High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/879/2009allowed

Karnail Singh v. State Of Haryana

2023-05-22Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat25 pages

"# $% "& '$ (

'#) #* +# $ #*"& ,-

00 1

000

345 .

)/,0 #..6768

" ##$%&##'((&)*+ ,

- !

" ##$$.##'((&)*+ , / 0 1 !

- 1 !

" ##2'22##'((&

11 / 3 " ##$%&##'((&)*+ , " ##$$.##'((&)*+ , " ##2'22##'((&

#..6768 ).

-1 0 !0

" # #$%&##'((&)*+ , 9

" ##$$.##'((& )*+ , 9

" ##2'22##'((& ;

01 !000 1 -1 0 !!!'6(7'((& 8 "1

91 : 8 8

!!!1 #

!!"#$%& ;!2< =/ ! 1 0 0 2 (( ((( >#? 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 ;!2'(#?"

10 0 '((( ># ? 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 0

!!"#$%& ;!2< =/ ! 1 0 0 2 (( ((( >#? 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 ;!6(&?"

10 0 '((( ># ? 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 ;!6'(?"

10 0

'((( ># ? 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 ( (( !!

;!2< =/ ! 1 0 0 2 (( ((( >#? 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 ;!6'(?"

10 0 '((( ># ? 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 ' 1! !1 00 1!#2%7"" '<(7'((% 01 /)@1, : 8 "0

"8- 30A 8" 101 : 8!! 1 !0!

! 1 !!0 ! 8 18? ! ?!

!311 1 !" : 8 ? / B"

0 "8 B" 0 ! 311 1 : 8

0C ! 1'(8

1 !

!!:?=266'7(7'((% 1!2<>'< =/ ! !" : 8 ! 0 8 0 18!1!

0!311 18

18 10 8 0

018!B ! 01 80C !1

1!1! !18

01 /0

- ? !>*! " : 8 0 !

00 - ? !>* ?

D ?"

!0 030 ! 8"8 1001 / ! 0 - ? !>* 08 ! !!

!311 1 ?8 ?

B"/ "8 0 !1 ! 0 10 ! B"

0 ! 0 / 1

0C !

0 18 0 ! 311 1 8 8 !

1 8 !1 ! ! 8 :?=266'7(7'((%5 !

! 8 !

1 !

01 :? =26608

1 !

1 0 EF EFE F 22 8

10C !

! 5 8

1 !

8 !

1 87& $(( 0 228 01 1 1 ! 6(

8 7 0 2(( 0!

0 !

8 0 2(( 0!

10C ! !

! 5 ! ! ! !

1 0 EF F1 801 / -

? !>* ! !1 B" ? !#!!1 0 ?8 B"/ "8 0 -0C ! 1

1 !:? =266'7(7'((% 1!2< =/ ! !!1 2('' 6(( 0

1 1 11 ;0 1@ 8 :? BC2 !!1 !!1

2('' 6(( 0

1 111 1 ! !-1 0C !

1 !

! !:?=266 '7(7'((% 1!2< =/ !/1 !1 !!1"8 0 ?8 B"

/ ?

;0 1!2%7"" 1!8 "1"9 : 8 !00 ! "1 91 : 8 6

# 2&(''(($

91 : 8 0 !

1 !27 "1 ! !!1C! !!1

0 C!!1!

!00! 1 81!2< =!!/1 !

!18! !) E=/ !F,

1!6(&?" 1 '(8

1! 7&$ !

6( 0

1 2(( 0!

! ! 18!

!00 !08!

0 !!1C! !

# 1 !6'(?"1 !

1!2'(?" < 5 8 0 1 !!1>

!1C02$5 !1C0G#2 B"

10 !" : 8 (.(6'((% 0 ! 0

:D(.(6'((%5 !11 C0G#'"8 9 10 ! ?@1

5 0G#7"*0 G#6"0

015 !11 C0G#<"

?- !!!! 0 8122 2<

'7(7'((% ? "?-

B"/ B" B"1 "8

0 ! !

! !0 " : 8 ?

!!!

!" : 82( (( !0 0'6(7'((% ? !! !!1-

1 1! 0 "15 0G#.

?- 01G#% 0101

G#$?9 - G#&/100 1 G#2("1 '$(<'((% /?/ 10 !

! 311 1 108 ? ?8 0G#22"

1 10 ? ? *! !1 =/ ! G#2'" -8 C 8 BC'<5 !11 C0? ! - ), G#27 0G#26/01 1

! !1 :? !1! 81 0 ! !0 ! 1!2%7 "" 8 ? ! !# C0 !081:?=2660 !0?!22 (( 1! !

