High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/666/2005allowed

Gurmit Singh & ORS. v. State Of Punjab

2022-08-09Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan18 pages

% $'

(('

)''

*+, '& *'

+ -.$(/ &0

'$'$/ &0 2+ &0

(('

( &$/ !/ *+,

33333 '& % / 5#+ %

+ (# $" '& % "&/ 6&"( *# 5'1 & "( &&( ''"'

5&#/ 89/ #"'& 0"& 8: ;

&& < =4

/ '

& "'

> / >=/ >>/ == / ==</ 4= 4=

:* " < '

/ #"'& *(" " $ . % "& ,'&

&"#'

&(& ("

&/ 1$'/ '? $& @"& &"#'

#"' $"

'& ,&

"# &7 (/ 5#+

% + 5'1 (' & $0 @"&/ $/ &"#'

'& ,&

"(7 '& '

'" '7 < =4

/ "

&"(#( '$

*(" " $ ./ (" 7 (& :?6

$ 1 *"

7 6($ / $ ./ 1$/ '$

"+& & "& && ' / 1$"/ '& "'

'"& )"((# $1( $0"# $ ''

(7 !& !

!&"( "#$A

"' 1 ''

"& 1$'/ $"& (7 !&"( ,$(A (& '"&"( $' 1'$& 17 (& 1 "0/ $10/ 1$ 1 (0( "0 &&/ $ ' " "0 ,& # &"& (" , '"&"# " "0 ,& '"# $$'

" 7 $'

, 1 7'A (" '1 1$

'' '

, '

(&A '"& & " < =4

/ (" # $' 5# )"((# (1( 2( ,'7

"# "'

&#$ 2(1 2 0

"# ''" "0&/ 1$ , 4

/ $7 .1 6 ''

"& (# ' $ ''

(#$"# '

$( '

$7 #'

&#' '"'A " '"& " "/ (" '$

(# ''

!& !&"( &#$"(1 (," 2 1? !& &#$ +" 2 1 $" (& ''"# 1

"0 , , > * $7 ,'0& '? -.$1"& 4 , - #/ 5'1 '? 0 (' $0"# 4 , - #/ ' 2'$ " ? )"((# "&1(/ 1$' (" 7 &"& .1

*# "#$ >4

, "(A

6 % ' "& #&'/ 6&"( ' 2(& #&'A '? $& #&'/ + '? (&0 $0"# "( ' $A 1& (" 7/ $7 1& (" 7 ,.

$1"' $7 1(& , ,( 'A

(" 7 '.&

$ ''

7 1$7 $7 (#$& $" 1$ / $"# '& B("# (" 7A

6 "'& ((. (" 7 , #$ $(& $7 '$(& , ((1& 'A $"# "& '$

4 , - # &"(7 1&'

(" 7 '$ $" !& $'/ / .

( '"# $"

"+"'/ $ !& (( &1A

(" "'& $ 7/ 1$"$ 6 #0 #&' ,(1 $"

'"# $"

"+7 ("( "# $&/ $ 6&"( #0 #&' ,(1 $""# (" $ ,A (" 7 "'& $ 7

( $ (( ( ' $" 'A

$ (" 1 1&'

!& & (&7 @"&A & ("'$& $$'

7 $1 17 $'$(& "('

(7"# $$'A

"0 ,$"& (" 7 ("0"# (& "0 ,& 0& &"# 1 "0 ",(7 1& . ''''" (& C$ (" (0"# !& "#$D'

&& ,&7 '"7/ 1 "0"( 6'"(/ $ .

."# "+"'/ 1$/ "&

&"(#( @ "" #0 $"

(" '#$ ."# " #"' 7A

:?6

$ ' '"& ' '$

E@* "# &' E@*? (" '" ,'"'

1$"$/ ( 8: &&A :0'"#"#

(# $ (" ""('

1 ' 0& 7 '$(( 4 , "&#'

(7"# ,'$'

(' ( A 7 '$(( # 0& " ( '(& '( :

$0"# "'"" DD $/ . " ''''" 0"& 07

E@*</ '& 1"'''A

:0'"#"#

" & "B' #& ( &$ !& E@*4 A $ ' && ,&7 @ "" "0"( 6'"(/ F" < =4

$#$ ( E@*44 ' ',( '$ "(

(# && ,&7A :0'"#"#

" .

