High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1441/2016allowed

Tarsem Singh v. State Of Punjab

2018-04-21Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal15 pages

!"!#$% &"'!#() **++ #

,"

-#.

/ "*#0#

1

.!#0&2-'

& **++ #

,"

-#.

/ "*#0#

3 4%5

& '.!

!#() #0 # )& **++ # "

,"

-#.

/ "*#0#

6$

!

"#$

%"

!

"#$

&

'( )' *

(

+,- !

"#$

( . &

/ (0&

23

! %"

!

+,- !

"#$

0( $ #" "#$ 6(

( . & '

2"3 ( '

"" #+ "#8 '

9

('

( '

&

0 : 0 ! (

.

( 9

/( & !(

9

9

.

&( ##

. 7 #-

0 ;

& '

&.

; <( ' 7

0 )( ;

&. =.

> .

>

9 '

7

(

0 )( &.

=.

> .

>

?

9

<( &( & '

&. '

@ &

9

'

( (&

; &( & /A @ (

/A : : <( (

'

;

. 7 #- . + & ( '

(.

& ( ( &

+ 7 "+# + &@ ( ( "% . +##

& ( '

(.

&

B

9

B:B : : :

B (

9

) '

.

; &

9

C9

; ( '

( & 6 =; '

=

2 3

( +

( '

2+3 ( =

!(

?

9

D9 ; E

?

D

?

"E 9 6

?

9 = .

?

+

9 ) '

?

$ 7

*

?

- :

?

, 7 2$3 9

(

( 88

7'

.

( 88

9

=

:?

2-3

( ( ( + :

( (

# '

#####F

( ( 2,3 * ( DE (&

C* C

"%

=;

( & : ( & ; "+ #+ "#8 &0 C* "- #+ "#8 C* 2%3

( & C* -"

( '

(

'

%

% (

( =

!( ?

9 = .

?

+

'

(

'

( .

( 2#3 * ( ( (&

@

A & (&<('

&

'

"" #+ "#8 C

" #+ "#8 &0 C* "- #+ "#8 /A (&(

:?

( & :

@ !

"8$8 !"8 ) $%"

( ( 23 * ( (&

+# "

+- :

7

(

& ( &( .

2"3

( (&

=( <( '

'

(.

( >

C9

""8 ( + :

283 (&

( 2 3 =

!( ?

( .

'

C* " #+ "#8 ;&0 @ '

G@

"- #+ "#8 ::

%

2+3

?

= ( (

(

'

0 '

&'

& &.

: &(

?

'

/( & '

( &

9 ) (

. '

'

"% '

(

9 (

(

<(

.

&(

(

2$3 =;

6

?

=

C* C

&

'

?

8

"%

=;

'

(

.

= (

'

=

9 ) ( '

'

2-3

9 = .

?

+ (&

'

&( % 8#

<( &(

% &( (

( '

+ '

'

0( =

!( " #+ "#8 % ##

&'

+F$

'

'

%

7 ' &( "- #+ "#8 =

!( ?

&0 C* " #+ "#8 "- #+ "#8 C* 9 .

'

('

% (

?

?

+ &(

(

(

'

'

C* -"

( 2,3 ( ( ?

9

C* C

"% G ( =;

&( =;

(

%

( ( ( & .

<( & "" #+ "#8 C*

"8 #+ "#8 &0

( C* "- #+ "#8 @

!"# $%%&'$(

'#) ( *+,

( <( &

.

( '

( ( (&( .

2%3 ?

?

+ ( 0 '

( ?

+ &(

C* "- #+ "#8 ?

+

" #+ "#8

= " #+ "#8 &

"- #+ "#8 C*

&

+"

:

! !"# $%-.'-(

'#) ( /*/ '( (

'

(&

2"#3 A(

0( ( 9 !"#

"0 12$%-+'3(

'#) (*..

& A( & (

( (

0( ( 9

( & ( '

2"3 9 "24 5"6 #0 6"#6 6 "

7"6"

#" #)

17)'$%-%(-* 3.& =B&

@

( '

&

( (. @ (

( '

&(

( $

(

2""3 9

0#

!" " 8"

"7 $%-+'$(

'#) ($3+

0( '

( (

&'

@ ( ( 0

(&

(

( & ( '

A( & 9 147!

!"#

"!! 7#! !"#$%-+'-(

'#) (**&

& =B& (

(

2"83 +#

(

& ( & ((

(

(

@ & /A 9 " 1 !

0#)

!"#'$%-,($

'#) (,%

(

( ( ( & ((

( & .

( ' '

( 9

/( & '

( '

A(

(

( '

(

2" 3 ( '

((

'

( ( '

( ( & ( '

:

'

(

<(

(

>

=.

> .

&.

'

'

(.

(.

&( & &

&( & (.

( ( '

(.

& ( (

(.

#2 7!

" 0 12 $%%%',(

'#) ($// (

(

&

& ( & '

( ( ('

:

@( & '

(.

(.

( & ( ! (& '

<( 2"+3 =

!( ( $

( @

@

0#7 7!

"#4$%%/',(

'#) (*&.

+- :

( G

+-

'

( &(

&'

'

#29 7!

"#4$%%-'-(

'#) (+%$

'( (

'

+" ++ +- :

' &( ( '

( ( & A( &

:

(

. /A (&( 2"$3

( (

'

<(

<(

& (&

<(' 0( $ #" "#$ 6(

( &'

" "#,

6 8 ? .

F HF ? & HF