0 1 0 ! 0 !1 !

81 8 !!// 8 !0 - !00 ! 0 022 (< 0 0 !:?=266 0 !00 1@5 !1 1 C0? !8 G#2< !!1 0D1 G#2.18 18

1 : 8 0 G#2%? ! 1!2%7""

08 "10 G#2$ 8

8 !! @181 !10 81 !181 .

!1 ! 0 !!1 ! 0 !5 ! !!1 C022!/G#2 ! *!/3 ! @1 8/ / 0 BC/G#2>/G#'// 0

! 0 @1 !1! !0 0 8 "8 0 /G#7"

0? ! B@1*! @1 !0 8 0 /G#69 ?

*'6(7'((%

1 ! 0 3 ! 311 1 @1 81

!080 3 18

8 ! B /G#</ D108C0 ! /G#." 1081 100! ! 01 / /)@1, : 8 8 ?

? ?!

! 001

/!11/G#%"81 81 !// C0/G#$

0 !!1 0 / 0

1 !! 0 9 '<(7'((%5 !C0/G#&=10 91 0 !0 D = C0G#2( ! 8 0: 8 '.(7'((%BC/G>2( /G#22 0 3 C08 8 ! % ? !1

!1 $ D!1

0 1 ! :?@1 8!

0 810 !01! ! 0 180

! ! 5 1 #!0 ! 0 E=/ !F !11 -1!

0 5"1

! C08 !1 !1!80! 8 1 1 0 !

0! C0 !1 8 8 D !1 1 180 !

!!10! !0 8 !5 180 8

8 !18! !!1 !!1 2('' 6(( 0

15 !

!:?=266'7(7'((% 1! 2< =/ ! 8 ! ! 11 10 !!10C!

18 1

11 8

0 !!1 !00 ! 1!6(& 6'(2'(#?"88!!8 "1 & ? !1 8 !H? 1 5"1!!1 !

2( D!1

0! ! #!0 ! 0 !6' =/ ! !

0 085 !1

C0G#2601 / 0!1! !? !#C0 0 !0 ! !8122 (( 1! !0 1 0 ! !!// 8 !0B ! ! !

!01! !! 1 8!

8!@18 "1 22 D!1 0

180 8! ! 01 / 0 ! !1! ! !8 A !! !! 8 0 1!!0 ! !6' ! 2' ? !1 ?0 0 1!! 18008!1

27 ? ! !6' !

C! 8 #

! " # "$#%"" # &" '%# " #"## " " " &"'%# ! "%"$ " #('%##

" " "('%# "%# !"# % ! "" " ###"# % ## """" ) #"# %""""") " "& * !

" "% " "# "% "+ !

& * + ! # "%%## " , % "% "# %" # "%" " #

-!# " % ""% ##"

1 I81 0"1 0 )

* ) + , !('"-&".& /-

"# & " /"", /1) %)" " 1 """, 2 " # # " %34 ( #! #" % % %& & # "/.34 (

" )# "

)#" 2 % " # " # # " %34 ( 2 # "# "% %34 (

"# 6 "& 2*

"%% ## ! "

" % " - 6 # "

"""

7! " # " #(

%34 ( 2 # %34 (

#" """

85(

"# % # 2 %" %%

&5(

# # % " " ! 8 "%# "!"

& 2*% ###"# % ## " " # %#" " 8 %(

# "

1 $ % # %#" % "

9 5 (

# ! # %(

" ## " 2"# " %# 1 $# 8" # $ """

)

2 " % # " #"% " % & & " " # " %( .. :/&

& " )#""" #"

8 2 # (

" %& &#" ( .. :/&

& # " %& & " """"%"

1" # " % #

/ ; # # "(

"# " %(/. # " #)"" ';6 %

2 " # <"# )"!# ';6"# # "(/.# " %"

# " )

:1 %(/ /=" ! #! (

#"% # 2# "" "!" # $# > """% %""#

?1 # J

2 " "% & 8 >#& 1 !!"/&".&/(/2 !!"3&45*6 .

" * &'- 2 !!"

&/- & %(

1 &8% " " "# " 8 1) >#"", 276

87 .% 61 96) !!!"(&".&'((" !!!& /(- ? 8 & " # " (

3 4

( @A/ 34 ( #"! # ##" " > 2)7 .1 !!("-&".& 2" !!(&'' " ?8" (

# "# "

2%" " "(

# " " &8"%

91# >34 ( #! " #! # " " # "" "" #" % # # &"#"! 3&#&"B$

% %# ! "# " .