" ''''" ,(& '"& $ ' ( $

' "# $" ' ('

'("# $' '( $0"# "'"" DDA '"

' ( '( & '(7/ $

,$ ('

$ . " ''''" 0"& 07

E@*4/ '& 1"'''A

:0'"#"#

" & #$ '" ( ( E@*4>A

&"# ' "'"/ :0'"#"#

" .

" ''''" ' ('

'' '1 (& & $" ('

'("# $' '( ,"# """( DD $ $' . " ''''" 0"& E@*4=/ '& 1"'''

C$ &/ 1$ && '

@ "" &'& &"# &( $&& 0 0"( ""# (('

'(& '( ($'

&'& & '

@ "" (" ""(/ 1$ 7"# && ,&7A '"& (" ""( $&&0 && ,&7 :

1$ 0& ($'

&'& " .$ " ( '("# '( $0"# """( DD

$ .

' " ''''" 0"& 07

E@*4 / 1$"$ '& ',( "(

',( '$

/ :0'"#"#

" '& $"'

0& 4 , - # ; =4

$& "#$A (& & 7 (" ''''" #/ '$/ # 0& " ( :

'(& '( $0"# """( DDA

'( "

''"

& '( ' $&& 0 :

5#" "#$A

( # . " ''''"

0"& 07

E@*4

/ :

" ''''"

. 1+

,"# #"'" ; *=<4 > (# "'

#"'" "" 0"& ' 07

A ' &7/ :

(' 0& #&'

$& !&"( ."# ' " ''''" 0"& 07

E@*4 '& 1"'''A

(' 0& #&'

$& % 4 =4

. " ''''" 0"& 07

E@*4 / '& 1"'''A

(' 0& (# "'

#"'" ""

'&A

' '

1"'''

&&A (( '& $"'

(" "0'"#" $ (""'/ $(( #"' & "(& :((B #"'/ 1$ '"# (" " < */ " '(7 & '

("& $(( ''/

"&/ ''"'

5&#/ 89/ "(

C$ B'" ''"#& &&( ''"'

5&#/ 89 1$ ( $# '

& "'

4= / > / >=/ == & " 4=

:* #"' $# '$&

&"#(7 '& ,'& &"# &7 ' (& , & &'" "'' 1'

' ( " & " */ #"' $"

/ '$/ &(& ("

&/ 1$'/

@"& &"# &7

> "# ' '" 0"&/ '" @ "& ((1"# 1"'''

*G4 0

*6 $ . '& < =4

&"(#( @ "" '$

= * & ((1"# "+"'

' " :"'& 1&

@ >

'( & &'( ' $& "'

&"( '"& 8'$ ,(&"# ' "" :"'& 1&

'( & " '"& $ , $& "'

( $(@ "$(#( +" 8'$ (& ,(& ' """,'" <

&'( ' $& ,' $ , *G 6,'

*1"

1$ "'& ' & '(& '" ( E@* &'& #&

*G> ',( "(

1$ && :

# '

@ "" && && ,&7 !&

"0"( 6'"( F" '""& #& $#$ "&0" E@*> *G= 5#"& 2 / (.

" / F" '& ,"# ;*=<4 > '&'

5#+" 6+" ''

-.$1"& 6 0& #"'" "" E@*= *G

6+" C' (.

/ ;.& 0& #"'" "" ;*>> >

> 2$ '$ ,"# E@*

*G ? '$

(" 0"&& 7 1"''

""&/ 0"# ' E@*

0"& 1$"$ 7 '$(( . " ''''" E@*<

*G 2 0"&& ( 0'" ""&

*G< :

!& 1$ 1."# 6 (" '" < =4

'& '(& ('

&'"& $"

' ' 8'" " -,7 (7'"'

6 0& "&0" E@*

*G ',( (1 1$ . '(& ('

" 8'" " -,7/ $&"#$ 0"& "&0" E@*

'""& #&

$ :

&'& #&"# "0'"#" && $"

,'"&'

0"# &' E@*? E@*? 6 (' 0& "B' &'& !& E@*4 ,'"&'

0"'

$ & '

*G4 $ . $",/ *$#$ '""& #& $#$'

. $"

6 0& #"0'

1(( $#$'

*G44 :

5#" '& "& :

&"# ' '$

< =4

(' .

