High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/846/2009dismissed

Dharambir v. State Of Haryana

2017-12-05Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh16 pages

!"!

# $

(

!"!

)

* !

+,-.,/ /- 0'1

2! 3

45 67( &8 !

3% 9!:" 6&5 8

6 :6# $ ;;;;

+ !4"&(

! & ! ! <

! & $ 88"!&

8 ( 4"&( 8

& & ! 8& &= !!& $&&

!>"&( 8" 2!

(- 86 8 ""

& 8&"& !! 8&"&

! 25

! 86 6 )""9!

& !?8?65 &< 86< !8

8& &! 8&

8!"

! !"

@ &

A1 /2

! &(

$ !

& " $

6! ""

! @ &

' /2

! &(

$ !

& " $

6! ""

$ @ &

A 5 = +8

! &(

$ !

& " $

6! ""

# <56< ! 8B"

& 8!"

! "

!AA6' &<

A/2

AC 8 !"

5!! 8!< && "

8" $ &

! 8"

& 8 !< !

&& ! (

!! 8 < &&

' ! & $8

( (

! 8B"

)

* 6% !*3! 6%

" 5 "

!AA6'6' &<

A/2

AC 8 $6 8! 8 ! !

! ./%

'& &11"

!A16AA6'6' & <

A/2

A 8< !( !& 2 8

2 <

! & $8

(

11 ! & "(6

8 &? C? (&

"'$ !< !

"!88"!&

"! $ 8

$ 9

( C

8 & "

(

!< !! + C !&" &8$ &

868 "!

$6> !

& "! &8 "( & 88"!&

3 < 6 !

!6 $6)

* 6% ! * 3! 6 % & " 5 8& & 88"!&

(& !!8 "< (

( 88"!&

89 <"

> !

( &8 "!&

4"$"

$ C2 C8 !"

!B" $

& ! < ! 9 ! & 8 C

< ! & 8 +

< !

$ 8 8

&"8

& 8 C

C & 88"!&< ! !& -

68 < !! " !

8 & 8" !<!" 88"!& $

>"& 3 ( ! 6 2 < 8

(! !B"

2 (! < & (

! 88"!&

!A16'/2

A5 8 & 88"!& < 8 (!& 8

8! "

& !8

AA6'6' &<

A/2

AC 86

< 86$ &&

$ &8 & + 5 !8 !6 !8"

& ! $ !

!!!

& !8"

5 8 < ! 8 !&

88"!&<8 &&"

AA 26<

6$ && !

& (

&8 & 88"!& &"8&& 8" $5 8

& 8 5 8 & & 85 8< !8 !&

- 8

5 86 88"!&

< !

8 ! &< !8

8& &! 8& !

588"!& )

* 6% !*3! 6%

" 5 < 8B"

8 (! & (

! + !

&4"&( 8

& ! 8 !"

48 8 (

& $ 88"!&

# <56 8

( ! !

8 (& 8B"

& 88"!&"

!AA6'6' &<

A /2

AC 8 & $ 88"!&

< ! &

&8 5$

< ! !

! $&"

( 8$ 6 ! 8 !&"

< !!"! && &< !

&& !&

7 &( &8 !

( 88"!&

! ! !$ 8 &

8 !6 < !6

8 ! & " (

! + !8 ! &8

! <

!!! & !

!"8 !

$ 8

7 &8 !"

$ 4 5

! <

!!!< &

" " &&

' !

6< 8 9! !8"

8 !& "!!

C2D 6! < !8 && $ /

2D 6< !6!

!! !! &&"

(8 C

&& $! C (& 88" 8 +< !

&& $

(./%

( ! C

& ! <& $ & 88"& + (&

& 88"& &./%< !( !& A

& !!"8 "

&& $ "!

./%!! @ )"

2D 6!&

( $C

& C

"6< !6 ! !8"

6 C< ! 9 ! A

$ !@ )"

2D !

! &

! < !

4"$

5 ! & ( C #$ < !

! &

(< !! / ! 6! !

( 5 $8 8"

( &

(

< C " !

$! &

$ !C"

8 "!8 "&

"& "7 &8 ! !

! ! .

8 87

! < !&8&

8 ! &"

8 C

$63

2D < 8

&"8&& ( C

8 ( 8 $! &

!( < !! / ! !

(" &8 !

&& !8 !

< 8 5

$ " < 8

( 7 & 8 ! !

! !"

!8"

!"$ 5& !8 ! $

& !

! C &$<

!!> !

(2D - $

&& !8 ! 6< 8 $ 88"<

( ! 2 C< ! & &$

88" 8 & ( ! 5&

8 8 6< 8 ! 5&

& !,C2:+ 8" ! !

5& ! @ )"

2D 6 < & ( $C

& C & &

4" !

C!.

7 6

&< !

8 C6< 8! <! ! &!"&

4" ! 7 &8 ! !

! 8"

A1/2 !

! <

!!!

8"&

(! C !< !& 6< & ( $C

&+ < !

!$ 8 88"!& !< !

$ < $ C & 88"!& 7 & 8 ! 8

! 88"!& !