%# # % "

"# "$"%

/ " ># & 8#"# ")# (

/. # # " " # " $ " "" " # "(

1&8 / 1 # "(

%% # "# " "# "(

% % % ( 9 # " %(

-" C&""# "(

(

%C& ## % 26 ! ! 8 !1 !

0 0 G#2601 / !!0 0 !G#27 - ? ! !01! !@1 @1 0 ! ! !5 1 8!

0 !6'

! 5 "1 !00 !!

2< 1 8!

!6' ! 818 "1 1 1 !1 ! 0 ! 1 ! !0 1 0 !5 0 -1!0 !! !! 10 18!0 ! 1 81 0 -1! 1 8 ! 811!1 !!0 !111 0 -1! #!0 ! 2.

0 !

8!!1!6'(?" ?! !

1 !! 88 0 !00 !1!6'(?" 1 !

! 0 2% !62<E"

F 8 1!8 ! # 3(/

% % """ % "% "" "" %#" #% #"!"## # 0D

11 1! !

10 ! !

! 0!1!10 0 8 0 1 !8 !

B!1 !!

! 1 8 C! 0 1!0:0 1 ! !

!1! 6'(?"01

1! 0 ! 0 0

0 ! 0 6"!

! !

1 81 !11! 2< =/ ! !6'(?" 8 ! D !1

1 ! 8 !!1!6(& ?" 8 !1 1

1! 18

18 !!?

1 !2< E=/ !F?! !!008

!1 =/ ! !

!1 ?" !5 18008!1

8 0

8 !18

! 0 =/ ! !1 !6(&?" 8 !? 8 0E9

!(;*(- 2 !("-&. '( 62

2""! "" " #

) " " 2 " >'

( 9B .

"""""#,

" # ) "( " "# " # % "

%" 2 " #% """ "" " " "

" # " " " %" " 1"#" "" #" " " "% %D

0 1""! "E" " "E %!" % " %% %% %" % &"

.: ($ B F##" 6F " 1 " % "#"## "!## %"% "## %"## ! "% # " " 2 66 ; 1 :

8(6. 6-( /CE " $&)" "

( 8< / @A % #"% $" %"# "% $ " @ 8 (F"( " 9= @A " "% " """% $ 2 %"% $ #" ( " " E" %"" " %E " " $" "%" < ;# " " " " $"%" " ( %$" 8 "" 6!

@A.

? ! ?1!! 10 8!1

! 1 5 1

8 !!1!6(&?" '(

0 ! 8 !!1!2'(#?""0! ! 8 1!2'() , ?" !

1 # 0-# , """ """ """## #"

%#$ ### ""##" "# # # # '2 !2'(# !8 1 0!0! !

8 ! 1 8 0 0 ! 5 ! !0 ! ! ! 8 8 8 ! ! 8 !!10 ! ! 2( B! ! 1! ! !8! "1 8 18 0

! !00!!8 1 18 0!! ! !8 !!81!#!

! !8 !1 !

!1 8 1 !18 0 ! 008 ! !B -1 0 8 5"1 # !@1! !8 "188 8 "1 ''

0 !1

0 1 !! 8

!1! 0! !1 8-! 1

8 !!1 !

0 5"1 !0 0 0 1 -1 088 15 180 8 0

8 !1 '7 !1 "1 1!! 18008!1

? ! !!1C0/G#6 9

*'6(7'((% !0!

0 3 "

1 =108 0 0 3 ! 311 1@181

!080 3 18

- 1 !

0 3 ! 1A !00 : 8!8

311 1! !!

1 !

1 ! !!: 80 81

8/G#</ D08

0 ! C0/G#." 10 1! 100 BC/G#.> ! 8 : 8 2<(6'((. 8 -1 ! 01 / 8 ?

! 0 01 / G#26! 1!

! 115 ! 01 /0!

0 !!1 !! 0 ! ?

8 B"/ "8 0 8 !@18 5"1 !@1 18

!5 1

01 /

0 0! ? ?!

! !1 01 / !

0 !BC/G.> '6 ? 8!1

1!!5 0 1 -1 0!!!'6(7'((&

8 "1 91 : 8

8!@1 !

5 88 18 !

!!1 88 -@1 ! '<

! !! '. " 8 C 0

!!! 5"1!88!

#..%<=$

)'*&% > K>= 8

K>=