"0'"#" &"# $"

'& '0(

*G4 * +" &"(

" && '

@ "" && ,&7 !& "& ' &$ '$.

$# 6 0& '

E@*4

= '

&& & " >4> */ 1$"$ (( ""

""# " ''

"# '" 0"& #"' '&/

, $7 &"& ' / &"# $7 " $0 , ('(7 "0(0& $"'

,"# ("0'

(&0

'& '& (# "'

''''" &"'& (& #"&1"'

&"'& (& $" 0 &7 / (#$"# (& 1$ !& '$

/ $ ((7 '& "+"'

' *"( "+7 '& !& & "0 & 7 '

6&"( *# ''

2'$ " && $7 , ('(7 "0(0& $"'

,' $7 ,"# ("0'

(&0

'& && (# "'

''''" &"'& (& #"&1"'

(' $" 0 &7 / / (#$"# (& 1$ !& '$

$ &(7 '& "+"'

' *"( 6 $ '& "+"'

'& !& & "0 & 7 '

"# $" & 0"& @ "& ;$ G4/ ##1( G/

#"0"# '0( $ '

& ""( 1"'''/ ('& $" & 0"&

$"# # '/ "( 0"& +&# && >

& 0 & 0"& '& % / 5#+ % +/ 6&"( *# 5'1 &# :

" ' ?A &( 7 "/ $ &# :

7 H?'

> =/ *:

?1 " 4=

:*A

% '& &# :

1 7'

& " >= :*A 5#+ % +/ 6&"( *# 5'1 '& &# :

I 7'

& " >= & " 4=

:*A 6&"( '& &# :

1 7'

& " >= :*/ 1$'/ % / 5#+ % +/ *# 5'1 '& &# :

I 7'

& " >= :*A (( '& '& &# :

1 7'

& " 4= :* '& B"& & " > ?1 " 4=

:* (( ''

&& (7

< 8("# ##"0& +&# $" 0"" & '/ & ( , $"'

1$"$ . < = / 1$ & "& $"#

(""'

$0"# , "(& ,$( (('/ $" ' ''&& $7 && , ('& ,"( &"# &7 (

$0 $& (& '( ((?'&/ (& '( ,'"&'

#"# $#$ & : $"'

'/ 8:/ % "& "'

& 8$ / &"& &"# &7 "( 1$'

5#+ % + 5'1 (' & $0 @"&/ &"# &7 (

-& "( (& ((1"# "'

& "" " G$$ 5'1 ' ' "#$(7 &(& " &"# "0'"#"J "" G$$ 7 (" 7 ''''" &"'& (& 1$"$ 7 ##'' 7J """G$$ '& &$ !&" @"' "0 & 7 ,&7J C."# " ; "/ "( ,'0& ($#$ &"# ' "0'"#"/ (" &(& 5'1 , " , ','B(7 '

& "(

(# '&

4 H& " ; "" "( $'

,'0& '" ,#$ 0"& "( '$1 (" 7 ''''" &"'& (& $#$ '$

($#$ '$

1$ "'

0'" ,#$ & 7 0"& "( $7 ''''" &"'& (& "

&"(7 , #"&1"

$"9&(7 $#& (7

$ $

" "

&"(7 , '/ ("" 7 "+" "(& 7 &"'

"''& ( / "+" &"'

"''& &( C$ "( & "& 0"& , ,#$ "( $"'

'$1"# &7 $7 ''''" &"'& (& ,' *G 6,'

*1"

0& '(& '" ( ( 1$ .