!6 $6)

* 6% !*3! 6%

" 5 5<

($ 8B"

$ "+

(!8 && $ " 8

$ 8! ! !

& !

& 88"!& &

"! C< !< !

< !<

!!& $8 "!

C6 $6> !

(+ "< 8B"

& 88"!& !

! > !

( $

(

8 ! & ""

!AA6' &' &<

A/2

AC 8+

88"&

& "! & 88"!& 6 $6

< !

8& 8"

! "

'/26< !6 88"!& !

!< 8B"

8 (! & (

C 2D & $ <

!! > !

( 2D

< 8" "

&5!

(< !8 && $ "B" ! ( 5 $ C &$<

!! + 8B"

88"!& ! $ <

(/ ! !

(" &8 ! 88"!& !

5 8B"

& 8"

! "

!AC 8

( & 8

(& 8

8< !8 & "

8 8 & !

88"!&!

"8 ! 5 8

86 < !6> !

(2D !!8 8 $! &

!! 8< !8

8 "$ & "! C6 < 8< ! "

85 < &$"!&& $ (" ( (

! !

< ! C

"8 ! 7 &8 ! !

! & &$ 88"!&

!<!

! 5 ( &<9

< 8 "

(2D A6<

< !

& <

!! & & &! & !

& "!& C &8 "!

> !

( $ ! + ! ! !

& <

!!! 8 $ 5! 8 < !

& "

8 86< 8 !<

A C 8 +8 !< ! & (

'1 &4"&( < !

9!5& D ("

< !"

& $ 3 (

(6 &5 8

8 4"&( 6 < 8 5

&& 7 &8 ! !

!!"

< !"

8 "

!AA='='=A/2

AC 8 ! & " (

! + C2D

! ,C2 !

<! &

4"$< !( 5 8 "!

> !

(2D $ !

!,5 < !

! & $

! < !

8 "!

4"$ "

!!!+

(

C $ <

> !

( + C <

" & 5&! +!

5 !$ 8 &

( $

6< !

88"!& !< ! $ < $ C !

!/ ! !

& % )" 6"

8 2D &2D &8 "!&

4" ! 3 ( 6

< 86./%

& & < !( !&"

!AA6A' &'/2 2 8

2 <

8 !!

A< !<

!!/ 8 !6 % )" 8 C2D &> !

(2D < !

8& &! 8& "

&( < $ !%/5 &4"&( & & '6 6 ! 5& !

! 5 !$

8 &

!8 ! 95 (/ &6 ! !

& $ 9

5 8 5

& 8

! 5 ($ 8B"

$ "

8 !B"

& $ ! "

! 8B"

# & (" ! &5 8& $ & 8 !

! & 5 !

(

"(5 & "

8"&

(! <

!!! . 8!

( &(

( ./%6 !

8 (! & 8

88"!&

8B"

88"!& !

!6 $6)

* 6% !* 3! 6% " 5

& !"&+ C< !

$3& 8 - 86 $6@ )"

62:/3 6% 9

&! < !8 && "

6@ )"

2D & <

4" !

C0 8 &< &8E'8

&$ <(

&< !!

< & "

4"$!

4"$<

"!+$ <

< ! "

!&& ! "

8 "8E8 ! "&4

4"$!

4"$ <

"!+$ <

< ! "

A "

!&& !

8 "8A8 (! "&4

+$ <

< ! "

! & < !

$ 5

"!& 8

(

& $ !C" 8 8! < < &5 & !!<<&5 & C $ &"

8 < ! !5 (

6< !

4"$

( C (

#$ < ! 6 (!

$ <!

! &

(< !! $ 2

C 8&

( 5 (

& 5 (

& & <

(!@ )"

2D (

( "(.

7 ,C 2> !

! &

$ !C"

8 "!8 "&

" "! ! C2D 6> !

( 2D 6< $<

!< !! 2D 6 < & ( $ C

& C 8 $ ! <! < ! 8 & "

C & ! < !

!!& $> !

(+ ( C ! 5&

8 &

(8 8

5 8< ! "(

& $& 8 5 ( C < !+

! C< !

5 !!< !

8+& $

(./%

5 !

86 C<

&!< !

"!+

< !<

!!& $ > !

( 2D 6 < ! 8 "!

C ,5

& 9 8 < 88"!& $ &$<

!!6 < 8 ! !

$ ! 6< & ( $C

&> !

( " !

C ! 8

&"8

(& 8 C

C6./%< ! &(&< 8 )

5 < " 86 ( C !

< !

$ ! 8

86 / 5 < & $ ! $ C

&3 56

(!"8$ ! 8< !

( $ "" !8!

(

5&6 9! &8 < ! "& & 8

+ 8

& !8 ! &8

! <

!!!6 < 8

5 &!

&/ !

& 88"!&

< !

!$ 8 &

!8 !< 8

5+< !

( < $ ! C & 88"!& )

5 <5 8 5

8"&

( ! 6 C &$<

!!6/

(!8 && $ "88 &

($6%

& $ 88"!& 6 $6

$& ! !!& "

!# $%% &&$!"' ($"&$'#"''

)$'

'*'% + +(,!#"' *!+*"-% + ,

!# $%% $&# ( !$.

