !,!* !( < "!9=7 () )=7;$)!9###*" ; "()!9"#

"##$$ " +" "" )B *" !(

(#$ (*"#$!9< !+"+ ' !"$9#$

I !"! 9 +" ,

<! #"$

!)! " ' )9 5/%2 */! 6 5//

'$&(& #(*1.0

*" 032 *%$#$&!% 7%8'$&(& #(*1.0

*" 019"

$&,'$&(& 3,;,0!*% /$!0

*" '$ *%$ */! 6 !*:

'$&(& #(*1.0

*" !!! (* $!

$ ! "

##$$ / ##! " + " ##$ "#! ! ! 9 " > <"" "(!, "( 9

!)! " #!+ " /##$$ < !)!)! 9#! 9 ! *! #* +

/ $"! !) !"!9#$ 9#! 9 ! #! > 9 "+ <"" " 9 9 9 #!!( ! # 99!$ B * " !( $" )" " !! + " !$ ! " (!," "##$$;" , ##$* > " ##$" !* #$*<"""$""##$ " !9+<"" ( ;<"!9" ?<,!+ <" 9 # ) + " !$ ! !"! "< 9) 9*"

:"#> ! 3* * 4*% '$&(&+("%2 */!0

*""(!," !$ ) 4!! ) &*"!# ( 9!" " $#($"9( "$! $* , $<"$" !9! $,$! 9# "*+( "! )" 9*" <$$

:" )";# ) ,<"" )B *" !( !,!!9"##$$ <""=999!$B *+ 9>9 9 # "9 <"" $ ( <! < !)! 9#! 9 ! #!

*! #

/+ "<,! $*9 9 9# "9 "( <!

4"! "! * ! " 9#! 9 <!"##$$ !$)$$*#!9($

:"9# ) ' )9 , !! #(*"!$ !!<$$ ! +( # #!#!

##!$ ##! , !! !#! $<

:"! $$)$*! !9*"!

:"' )9 ,

!! ! #"$<"!"##$ ( <" *9! "99! )$*

##$$ !"( ($)! "9(* " ! ?($ $$ "0 $)!+1 " ! !!<!! )"9!!9;"9

!)"!9 )

4!* 9 ( "B !! !

%)6 A %% !*$"

#2*'

!8)"9 $2 * A %% '$%!7/

$2 *