( '& ''@ "" .$' , '$1 '" ( ''''" 1$ & '" ( 4

''''" ('

$ $

"((7 *G

$ '& '' @ "" && , $"

+ ,&"

#"&1"

(& &"' 1$"$ $7 && , ("0"# ''''" (& 6"

: ,'0& $#$ '$

(" & "& ''@ "" % "& $'

''''"

(& &"' , ((7

$' ''

''''" (& &"'

4> &"(& (7'"'

0"& &&& "'

$ '

" ''

'/ "( ;4 $'

,'0& (" 7 ''''" &"'& (&/ $10/ 07 $7 &"& # "(" "+"'

7,&7 1$ & $"9&(7 &"'& (& &"# '" '7/ (" 7 ' 0"((# (1( 1$ $7 "0& " " 7 (#$"# &"'& (& '

C$ " " "0& , 4 $ (" (# $'

1 '/ $"# $ , 4> *

: '

' G ##1(/ "0& '"@ "+"'

' &"" '"'

1$ . $'"(A "+7 ;4 1$"$ '& '$ &#& 1 &(& , &#'

(" 1$'

"+7 ; (' &(& #"0'

'& ,( &#& 1A ""# 1 "+"'

'$ &#& 1 1 "+"'

,( &#& 1 $0 , &(& '"

( $ & '& ''@ "" * (7 = " $& $'"( "

/ 1(& $0 &"& C$ & $ 0& "+"'

' *"( '"# ""'& 1&'

' ' *"( #"0'

$ & "& '' @ "" &"# "0'"#"/ " !& &'& "'

# ' 1$"( $7 #&''/ ''

."'

"' "+"'

'& *"( $ @"' "0 &/ "& '$A $1"' '$

(" '"" "

$0 ' (1 "'& #"# ' '

$7 '$(& $0 &

("/ ,'0"# (" 7 "'& ."# ' "# (" 1 ' '& "+"'

7 '$ (" 7 ((7 ##'' 7

4= "# " ; """/ "( ,'0& $0 . ( "0 & '"# "

"+7 !& '& $0 . ( "0 & 7 ,&7 , "0 & 7 &'

(7 ' : ; 4 / "( $'

,'0& '"# &$ !& @"' "0 & ,&7 "'

(' 0"(,( ,' &'

@& "(""#

$ "'

''7 "(" ' & : $'

, ,'0& % "& "' "' '$(& $0 "& " $ " (" 7 "& '"# "+"'/ $ '$(& $0 "& '$'

0"( '

,&7 (". (#'

& (" 7 , "& '$ &"(7 $' !& "((7 1$ "+7 , '& $"

: 17/ 7 " @&& "0 & ,&7 '"# &$ !& # '$

C$ "( "'( 0"& ,#$ "( '"/ '"&"# & 0'" $ '

" ''

& ( ,'0" ;4 "

#& +&# *G

' $'

& "& ''@ "" &"# "0'"#"/ " !& &'& "'

# ' 1$"( #&''/ ''

."'

"' "+"'

'& *"( (7 $/ @"' "0 &/ "& '$ C$ "( $'

& & 0'" (" 7 ##'' 7 #"0"# '"# (" 7 '"" "

$0 ' (1/ "'& #"# ' '/ $7 '$(& $0 &

(" '$(& $0 . ' '

, "'& &"# $/ $7 1 '/ .

I $'

$"# '/ 0"# &"' I .

( 1$ $7 # " 1&&"# '& "+"'

7 : 17/ (" 7 ( ##'' 7

! "

# # " $ " % #

& " #

" "

& ' % #

() !

* +,-.+ / & 0

& '

.! "

1! -!

"#& ' %

" " " "

% * / )

* " /

" -2

1314! 5* $ % 6 %

"" $ * "7 * " -

.1!

8 * " # # 5 " * % $

9 * ! () 9"

1! - " 14! '

#&'

0"" & " >= :* 6&"( 0"1 &"(& &"'''" ,0/ "'

''",( '"

"( ''/ 0"" $ & " >= & " 4=

:* , ''"& :

7 ,

"& $ &"# &7 (/ 5#+ % + & $0 @"& C$/ ( B

'&'

,& ""# ((?'& B"& $# #"'

C$ ( '&'

((1&

G$$ '."#?'&

; G$$ ,(

;