*'!

!#)"!#!

*+ - /$""-%$!

!# '

! & (

4"&( 8B"

88"!& !

!6 $6)

* 6 % ! * 3! 6 % & " 5

( &

& $

( ! && $ "6< !6 !

& 88"!&!

!<!

6< 8 & 88"&

& "! C +

4"$ ! 5&

88"!& 5 8B"

8 (! & (

! +

(!8 && $ "< 8B"

( 88"!& !

! &"8& !"

&0 !( & 8! (& (

! 88"!&)

* 6% !*3! 6% " 5 "

!AA6'6' &<

A/2

C 8 < 8$ 8

( 6 !8"

8 ! !

+ 5

8!"

AC 86 !8"

< !

& 5 8

(& ! 8 < !

& "

8 8 &<

85 < 8 !

(! !8&"&8 ! !8&"&

$ & 8"! <

<&( 88"!&!

!& $< &! (

!5 8 ! <

!"!"8 !

! 8

(& !

( ! C,C2 &!"

!B" ! 3 )"

" !2D &! > !2D 9

! ( &

( 8! "

AA6'6' &<

A/2 8

8 &6! !

5& (

! 88"!&

* 6% !*3! 6% " 5 ! ! ,C 2

(

!" "

)" $ 88"!&!

" "

8 ! *'$$+ !# '0'!$!

*1$( " " !!6<

6 88"!&!

!< &&

! !" $! !

8 &&&"

" " < < !"8!" $! < ! $

2 &! 8

A ./% + (

! (

! 88"!&!

! !< ! 88"!&

8!"

!AA6'6' &<

A/2

A C 8

5& +

(

! 88"!&)

* 6% !*3! 6% 8"

A1/2

A5 8 (

! 88"!&)

* 6% !*3!

&% " 5 88"!& !

!< $& ! 88"!&

!" $ ! # <56 !

26!" $! 8

& ./% + (

! (

! 88"!& !

A1 /2

A5 8<

& + << ( &

4"&( 8B"

<!& 8

8 !!<

( 8 8"!

8! & 4"&(

! & 5!6 "8

< 4"&( 8B"

+ "<

(!"8 ! "&

& !"

8 8 88"!& &" "?!

8B"

!!!"

8 8/ 8

< 5 < !

! "& 5

&&6"

& !

8 /4"&( 8B"

& 8

( !

8!!

4"!

$ 4"&( 8B"

! "&

&< + !5 < ! 9 $#

" "

%# 0' !$!

2 $&$ 3445 657 6&7 89 :$!#$ .$!$')$/,0' *(&" '

"-# *!

34456;47 "/"$&8<9!$!

0'$(*34456=7 6&7<85$+ * #$+ $&0' #$" $&344=6;7 6&733; / *&:

&*$+$ !# 0'!$!

% '

+(,!# *(&"

$+$ !# %%

A6 " " ! && < <

(("

! "

(< 8 !!< " & 8B"

& 88"!&0 F + 88"!& !!"&

8 "

5& ("

$+ 88"!& !!!!& !!"

< < !

"+ "?! 8B"

!! !"

8 + < 5 <

( 5 8 ! < & & "8 8

5 8

& /8 5 < "?!8

8"!

< !8

8! & <6 " ""!( 5 &"< (

" A + "! "& !

& " &&

8 &5 ( < 8

!!! + "

5 " 8&

$ <

!!! + " $

$ 5" < ! !" "?! 8B"

!5$!"

!G &

' /< !

5 <!8 8&

&! 8B"

6 8

H # (

' "!= 8 "!"!"

5 " 88"!& & 8B"

! "&

&< 5 " 5! !!

5 8

( < &! 88"!& 1 + "4"&( 8

! !

& 8 "! "?!5 < !

+ " < "&

4"!

( !

& 8 "4"&(

!! 5! 8

(

5 8

& 4"&( " ! 5! < $"

!"!

<G #

C "

!$"-#0'!$!

*1$( ;>?8637 6&75@ !

!5& < 5 <!

! 5 8 &&"8&

8 ! & " ! 9 << 8 ! "!

6 "! "&

(< & 8B"

/ (

! 8B"

6 8

8 "

& 8 5

5& ! 8 < !

85 < !

& 88"!&!

!"!&& $< &! (

!5 <

!"/ ! !

& !

!<! 8

( !

$ C (

" $! & $ C ! $

2 &! 8

& ./% !

! & $#

I C "

8 ! *'$$+ !# '

0'!$!

*1$($+ !# ' " " !!

/ 5 < < ! & !8"!!&

56/ 5 < 4"&( "

8B"

( 88"!& !

! !

& "!

&! & !

$ ! " +

(" ! &5 8& $ & ! 8

& $8

( ! !

& ! !!& 88 &

($4"&( 8

& ! 8 & &= "B" 88"!&

!"&

!& ! !!&

& $8

(

! 8B"

! !

& ! !!& '1 6 7

D! 9

(= !

& J!

D J!